Ball v. Artrip et al

Filing 13

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/31/2014. (kab)

- O œ: OFFI u.. sm rn l
OE s Dl
e
ATROANOKE,
VA
FiED
L

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F VI G I A
CT
R NI
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI
R EG I A LD K EI H BA LL,
N
T

CA SE N O .7:
14CV 00438

0CT 3 ' l
aj
J c.
um
BK

DE
P

, E
CL Rk
,

CL
ERK

Pl ntf ,
ai if

M EM O M N DU M O PI O N
NI

JEFFREY ARTRI c & ,
P,

By: GlnE.Conr
e
ad
C hi fU ni e St esD i t i tJudge
e
t d at
sr c

Dee
f ndant .
s

Thi cl e m a tr i be o e t c to pl i ifs motons s e ng r nsa e e a
s os d te s f r he our n antf
i
e ki ei tt m nt nd
a e
m ndment Re nad Ket Bal,a Vigi a i t pr e ng pr K ,fl t s cvi rght
. gi l
ih
l
r ni nma e oc edi
o
ied hi i l i s
.

acin ptrua t 42 U. C.j 1 algi t ti cls iyi Mm t lng-em s grgai
to zs nt o
S.
983, le ng ha n a sf ng
o o tr e e ton
sa us prs ofki l vi ae hi d pr s rght by knowi y r l ng o f s i or ton
tt , ion t a s olt d s ue oce s i s
ngl e yi n ale nf ma i
t tBalhad c pied t kila wa de
ha l
ons r o l
r n.By o ni a or re t r Se e r29,201 t
pi on nd de n e ed pt mbe
4, he

c u tsl rl d s se ti a to wi o tp eu ie p ru n t 28 U. C.j 1 5 b ( )
or l
mma i imis d h s cin t u rj d c , u s a t o
y
h
S.
91 A( )1,
f fiur t saeac tt i lcam a tona et rj 1
or al e o tt onsiutona li ci bl mde 983. Balnow mo st a ndhi
l
ve o me s
c pli t a a tona d e nt a t c le t c tsnzi t thi a lga i f i
om a nt o dd ddii l ef nda s nd o hal nge he our ' lng ha s le tons a l

t sae a a tona e cai t rPane v.Ba r 595 F. 1 201 ( h Ci.1 . Bals
o tt n ci bl l m mde i
ke ,
2d 97,
4t r 979) l'
m o i m us be de e
tons
t
ni d.

The c tc nnot a ee t Ba ls a lga i ,e n a s
our n
gr hat l' le tons ve s mende sa e any a tona e
d, tt
c i bl

cli t r j1 3. Fort ras dic s i t c ts pror o nin,he fist sae
am mde 98
he e ons s used n he our' i pi o
al o tt
s cii fcsr gadi t mn ri whiha horte ha r id (rwilr l ont alege y
pe fc a t e r ng he nne n c ut iis ve ele o l ey) he l dl
f s i or ton i hi fl i maki a c tt i l sgnii a de ii Ba r s a.
ale nf ma i n s ie n
ng ny onsiutonaly i fc nt c son. ke , upr
M or ove ,Ba l doe not de ons r t t t he ha f l d a r que tt ha t f s i or a i
e r l
s
m t a e ha
s ie
e s o ve he al e nf m ton

r move fo hi fl a pur ue t tcai t oug a llve soft g iva e pr e ngsl
e
d r m s ie nd s d ha l m hr h l e l
he re nc oce di .
Untlhe does s he ha note
i
o,
s
xhause aval bl a nita i r m e e ,a r quie unde 42
t d ia e dmi sr tve e dis s e r d
r

U. C.j 1 () Fi ly,Balfist s a ra on t tt sc s whih wasdimis d
S.
997ea . nal l al o how ny e s ha hi a e, c
s se

wi o t eu ie s o l b ri ttd.F rt s ra o s tec u t ld n plitf p ndn
t u prj d c , h ud e ensae o hee e s n ,h o r wil e y anifs e ig
h
m otons A n a o i t or rw ili s t sda
i .
ppr pr a e de l s ue hi y.

The Clr i die t t s nd c e oft s me or ndtm o ni a a c pa ng
e k s r ced o e opi s
hi m a l pi on nd c om nyi
o de t pl i if
r r o antf.

Rd y foco e , 01 .
E r 'hs s l a o- tb r 2 4
xrsR: r i
Chi fUnied St t D i ti tJ
e
t
a es sr c udge

1 l t gre nce pr ee ngs doc nt by Bals s s i , Bal as f r r a of a
n he iva
oc di
ume ed
l' ubmisons
l ked or eve s l

ca st to d cso ,whih a toiisd ne Th c uttk sj iilnoieo t fc t tp io of as
lsi in e iin c uh rt e id. e o r a e udca tc f he a t ha rsn t l
ka
e
ki
ge aly a e sonl oneis pe greva . Baldoesnotde ns t t theha ma an spa aerquetf r
ner l ddr s y
sue r i nce l
mo lae ha
s de y e r t e s o
auho ii t r
t rtes o emovet ale dl fle i or to fom hi fl - by frtflng ar ques f s vc ont is
he lge y a s nf main r
s ie - ls ii
e t or er ies he s ue
and t n purui a i o m a compl nt a t r gulr p i nc pr edt e, i t is i not s ifc o iy
he
s ng n nf r l
ai nd he e a eva e oc l f he sue s
r
atsa t rl
r s ve
e ol d.

2