Dillard v. Quinones et al
Filing
11
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 09/25/2014. (kab)
. ,
R F*#: *4 1 ' #, # #' f'=
d
. 1. J pi# * *#
:
'
A fOA S ,A
T y NtK: V
Fl ll
tfi
SFP 2 2 1
,
24
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGI A
NI
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI
ALPH ONSO LEROY DI
LLARD,
JULt ' r
ABY:
DE
'
CL
ERK
CLERK
CASE NO .7:
146+ 00405
Pl ntf ,
ai i f
M EM O M N DU M O PI O N
NI
By: Hon.Gl n E.Conrad
e
C hi fU ni e St t sD i t i Judge
e
t d a e sr d
DR.QUI
NONES, AL.
c
,
Dee
fndants.
t)
Al
phons Le oy Dil z a Vi gi a i a e pr e ng pr K ,fl t s c vi r gh s a ton
o r
la d,
r ni nm t oc edi
o
ied hi i l i t c i
pts a tt 4 U. C.j1 8 . Di ad alg sta a trh n tfe t d fnd n j i d co of
t u n o 2 S.
r
9 3 l r le e h t fe e oiid he ee a t al o tr
l
hi c o c kneepan,f whih a he doc orha pr c i d pa n media i a f l u
s hr ni
i or c not r t
d es rbe i
c tons nd olow p
c r, h j i d co rc mme d d o l o e-h -omtrp i me iain f rDilr Th c u t
a e t e al o tr e o n e ny v rte c t e an d c to o lad. e o r
fn t tt e e alg to f i t sae a y cam a to be t e j 1 8 a d sl rl
ids ha h s le ains al o tt n li cina l md r 9 3 n l
mmai
y
di m i s s hi c pl i .
s s e s om a nt
I
Dilr s s isons i c t t f lowi s nce ofe nt r e tt hi cli s
la d' ubm s i
ndi ae he o l ng eque
ve s elvan o s am .
Dilr was teaed f a s vee kne ij y o M ac 25,201 a was r e e wih
lad
r t or e r
e nur n rh
4, nd
elasd t
pr c i i a a f l up e m i ton s he e f rAprl22. On M a c 26,201 Dilr
es rptons nd olow
xn na i c dul d o
i
rh
4, la d
wa ic r eae a te M ide Rie Re in lJ i (t ej i',wh r h i p e e t sr ig a
s n a c rtd t h d l v r go a al th al) ee e s r s nl e vn
t
'
y
zomont s nt nc Durng hi i ake m e c it r i w,Dilr des i d hi kne co to
h e e e.
i
s nt
dial n e v e
la d crbe s e ndii n
a t medi to a f low up or r d by hi ou sde doc o . On Aprl6,Dil r fld a
nd he
cai ns nd o l
de e
s ti
tr
i
la d ie
r ques f m a ki why he ha notye r c ve hi pr c i i ,a a ofi i lr s
e t or s ng
d
t e ei d s es rptons nd n fc a e ponde t t
d ha
he w ason t ls t s e t doc or
he i t o e he t .
.
Dr Qui
. nonese ne Dilr on Aprl8 201 Thedoco alege y s dal heç
xnmi d la d
i , 4.
tr l dl ai l t
was
rquie t gi g lad)wasM oti unls c ime by a ousde s ce' ( No.3,a
e r d o ve Dilr
rn e s onfr d n ti our .' ECF
t
1 . Dilr g v t ed co tep nenl e sf rh sd co a d t me iai n p e c ie
6) lad a e h o t r h ho l r o i o t r n he dc to s r srb d,
mb
b tn o e fo tej i c na td t e o tie d co . I lt Ap i,Dilr a ke a o th s
u o n r m h al o tce h u sd o tr n ae rl l d s d b u i
a
s hed e f l up vii bei c ncel d. Ofi e s t d Dil r t the woul ha t tl a
c uld olow
st ng a le
fc r ol la d ha
d ve o 5e
rques t s eDr Qui
e t o e . nonesa utt ne df s ha a nt nt
bo he e or uc n ppoi me .
Dilr wr e a greva e on J 28,sa i t tl k oft operc r a t r py' f
la d ot
i nc
une
t tng ha ac
l
pr
a e nd he a ' or
h sk e c n iin wi ma ehi Ge smo ie rij r d o c ipld o a1t a o e' (d)
i n e o dto l k m ç s b l, enu e , r rp e r l he b v . l .
l
l
'
Ag i aji o t a r s n e b tlig hm t rq e ta a p it n wi Dr Quio e .
an, al fkil epo d d y el i o e u s n p on me t t . n n s
n
h
Dilr sgreva a lsae t tbe a eDr Qui
la d' i nce ppea ttd ha c us . noneshad no hel d hi i t pas,he
t pe m n he t
woul no wrt any mor r quess t s e t doc ora wa e t be tansere t a f c lt
d t ie
e e t o e he t nd nt d o
r f r d o a iiy
wheehec drc vepr pe c e Thers ewa :tse i rques t seDr Qui ne f
r
oul e ei o r ar.
epons s ç nd n e t o e . no s or
me c i c nges' ( NO.3,a 1 ) Dil d di s on J y 3,a t docore mi
diaton ha . ECF
'
t 8. lar d o ul
nd he t xn ned
hi on J y 1 bu di noto de a pai mediato f hi .W he Dil d c
m
ul 5, t d
r r ny n
c i ns or m
n lar ompli d a ut
ane bo
hi pai a l c ofm e cai n i a J y 20 r ques f m ,t r pons no e t the c d ge
s n nd a k
di to n ul
e t or he es e t d ha
oul t
Tyl nolo M ot i f om t c m i s r
e
r
r n r he om s a y.
1
1
The c ti rquie t dimis a acin orcam fld by a prs rpr e ng L
our s e r d o s s ny to
li ie
ione oce di q
f
onna pa rs i i de e m i t a ton o cl m i fi ous m alci ,orf l t s a e a cl i
upe i f t t r nes he c i r ai s r vol , i ous
ais o t t
am
on whih rlefmaybegrntd.28U. C.j 1 A( ( ) To saeacam i a fdealcvi
c ei
a e
S.
915 b)1. tt li n ny e r i l
a to t eplitf sG ta t a alg to smu tb e o g t rie a rg tt r l fa o e t
cin, h an if tl cu l le ain s e n u h o as ih o ei b v he
l
e
s ul tve l ve ,' o one t t i E a i e on is f c ' r t rt n m er l Gc ei bl .' Be l
pec a i e l' t
ha s : usbl
pl
t a e, a he ha
'
e y d onc va e ' l
At.Cop.v.Twombl 550 U. 5 570 (
l
y,
S. 44,
2007) To sae ac eofacin t rj 1 3,a
.
tt aus
to mde 98
2
pli ifm us esabls t theha bee de i d ofrg sg r nt e by t Consiuton orl ws
antf
t t ih ha
s n prve
i ht ua a e d
he
tt i
a
oft Unie Stt sa t tt sde i to r ule fom c
he t d a e nd ha hi prvai n es t d r
onduc c mitd by ape s a tng
t om te
r on c i
t e c l ro saelw.W etv At i , 8 U. 4 ( 9 8 .
md r o o f tt a
s . kns 4 7 S. 2 1 8 )
Di ad c aln e te c t s o me ia te t n t a tej i d co h sp o ie hm.
l r h le g s h ot e f d c l r ame t h t h al o tr a r vd d i
l
r
A prs ofi a ' de i r t i fe e e t an i t s s ro medi lne ds vi aes t
ion fcils lbe a e ndif r nc o
nma e' e i us
ca e
olt he
Eiht Amendme . Se Eselev.Ga e 429U. 97,1 ( 976) A c tt ina vi ai
g h
nt e t l
mbl,
S. 02 1 . onsiuto l olton
i t i c n e tiv l sb t a o jci a das be tvec mpo e t Th o j ci ec mp n n
n l s o tx n ove oh n be tve n u j ci o n n . e be tv o o e t
z
i me i t ede rv to i t u t e ty sro s' F r rv. e n n 51 U. 8 , 3 ( 9 4 .
s t f h p iain s ç fkin l e iu . a me Brn a , 1 S. 25 8 4 1 9 )
s
'
Th s be tv c mp n n i me i a p io of ca i G eie aey id fee t't ti,i h
e u jcie o o e t s t f rs n t il s l l r tl n if rn ' ha s f e
i
d b
t
t
know s of a di r r a e s i r s t i a e he lh o s e y' a r ponds
nd s ega ds n xce s ve i k o nm t
a t r af t ' nd es
lnr as bl t t rs Fa mer 511U. a 837. A ca m c
l e ona y o he ik. r ,
S. t
li once ni a m e e dia e m e
r ng
r s gr e nt
bewee a i e and m e c lpe s
t n n nmat
di a r onnelr ga di di gnoss a c s ofteam e doesnot
e r ng a
i nd our e r t nt
i iae t e Eihh Ame d n . W rc tv.Col ,7 6 F.d 8 ,8 9 ( t Ci. 1 8 )
mpl t h g t
c
n me t
ih
li 6 2 41 4 4h r 9 5 .
ns
Queto s o me ia j d me ta e n ts be tt j dca rviw u d r j1 8 . Ruselv.
sin f dc l u g n r o u j c o u iil e e n e 9 3
sl
Shefr 5 F. 31 ( h Ci.1 ) M orove ,me c lmapr cie doe notsae afde a
fe, 28 2d 8 4t r 975 . e r dia l a tc
s
tt e r l
c am ,Esele,429 U. a 1 1 nordoe me eneglge i di
li
tl
S. t 05- 06,
s r
i nce n agnoss Sos beev.M um hv,
i. e
7 7F.d 1 9(t Ci.1 8 )
9 2 7 4h r 9 6 .
Dilr f l t algefcst s t tDr Qui
lad ais o le a t o how ha . nonesha i e hi me ca ne ds On
s gnord s di l e .
t c r r Dil d' own sa e nt ,i hi co pl nta o t admi sr tve r medy f
he onta y, lar s
t t me s n s m ai nd n he
nita i e
onns
s
ubmitd wih hi co pl n ,ma i cl rt twhe he hasfl d t pr rf m r si t
te t s m ait ke t ea ha
n
ie he ope or eque tng o
s et doc o ,a a nt e hasbee a r nge The docorhaspr crbed M oti f pai a
e he t r n ppoi m nt
n ra d.
t
es i
rn or n nd
ha ad s d t tDil r co d co i t ptr has me c ton fom t c
s vie ha la d ul ntnue o lc e di a i r he omm is y. Dilr
s ar
la d
beleve t tDr Qui
i s ha . noness dha s nhi s ra s dha pr vi dt te t nt
houl ve ee m oone nd houl ve o de he rame
pr s rbe by hi outi docor ,i udi pr crpto pan m e ca i a a f l up vii.
e ci d
s sde t s ncl ng es i i n i
di ton nd olow
st
Dilr ' d sg e me twi te d co ' me ia j d me t,h we e , o sn ts p o t cam
l d s ia r e n t h o trs d c l u g n s o v r d e o u p r a li
a
h
t t Dr Qui s ha a td wih delbert i fe e e t Dilr s me c nee . Thi
ha . none s ce t i ae ndifr nc o lad' dial ds
s
dia e m e ove t appr pra e co s ofteam e a
s gr e nt r he
o it ur e r t nt mount t a al ga i t tt doc or
s o n le ton ha he t
a t d ne i nty i maki team e de sons whih doe notsa e an Ei h Am e
c e glge l n
ng r t nt cii , c
s
tt
ght
ndme
nt
l he our s
m ympa he i t Dilr sc
t tc o la d' once s t c t
m , he our
cai a ns t doc or1 W hiet c ti nott s
l m gai t he t .
mus sl rl dimis t c an,ptrua t j1915 b)1,f f lle t sae a
t lmmaiy s s he omplit zs nt o
A( ( ) or aitr o tt ny
consiui cam a ne esayf hi t pr ee wiht sa tonunde j 1
tttonal li s c s r or m o oc d t hi ci
r 983.
The Clr i die t t s nd co e of t s m e a l opi o a a ompanyi
e k s r ced o e
pis
hi
mor ndlm
ni n nd cc
ng
o de t pl i if
r r o a ntf .
EN TER: Thi
s
X N
da ofse e r 201
y
pt mbe , 4.
ChifUnie St t DititJ
e
t d aes src udge
1 Th c u td ci st e rie spplme tljrs cin o ra y rltd sae lw cams
e o r e lne o xecs u e na uidito ve n eae tt a li ,
pus n t 28U. C. l 67c,a dimisss hcamswih utpeu c
rua to
S. j 3 () nd s se uc li to rjdie.
4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?