Muhammad v. Clarke et al

Filing 8

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 10/20/2014. (tvt)

F*ie. :% - '
i
I *

A > I ,a
4 kiv

C FD 1# G
T1 1t
1
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O AN O K E D I SI N
VI O
M A LC O LM M U H A M M AD ,
Pl nt f ,
ai i f

JU A C nL
BY;
.
DEPUW CL

Ci lA c i N o.7: 4- v- 24
vi ton
1 c 004

M EM O M ND U M O PI I N
N O
H A R O LD CLA R K E,e al,
t .
Dee
f ndant .
s

By:

H on.Jac on L.K i er
ks
s
Se orUnie St esDit itJudge
ni
t d at
s rc

M a col M uha m a a V i gi a i a e pr e ng pr K,fld a Compli tpuruan t 42
l m
m d, r ni nm t oce di
o
ie
an
s to
.

U. C.j 1 na ngva i safoft Vigni De rme ofCore tons(ç
S.
983, mi rous tf he r i a pa t nt
rci d
VDOC' a t
' nd he
)
Ke nM ot ai Core to lCe e (I CC' a dee t.Thi matri beo emef
e
mt n rcina ntr I
KM ' s fndans s te s fr
)
or
s re ng,ptrua t 28U. C.j1 5A.Afe rvi ngPli ifss sin,Idimist
ce ni ls nt o
S. 91
tr e ewi antf ubmiso
s s he

Co an wi o t rj dc a fioo .
mplit t u p eu ie s rv lus
h
Pl ntf c
ai if ompl i t ton M a 2 a 1 201 et rKM CC m aloo orbusne sofi
ans ha
y nd 6, 4, ihe
ir m
i s fce
saf o
t f pene t e opesfom t sc tnoti Pli ifspr s nc whi h al ge y vi a e
d wo nvel
r hi our
n antf
e e e, c le dl olt s

VDOC Op rtngPr c d r 8 3. (t '. Oneo Plitf' p io g iv n e wa d e d
eai o e u e 0 1 ( )1
OP'
f an ifs rs n re a c s s e me
f und be aus m a loom sa fdi not1 g andpr es o oft e l pe asl ga m al
o ed c e ir
tf d
o
oc s ne he nve o s e l i.
Pl i ifc ude t tDe e nt vi a e t Fis,Fourh,a Foure nt Am e
antf oncl s ha f nda s olt d he r t
t nd
te h
ndme soft
nt he
U nie St t s Cons iuton w he s a fvi a ed t OP by o ni l ga m a lnoti hi pr e e.
td ae
tt i
n t f ol t he
pe ng e l i
n s es nc

Im us dim isa aci n o cam fl d by a i m a ei 1de e mi t tt aci o cam i
t s s n to r li ie
n n t f t r ne ha he ton r li s

fi ousorfist saeacli onwhihrle ma begrntd.Se 28U. C.jj 1 5e)2)
rvol
al o tt am
c eif y
a e
e
S.
91 ( ( ,
1 5 b)1 ; U. C.j 1 () Thefrtsa r i l scai ba e uponû ni s a y
91 A( ( ) 42 S.
997ec .
is tndad ncude l ms s d
t ndiputbl
a
m e il sl alt y,'t a msofi rng m e ofa lgali er s whih clary doe note s,'
rtes eg heor 'k i
cl
nfi e nt
e nt e t c e l
s
xit'or
c ai swhe e t k ac ua c en i a e c ea l bas l s . N eiz v.W ila s 490 U . 31 3
lm
r he l t l ont tons r l ry e e s'
f
' t ke
li m ,
S. 9, 27

( 989 .AlhoughIlberlyc tuepr â c ans Hai v.Kene,404U. 51 5201 ) t
i al onsr o q omplit, nes
r r
S. 9, 21
1Pl i ifpr f r t t OP s ys ç l icomi lgalc r s
a ntf ofe s hat he
a , ç ln
A
ng e ore ponde s l beopene a s r d fr
nce hal
d nd eache o
c r ba ...o y i t pr enc oft ofe rt whom i i a e s d.
onta nd
nl n he es e he fnde o
t s ddr s t '
'

( 972) ldono a tasa i t sa
1 ,
t c n nmae' dvocae s s edeveopi saut ya c tt inal
t, ua pont
l ng tt or nd onsiuto

camsn t la l rie i ac mpan .S eBmc v Car l,1 7F.d2 , 4 ( t Ci.1 9 )
li o ce ry as d n o lit e
k . rol 0 3 41 2 3 4h r 9 7
( tg, .c ri ;Be tv.CivofHn on,775F. 1 4,1 ( h Ci.1 .s as
Luti J, oncurng) audet t
mpt
2d 27 278 4t r 985) ee lo
,
Go do v.Le ke 574F. 11 11 ( h Ci.1 (e og zngt tadititc ti not
r n
e ,
2d 47, 51 4t r 978) rc nii ha src our s
e
xpec e t a s e t r e ofadvoc t f a pr K pli it
t d o s um he ol
a e or o
antf).
.

Pl n ifptr uesi s a y m e ils l ga t ore i t saci Fis,i i wel
aitf ls ndiput bl rte s e l he i s n hi ton. r t t s l
e tbls d t tt f c prs ofi i l ha notf lwedt i own i pe ntpolcisor
sa ihe ha he a t ion fc a s ve
olo
her
nde nde
ie

pr edu e c r s e i aj1 3aci
oc r s amot ucc ed n
98 ton.Se e. ,UniedStt v. ees 440U. 741
e. c. t aes Cac r ,
S. ,

7 2 5 ( 9 8 ; c i v. t. fFara 9 7F.d 1 5 ,1 6 (t Ci.1 9 ) S c nd Plitf
5 - 5 1 7 ) Rico Cny o ifx, 0 2 4 9 4 9 4h r 9 0 . e o , anif
c nno pr ee a i tDe e nt i t sa i unde r s
n t oc d gans f nda s n hi cton
r e ponde ts ror Se e. ,M onelv.
a upe i . e. g.
l

De tofSoc.Se v .436U. 658, n. ( 978) Pl nifac
p'
r s,
S. 663 7 1 . aitf knowldgest themus d crbe
e
ha
t es i

a a ta ij r t saea a c s t c u t cam.Ho v r h dse a d t ece rye tbih d
n cu lnu y o tt n c e s o o rs li
we e , e irg r s h lal sa ls e

1w a dag e ta teij r i meeysafsviwigteç o fd nil n e s r d
a n r u s h t h nu y s rl tf e n h t n i e ta u c n o e
c
c mmu iain 'a dt t ei e c e fo s o n a a t a ij r Cf Le sv. sy, 1
o n c to s' n ha h s x usd r m h wig n cu l nu y. . wi Ca e 5 8
U. 3 3 3 3n4( 9 6 (e u itngt en t nt a t eç cu lnu y' e ur me t wav d,
S. 4 , 5 . 1 9 ) rp dai h oi h t h s ta ij r 'rq ie n be i e
o
a
e ni aprs rwa a ol el de i ofall almaeil) Furhemor t or r sntt
ve f ione s bs ut y prved 1 eg tras. t r e,he des e o
Pl i iffom t sc ta e publcr c d a notc i ntal Ac or ngl Pl i ifptrues
antf r hi our r
i e or nd
onfde i . c di y, antf ls
i s t bl me il sl lt oresi t sa ton a
ndipu a y rtes ega he i n hi c i boutt aleg vi a i n ofaVDOC polc
he l ed olto
iy,

a dti matri ds se wi u prj d c a fi oo s p ru n t 2 U. C. 1 5 b ()
n h s te s imisd t t eu ie s rv l u , u s a t o 8 S. j 91 A()1 .
ho
EN TER :
Thi

a ofOc obe , 4.
y
t r 201

Se rU nie St t sD i ti tJ
ni
t d a e sr c udge

2