Robles v. Kelly et al
Filing
10
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 09/18/2014. (kab)
cL- s oFFI E u. .
c s = ea .
A M NM L VA
T
LE,
F D
.
I THE I NI
x
J TED STATES ol
sTm c' cocR'
r
r
--
FoR THE w Esu l x ol
t
sTm c' oF VI NI
r
RGI A
R o A xo u m v l o x
sl
O SC A R R O BLE S,
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
- --.0
.
5L' รถ @ 1
!
J wa
uu
BY;
Ci lA ct on N o.7: :vvi
i
14- 00360
.
Ep
M EM O M NDUM OPI ON
NI
By: Jac o L.K i e
ks n
sr
Se or U nie St t D i t i tJudge
ni
t d a es s r c
LT .K ELLY ,e aI,
t .
De e a t)
f nd nts.
Os a Ro e ,pr ee ngpr K,ie acvi rght c
c r bls oc di
o fld i l i s ompli , ls nt o42U. C.
antptrua t
S. j
.
1
983. By Or re t r d J y 1 201 t c t r cedpl ntf t s i t n 1 da fom
de n e e ul 8, 4, he our die t ai if o ubm twihi 0 yj r
'
t da eoft Or rasatm e ofas e s a i t ac ountf nn,a a c rii c of .
he t
he de t e nt
s t , n nma e c
o
nd e tfed opy
pli ifstus f ac ountsa e ntf t sx- on h pe i i me ael pr c ng t flng
antf ' r t und c
t t me or he i m t rod m di t y e edi he ii
oft c pli ,obt i fo t a opra eprs ofi i ofe h prs a whi h i orwas
he om a nt aned r m he ppr it ion fcal ac ion t c s
co i d dtrng t tsxnfne ti ha i mont pe i aswe la t e c e verfed saeme f m .
h rod
l s he xe ut d ii t t nt or On
Augus 7, 4 pl i ifr tmwd t sa e ntofa s t a ve iid satm e f m a alter
t 201 antf e t
he t t me
s es nd rfe t e nt or nd et
e ani why hehad nots
xpl i ng
ubmit t i t a countr por a t s f nd a c
ted he nma e c
e t nd nlt u c ount
saeme s Pl i ifsa e i t lte t tCol SprngsCo r ci lCe e had nots nt
t t nt . antf t t d n he e tr ha
d i
r e tona ntr
e
pl ntf t i t a ot r tba t hi butr a dl sheha s it a i ae
ai if he nma e cc mt epor ck o m
eg r es
d ubm ted n nm t
a coun r por whe hefld hi co pl nton J y 18, 4. i ae a co r por t t
c
te t n
ie s m ai
ul
201 The nm t c unt e tha
pl ntf s ntt t c twih hi c pli wa i omplt a t r f et cou tc tona l
ai if e o he our t s om a nt s nc
e e nd he e or he r ondii ly
fl t c s pe ng pl ntf r ttn t r quie pa r k. On Aug t7,201 t co ts t
ied he a e ndi ai if etr he e r d pe wor
us
4 he ur en
pli tf a t rco tona l fl d or rdie tng hi t s
a n if no he ndii ly ie de r ci
m o ubmi t r uie pa wo k and
t he eq r d per r
ga hi 1 da t c pl On A ugus 1 201 pl ntf s nta l te t t c ts a i t the
ve m 0 ys o om y.
t 3, 4 ai i f e
e t r o he our t tng ha
ha bee r l s d asw e la c nge ofaddr s . n Aug t25, 4 t co tr c ved t
d n e ea e
l ha
esO
us
201 he ur e ei
he
c tonaly fld or ra undei r bl whi h ha t Col SprngsCore i Ce e
ondii l ie de s
lve a e c d he d i
r ctonal nt r
a es t r f eoutofa a
ddr s he e or
n bunda eofc ton, hec ts ntpl ntf t co tonal fld
nc
au i t our e ai if he ndii ly ie
,
c
E
Aug t7, 1 o de t t ne a es a ga pl ntf 1 da t c pl Pli tf wa
us 20 3 r r o he w ddr s nd ve ai if 0 ys o om y. a n if s
a v sdt a afiu et c mpl wo l rs li ds sa of hsa to wi u p eu ie
d ie h t alr o o y u d e ut n imis l t i cin t t rj d c .
ho
M or t n 1 da ha ea ed,a pli tf hasf l t c pl wih t des rbe
e ha 5 ys ve lps nd a n if
aied o om y t he c i d
c n iinsb c u ec mpl Ac o d n l,hec u t imis st ea to wih u p eu iea d
o dto e a s o y. c r i gy t o r ds s e h cin t o t rj dc n
srkest c e fo t a tvedocke oft c t Pli ifm a r fl t c am si as pa a e
ti he as r m he c i
t he our. antf y e ie he l i n e r t
a ton oncepl ntf i pr pa e t c pl wih t not c tons
ci
ai if s e r d o om y t he ed ondii .
The Cl r i die t d t s nd a c oft sM e or ndtm Opi on a a om pa ng
ek s rce o e
opy hi m a l
ni nd cc
nyi
Or rt pl i if
de o antf .
E r T i 1=
x' hs
sR:
dyo spe e,04
a f etmbr2 1.
e orUnied St t DititJ
t
aes src udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?