Little v. Colvin

Filing 26

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 3/31/16. (eot)

CL S OFFI U S DI .
ERK'
CE
ST COUR:

,

x m j kv
y
x jA
FI
LED

l TT UNI
x m
TED STATES Dl r c' COURT
srm r

FORTT wES
m
TERN Dl w c' oyVI NI
sl r
RGI A
Rowxoxs or sl
vl ox

MA2 3 12 1
26
J
u
BY:

J
O

B. LI
TTLE,

Plitfl
anil
v.
CAROLYN W .
COLVI Aci g
N, sn
Co sin ro S ca S c rt,
mmiso e f o il e u i
y
Dee d n .
fn a t

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

o

l

cu
uas

'

l

v

CiiAcinNo 7:4CV0 4 4
vl to . 1
04
M EM O

UM OPI ON
NI

By: Ho GlnE. n a
n. e Co r d
Che Unt dS ae Ditit ud e
if ie tts src J g

Thepl i if J XnneB. tl hasfl d t saci n c le ng c ran pr sonsoft
antf, o
Lite, ie hi to hal ngi e ti ovi i
he
fnaldç ii n o t Comm isone ofSocalSe urt de yi pli tf sa i ai f
i
c so f he
si r
i c iy n ng a n if pplc ton or

d sb l yi ma eb n f t e teS ca S cliyAc, sn nd d 4 U. C. ç41 ()a d
ia ii ns nc e eks md r h o il e t t t a me e , 2 S. j 6 i n
t
r
423. Pli ifa s c le st esa ihm e ofape i ofdia lt f pu pos sofhe
antf l o ha lnge he t bls nt
rod
s biiy or r e
r
a ia i f s e e als c iyi omebe st asofDe mbe 7,201 r t rt n on
pplc ton or upplm nt e urt nc
ne s
ce r
2, ahe ha
Ocobe 1 2009,asale by pl i ifi he a i ai n f rbe ft . See ge , U . C.
t r 5,
lged
antf n r pplc to o ne is
, n.42 S.

j1 81# sg.J rs ito o t i c u tse tb ih dp ru n t 4 U.. j4 ()a j4
3 . e u id cin f hs o r i sa ls e u s a t o 2 SC. 05g nd 2
1

U. C. 1 8 ()3 .
S. j 3 3 c ()
By o de e e e Se e be 3,201 t c tr f r e t sca et aUried St t
r r ntr d ptm r
4, he our e e r d hi s o
lt
aes

M a ikaeJ d ep ru n t 2 U.. j6 6 b ( )B) OnFe rlr 1 , 01 ,hema itae
gs t u g u s a t o 8 SC. 3 ( )1( .
bt y 6 2 6 t
a
gsrt
j g s b te arp r i whihh r c mme d t a t eCo s in rsfn ld cso be
ud e u mitd e o tn c e e o n s h t h mmiso e ' i a e iin
a fr di al ep cs Plitf ha fldo j ci n t t ema itaej d esrp r.
f me n lr s e t. an if s ie b e to s o h g srt u g ' e o t
M r . tl wasbom on De e r28,1
s Lite
c mbe
958,a e nt ly c
nd ve ua l omplt d he li h s hool
e e r tg c
ed a i Pl i ifhasbe n e o asa ntri as it nt hous kee r pr uci n lne
uc ton. antf
e mpl yed
lsng ssa ,
e pe , od to i
wor r a nur e' a de Appa e l M r . tl l s wo ke on ar a a s t ne bassi
ke , nd s s i .
r nty, s Lite a t r d
egulr nd usai d i n
''

.

2009, houg i s m st ts e ge i s r i wor a tviyt r fe .TheAd i sr tve
t h t ee ha he nga d n po ad c k c i t he ea tr
m nitai
La J
w udgef up. t tpli tf' wo k a trhe al ge dia lt ons tda ewa no s t nta
o d ha a n ifs r fe r le d s biiy e t s t ubsa il

g i n a tvt .( 1 - 5 .
anfl ciiy TR 4 1 )
I Jmeof201 M r . t fl d a i a i f rdia lt i m a ebe tt a
nt
0, s Lide ie pplc tons o s biiy ns nc neis nd
s e e a s cliy i om ebe ft .Sheal ge t ts bec m edia e f a 1f
upplm nt l e trt nc
ne s
le d ha he n
s bl d or 1 onnsof
s tntalganfl e o e on Ocober1 2009,d t c ozi obsnztvepul onay
ubsa i i t mpl ym nt
l
t
,
ue o hr lc t c i
m t
die e;hi bl pr s r ba k pr e s me a pr e ;fbr
s as gh ood es u e; c oblm ; nt l obl ms i omya gi irt bl bo e
l a; ria e w l

s n r me e h s ma n r e ; n ia he rngl s ; n po rvso ( 2 0 . S n w
y d o ; mp y e ; e v s a gn ; ai o s a d o iin. TR 5 ) he o
mant i t ts hasr m ane dia e t t pr s n tme.Ast he a i a i f dia lt
i ans ha he
e i d s bl d o he e e t i
o r pplc ton or s biiy
i tr nc be ft ,her co dr ve l t tM z .Litem e t i tr d sa r quie e soft
nsla e ne is t e r e a s ha s tl t he nsle t ms e r m nt he

Ac tr ug t ef u t q a tro 2 0 b t t h r atr S e g n,4 U. C. j41 ()a d
th o h h o rh u re f 01 , u no t ee fe . e , e . 2 S. j 6 i n
4 3 a .Ac o dn l M r. tl i e tte t ds blt i t a c b n ft o l i s eh s
2 () c r igy, s Lit s n ild o ia ii nsl n e e e s ny f h a
e
y r
esa ihe t s be me diabld f a1 f m sofs t nta g nf le o e o orbe or
t bls d hat he cn
s e or 1 or
ubsa i l ai ' mpl ym nt n
u
f e

De e e 31 2 0.Se 4 U. C. 42 ()
c mb r , 01 e 2 S. j 3a .
Pli i sa ia i we ede e upon i talc i r to a r co i r ton. She ,
antY pplc tons r ni d
nii onsde a i n nd e nsde a i

t nr quet a rc ve aéçno he rngandrviw beor a Ad nitai La J
he e sed nd e ei d
vo ai
e e f e n mi srtve w udge.
l a opi o daedAprl5,201 t La J
n n ni n t
i
3, he w udger l dt tM r . tl bec me dia e f a 1
u e ha s Lite n
s bld or 1

f r o s bsa ta g i fle o me to De e e 7 201 ( 21 .I mn n t s
o ms f u tnil an l mply n n c mb r , 2. TR ) n kig hi
l
de e mi to t La J
t r nai n, he w udgee i ty r i o ac ula i e m i ton a r por
xplcil eled n ons ttve xa na i nd e t

c mpee b Dr W i im Hl hre .( 2 ) Th r c r rve l t t . l h isfrt
o ltd y . l n l is TR 2 . e e o d e as ha Dr Hl re is
l
mp
mp
e mi d M r . tl on De e be 7,201 t s m eda esa ihe by t La J
xn ne
s Lite
cm r
2, he n
y tbls d
he w udgeas

p an ifsd t o ds bl yo st ( 8 5 .TheLa J g itmrtdame ia s u c
litf ae f ia ii n e. TR 5 )
t
w ud e n e ee
dc l o re
2

sa e ntpr vi d byDr Hlmphre a i c tveofr sdua fm di lc pact f l st n a
t t me
o de
. l
is s ndi ai
e i l t ona a iy or es ha
f l r ngeofs ntr wor a tviy.TheLa J
ul a
ede a y k c i t
w udger c ni t t g ve pl i i sa ,
e og zed ha , i n antY ge
ed ai n,a prorwor a tviy,a as lmi ar sdualfmci lc pact f no m or t1
uc to nd i
k ci t nd sl ng e i
t tona a iy or
e 1=

s de a y e ri M r . tl i dia e f a 1f r so r gua wor aci t bas bot on t
e nt r xe ton, s Lite s s bl d or l o m f e lr k tviy, ed h he

'

a i nd pplc ton he
t si on oft voc tona e r a t a ilsr tvehe rng, a a i a i oft medial
e tm y he a i l xpe t' he dm rita i
t
c
voc tona gu dei ss tf t l rAppe x 2 t Subpa tP oft Adm i sr tveReg a i
ai l i lne e orh mde
ndi o
r
he
nita i
ultons

PM 4 4 ( 2 - 4 .Ho ve, st t d yp irt Dr Hu hre ' dc l x miain a
0 . TR 3 2 ) we r a o he a ro o . mp is me ia e a n to , nd
a t a 1r l va tm e prort r t t La J
s o 1 e e nt i s i he e o, he w udger l d t tM r . tl r m ai d ca bl of
u e ha s Lite e ne pa e

pe f mi alm ie r ngeoflg wor a viy.Gi n t t tm o oft vocai le r,
ror ng i t d a
iht k di t
ve he esi ny he
tona xpe t
a a trc i rngpli i sa ed a in,a prorwor e de ,t La J
nd fe onsde i
antY ge, uc to nd i
k xpe nce he w udgef
ound
t tpli ifr t i d s c e fmc i lc pact t pe f r s ve als cii lghtwor r e
ha a ntf e ane ux i nt l tona a iy o r o m e r pe fc i
k ol s
e si i sgnika nt be i t na i le onomy,a a1r lva tm e on a bef r
xitng n i l nt l r n he tona c
m
t 1 ee nt i s
nd o e

De e e 6 2 2 ( 1 , 3 .
c mb r , 01 . TR 6 2 )

.

I t nnsofpl i ifsc = e a i ai nsf be ft,t La J
n e
antf onc nt pplc to or ne is he w udgeuli t l
tma ey
c ude t tM r . tl bec m edia edf ra1f
oncl d ha s Lite n
s bl o 1 onnsofs t ntalganfl e oyme f
ubsa i i ll mpl
nt or
pu pos sofhe a ia i f s pplm e a s c iyi omebe f a ofDec mbe 7, 2.
r e
r pplc ton or u e ntl e urt nc
ne ks s
e r 201
Howeve ,ba e on hi fndi o r sd lG nc i c pact f a lp ie r ng oflg wo k
r sd
s i ng f e i ua
tonal a iy or i t d a e i ht r
r e a a 1r l va tm e o a be or De e be 6, 2,t La J
ol s t l e e nt i s n nd f e c m r 201 he w udgec l
oncudedt tM r .
ha s

Lidewa no e il dt s e e als ctiy i ome be ft d i t se dirpe i a
t
s t ntte o upplm nt e trt nc
ne is urng hi a e rod, nd
t ts i note il t dia lt i ur ncebe ft ,i muc ass hasf iedt e t ih
ha he s
ntted o s biiy ns a
ne is nas h he
a l o sabls

d s bl yo e o o b f r De e e 31 201 ,hels d yo wh c s esile j y di u e
ia it nst n r eo e c mb r , 0 t a t a n ih h tl no e ns r d
i
sau .Se 2 C. R. 4 4 1 2 ()a d41 .2 () Th La J d eso ii nwa a o e a
tts e 0 F. j 0 .5 0 g n 69 0 g . e w u g ' pn o s d ptd s
3

l

1

t fna decson oft Comm iso rbyt SocalSe urt A d i sr to sAppe sCouncl
he i l ii
he
s i ne
he i c iy m i tai n'
al
i.

Ha ng e use a la ia ead ilsrtver medis M r . tl hasnow a
vi xha t d l va lbl m ritai e
e , s Lite
ppeaedt t s
l o hi
court
.

On a al pl ntf as ss ve a a pl nt .M r .Litecontndst tt
ppe , ai ifr ie e r l r me s
s tl
e
ha he

Admi sr tveLa J
nita i
w udgei pr ry dic e am e c s c sae e fom ate tng
m ope l s ount d
dial our e tt m nt r
rai
physc a a ssa ,ndia i t tpl i ifwasdia e f a 1f m sofwor asea m J y
ii ns s it nt i c tng ha antf
s bld or l or
k
dy s ul

1 , 0 8 ( 8 - 4 .P an ifas man ansta i f nn aigh poh tc l u sinsf r
5 2 0 . TR 212 ) litf lo iti h t n o ultn y t eia q e to o
t vocai na e r,t Ad i sr tveLa J
he
to l xpe t he m nitai
w udge f ie t pr ry a co f fndi of
al d o ope l c unt or i ngs
mode a edit uly i mai ai ng co e r ton, r it e, pac ass tf rh i ame a
r t fk t n nt ni
nc nta i pe ssenc or e e o t n
nt l

h at e au to b asaea e c p y h lgs.( 1 425 .M r . tl as a srst a t e
e l v lain y tt g n y s c oo it TR 2 - ) s Lite lo se t h t h
h
Admi srtveLa J
nitai
w udgef ie t pr ry c e the 1y t si onyast t e entofhe
a ld o ope l r di r a e tm
o he xt
r
physd ld s o f t nd de lttng s
i a i c m or a
biia i ympt s Howe r pl n i spdma y c e i on
om .
ve , aitc
r ont nton
a
ppea i t tt Adm i sr tve La J ge f ie t ofe a e a to wha s ve f t
l s ha he
nita i
w ud al d o f r ny xplna i n
t oe r or he

f ngt tM r .Lite s zl be n ei pa eofm or t n almie r
mdi ha s tl uddely c m nca bl
e ha i t d angeofs de a y
e nt r
e to on De mbe 7, 2, t ts r ti d s sc e f nc i lc pa iy f lgh
xeri n
ce r 201 but ha he ea ne uf i nt u tona a c t or i t
e ri n a a 1r l va tm e o a be or De embe 6, 2.
xe to t 1 e e nt i s n nd f e c
r 201
Thec tbe ive t talo pl i ifsc e i hol a gua em e i. The c t
our le s ha 1 f antf ' ontntons d r bl rt
our
co l ,howe r t ti i be
ncudes
ve , ha t s yond q si t tt La J
ue ton ha he w udgef ie t ct a evi nc f
a ld o ie ny de e or
t r m a ka epr poston t tM r .Liteco d do lg wo k o a be or Dec mbe 6,201
he e r bl o ii ha s tl ul
i ht r n nd f e
e r
2,

butt ts s rl be n elmie t a hi mor t n ar tit d r nge ofs de a ywor
ha he uddely c m i t d o nyt ng
e ha esrc e a
e nt r
k
!

he r
ha he s xa ned
.
a tviy on t ve ydayt ts wa e m i by Dr Hlmpl es The c t i G
ci t
z ui .
our fnds t
good c e'
aus '
f rr ma oft sca et t Comm iso rf f rhe c nsde a i oft is ofdia lt
o e nd hi s o he
s i ne or u t r o i r ton he s ue
s biiy

4

ons t i a mn rc it ntwih t nze e t bls d b t Unie St t sCo tofAppe l f r
e, n
nne onsse
t he l s sa ihe y he t d a e ur
as o
J

t Fouth Cic t
he
' r ui.
t

.

Aspr vi l no e on Se embe 3, 4,hec t e e r d t sc et am a sr t
e ousy t d,
pt
r 201 t our r f re hi as o
gita e

j g frar p r s tigf rh fn ig o fc, o cu inso lw, n arc mme d d
ud e o e o t et o t i dn s f a t c n lso f a a d e o n e
n
d s osto Th ma itaej d efldarpo t nFe nlr 1 , 1 .Asrg r st is eo
ip iin. e g sr t u g ie e r o b ay 6 20 6
e a d he su f

ds blt o st t ma itaej d ec mme tda f lo : .
ia i y n e,he gsrt u g o n e s olws
i
The ei ampl media e de et s
r s
e
c l vi nc o uppor t ALJ Sc uson t tLitewas
t he
' oncl i ha tl
c pa eofpe l mi ar ngeoflghtwo kprort De embe 7,201 a t t
a bl
rbr ng a
i
r i o c
r
2, nd ha
Litewaslmie t pe l ngar ngeofs ntr wor a trt tda e.
tl
i t d o rbnni
a
ede a y
k fe ha t The
ALJdi notG r ta iy's l ta o e dae;i t d,heco i r d a1 oft
d
t bir rl ' eec n ns t t nsea
a
nsde e 1 he
e d nc ofr co dbe or s l tng adaet tha as t i ntm e ca ba i,
vi e e e r f e eeci
t ha d ufk e
di l ss
ba e upon Dr Hlmpl es r por.
sd
. l ui ' e tThus t si no ac ewhe et ALJ
,hi s t as
r he

abtai c s ads b l yo s t aewi noe pa to (iaino te )
r irrl ho e ia ii n e d t t
y
t
h x lnain. ctto mitd .

( p r a 1 ) Th dfiul i t ma itaej d espo iin i t a t ee d nc d veo e
Re o t t 0 . e ifc t n he g srt u g ' sto s h t h vie e e lp d
y
du i t pe i pro t Dec mbe 7,201 i i s t nta co lct W ihoutgoi i t a
rng he rod i r o
e r
2, s n ubsa il nfi . t
ng n o ny
p e tdeai a t spoi ,t c tnot st tDr Hlm phdes fmc i a s s m e , lc t
a t l t hi nt he our e ha . l
' l tonal s e s nt wli h he

La J d ea c r e G ra weg t ( 2 ) co eyr smb e t ee rira s sme t yBeha y
w u g c o d d t e t ih ' TR 2 , l s l e e ls h a le se s n b t n
g
'
Borng,heph i insas it nt whi h t La J
i t
ysca
ssa , c he w udgedee m i d t bewo hy ofG itewe ght'
t r ne o
rt
t tl i '
l

a dû n u p re b t eme ia e i e c o r c r a awhoe' ( 2 ) l a ye e t i
n t s p o td y h dc l v d n e f e o d s
u
l . TR 0 . n n v n ,t
'

s e t t ec u th ttema itaej g ha r a moeit t La J d e so i o ta c q
e ms o h o r t a h g srt ud e s e d r no he w u g ' pnin h n a
a ly bef md. St t d smpl t Adm i sr tve La J ge ct d no e de ,medial
cma l
ot
a e i y, he
nita i
w ud ie
vi nce
c
opi on,orr as ng wha s ve i s
ni
e oni
toe r n uppo toft no i t M r . tl coul do lghtwor on
r he ton hat s Lite
d
i
k
De m be 6 201 butha be om edia e f a hi m or t n almie r ngeofs de a y
ce r , 2,
d c
s bl d or nyt ng
e ha i t d a
e nt r
wor byt tm e s wass e by Dr Hlmplre t f l ng da
k he i he
en
. l ti s he olowi
y.
'

.

5

'
.

TheUried St t Cour ofAppe sf t Fourh Cic ta e s d a sm ia is i
lt
aes
t
al or he
t r ui ddr s e i lr s ue n

Balyv. tr 6 F.d7 ( t Ci. 9 5 .l Baly teFo rh Cic titr rtd S ca
ie Chae , 8 3 5 4h r 1 9 ) n i ,h u t rui n ep ee o il
e
Sec y Rulng 83- s ast c l t t i t e de eofdia lt ons ti nmbi us t
udt
i
20 o o oncude ha , f he vi nc
s biiy e s
guo , he

Comm iso s ul r c veas itnc 9om am e c lad s ri or rt pr ry a s sa
s i ner ho d e ei
ssa e
di a vio n de o ope l s es nd
de e mi t da eofdia lt o e . TheFou h Cic tr as d t ta Adm i sr tveLa
t r ne he t
s biiy ns t
rt r ui e one ha n
nita i
w
J
udgedoe notpos e st dic e i ne s my t e t bls adia lt ons tda ewihout
s
s s he s r ton ce s o sa ih s biiy e t t

s tnta evi ncei t f m ofs meme c opi ono t tmony.L a 79- Sttd
ubsa il de n he or
o
dial ni r esi
4. t 80. ae
dif r nty, m e c ls cei be trpl e t e gei s h ç
fe e l a di a our s te ac d o nga n uc t a e gu s r 't n i t
educ t d es wo k' ha s he
Admi sr tveLa J
nita i
w udge.TheBal y Co twe on t e a n a f l w s
ie ur nt o xpli s olo :
Ther quie e t t i a 1butt m os pl i c e , me c la s rbe
e r m nt ha , n 1
he
t an as s a di a dvi o
cons t d pro t i e rng a ons tda ei me ey ava to on t m os
ule i r o nf ri n e t s r l
dai n
he
t
pe va i t m ei a nita i l
r sve he n dmi sr tve aw- t ts t ntale de e s
ha ubsa i vi nc uppor a
tn

a e ysd cso .Se Pla a tValyHo p.nc v S ll 3 F.d6 , 0 (t
g nc ' e iins e e sn le s .I . . haaa 2 3 7 7 4 h
Ci.9 4 ( eS c eays( w Co s in r ld cso s o l b afr d
r1 9 ) G
Th e r tr ' no mmiso e ' e iin h ud e fime
s
whe es
r upporedby s t nta e de a nota birr ca i ous o
t
ubsa il vi nce nd
r ta y, prci , r

o h r s c nrr t lw.)(n en lq tto maks el e , ndctto
t ewie o ta y o a ' itr a uoai n r , li s a iain
'
ps
Afe aA novorviw oft rcod,hec ti c tane t co l t tc ranof
tr
e e
he e r t our s onsri d o ncude ha e ti

p an ifso j cinst t ema itaej d esrp r mus bes ti d Th c u t st bet
litf b e to o h gsrt u g ' e o t t usane . e o r i ma l o
dice a r a on f t La J et c l t tM r . tl be nme d s bl d on De e r
s m ny e s or he w udg o oncude ha s Lite c
ia e
c mbe

7, 2, no e rir Ac r ngl t c ur fndsG
201 and t a le . co di y, he o t i &
good c us 'f r m a oft sc et t
a e' or e nd hi as o he

Co sin rf rf rh rd v lp n a dc n ie aina stf rha ve Se 4 U.. j
mmiso e o u te e eo me t n o sd rto s e o t bo . e 2 SC.
40 () I teCo sine i t bet d cd ti c s i p an ifsfv ro t eb sso t
5 g . f h mmiso r s ma l o e i e h s a e n litf' a o n h a i f he
e si r c d,a s e e e by i
xitng e or s upplm ntd nputfo amediala s , heCom misone wil
rm
c dvior t
si r l

6

c
onduc a s e e a ad i sr tvehe rng a whih bo h sdeswilbealowedt pr s nt
t upplm nt l m nitai
ai t c t i
l
l
o ee
a tona e de a a pl e t
ddii l vi nce nd r m n .An a opra eor rofr m a wilbe e e e t sday.
ppr it de
e nd l
ntr d hi
TheClr i die t d t s nd c rii d co e oft sopilon t a1 c ms lo r or
e k s r c e o e e tfe pi s hi ri o 1 ot e f ec d.

?
y r rh, 01 .
oATSD:Thi 5id da o M a c 2 6
s
/

Chi Uit d Stt sDititJ
e
e a e src udge