Smith v. Hardy et al

Filing 56

ORDER granting 55 Motion to Dismiss without prejudice. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/23/2015. (slt)

cœRKsoFj u: nlx' pc:
s

A RFI x V
T' Mi k A
o LED

I TH E UN I D S
N
TE
TAT E S D I
STR I CO U RT
CT
FO R T H E W E S E RN D I RI O F W R GI I
T
ST CT
N A
RO AN O K E D I SIO N
W

DE2 23 2 1
25
JULG Q DU
BY;
DE U

.
L
E

TI
FFIN L.SM I H ,
T
Pl nt f,
ai if

Ci lA cton N o.7:
vi
i
14cv00477

SH ERI CH I H ARDY,: P=
FF
P
4J

By: M i
chaelF.U r
banski

Unie Stt DititJudge
td aes src

D ef
endant
s.

D ISM ISSM O RD E R
Thi m ateri bef e t cout on pli fTifn L.Snlt sm oton t vol atl dim i
s t s or he
t
andf fi
ih'
i o unt iy s ss

ti cs ( No 5 ) whc t ec u tc nsr e a amo inp tu n t Rue4 ()o t Fe ea
hs a e ECF . 5 , ih h o r o tu s s to u s a t o l 1a fhe d rl
Rul ofCi lPzocedlr
es
vi
z e.

Sm ih,an i at w ho i pz
t
nm e
s oceedi pt a ,t dt sj1 3a do i Se e r201
ng q q fl hi 98 c n t ptmbe
e
l
4.
-

D ef
endant t reaferm oved t dim i t com pli and Sm ih s
s he t
o s ss he
ant
t oughtl ve t am end. By O z
ea o
der
ent red Se em be 21,2015,t cour deni def
e
pt
r
he
t
ed endantCalgiuism odon t dinas gra ed
it '
o s is, nt

S tf Hadn a dt Al mal Co n yRe in l al mo n t ds s, rntdi p t S t s
heif t ig n he be re u t go al is do o imisg a e n at mih'
'
m odon f l ve t am end,and ga pl ndf Snaih 30 days t fl a a ended com pl ntcarf i
or ea o
ve ai f t
o le n m
ai l iy ng
ce ti re ai ng cli s Snat s
r an m ni
am . ih oughtand wasgr ed a ext i untlN ovem ber25,2015 t
ant n enson .
i
o

fl hi am ended com pli . H e f ied t com pl w ih t sdeaHlne. I an O t ent ed D ecem be
te s
nnt
al q
y t hi
i n
der er
r

7, 5,teUrie SttsMa itaeJud wane Smih t tafitet fl a a nde c ant
201 l ltd ae gszt ge r d t ha alr o te n me d ompli
a
t
wihi 1 da wil euli i dit ds sa oft sa donwi utpzj c .S t a a' fie
f n 0 ys lr s tn mme ae imisl hi c
t
ho eudie mih g m ald
t com pl wih t de i O n D ece ber18,2015,Sm ih fl t i antm odon t vol ao y
o
y t he aHlne.
m
t ted he nst
o unt
d
o
dim i st scas as rtng he l ks t l s ls t pr ec e t scaseprq >q and woul Eke t
s s hi e, se i
ac he egal kil o os ut hi
- ..

r a t couns once z eas fom cusody and re-le li cbi s
etil
el
el ed r
t
fl as m .

.
.' --

Alhough tascas hasbeen pendi f m or t ayea i i s ililtae e l s ages of
t
li e
ng or e han
z, t s tl t l ary t

lia o .Ass c ,hec ut f sads sa p ru n t Rue4 ()2 t bea p o rael
ig d n
t
u h t o t md imisl u s a t o l 1a () o p r p it.
A ccordi y,i i her O R D E RE D t t scas i he eby D ISM ISSE D wihout
ngl t s eby
hat hi e s r
t

prj lc a STM CKEN fom t a dvedoc toft c tt
eucie nd
r he c
ke he ott.

Enee: / &J A-t d A/ /z
z

/
w/

.

* >J .

'

Mi
chaelF.Ur ki
bans

Unie SttsDitit udge
td ae s c l

1 tr a iey ti matrc td b cs se wi ut rj cc o a c t o p and f fi t t p osc e
Alen t l,h s te oz e l mis d t p eul e n c o mt f li f' al e o r e ut.
v
l
i
ho
i
s u