Vance v. United States of America

Filing 2

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 07/22/2014. (kab)

O = K8AT C: U.q. gm = r
QFFI
nl
qotNoKr, A
V
Ffen
u

I T H E UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STR I T CO UR T
C
FO R TH E W E STER N DISTRIC T O F V I G I IA
R N
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON

JUL 23 2 1
24
J A
BY uul c.
:

Dep

u

,

TL RK
U

RI
CKY LEE VANCE,
Peii ,
ttoner

Ca eN o.7:4CV00354
s
1

UNI
TED STA TES O F AM ERI A ,
C
Res
ponde .
nt
U N I D STA TES O F A M ER I A ,
TE
C

Cas N o.1: 4CR00022
e
9
M EM O R AN D U M O PI I N
N O

R I Y LEE V A NC E,
CK
D e e nt
f nda .

By:Hon. e E.Conr d
Gln
a
Chi Unie St t Diti tJ
ef t d aes src udge

Thepettone ,a f de ali t pr edi pr s hasfld apladi t the syl asa
ii r e r nma e oce ng o e,
ie
e ng ha
t es

C TI FOR W RI OF ERROR COM M NOBI AND OR AUDI QUERELLA (i)
TETI ON
T
S
TA
sc
W I REQUEST FOR COUNSEL.'( t 1. Thec tdoc tdt pla nga apeii f
TH
' Pe. )
our kee he e di s tton or

awrto c r m no i u d rt eA1 W rt Ac, U. C.j1 1a .Afe rv e o t ep tto
i f on b s n e h l is t 28 S.
65 () tr e iw f h eiin
a t c ts r c ds howe r t c tfnds t t pettone i not e il d t t r i
nd he our' e or ,
ve , he our i
ha
ii r s
ntte o he elef

r se under j1 , a t t hi s si i a opraey c tu a sz rl
equetd
651 nd ha s ubmison s ppr itl onsr ed nd lmma iy
dim is d a a t ut i d s c
s s e s n ma horze e ond or s c sve moton t vac t ,s tasde or co r c t
uc es i
i o
ae e i
r e t he
s ence,
ent

CL
nRK

1
ptruan t 28U. C.j2255.
zs t o
S.

1Th c u ti no bomdb te j1 51lb lta a po s peiin ratc e t hi pla ig a d ma
e o r s t t y h 6 a e h t r e tt e ta h s o s e dn n y
o

lbe al consr a a le shi s ison a co di t t naur oft r lefs
i r ly
tue nd dcr s s ubm s i c r ng o he t e he ei ought SeeG o aezv. os
.
nz l
Cr bv,

5 5 U..5 4,5 (0 5 (mdn ta h b a p tto rstl g s e ig rl fu d rc n e i sbsa tv 1w
4 S 2 31 2 0 ) f ig h t a e s eiine' ii e kn ei n e ha g n u tnie a
n
e
s b e uett f s h be spo e dn i p o ryc ntu da dds se a sc e sv h b a )
u sq n o t t a a rc e ig s rpel o sr e n imisd s u c sie a e s.
r

Pe ii rRi ky Le Va e,afe t br a
ttone c
e nc
tr he e kup ofhi ma rag i 1
s r i e n 995,pl e a bo b
ac d
m
ne t t nks of lqui oxyge owne by BrsolCompr s s hi wie' e oye ,butt
ar wo a
i d
n
d
it
es or , s f s mpl r
he

b mb fie t e pld . A jly f u d Va c g it o us o ad snztv d viei a ci o
o ald o x o e t o n n e u l f e f e t cie e c n rme f
r
y

voe e 1 U.. j9 4 t t On ) atmpe d smcin o ab idn u e i i trtt
ilnc , 8 SC. 2 /) co mt e ; te td e t t f ul ig sd n ne sae
o
) o s sin f n
c mmec b me ns o a e plsv , 1 U. C. j 8 44) t u t Two ;p s e so o a
o re y a f n x o ie 8 S.
4 1 co n
'nr gitr de tu i d vc , 2 U. C. j5 6 ( ) t u t Th e ) a rc ii o
l e se ed sr ctve e ie 6 S.
8 1d co n
r e ; nd e evng r

ta pori soln e osve maeras 1 U. C.j 842(9 t mtFour.Ats tnci t
rns tng t e xpl i
t il, 8 S.
1 cot
)
ene ng, he
c the r e de e t t wlie a tng s nt nc Va e ha a t e t hie a hi ma t kil
our a d vi nc ha , ll waii e e e, nc d tempt d o r
t n o l

hi wie a t tt bom b woul ha c us d e e i da a ha i expl
s f , nd ha he
d ve a e xt nsve m ge d t
oded. Fi ng t t
ndi ha

Va e' t ope iy f r i vim wasnotade tl a c e f by ( s ci na hit y
nc s û nst or ecdi s
pr
quaey c ountd or hi) rmi l sor
c t gor ' t c t s e e Va
a e y,' he our entnc d nce t a t t l of 720 m o hs i prs c itng of
o
oa
nt n ion, onssi
c e utve s nt es of 1 m o hs on Cot Two,Thr e, a Fotr a a co ec i
ons c i e enc
20 nt
mt
e nd
l, nd
ns utve
s e e of 360 m ont on CountOne. Unied St t v. a ,8 F. 1309,1 W L 308280,
ent nc
hs
t
a es V nce 7 3d
996

a * ( hCi.1 .Va sa alwa t ucc sul L.
t 2 4t r 996) nce' ppe s ms esf . ds
u
Va e fl hi c r ntpe ii on J y 18,201 a lgi t the i en il t a m i of
nc ied s ur e
tton
ul
4, le ng ha
s tted o
t
c a nobi oraudi que e a s h t tt c tmus va t hi s nt nce a r ope hi ca e
or m
s
u
r l , uc ha he our
t cae s e e
nd e n s s
f r s nt i Va as e t t ta t tme he wass nt nc d i Febrzr 1
or e e encng. nce s rs ha t he i
e e e n
t y 995,a i bl
a
pplca e
lw lmie hi s ntnce e
a i td s e e
xpos e on CountTwo t onl t ry yea s i prs a r quie t
ur
o y hit
r n ion nd e r d he

j r t d tr ne te prpe s ne e i hs c s . I t e isn tpeiin,Va c ag e ta
u y o ee mi h o r e tnc n i a e n h n tn t o
t
n e ru s h t
b c u et e c u t n tt j r ,d tr n d h slnghy p io tr hs s ne c v oae hi
e a s h o r, o he u y ee mie i e t rs n e m, i e tn e i ltd s
sa u or a c tt i lrght a m us be va a e t ough a wrtof c n nobi . Va e
t t t y nd onsiutona i s nd
t
c t d hr
i
or m
s
nc

a gues wihoute a ton,t tt saut y ame m e son whi h her le we e t i a
r , t
xpl na i ha he t t or
nd nt
c
e is r s ed nd
bur
hi n, whih pr nt hi ,hi ti a t ne a t pr ec or fo dicove i t m f
dde ' c eve ed m s ral tor y, nd he os ut r m s rng he or
'

-

2-

ne ry t nt yea s Va de a a wrtofa t que el be a et co tdi notgi hi
a l we y r . nce m nds
i
udia r a c us he ur d
ve m
no i e ofisi e t ap y t pr e e e r por r c me to t de r u
tc
t nt nt o pl he es nt nc e t e om ndai n o pa t pwar Se Fed.
d. e

R. i . 3 ( .
Crm P. 2h)
A peii t rj 1 ,s h a one seki awrtofc a nobi o a t queel,i
tton mde 651 uc s
e ng
i orm
s r udia r a s
l

nota ia e t a de e
va l bl o
f ndanti f de alc t t r i e cl i s t tw e e o c d ha bee r i ed
n e r usody o a s a m ha r r oul ve n a s

t oug ot rr medi ,s h a am o i f rne ti loram oton s ki c lt r lr ifunde
hr h he e
es uc s
ton o w ra
i ee ng ola e a ele
r

j2 5 S e e:, ie S ae v. oms n 2 7 F.d 7 ,7 5 ( t Ci.2 01 ( o n no i)
2 5. e , ..Untd tts J l o , 3 3 51 5 6h r 0 ) c r m bs;
Untd S ae v. l e - c e o, 7 F.d 1 7 ,1 0 ( t Ci.2 0 )( i o a dt q r l)
ie tts Vad zpa h c 23 3 0 7 08 9h r 0 0 wrt f u ia ueea.
M or ove ,t wrt ofco n nobi wa t r dii l a ia e onl t brng bef e t co t
e r he i
rm
s s l a tonaly va lbl
t
y o i
or he ur
f c ua e r s û t ra t t valdiy a r a iy oft l lpr e ng is f's h ast
a t l ror ma e i l o he i t nd egulrt
he ega oce di tel, uc
he
de e ntsbei t r a o ha ng did be or t ve di t' Ca lse v.Unie Stt s 51
f nda ' ng mde ge r vi
e f e he r c .
' ril
td ae , 7

U. 41 4 ( 9 6 (iain o te ) Thewrt fa dt q rl i t v ia l i c i n l a e
S. 6, 29 1 9 ) ctto mitd .
io u i ueea s t alb e n rmia c s s
a
a
( a al wh r teei alg la c n rse wiha e ui be o j cint ac n ito t a h s
i t l e e h r s e a, s o ta td t n q t l, be to o o vcin h t a
f )
a
aie s e ntt t c ci a ( )notrdr sbl ptruan t anohe posc cin
rsn ubsque o he onviton nd was
e esa e ls t o t r tonvito

rme y' 7Am. l . dAu iaQu rl j 1( 01 )
e d.
'
Jz 2 dt e ea 2 4 .
r
Vmwei ce dyno e tte t et e o t ewrt h s e .Hep e iusy fld aj2 5
s la
t nild o ih r f h is e e ks
r vo l ie
25
mo in c aln i gt s mec i na j dg n a s n e c t th c le g si ti p tto .
to h le g n he n rmi l u me t nd e tn e ha e haln e n h s eiin
Va e v.Unie Stts Cas No.7:
nc
td ae , e
97CV0031 ( . Va.Fe 25,1 ,appe dimis d,
6 W D.
b.
998)
al s s e
1 F. 724 ( h Ci.Aug.7,1 .Be a eVa hadanavalbl r y t rj2255t
53 3d
4t r
998) c us nce
ia e emed mde
o
c le t valdiy ofhi s nt e a he r i i f de alcusody,he cn
hal nge he i t
s e enc nd
ema ns n e r
t
nnotptrue hi
ls
s

cuae cai i a peiin f a wrtt r j 1 . J o 237 F. a 755;Vade
nt l ms n
tto or ny i mde
651 ohns n,
3d t
l zPa hec 237 F. a 1 0. M or ove ,li c r t c le i notba e on a f m e a
c o,
3d t 08
e r ls uren hal nge s
sd
ny undn nt l

-

3-

f c ua e r r as r quied t w a r c r m nobi r le ,no does i r i e a newl m i e l ga
a t l ro
e r o r ant o n
s ei f r
t as
y nt d e l
2

o j cint h sc n cin , swa t ep r o eo a dt q e ea
b e to o i o vito s a s h u p s f u ia u r l.

Be us Va may notpr ee wih hi cli s t oug a e r or na y wlt un
ca e nce
oc d t s am hr h ny xta di r i der

j1 5 () t ec u t o sr e h scamsa a j2 5 mo in. i c u t y c nsd ras c n
6 1a , h o r c n tu s i li s
2 5 to Th s o r ma o ie e o d
ors c sve j 2255 moton onl upon s ii c rik ai fom t Unied Stt Cour of
uc esi
i
y
pecfc e tt ton r he t aes
t
Appe sf t FourhCic tt tt cli i t moin mee ceti crtra.Se j2255(9.
al or he t rui ha he ams n he to
t ran iei e
1

Va c h sara tk n h sbt a te j 2 5 a p ea d a misi hi p tt n ta h ha n t
n e a le dy a e i ie t h
2 5 p l n d t n s eio h t e s o
i
obti d c rii to fom t Cour ofAppe l t fl a s ond ors ce sve j 2255 moton.
ane e tfcain r he
t
as o ie ec
uc si
i
The e or t c tm us di m i s li c r t m oto a s c sve. ? n a o i t o der 5 i 1
r f e, he our
t s s ls ur en
i n s uc es i
t ppr pr a e r
v1
e e t sday.
nt r hi

The clr wils nd a c oft sm e o a
ek l e
opy hi m r ndum opi on a t ac om pa ng or t
ni nd he c
nyi
der o
t pe ii r
he ttone .

ENTER:Thi $% J d yo J y, 2014.
s
a f ul

Chi Unie St t Diti tJ
ef t d aes src udge

2 M or r Vanc s l m ont s nt e on CountTwo w a w elunde t t 't - r lm i he now
eove ,
e' zoh e enc
s l
r he ht y yea i t
r
es us ,a t Fourh Cic tuphel t c tsupwar depa t ei c cultnghi s enc . V a e,1996 W L
po es nd he
t rui
d he our'
d
rur n al ai
s ent e
nc

3 8 8 , t* 3(fimi c n it nsa dsne c )
0 2 0 a 2- afr ng o vci n e tn e.
o

-

4-