Neely v. Clark

Filing 15

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 12/05/2014. (kab)

- w**. *'F1 Q & 0*% * Qr
5:

A mN k,A
T d iV

F
j
k
-

I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES DI RI CO U R T
ST CT
FO R TH E W ESTE RN DI
STRI T O F V I I I
C
RG N A
RO AN O K E D I SI N
VI O
RO NA LD DA R RE LL N EELY ,
Pettoner,
ii
V.

HAROLD W .CLARK,
R e ponde .
s
nt

no ..
jQ

5;
A

JULA C D D
I
A:
EP
c

)
)
)
)
)

C i lA cton N o.7: vvi
i
14-c 00389

)
)

By:

M E M O M N D UM O PI I N
N O

H on.
Jacks L. ier
on K s
Se o Uni e St e Di t c Judge
ni r
t d at s s ri t

Ronal D a r l N e l pr e ng pr s ,fl d a pe ii f a w rtofha asc pus
d r e l e y, oc edi
o e ie
tton or
i
be or ,

purua t 28U. C.j225 whiehewasi r rt Peii ralege t tduepr es wa
s nt o
S.
4, l
ncaceaed. ttone l d ha
oc s s
vi a e whe hewa pe lze wih t f f iur ofg co uc tm ef aprs dicplna y
olt d
n
s nai d t he oret e ood nd t i or ion s i i r
conviton.Afe Res
ci
tr ponde fld am oto t dimis Peii rfld anotceofc ng of
nt ie
i n o s s , ttone ie
i
ha e
a e s i cai t thewa no l ri a ce a e The c ts e ntyr quesed
ddr s , ndi tng ha
s onge nc r r t d.
our ubs que l e t
Res
ponde t a e sPe ii r sc t a sa us a isaf e to t ha a pe ii
nt o ddr s ttone ' usodi l t t nd t f c n he be s tton.

Re ponde ac
s
nt knowldgedt tPe ii rhad be n r e edfom i ar e aton and a gue t t
e
ha ttone
e elas r nc c r i
r s ha
t sa i i now m oo . Thetme f rPe ii rt r s
hi cton s
t
i o ttone o e pond ha e r a t ca ei rpe f
s xpied, nd he s s i or
dipost o A f e r vi w i t r c d,1di m i st a ton a m oot
s ii n. t r e e ng he e or
s s he c i s
.

'A)fd r l o r h sn ih rt p we t rn e a v s r o i o sn rçod cd
$ e ea c u t a et e he o r o e d r d io y pnin o t e i e
(
que to t tcn
s i ns ha nnota f c t r g s ofltga si t c ebe or t m .' Pr s rv. e r
f e t he i ht
ii nt n he as f e he '' ei e N wki k,

422U. 395, (975 ( i NorhCaolnav. c 404U. 244,246( 971 Fe a
S. 401 1 ) quotng t r i Rie,
S.
1 :. derl
c t a e S e pow e ed t dec de m oo que tonsora t a tpr postons ...' ior a v.
our s r ç m
not
r o i
t si
bs r c o ii . ' Calf ni

Sa Pa o& Tulr R. ,1 U. 308,31 ( 893 .tMootquetonsrquienoa wer' M o.
n bl
a e R. 49 S.
4 1 ) s
si e r
ns .' .
Ka & Te Ry. Fers 1 U. 602,606( )
n. x. v. ri, 79 S.
1900 .
Pl ntf sr eas f i ceraton m oot t reques ed releft r t e good conduct
ai i f el e rom ncar
i
s he
t
i o esor

tme. Bec us Pe ii rhasale c
i
a e ttone
r ady ompl td t t nn ofi a ce a i t whih t good
ee he e
nc r r ton o c he

,

c n u t i wo da py,h r i n r me y.S eLu a v Dee d r o W i lf , 0 U.
o d c tme ul p l t ee s o e d e j n . fn e s f l ie 5 4 S.
d
5 5 5 0 61( 9 2 (ic si gr d e s blt ee n o sa dng ; wn sv. a vs 5 7F.d
5 , 6 - 1 9 ) ds u sn e rs a ii lme t f tn i ) To e J r i, 7 3
y
5 548(t Ci. )(çlfnoraitcposi lt e sst apli ifc nobti t uli t
43, 4h r 2009 $(1 e lsi sbiiy xit hat antf a an he tmae
r le,Peii wilf lt s tsyt rdr s biiypr '(nt lquottonmaksomit l;
eif ttoner l ai o aif he e esa lt ong. i ema
'
ai
r
tedl

Untd Sae v. r y 5 F.d2 0 2 3(t Ci. 0 )(( c s i mo twh nt eis e
ie tt s Had , 45 3 8 , 8 4h r 20 8 $ A1 a e s o e h su s
ç
prs ne aen l n e lv o tep rislc alg lyc g ia l itr s i t eo to .
e e td r o o g r i e r h a t a k e al o nz be ne e tn h uc me'
e
).
A cc di y,Re po nt sm o i t dim i s i g a t d, t a ton i di m i s d asm oot
or ngl
s nde ' ton o s s s r n e and he c i s s s e
.

Ba e upon my fndi t tPe ii rhasnotm a t r quiies t nta s
sd
i ng ha ttone
de he e st ubsa i l howi ofade a
ng
nil

ofac tt i lrgh asrquie by28U. C.j2253( ,ac riiaeofa l lt i
onsiutona i t e r d
S.
c) e tfc t ppeaabiiy s
de ed.
ni
EN TER :Thi

= da ofDe m ber 201
y
ce
, 4.
f

S i rU nie St t s i t i tJ
o
t d a e s rc udge