Ellis v. Zych
Filing
3
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 9/11/14. (mka)
eLER/:eF :e I,.' . . kr
A cq 'I J QIr x I
T
A klqt lK
qyk W k ,
g
n
:
I T H E UN I
N
TED STA TES DI RI T CO UR T
ST C
FO R TH E W E STER N DI
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O A N O K E D I ISION
V
R EN E'EL LI
S,
r
P l1 2 1
24
#' u
.
'
(
s
.
'
v
w
N .,
P
CA SE N O .7:
14CV 00486
Pet toner,
ii
V.
M EM O M N DU M O PI O N
NI
W A R DEN C H R ISTO PH ER ZY CH ,
..
*
By: H on.G l E .Conrad
en
C hi U nied St esD i t ctJudge
ef t
at
s ri
R e ponde .
s
nt
Re Eli,a f de ali e pr e ng pr K ,fld t s pe ii n f a wrtofhabe s
ne' ls e r nmat oc edi
o
ie hi tto or
i
a
.
cor ,purua t 28U. C.j2 ,se ngani dit c tor rt prve hi e ce
pus s nt o
S.
241 e ki
mme ae our de o e nt s xpe td
t a f r t a dif r ntpr s whe e he f a s f hi lf Thi c tw il s m a iy di m i s t
r ns e o
fe e
i on, r
e r or s ie.
s our l um rl s s he
p tto 1wi o tp eudc t a y rg tEli ma h vet a s r hi camsi a p o el fld
eiin, t u rj ie o n ih ls y a o s et s li n r p ry ie
h
ci lr g s a t o unde Bi ns v.Si Unkno n N am e A g s of Fe r Bur u ofN a c i s
vi i ht c i n
r ve
x
w
d ent
de al ea
r otc ,
403U. 388( 971 .
S. 1 )
Eli i c r nty a i t a t Unie Stt Pe tntayi Jo s le,Vigi a(C
ls s ure l n nmae t he td aes nie ir n nevil r ni C
USP
Le '. He alg s ta o S p e e 5 2 4 t d ysb fr h p e ae a d mald t i
e'
)
l e h t n e tmb r , 01 , wo a e oe e r p rd n
e
i hs
e
j2241 peii t r ponde si t tEli woul be ta fre t S
tton, he es
nt ad ha ls
d
rnser d o t
USP Mccr r 'on
eay'
Se e be 1 201 Eli saest t f va i r a ons he be iveshi lf wilbe i dange
pt m r 6, 4. ls t t ha , or rous e s ,
le
s ie l
n
r
i hei ta fre t USP Mccray.Eli as c e t tj2241prvi a hort f t s
f s rnser d o
e r ls lo ontnds ha
o des ut iy or hi
c t t or r ofi i s f r s f y r s , not t ta f hi . H e c ai s t t no Bur u of
our o de f c al , o a et ea ons
o r ns er m
l m ha
ea
Prs (% OP' ad nitai rme i a l et a e shi e r nc st ton,be us
ions t ' mi srtve e dy s vaiabl o ddr s s me ge y iuai
)
ca e
t r m e e pr e est ke t l t pr s .
he e di s oc dur a oo ong o oce s
1 Habeas Rul 4 r r t cour t exa i a petton pror t or i a a wer and t
e equies he
t o m ne
ii
i o derng n ns
o
s
umma iy dimist p tton çifi pli y a e r fo t peiin a d a y atc e e bist a t
rl s s he e ii û l t anl pp a s r m he tto n n ta h d xhi t h t he
l
peii e i no e tte t r le . S e28 U. C.j22 4 Rue 4 a ia et j22 p tton tr ug
tton r s t nild o eif' e
'
S.
5 l , pplc bl o
41 eii s h o h
Ha a Rul lb)
be s e ( .
A j2241ha aspeii i no t pr rf m frEli t us f se ng hi de ie
be tton s t he ope onz o ls o e or e ki s srd
r i . Fede all w pr vi s t o a nuesofr i t pr s r :a pe ii f ha s c pus a a
elef
r a
o de w ve
elef o i one s
tton or bea or
nd
cvi rght c ant Muhn d v.Cl e,5 U. 749,750 (
i l i s ompli .
mma
os 40 S.
2004) t le
. d lngest t
cha
o he
va i t of a eo i m e or t pa tc ar a f c i is d a in a e t pr nc ofha as
ldiy
ny nfne nt o riul s f e tng t ur to r he ovi e
be
c r usg ie r q e t f rr l ftr i o cru tn e o c n ie n ma b p ee tdi a
o p wh l) e u ss o ei u nng n ic msa c s f o fn me t y e r sn e n
e
j 1 8 grBie la to . I . Se to 2 41c p o i e ta Cth wrto h be sc russ al
9 3 o v ns cin' d cin 2 () r v d s h t t q e i f a a op h l
'
g
note e t aprs runls ...( e i i c t i vi ai oft Consiuton o lwsor
xtnd o ione e s hj s n usody n olton he
tt i r a
te te o te Uni d S ae . j22 ()3 . Be a e Eli i n tc n etn t e fc o t e
r ais f h
t tts'
e
'
41c( ) c us ls s o o tsig h a t r h
durton ofhi co i me tbyt BOP,hi cai i no pr ry a esedi a j2241ha s
ai
s nfne n
he
s l m s t opel ddr s n
bea
pe ii n.
tto
As Eli i pr e ng pr K ,t c tco d consr hi s
ls s oc edi
o
he our ul
tue s ubmi son a a ci lrght
si s
vi i s
a ton unde Bi ns Aijv.Smih,1 F.App' 7 7 ( h Ci.J y 27,2004) Bec us
ci
r ve . a
t 08
x 43, 43 4t r ul
. a e
Eli a is how e r t t he ha nota l hi s l of t a i s r tve r m e e w ihi t
ls dm t ,
ve , ha
s
vaied m e f he dm nit a i e di s t n he
BOP,hi lws ti bar d t r42 U. C.j1
s a ui s re mde
S.
997e() whih r quiesf le usi beor
a , c e r ul xha ton f e
flng t sc ta i The ef e t c twilnotco t et p e e ac in a aBi nsc e
ii hi our cton. r or , he our l
nsnz he r s nt to s ve as .
Furhemor,Eli'a ton doesno pr e f t warntng t itroc or ij tve
t r e ls ci
t esnt acs ra i he nel ut y nunci
rle h s e .A pat s e ig ap ei n r ij n to mus ma ace rs o n 1 1 ta h
eif e e ks
ry e kn r l ay nu cin t ke la h wig $ 1 h t e
mi
g
i lk l t s c e o t e meis ( )h i l ey t s fe irpaa l h r i t e a s n e o
s iey o uc e d n h rt; 2 e s i l o u fr re rb e am n h b e c f
k
prlmi r r l f (jt a t b ln eo e ute tp i hi fv r a d g )a ij n to i i t e
ei nay ei ' 3 h t he aa c f q iis i s n s a o ; n 4 n nu cin s n h
e,
publci ees. W itrv.Naur Reour sDee eCouncll ,555U. 7,20(
i ntr t' ne
'
t al s ce fns
i. nc.
S.
2008).A
)
m er pos biiy t t m ovantwili
e si lt hat he
l ncur i eparabl har i t absence of courti erventon
rr
e m n he
nt
i
i i ufi i nt g ounds f r r le . 1 a 20. Eli doesno pr en any m or t n hi ge r lze
s ns t c e r
o e i f d. t
ls
t es t
e ha s ne a i d
f a s an s c aton a
e r d pe ul i boutpos i e da z he w oul f e i hous d i t ge r popul ton a
sbl nge s
d ac f
e n he ne al
ai t
2
U SP M c e r Y e ,he s a e no f c s s
cr a y. t
tts
a t ugge tng t tofi a satU SP M c ea y,i i o m e of
s i ha tci l
cr r f nf r d
Eli'ne d f rpr eci n,wo d a sgn hi t t ge r lpo a i r t rt n pr di s e
ls e o ot to
ul s i m o he ne a pulton a he ha ovi ng om
o he c t gor of c t
t r ae y
usody smia t hi c r nt st ton a U SP Lee Eli a s ha no
i l r o s ur e iua i t
. ls lo s
s t nta lkelhood of s e ng on hi cai t the has s
ubsa i l i i
ucc edi
s l m ha
ome pr eced rght no t be
ot t i
t o
t a f r e t a pa tc a BOP f c lt Sl BO P has di c e i t de er i w he e a unde
r ns e r d o
r i ul r
a iiy. ç-he
s r ton o t m ne
r nd
r
wha co tons a f r l prs r i hous 'and i t s do ç t ha a pr e t d lbe t
t ndii
ede a ione s
ed'
nma e
ç
no ve
ot c e i ry
i e e ti r m ani a' a pa tculrprs orc t gor ofprs Ai i 1 F.App' a 743
ntr s n e i ng t' ny ri a ion
ae y
ion. a, 08
x t
( tngBelv. olih, U. 520,53 5 41n.23( 979) Sa nv.Col r 51 U. 472,
cii
l W fs 441 S.
9, 401 ; ndi
me , 5 S.
48 ( 995).
4 1 )
Fort sae r s ,t c tc nnota es,unde j2241 Eli'rquett sop hi
he ttd ea ons he our a
ddr s
r
, ls e s o t s
she ue ta se a d fn sn b ssf ritro u o yij n tv r l fi a y fr Th r fr ,
c d ld rn fr n i d o a i o ne lc t r nu cie ei n n o m. ee oe
e
t c twil dimis t a i wiho prj c a de Eli' pe ng motons An
he our l s s he cton t ut eudie nd ny ls ndi
i .
a opra e or rw ile e t sda
ppr i t de l nt r hi y.
The Clr i die t d t s nd copi of t s m e a
ek s rce o e
es hi mor ndum opi on a ac ompanyi
ni nd c
ng
or rt peii r
de o ttone .
ENTER:Th s llN d yo Se tmb r 2014.
i
a f pe e,
Chi fUnied St t Diti tJ
e
t
aes src udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?