Sayers v. Buckingham Correctional Center

Filing 27

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/31/2014. (kab)

- >*<. QFFI U.. AT.n I
OE : DI r r
AT ROANY , A
V
F# E
LFD

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
R O AN O K E DI SI N
VI O

0CT 3 2 1
21
J I C.
ULA
DEP

JERRY SAYERS,

u>, ERk
CL

BY;
LERK

CASE NO .7: 4CV00385
1
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
M E M O M N D U M O PI O N
M

B.
POW ELL,

By: Gl n E.Co
e
nrad
Chi f Unied St e Di t c Judge
e
t
at s s ri t
De e
f ndant
.

Pl i ifJ
antf eny Sa r ,a Vigi a i t pr ee ng pr s ,hasfl d a cvi rg sa i
ye s
r ni nma e oc di
o e
ie
i l i ht cton

t r 42 U. C.j 1
mde
S.
983,alegng t tt dee nt tu ta co ofie i vi ai hi
l i ha he fnda r s c unt fc r s oltng s
c tt tonalrg s by fe i hi Ve e a diabiiy be tt unde a ga nihm e sl ons
onsiu i
i ht
r ezng s t r ns s lt neis
r
r s nt lmm
f runpai alm ony.1 The co tde e Sa r 'm o i f t mpor y r tani or ,butt k
o
d i
ur nid ye s ton or e
ar esr i ng der
oo

h smo inf rprlmi r ij ncin t e a v sme ta d drce t ed fn a tt r s o d t
i to o ei nay nu to md r d ie n n ie td h ee d n o e p n o
t moto as wel as t c
he
in
l
he ompl i . The de e nt ha fl d a r s ns as e tng t t
ant
f nda
s ie
e po e, s ri ha
i e l ut y r le s d be de e a Sa sha r ple a fl d addii lm o i . Afe
ntroc or e if houl
ni d, nd yer s e id nd ie
tona tons tr

r ve o te es b si n ,hec u t e isS y r ' to sf r ei nayijmci erle .
e iw f h s u miso s t o r d ne a e s mo in o prlmi r nt tv eif
Sa s an i ae a Buc ngha Core tona Ce e ,i a diabl ve e a whos s e
yer , nm t t ki m
r c i l nt r s
s ed t r n
e ol
i ome c it oft pe c nt e ofhi Vee a be ft pai t hi d li hi i ar e a i
nc
onsss he r e ag
s tr ns ne is d o m trng s nc c r ton.
The Taz we l Cot y Cic t Cour r e l s r ed ga ihme s
e l
mt r ui
t ec nty e v
m s nt umm a i s aga ns Sa s
re
i t yer '
Bucki ha tt ta c
ng m rl c ountf ai o pa
s
or lm ny yment aleg y owe t Sa r 'e wie. Ptr ua t
s l edl
d o ye s x- f
ls nt o

t Cour' o de ,t de e ntplce o r $3, 9om Sa r 'tts a co it a r s r e
he
ts r r he f nda a d ve 000
ye s rzt c unt n o e e v
a coun ,pe ng a Nove r9, 4 he rng on t gn nibme m a tr Sa r i notal d
c
t ndi
mbe 201 a i
he r s nt te . ye s s
lowe
1 Pl ntf fld hi aci i t Unied Stt DititCour f t Ea tr DititofVigi a. l was
ai if ie s ton n he t aes src
t or he se n src
r ni t

ta serdh r b cus tec u eo a to ao ei Ta e l, rii, ti ti c u ts t idcin
rn fre ee e a e h a s f cin rs n z welVigna wihn hs o r'jls ito .
r

t s nd a of t fl i t s r s r e ac ount Sa r fld a m o i i t cr ui c t
o pe ny
he znds n hi e e v c . ye s ie
ton n he ic t our,
a s ri t thi f ndswe e e m ptfom ga n s e . The Cour deni t sm oto i tal
s e tng ha s u
r xe
r
r ihm nt
t ed hi
i n nii ly,

b t ltr v c td t e d n a o d r a d d sg ae a d fee tj d t h a t e matr i
u ae a ae h e il r e n e i n td ifrn u ge o e r h
te n
Nove be .
m r

Sa sfld t sj 1 a ton and move t s c tt or rt prs n t r e e hi
yer ie hi 983 ci
d hi our o de he io o elas s
fl i m e a e y,des t t c r ui co ts or r Sa s a s t t t w ihou a ce s t t
l
nds m di t l
pie he i c t ur ' de . yer s ers ha t t c s o he

foze f nds t i a tr t Nove be he i he wils f r ir pa a e hn m be us he i
r n u
mtl fe he
m r arng,
l ufe re r bl r
ca e
s
unabl t s nd money t hi age m ot r t pay c yme s f m e ca a de a ca e,ort
eo e
o s d
he , o
opa nt or di l nd nt l r
o
pur ha ee gls e , a i ai ,a co mis r ie s
c s ye a s s he rng ds nd m s a y t m .

< p ei n t ij n to i a e ta r iay rme y n v ra r e a o rg t' i tr
i rlmi a' nu cin s n xr o dn r e d e e wa d d s f ih . W ne
A
y
'
v. t a Re . f Co n i.n .5 5U. 7 2 ( 0 8 .Be a s i tro u o yij ndierle
Naurl s De . u cl lc, 5 S. , 4 2 0 ) c u e nel c tr nu v eif

i a e ta r ia y rme y t e pat s e ig te p ei n r ij n to mus ma e a ce r
s n xr o dn r e d , h ry e kn h rlmi ay nu cin t k la
s
howi çha he i lke y t s c d on t m e is he i lkey t s f rir pa a e ha m i t
ng ç t s i l o uc ee
t
he rt ; s i l o ufe re r bl r n he

a s n eo p ei n r rle ;h tt b ln eo e uie tpsi hsfv r a da ijlcin i i
b e c f rlmi ay eif ta he aa c f q t s i n i a o ; n n nln to s n
i
t publc i e es . I a 20.
he
i nt r t' d. t
'

The c tc nnotfnd t t Sa s has de o tae any ir pa abl har he wilf c
our n
i ha yer
m nsr td
re r e m
l ae
wihoutt s c ts i e l ut y i e ve i n t pr de hi a ce st hi foze f nds. l i
t
hi our' nt roc or ntr nto o ovi
m c s o s' n u
r
ts
t s e t t hi i biiy t pa m e ca c ys a t s tm e wil not pr vent hi fom
mdiputd ha s na lt o y di l opa t hi i
l
e
m r
ob ani tmel m e ca c r as ne es a y f s rous m e ca ne ds Att mos ,Saye s
t i ng i y di l a e
c s r or e i
di l e .
he
t
r
a s t at mpor r i biiyt buy a ma ie sfom t commi s r f hi pe s
s ers e
a y na lt o
s ny t m r he
s a y or s ronalus ort
e o
s nd a much mone hom e, hewoul pr f r Suc s tlve de i tonsoffnancalm e ns
e s
y
as
d e e . h hor-i d prva i
i i
a
c nno c tt t t t of i r bl ha m ne es a y t w ar ntt e r or na y r med
n t onsiu e he ype
nvpa a e r
c s r o ra he xta di r e y
Sa r s e he e I t eve t tSaye spr va l i hi cl msa o a nsa c st hi f ,
ye s e ks r . n he nt ha
r e is n s ai nd bt i c es o s unds

2

he c m a t desr d git,pur ha e ,a pa e sa t tm e.Ashe t make no c e r
an ke he ie fs c s s nd ym nt t hat i
hus
s
la

s
howi t the i lke y t s f ir pa abl ha m i t a e e of i e l or r le ,hi
ng ha
s i l o ufer re r e r n he bs nc
nt rocut y e if s
m oto f s h r lefmus bede e
i n or uc ei
t
nid.Thec twil howe ,al Sa r t a ar ques f
our l,
ver low ye s o dd e t or

p r n n ijmci erle t h sc mp an .Ana p o raeo d rwilis eti d y.
e ma e t n t tv eif o i o lit
p r p it r e l su h s a
The Clr i dieced t s nd c es of t s m e o a um opi on a ac ompa ng
ek s r t o e opi
hi m r nd
ni nd c
nyi
o de t t pli tf
r r o he a n if
EN TER : Thi l l
s A

d yo- tb r201
a toco e, 4.
Chi fUnied St t Diti tJ
e
t
aes src udge