Hurd v. Clarke
Filing
11
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 12/11/2014. (tvt)
Pro t t tme l di up t t tans ton,Da r n a ( ttonej ha
ir o he i ea ng
o he r aci
me o nd Peii r d
s ver l pho c
e a
ne onve s i . Thes c
ratons
e onve s tons we e r co de usng a
rai
r e r d i
r or ng de ce pr ded by l w e or e e ofii l. Law e or e t
ec di
vi
ovi
a nf c m nt fc as
nf c men
ofi i l a s tted Dnme on wih a r co di de ce t r or he m e tng wih
fc as lo it
r
t e r ng vi o ec d r e i
t
( tto e) The r c r ig o te p o e c n e sto s a me t wee
Peiin r.
e o dn f h h n o v rain nd ei
ng r
a it i o evi nce a t i .
dm ted nt
de
t ral
Peii r arve a t l ai of t me tng i a ve ce wih t ohe
ttonel ri d t he oc ton he ei n
hil t wo t r
i vi l . Li utna Da r Dut a unde c r polc ofi e ,was wih
ndi dua s
e e nt ryl
y, n
r ove
ie fc r
t
Dnmeon,andt a oa he ( ttoner' ve cl Oneoft occ nt i t
r
hey ppr c d Peii ls hi e.
he upa s n he
c ri t c e t tonl one oft m s d c et t ve cl Dut e e ed t
a nsnzt d ha y
he houl om o he hi e. y nt r he
ve cl, a t oc upa pe m itd Dut t e m i a bag of c a k c ai
hi e nd he c nt r te
y o xa ne
r c oc ne.
W he Dut que tone w he he t ba co a ne tve gr m s of c a k c ai ,
n
y
si d
t r he g nt i d i
a
r c oc ne
t oc upa a g ttone la s ed Dut t t ba c ane fve grmsof
he c nt nd peii r sur
y hat he g onti d i n
c a k c i D ut e t d t ve c e on t pr t xtof g ti t m one t buy
r c oca ne.
y xie he hi l
he e e
e tng he
y o
t eca k c c i e AsDu y wak dt hsv hce ( eiin r y le ta t a h
h rc o an .
t l e o i e il, P t o eq eld h t h t e
t
wan e t money. A d to l ofi e s a rved a t l a i a a r se
t d he
dii na fc r ri
t he oc ton nd re t d
( eiin r a t et o c p n si t ev hil.
P tto ej nd h wo c u a t n h e ce
Hur v.
d Commonwe t No.0046- 2- si op. t2- ( Ct App.J y 1 201 ) s eJ s
a1h,
1 3, lp a 3 Va. .
ul 2, 2 ; e one
v. ra , 4 F.d 1 06 1 1 (t Ci. 9 )(ttn wrte fn i so h so ia fc b t e
Mu r y 9 7 2 1 , 1 0 4 h r 1 91 saig itn idng f itrc l a t y h
saec t r pr lmedt becore ta e ildt defrnceunl ss wnt beer ous.
tt our a e esz o
rc nd ntte o ee
es ho o rone )
Afe r viwi t sae c t ec d,1fnd t tt pe iin f rawrtofha sc pus
tr e e ng he t t our r or i ha he tto o
i
bea or
mus be dimis d be us t diposto oft sc am wasnotco r r t o a t e ona e
t
s s e ca e he s ii n hi l i
nta y o, r n mr as bl
a i a i of cla l e t bls d f r l1w orba e on a urr s bl deer i ton oft
pplc ton , e ry sa ihe ede a a
sd
n lea ona e t m na i
he
fcs2 2 U . . . 2 5 ( ; e l r W i s i , 9 U. 3 , 6 ( 9 0 (e o nii gt eDue
a t. 8 SC j 2 4 * se n e n h p 3 7 S. 58 3 4 1 7 ) rc g zn h
2A fd r l o r rve n ah b a p tto f rs mes te(ttlc u t fcua t dn st b su d
e ea c u te iwig a e s eiin ç eu llh sae o r' a t li ig o e o n
p
s
n
u ls (eiin r rb t ih pe u to o c remesb cera c n n ige ie e' Mie- v. ek ,
nes p t o e) e us te rs mpin f orc s y la nd o vicn vd nc .' l rEl Drte
t
' l
5 5U.. 31 2 0( 0 5 (u t 2 U.. j2 4 e().S e ec.Le zv. ahi tn 4 4F.d2 , 0 4 S 2 , 4 2 0 ) q oi 8 SC. 25 ()1) e . . , n W s ngo , 4 3 95 3 0 01
ng
(t Ci. 0 6 .Sllve u d rj2 5 ()l i l tdt terc r ta wa b fr tesaec u th t
4h r2 0 ) ûke iw n e 2 4d () s i e o h e od h t s eoe h tt o rta
l
mi
aj dctdtecam o temei . Cul nv. n oltr 5 3U. ,1 lS. .1 8 ,1 9 ( 01 )
du iae h li n h rt ' l Pih se, 6 S.
s' e
3 Ct 3 8 3 8 2 1.
Thee l to ofwhehe asa ec tde soni kc r y t ' ta u e ona ea ia i of'fder
vauain
t r tt our cii s dontar o'or çn nr as bl pplc ton
e al
lw i b s do a i e e d n r v e o e c sa d r .W i imsv Ta o , 2 U. 3 2, 2- 3( 0 0 .A sa e
a s a e n n nd p n e t e iw f a h t n a d l a . vlr 5 9 S. 6 41 1 2 0 ) tt
l
c u t eemiai i ç o tayt'fd rllw iiç rie a ac n l ino po i t ta r ah db (h Uni d
o r d tr n t sç nrl o' e ea a ftt rv s t o cuso p st o h t e c e y te t
on c
a
e
e
Sae Su rme Cout naq e t no lw o itesaec u t cd sac s dfee t ta (h UntdSae
tts pe l r o u si fa r f h tt o rdeie a e ifrnl h n te ie tts
o
y
S p e )Co r h so ast maeil idsig ih befcs' 1 a 41
u rme u t a n e of tral n itn us a l at. d. t 3.
y
'
2
Pr es Cl e oft Four e nt A m e e pr ec s a s a e c tde e
oc s aus
he
te h
ndm nt ot t t t our f ndan f om co c i
tr
nvi ton
d xce upon pr be
t pt
e
oof yond ar as bl doubtofe r f ctnec s a yt c tt e t c i
e ona e
ve y a
e s r o onsiut he rme
wihwhihhei c r '.Peii doe note tbls t tt Cour ofAppeasofVigi a
t c
s haged' ttoner s sa ih ha he
)
t
l
r ni
ba e isdec son on an unr as bl de e mi ton oft f t,a t e de e whe vi
sd t
ii
e ona e t r nai
he ac s nd he vi nc , n ewed
i t lghtm os f vor bl t t Comm onwe 1h,esa ihe t ta r tona tiroff c coul
n he i
t a a e o he
at tbls s ha ny a i l re
at d
ha f
ve ound beyond ar as
e onabl d
e oubtt tPe ii rc pied t diti ecoc i .
ha ttone ons r o srbut
ane
û
t pia i de i a t n a ee ntbewe n t ormor peronsby s m ec
cons r cy s fned s a gr me
t e wo
e s
o
once t
red
a ton t commi a ofens ''Fe g e v.
ci o
t n f e.' i l y Comm onweat 1 Va.
1h, 6
App. 7,
71 722,432 S. 2d
E.
5 0 5 4 ( 9 3 ( u t W rg t Co n at , 2 Va 5 2 5 5 2 7S. 2 71 , 3
2 , 2 1 9 ) q oi
ng ih v. mmo we lh 2 4 . 0 , 0 , 9 E.d 1 7 3
( 982).Pr ofa e ii a e me i no rquie a t Commonweat ma rl o
1 ) oof n xplct gre nt s t e rd, nd he
1h y ey n
cr um sa ilt de et e t bls t co pia y.Stve v.Comm o a1h,1 Va.
ic t nta vi nc o sa ih he ns r c
e ns
nwe t 4
App.
238,241 41 S. 2d881 883( 992)
, 5 E.
,
1 .
Dnme on t sii d t Pe ii ne ha ag ee t s l Da r sfi $500 worh of
r e tte hat tto r d r d o e l me on' rend
t
c i a Peii rwasi t ve c edrve t t m e tng t tc aned $500worh of
ocane, nd ttone
n he hil i n o he e i ha ont i
t
c i Tr 47- 63,80,8
oca ne. . 48,
4.The c i w a pos es e by a t roc upa i t c w ho
oca ne s s s d
no he c nt n he ar
r t t buy l ai wih Pe ii rwhie Pe ii re tr ge t unde co ofi e t
ode o he
oc ton t ttone
l ttone nco la d he
r ver fc r o
buy t c ai 1 49,60. Pe ii ras ur d t ofi e t tt c a ne w e ghtw asa u a e,
he oc ne. d.
ttone s e he tc r ha he oc i
i
cc r t
a Peiine de nde pay ntwhe t ofi rwakeda ywiht c ai L.48 5 65nd tto r ma d me
n he fce l wa t he oc ne. d - 0,
o
A fdealco tma as is t wrtunde t iu e ona ea iaton'clus i t f r lcou tfnds
e r ur y lo s ue he i
r he tnr as bl pplc i ' a e f he ede a r i
t th saec u tç e tte tec re t o ennglg l rn il fo gh S p e ) u t d cso sb t
ha te tt o r (d ni s h or c g v r i e a picpe r m te u rme Co r' e iin u
i i
s
u ea ona y a ist tprnci et t f t oft prs r' c e. l Thi r s blnes sa r i an
nr s bl pple ha i pl o he acs he ione s as ' d. s ea ona e s tnda d s
'
o jcieo e l a 41 .A Vigni c u tsf ig cl b d e du rao a emeeybe a s id e n t
betv n . d. t 0
r i a o r' i n s amot e eme n es n bl rl c u e t o s o
nd
c t e t bls d U nied St t Supr m e Cou tpr o nton a i s i t r ul r ac i notc r r t t t
ie s a i he
t
a es
e
r e ede
n s ue f he es t e hed s
onta y o ha
etbl h dpe e e t Mic el . oaz , 40U. 1 ,1 (0 3 .F rh r r,t )saec ut ata
sa i e rc d n. th lv Es ra 5 S. 2 6 2 0 ) u temoe ia tt-o r fcu l
s
l
dee na i i notunr a onabl me el be us t fder ha sc twoul hav r ac d adifr nt
tnni ton s
es
e r y ca e he e al bea our
d e e he
fe e
c n lso i tef s isa c . W o dv Ale , 5 U.. 9 , ,l 0S. . 41 8 (01 )
o cu in n h i tn tn e' o . ln 5 8 S 2 0
r
'
3 Ct 8 , 49 2 0 .
3
66.Cons quen l t e de e wass fce t s w Pe ii rsa e m e t diti e
e
ty,he vi nc
ufi int o ho
ttone ' gr e nt o srbut
c i .3
oca ne
Ac di y, g an Res
cor ngl l r t ponde ' m o i t dim isa dim ist peii f awrtof
nts ton o s s nd s s he tton or
i
habe c pus Bas d uponm y fndi t tPe ii rha notm a t r uiie s t nta
as or . e
i ng ha ttone s
de he eq st ubsa i l
s o n o ad nilo ac nsi to a rg ta rq rdb 2 U. C. 2 3c , c ri c t o
h wig f e a f o t u in l ih s e uie y 8 S. j 25 () a e ti ae f
t
t
a a a lt i denid.
ppe l biiy s
e
E T R:hs u. a o Dee e,04
N E T il -dy f cmbr2 1.
%
i Unied St t D it i J
or t
a es s rct udge
3Alhoug Pe ii r a t ksDa e on' c e biiy and ac us he ofbei a pr e sona i onna twih a
t
h ttone tac
m r s r di lt
c es r
ng
of s i l nf
n t
c i i hit y,lam notpem itdt r dee net c e biiyoft wine s swhot tfeda til M a s l v.
rm nal sor
r te o e- tnni he r di lt
he t s e
esii t ra. r hal
Lo b r e, 9U. 4 , 4( 9 3) No tees Da rnh dak o e g d ighe tsi n ta s ha
n ea r45 S. 22 43 1 8 . neh ls, meo a c n wld e urn r etmo y h t he d
wor a apolc i or
ked s
ie nf mantandm a contole pur ha esofdl gso num e ous proroc so .Tr 68 77.
de
r ld c s
- n
u
r , i ca ins . ,
4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?