Smith v. McClure et al

Filing 6

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 07/21/2014. (kab)

D Fpœ: OFFI U. Dl CotRr
CE B, :T, l
AT ROANOKE,
VA
F) R!
! .
.3

JL2 2/
U 2
1
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DISTRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGI A
M
R O A N O K E D I SI
VI ON
ANTH ONY ANTH A SM I ,
TH

J A C. l
ULI
,
CLERK
BK
DEP
CL
ERK

CASE NO.7:
14CV00
356

Pl ntf ,
ai if

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
M
V.

CHARLESA.M CCLURE,ESQ.e aI,
t .

By: G l n E.C onr
e
ad
C hi fU nie St e D it i tJudge
e
t d at s s r c

D ef
endant .
s

Ant
hony Ant Sm ih,a Ke ucky i ae pr ee ng pr K , fl t s a ton i t
ha
t
nt
nm t oc di
o
ied hi c i n he
Unied Stt Ditit Cour f t So he n Ditit of Ohi cli i t t t de e
t
aes src
t or he ut r
src
o, am ng ha he f ndan s
t
i rnge o hi pae rg s Li r ly consr ng hi s
nf i d n s tnt i ht . be a l
tui
s ubmisons t c tdoc t d t m as
s i , he our
ke e he

a ci lrght acin purua t t 42 U. C.j 1
vi i s to
s n o
S.
983. Be aus t e nt gi ng rs t t
c e he ve s vi ie o he
pl ntf scai soc u r i Le ngt Vigi a whe e one oft de enda sr sde t Ohi
ai if l m
c r ed n xi on, r ni, r
he f nt e i d, he o

c u tta serd te c s t ti c u t Se 2 U.. j 1 0 () S t h sn tp e i te
o r rn fre h a e o h s o r. e 8 SC. 4 0b . mih a o rpad h
rquiieflng f a hass te a a iai t pr e j fr pa rs Upon rviw
e st ii ee nd
ubmitd n pplc ton o oce d . oma upe i.
q
e e
oft r e d,hec t i t tt aci n m us bes
he e or t our fnds ha he to
t umm a iy dim is d.
rl s s e
Sm ih s a now - c as a t ne Cha l A .M c m e,of Le ngt Vi gi a,who
t ues
de e ed tor y, res
cl
xi on, r ni

r pr e e Smih i obt i ng a 1 pa e f a de c Sm ih i nt t ûpora e Li d
e es nt d
t n ani
999 t nt or
vie
t nve ed, he i tbl qui
Sn t ton Ca t' Some i e a t ob ani t pa e , Sm ih s f r a sr ke a wa
nia i
r.
'
tm fer t i ng he t nt
t ufe ed
to
nd s
t
empor rl i a ct t Smih bele st tdurng t sperod a t r afe ,M c ur ofe ed
a iy nc pa iaed. t
ive ha
i hi i nd he e tr cl e f r
t s t ton c r de c f s e ashi own on hi bus ne s webs t Pa e st m , hus a l ge y
he ania i a t vi e or al
s
s i s
ie, t nt or t
le dl

i rngi on Smih' rght unde t pa e .Smih a s rst tM c ur wr uly de ed hi
nfi ng
t si s
r he t nt
t s e t ha
cl e ongf l ni m

a1p oistuso tie a d s e c mpe s tr d ma e a d a ijmcin a an tM c t e s
1 r ft h b an d n e ks o n ao y a g s n n n t to g is clr '
l

t lo ue i
c i ton of fa ent c
ontnua i
r udul
onduc a r us l t m a r pa a i . Sm ih a s s s Jm
t nd ef a o ke e r tons
W ense n,who al ge y kne a utt fa s he e.
i ti
le dl
w bo he r ud c m

The Prs Lii to Reor Ac I t saest a f rlc ts ldimisar
ion tgain. f m t PLIAI tt hat edea our hal s s l
a ton fld j f ma paupei ata tme i t cour deer nest tt aci i fi ous
ci ie . or
q
rs ny i f he
t t mi ha he ton s rvol ,

maiiuso f i t saea cam o wh c rle ma b ga td.28U. C.j 1 5 e( )B)
lco r al o tt li n ih eif y e ' n e
s
r
S.
91 ()2 ( .
Cong es ha not d t ta ltg tt
r s s e ha ii an t
whos flng f sa e as um e by t publc,unlke a pa ng
e ii ee r s d
he
i
i
yi
ltga ,lcks a e onom i i n i t r fai fom flng fi ous malc ous or r peii
ii nt a
n c
c nce tve o e r n r
ii rvol , ii
e ttve

lws is' J h s n v.Edo 3 F.u p.d 7 5 7 6 ( D.Va 1 9 )( u tn Netk v
a u t. o n o
'
lw, 7 s p z 7 , 7 E.
. 9 9 q o ig iz e .
W il ms 4 0 U. 31 ,3 4 ( 9 9 ) Ac o digy c u t ae c a g d t ds s a a to
li , 9 S. 9 2 1 8 ). c r n l, o rs r h r e o imis n ci n
n
pr e ng j f ma paupei a tme durng t coure of t ltgain whe i be mes
oce di . or
q
rs ny i
i he
s
he ii to
n t co

a pae tta t ea to i fi lu , lco s o fist saeacam.28U. C. 1 5e ( )
p rn h t h cin s rvoo s maiiu , r al o tt li
S. j 91 ()2 ;
Canv.
i Commonwe lhofViMi a,982F.Supp.113 11 ( D. 1 )
at
r ni
2, 36 E. Va. 997 .
A ltga m a be de med t ac malci l i hi m o i i t ve a ha a s t
ii nt y
e
o t i ousy f s tve s o x nd r s he
def nda s J
e nt . ohns 37 F.
on,
supp. a 776. l de er i ng whe he an a ton i m a i i ,t
zd t
n t m ni
t r
c i s lc ous he

co tmus r vi w notonl t i tntc
ur
te e
y he nsa ompl i ,butas t pl ntf sprorltgi c
ant
lo he ai if i ii ous onduc .
t

I ( ingCo h a v. o i ,7 F.d 1 1 1 1 - 7 ( t Ci.1 9 ). I te atmai e u o
d. ct
i
c rn M n s 3 3 3 0, 3 6 1 4h r 9 6 ) n h l tv , p n
e
fndi t tac antfl j f mapa rsr ie cli t tGha noagua eba i i lw
i ng ha ompli ied . or
q
upei ass ams ha i ve r bl ss n a
orf c ,'heco tm a s
a t't
ur y umm a iy dimi st ta ton asfi ous Nasm v.W a de M a y a
rl s s ha c i
rvol .
i
r n. r l nd

Ho s o Co r, 4F.d9 , 5 ( t Ci.1 9 )(ne eigp i rv rino j 1 5 e)
u e f r.6 3 51 9 4 4h r 9 5 itmrtn ro eso f 91 ().
Sm ih f l t s t s m e pa e i rnge e c a m s a ns M ccl e i a l s t ee
t ied he e he a
t nt nf i m nt l i
gai t
ur n t ea t hr

p i r lws is S t v.M c u e Ca e No.70 CV0 41 ( . Va 2 0 ) (u rl
ro a ut' mih
.
clr , s
:8 0 4 W D. . 0 8 s mmaiy
d s se wih u prj dieu d r2 U. C.j1 5e ( )B)f rfit et saea cam) S t
imis d t o t eu c n e 8 S.
91 ( )2 ( o alr o tt li ; mih
l
v. M c t e No. 6 1 CV0 0 2 ( . Va Jme 8 2 1 ) ( imisd u e 28 U. C.
clr,
l
:0 0 2 W D. . t
, 0 0 ds se nd r
S.
2

j 1 5 e( )B)i) wih p eu ie f r fiu e t sae a cam) S t v. M c l e No.
91 ()2 ( (i t rj d c o alr o tt
li ; mih
clr ,
z
7:4 0 8 ( . Va J ne 1 ,2 4 ( imis d t e j1 5 e( ( frfi r t saea
1 CV0 2 5 W D. . u 0 01 ) ds se md r 91 ()2)B) o al e o tt
u

cam) I d s s ig No 7:8
li . n imisn . 0 CV00 4, h c u tt o j iiln tc t tt e we st S t
41 t e o r o k udca o ie ha h b i mi
e h
r f r nc d m e el pr ded t ge r lpublc wih a opporuniy t s a ch a o an fe
ee e e
r y ovi
he ne a
i t n
t t o e r nd bt i r e
c e ofpa e sf a1 paentd i ntonsfom 1 6 t t pr e a di notofe a oft
opi s
t nt or 1 t e nve i r
97 o he es nt nd d
f r ny he

patntd pr t f s l I is opi on dimisng N o.7: 4CV00285,t cour not t t
e e oduc s or a e. n t
ni
s si
1
he
t ed ha
Pa e st m i no l
t nt or s
onge i ope a i a M cclze di d i 201 t m oo i a c a m f
rn
r ton, nd
tr e n
0, hus
tng ny l i or

ij ncie r l f F rte e smer a o s te c u tc n ld sta t e p e e ta to mus b
nu t ei . o h s n e s n , h o r o cu e h t h r sn ci n t e
v
e
s mma i d s se u d rj1 5 e( )b a fi oo s a iha noba i i fc o lw.
u rl imis d n e 91 ()2 () s rv lu , s t s
y
ss n a t r a
M or ove ,t c t tnds t t t a ton ag ns Defnda M c ur mus a s be
e r he our i
ha he c i
ai t e nt cl e
t lo
dimi s d asm a ii us Sm ih ha had n e notc fom t c tspror de ii t t hi
s se
lc o .
t s
mpl
ie r he our' i
c sons ha s
c am s ar ute l wihout m e i,a yethe c i
li
e try t
rt nd
ontnues t fl ne lw s t r ii t s me
o ie w a uis a sng he a

cai s The onl c
lm .
y oncevabl m o i f r s h r ttve flngs i ilwilt wa d t de e nt
i e tve o uc epe ii ii s 1 l o r he f nda
a a i e t con i t ha as hi wih me ils ltgai
nd n ntnt o tnue o r s m t rte s ii ton.
Fo t r s
r he ea ons sa e t c t dim is Sm ih' c
tt d, he our
s s es
t s ompli , pur ua t
ant
s nt o

j 1 5 e( )B) a fio o a d maiiu . Th Clr i dr ce t snd c p e o t s
91 ()2 ( , s rv lus n
l os
c
e ek s ie td o e o is f hi
m em or ndum opi o a a co pa ng or rt pl i if
a
ni n nd c m nyi
de o a ntf .

ENTER:Ths # l d yo J l, 4.
i
a f uy 201
Chi Unied St t D i ti tJ
ef t
a es sr c udge