Dudley v. Famous Anthony's Inc.
Filing
19
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/7/2014. (lab)
CLERK' OFFI U,S. ST.
S
CE
DI COURT
ATROANOKE,
VA
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FI
LED
F THEW ES
OR
TERN DITRI OFVI
S CT
RGm I
A
j g zj
gy
gj
ROA N OK E D I
VISI N
O
JULA C ' ' ' CLF'i
I
r' . s'
Y
CH R I
STOPHER J DU D LEY ,
.
BY c
:
'p
y
Ci lAc i n N o. 1
vi t o
7: 4CV 00
459
,
,,c,rp.
q .
,
Pl i i f
a ntf ,
M EM O R AN DU M O PI I N
N O
By:
Hon.Gln E.Conr d
e
a
Chi Unied St t D i t i tJ e
ef t
a es sr c udg
EX P,l C. d b/
N ,/ a
FAM O U S AN TH ON Y '
S*,
D e e nt
f nda .
Chr s ophe J. udl pr e ng pr s ,fl d t sac i a i thi f
it
r D ey, oc edi
o e ie hi ton ga ns s onnere pl r
m oye ,
EXP,nc.db/ Fa
l , / a mousAnt
hony' (s mousAnhony'',al i t thewasdic r di
st
Fa
t
s' legng ha
)
sha ge n
r t iton f flng awor r 'compe a i cai . Theca ei pr e l bef et co t t
eala i or ii
ke s
ns ton l m
s s es nty or he ur on he
d fn a tsmo int d s s frlc o s b e t te j rs ito a dt ep an ifsmoi nt
ee d n ' to o imis o a k f u j c matr u idcin n h litf
to o
diqua iy t de e ntsc
s lf he f nda ' ouns . Fort r as t tf l w,t de e ntsm o i wilbe
el
he e ons ha olo he f nda ' ton l
gr nt d a t pl i if s m oton w ilbe de e a m oot
a e nd he a ntf
i
l
ni d s
.
Backaround
Dudl y i ar i n o Roc M o ,Vigi a. Hewor f rFa
e s esde t f ky unt r ni
ked o mousAnt
hony' fo
s rm
J nua y 21 201 untlDe mbe 8,201 Fa ousAnt
a r , 3 i ce r
3. m
hony' i aVig ni c por ton wih is
s s r i a or a i
t t
prncpa pl c ofbusne si Roa
i i l ae
i s n
noke, r ni
Vigi a.
A c r ng t t com pl nta t a co pa ng e bis D udl y bec m e i1i
co di o he
ai nd he c m nyi xhi t ,
e
a l n
Se e
pt mberof201 a trbe ng e
3 fe i xpos d t m ol a wor On ora
e o d t k.
boutSeptm be 1 201
e r 7, 3,
Dudl fldawor r 'co ns toncam f ij isrs tngfom mol e ur Dudly
ey ie
ke s mpe ai li or nure e uli r
d xpos e.
e
alegest he and Fam ous A nt
l
hat
hony' s ted t wor s'com pens i cl m ,butt he w as
s etl he
ker
aton ai
hat
*Thedef nda i i r ty named i t compl nta lFamousAnt
e nt s ncorec l
n he
ai s û
hony',l ' Thepl ntf s
s nc.'
ai if
motonst a
i o mendt compl ntt pr l i iy t def
he
ai o opery dentf he endantwilbegr ed,and t docke wilbe
l
ant
he
t l
amende t r l t def ntscorec lga name.
d o etect he enda ' r t e l
s e nty tnni t d on Dec m be 8,201 i r t la i f flng t c am wih t Vigi a
ubs que l e nae
e r
3 n e a iton or ii he l i
t he r ni
W or r 'Compens ton Co m ison.
ke s
ai
m si
On ora tJ 1 201 D udl fl a Cha ge ofD icrm i ton w ih t Eq l
bou une 0, 4,
ey ied
r
s i na i
t he ua
Emp o me tOp o tnt Co si n(t
l y n p ru iy mmiso $
EEOC' ,nwhihh a s re t a heû srtlae
' i c e se td h t d eaitd
)
wa
a an tb c u ege fld awoke ' c mp nsto cam i v oaino Til V1 o teCi i
g is e a s h l ie
r rs o e ain li n i lto f te l f h vl
Ri sA c of 1
ght t 964,a a e d. Ex. o Com pl,Docke N o. 1 a 1 On J y 1 201 t
s m nde '
'
t
.
t
2- t 7.
ul 0, 4, he
EEO C i s a D i m i s la N o i e ofRi ht cont i ng t f l w i de enni t o C e
s ued
s s a nd t c
g s
a ni he olo ng t na i n: k d
Bas
upon isi tgai t EEOC i una et c l t tt i or ton o ane e tbls s
t nvesi ton, he
s bl o oncude ha he nf ma i bt i d sa ihe
vi a i oft s a ut s ' Ex. o Com pl,Doc tN o.2- a 18.
ol tons he t t e .'
t
.
ke
1 t
Dudl y fl d t i t nta ton a i tFa o A nt
e ie he ns a c i ga ns m us hony' on A ugus 28,201 On
s
t
4.
Oco e 2 2 1 F mo sAn h n smo e t ds s t ec mpan frlc o s b e tmatr
t b r , 0 4, a u t o y' v d o imis h o lit o a k f u j c te
j rs ito , ru n t Rue1 b ( )o t eFe ea Rue o Ci i P o e l e Dude flda
u id ci n pu s a t o l 2()1 f h d r l ls f vl r c dz .
r
ly ie
brefi opposton t t m o i a we lasam o i t diquaiy t de e ntsc
i n
ii o he ton s l
ton o s lf he f nda ' ouns l The
e.
m o i ha be n f l br e e and a e r pe f r vi w .
tons ve e uly i f d
r i or e e
Di si
scus on
M oton t Dim isf Lac ofSubictM ate Jurs c i
i o s s or k
e
t r iditon
Th c u t t is a d e sted fn a tsmoint d s s f rlc o s be t te
e o r mus frt d r s h ee d n ' to o imis o a k f u j c matr
j rs ito Se Owe slln i. n . M e d ,1 6F.d43 , 4 n. ( t Ci.1 9 )
u idcin. e n -lio s l c v. a e 8 3 5 4 2 4 4h r 9 9
( g ueto o s b e t te j rs ito mus b d cd dfrtb c u et e c nc r tec u ts
dol sins f u j c matr u idcin t e e i e is, e a s h y o en h o r'
t
veypowe t he rt c e.)(ntnz cttona quottonmaksomit .
r
r o a he as ' i e al iai nd ai
'
r
ted)
Fedea c t a eC t oflmie j idito 'whihç s s o yt powe
rl ours r t s i td urs cin, c s e s nl hat
cour
'
pos
r
aut i e by Consiuton a s a ut .' Kokkonen v.G ua di n Lie l .Co.ofA m . 511 U .
hor z d
tt i nd t t e '
r a f ns
,
S.
375,377( 994) Thebur ofetbls ngs j tmatrj iditoni ont pli ift
1 .
den sa ihi ubec te urs ci s he antf,he
pat ase tngJ iditon. RobbEva & Asocs.LLC v. i uch,609F. 359,362( h
ry s ri ' s ci
ur
ns
s .
Holba
3d
4t
Ci. 0) Thec t ypr pel dimisac antunderRul 1 b)1 oft Fedea Ruls
r 201 .
our ma o ry s s ompli
e 2( ( ) he rl e
o Cii P o e u e i t ec mplitfist alg fcsu o whc s be t te j rs ito c n
f v l r c d r ,f h o an al o l e a t p n ih u j c matr u id cin a
e
bebas d. SeeKensv.UniedStts 585F. 1 1 ( hCi.2009)
e
r
t ae,
3d 87, 92 4t r
.
I t se e, m ousAnt ny' a guest tDudl y' c pl ntmus bedim is d f rl c
n hi as Fa
ho s r
ha
e s om ai
t
s se o ak
of u j c matr u idcin b c u et p risaen tdv rea dDude ha no rie a y
s be t te j rs ito , e a s he a t r o ie s n
e
ly s t as d n
f r lque to overwhih t c tma pr sde Fort f l ng r as ,hec ta r es
ede a
si n
c he our y e i .
he olowi e ons t our g e
w ih Fa ousA n hony' .
t m
t
s
F d rldsrc c u t h v o i ia j rs ito o e a1cvia to wh r tematri
e ea itit o rs a e rgn lu idcin v r 1 i l cins e e h te n
c r s e ee t s orvaue of$75, a i be we n c tz nsofdif r ntsaes 28
ontovery xc ds he um
l
000 nd s t e ii e
fe e t t .
U. C.j 1 2. tse ton 1 r quiescomplt di riya
S.
33 d ci 332 e r
ee vest mongt pa te ,mea ngt
he ris ni he
c tze hi ofea h pl ntf m us be dif r ntf om t c tz ns p ofea h def nda . H os ha v.
ii ns p
c ai if t
f e e r he ii e hi
c
e nt'
'
c r
Appaa hinPowe Co.739F. 1 1 ( hCi. 4) l t i tntc e i i undiputd
lc a
r ,
3d 63, 70 4t r 201 . n he nsa as ,t s s e
t tbot pa te a e c tze ofVi gi a. B e a e c pl t di r iy i l cki t c t a not
ha h r i s r ii ns
r ni
c us om e e ve s t s a ng, he our m y
e ecs j rs ito u d rj1 3
x r ie u idcin n e 3 2.
Fe e a dsrc c u t as h v o iia j rs ito o e $ lcv l cinsaii gu e
d rl itit o rs lo a e rgn lu id ci n v r 1 l ii a to rsn nd r
a
t Consiuton,lws orteaisoft Unie Stts' 28U. C.j1331. t
he
tt i a , r te he td ae .'
S.
t rt
unde he
l t ndi wel- e d c
ongsa ng lpl ade ompl n r e ...as ta ie unde f r l1w onl whe t
ait ul ,
ui rs s
r ede a a
y
n he
plitf ssae ntofhi ownca eofa tons
anif ttme
s
us ci howst tii ba e upon ge r ll . Va
ha t s s d
fde a aw)' den
'
v.Dic rBa 556U. 49, ( )(ntnzlcttona quottonmaksomitd) Thus
s ove nk,
S. 60 2009 i e a iai nd ai
r
te .
,
t det m i w het an acton ar s undert l soft Unied St es,t coul m us exam i
o er ne
her
i
i es
he aw
he t
at he
'
t
t
ne
t pl ntf scom pl ntt tdi cer whet f alors at 1 cr est caus ofacton' and,i
he ai if
ai o û s n
her eder
t e aw eat he
e
i '
f
t cl m i notc e t d by f de all w , he he S he pl ntf sr g t r le ne s a iy de nds
he ai s
rae
e r a w t rk
t
ai i f i ht o e i f ce s r l pe
3
onr s uton ofas t ntalque to off de allw . Pi v v.
e ol i
ubsa i
si n e r a ' nne Noki sI ,402 F. 43 442
'
a nc.
3d 0,
(t Ci.
4h r 2005)(nenalcttona quoai maksomitd) Tos r t e r ieoff rl
itr iai nd tton r
te .
uppo the xe cs edea
jzid ci n tefd r l u si nmu t es b tn ilno fio o o p ee t a. Lo r v
l s ito ,h e ea q e to s b u sa ta, t rv lus r rtx u l ven .
r
Ed r s 1 0F.d6 8 65 - ( t Ci.1 9 )
wad , 9 3 4 , 4 55 4 h r 9 9 .
Ha ngca ef l r viwed Dudl y' c
vi
r uly e e
e s ompl i and t e bist r t t c t
ant
he xhi t he eo, he our
concudest theha f ie t r ieanyque ton off de a lw whih woul s
l
ha
s a ld o a s
si
e rla
c
d uppor t e r ie
t he xe c s
of urs ci underj 1 . Dudlyrpeaedl cams i bot hi compli a hi
j iditon
331
e e t y li ,n h s
ant nd s
me oa
m r ndum i o
n ppos ton t t de e
ii o he f ndan ' m oton, ha he w a r t la ed a i tf flng a
ts i t t
s e a i t ga ns or i i
wor s c
ker' ompe ai cam. Se Co .Doc tNo. a 3($wass pe d/tr naeddue
ns ton li
e mpl, ke
2t :
1
us nde emi t
t t fc t tIfldawor rsco ns toncai ' ,P1' M e i Opp' Doc tNo.1 a 2
o he a t ha ie
ke' mpe ai l m.) .s mo.n
''
n, ke
4t
(f antf ...c
s i if omme edt saci a i tdee nt...,i whi Plitf cli hewa
pl
nc hi ton gans fnda
n ch anif ams
s
unl ulydic ge i r t itonf rtlngaW or r Compe aton Cli ') 1 a 5
awf l shar d n ealai o ii
kes
ns i am. ' d. t
',
(f ai ifwass pe d/emi tdd t t fc t thefldaW or r Compe ai
s ntf
pl
us nde tr nae ue o he a t ha ie
ke s
nston
cli .) Thec ta e wih FamousAnt
am ' .
'
our gres t
hony' t ts hcli a ie onl unde saelw,
s ha uc am rs s y
r tt a
s cii lyVigi aCodej65. 308, c pr desasf l :
pe fcal r ni
2- whih ovi
olows
A . o e pl r o pe s s l di c r a e pl e s el bec us t
N m oye r r on ha l s ha ge n m oye ol y a e he
e pl e i e t fl orha fl a cl i unde t stte o hast s ii d ori
m oye nt nds o ie
s ied a m
r hi il r
e tfe
s
aboutt t tf i a pr e ng unde t stte. The di c r e ofa pe s w ho
o es iy n ny oc edi
r hi il
s ha g
r on
ha fl a f a
s ied r udul ntc ai i no a vi a i oft ss c i
e l m s t ol ton hi e ton.
B. ee ly ema b iga a to i acrutc u t a igj rs ito o e te
Th mpo e y rn n cin n ic i o r h vn u idcin v r h
e pl rorpe s w ho alege y di c r d t e pl e i vi a i oft s
m oye
r on
l dl s ha ge he m oye n ol ton hi
s cin. Th c ul s al a ej rs ito f rc u es wn,orsri vo ai n
e to
e o ' h l h v u idcin,o a s ho t etan ilto s
t
a or ra opra e r i ,i l ng a t lda age a a t ney' f st
nd de ppr i t elef nc udi c ua m s nd tor s ee o
s c s ulcl i a sand t r rng orr ns a e e oft e pl ,wih bac
uc es f a m nt
he ehii
ei t t m nt he m oyee t
k
pa pl i ees a t j me rt a pr de i j6. 302.
y us ntr t t he udg nt ae s ovi d n 2Va.Codej65. 3
2- 08.
l hi m e or ndum i opposton t t pe ng m oton,Dudl y a g st thi c a m
n s m a
n
ii o he ndi
i
e r ue ha s l i
k ha he w asr t i t aga ns a t r i t f rt tlng ofa W or r 'Com pens ton cl i ...
é t
t
e ala ed i t nd e m na ed o he i i
ke s
ai
am
a i e e l i l underFED ERA L LA W , s ii a l Til VI oft Ci lRi s A c of 1
r s s xc us ve y
' pec fc ly te l he vi ght t 964
'
(ç il Vl' a t Amei nswihDia ltesAc (û
k- te 1' nd he
r
)
rca t s biii t $ADA' . Doc tNo.1 a 3- (mphass
'
)
ke
4t 4e
i
i o ii l. Th sa g me t h we e ,swih u me i.
n rgna) i r u n , o v r i t o t rt
Til V I ,i a ton t pr hi tng di c i i ton on t ba i ofa em pl yee' r ce
te 1 n ddii o o bii
s rm na i
he s s n
o
sa ,
c o , e i on,s x,orna i
ol r r lgi e
tonalor g n,m a i unl wf f a e pl
ii
kes t a ul or n m oyert r t la e a ns a
o e a i t gai t n
e oyeef t
mpl
or t
opposlngja prciemadea unlwf e oymen pr tc by ( teVI1 o
i ny a tc
n a ul mpl
t acie Til I, r
bec us heha m a a c r t tfed, s sed, pa tc pa ed i a m a ri a i s i ton,
a e
s de ha ge, es ii as i t or r i i t n ny nne n n nve tga i
pr e ng,orhe rngunde ( teVl1' 42U. C.j2000e- (mphassa d) I t sca e
oce di
ai
r Til 1.
'
S.
3e
i dde . n hi s ,
D udl y doe notalege t tFa o A nt
e
s
l ha m us hony' r t la e a i thi f oppos ng a alege
s e a i t d ga ns m or
i n l d
vi a i ofTil V l ,orf pur ui a c r ofdi c i i ton unde Til V l . I t a he
ol ton
te 1
or s ng ha ge
s rm na i
r te l ns e d,
c a m st tS w a r t i t a i ta t r i t d f t flng ofa w or r 'com pe a i
l i ha l
he s e ala ed ga ns nd e m na e or he ii
ke s
ns ton
c a m .' Doc tN o.1 a 4. W hie D udl y' a l ga i ofr t la i m a s
li '
ke
4 t
l
e s le tons e a i ton y uppor a ca e of
t us
a ton unde Vi gi a l , he do noti plc t Til V l .
ci
r r ni aw t y
m i a e te I
Dudly' r la on t ADA f r sno be tr I a to t pr hi tng dic i i ton
e s e ince he
ae
te . n ddii n o o bii
s rm na i
t t bassofdia lt '42U. C.j1 1 t ADA ma siunlwf t S srmi t
s he i
on
s biiy,
'
S. 21 2,he
ke t a ul o t ci nae
di
agans a i vi lbe a es i vi lhaso
i t ny ndi dua c us uch ndi dua
ppos a a torpr c i em a unl ulby
ed ny c
a tc
de awf
gheADAIorbec us s h i viua ma ac r tsiid,asit orpa tcpaedi a
t
a e uc ndi d l de hage,e tfe ssed, rii t n ny
ma i a i siai pr e ng,orhe i unde gheADAI' 42U. C.j1
nner n n nvetg ton, oc edi
arng
rt
.
'
S.
2203()
a.
Once agai Dudl doesnotaleget Fam ousA nt
n,
ey
l hat
hony' r alat agai thi f opposng an
s et i ed
ns m or
i
a tm a unl w f by t A D A ,o f rpur ui a c r ofdi a lt di c i i ton unde t
c de a ul he
ro
s ng ha ge
s biiy s r m na i
r he
A DA . l t a he a l gest tt de enda r t la e ag ns hi f flng a c a m w ih t
ns e d, le
ha he f
nt e a i t d ai t m or ii
li
t he
5
Vigi aW or s Com pe a i Comm ison. Thec ti c nce t tDudl y' ca eof
r ni
ker '
ns ton
si
our s onvi d ha
e s us
a ton a iess ey unde sa elw, ndt tnet rt ADA nora o he f de a saut pr des
c i rs ol l
r t t a a ha ihe he
ny t r e r l t t e ovi
ab ssfrt ee rieo fd r l u sinj rs ito
a i o h xecs f e e a q e to u id cin.
l s ,heco tc udest tt a lga i i Dudly' c pl nt e n a e e as
n um t
ur oncl
ha he le tons n
e s om ai , ve cc pt d
tue a e i ufii ntt s
r , r ns fc e o how t tt sc e i one d rsng unde t Consiuton,lws orte tes
ha hi as s
t ii
a
r he
tt i a , r a i
oft UniedStts. 28U. C. 1 . Be a et c eedi riyr uie by28U. C.
he t ae '
'
S. j 331 c us he omplt ve st eq rd
S. j
1 3 i as lc i ,h c u t tg a th d fn a tsmo int ds s f rlc o s b e t
3 2 s lo a kng t e o r mus r n te ee d n ' to o imis o a k f u j c
matr u idcin.
te j rs ito
I.
I
M ot on t D i qualf Couns l
i o s
iv
e
The pl i i fha fl a m o i t di q lf t de e nt scouns on t ba i ofa
a ntf s ied
ton o s ua i y he f nda '
el he s s n
alg dc n lc o i tr s. Be a et ec mpan i s be t ods sa frlc o s b e t
le e o fit f ne et c us h o lit s u j c t imis l o a k f u j c
matr u idcinu d rRue 1 b () tep an ifsmoint ds u l ywil ed nida mo t
te j rs ito n e l 2() 1,h litf
to o iq ai lb e e s o .
f
S e ec, edv GM AC LLC, 6 F. u p. d6 9 6 2( D. . 0 )( ligta t ec u ts
e . ..Fil .
6 0 S p 2 7 , 9 E. Va 20 8 hodn h t h o r'
d cso t ds s t panifsc mpan t e d re )mo t h ohe mo in 'tldb t
e iin o imis he li tf o litd n e gd o t e t r to s'ie y he
r
pate ,i l ngt pl ntf smoint diquaiy c e)
ris ncudi he ai if to o s lf ouns l.
Concl on
usi
Fort r as nss a e t pl i if sm o i nst am e wilbe gr nt t de e nt s
he e o t t d, he a ntf
to o
nd l
a ed, he f nda '
m oton t di m i sw ilbe g a e a t pl i if s m oton t di q lf t def nt sco el
i o s s l
r nt d, nd he a ntf
i o s ua iy he enda ' uns
wilbede e a m oo . TheClr i dieced t s nd c tfe c e oft sm e o a
l
ni d s
t
e k s r t o e erii d opis hi m r ndum
opi o a t a com pa ng or rt t pl i ifa al cot s lofr or
ni n nd he c
nyi
de o he a ntf nd l m e
ec d.
ENTER :Thi ) X day ofN ovem ber 2014.
s
,
Chi fU nie St t D it i tJ
e
t d a es s r c udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?