Maxwell v. Clarke et al

Filing 9

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 10/20/2014. (tvt)

eke- goFFl u : >A Gour
o:

A x vlkV
T lk A

?Cl
F
L

0 T :2
:
I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES DI
STR I T CO U R T
C
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STR I T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI
BM DLEY M A XW E LL,
Pl ntf ,
ai if

JULI . U
A
BY.
.
E

, u

L

C i lA cton No.7: :vvi
i
14- 00487

M EM O M N D UM O PI O N
NI
H A R O LD C LA R K E.etal.
.
De e
f ndant .
s
-

By:

H on.Jacks L . i e
on K s r
Se orU nied St e D i t i tJudge
ni
t
at s s r c

Br dly M a l,aVigi ai a epr e ng pr K ,fl d aCompli pu s ntt 42
a e
xwe l
r ni nm t oc edi
o
ie
ant r ua o
.

U. C.j1 na ngvai safoft Vigi aDe rme ofCorecinsa t W ale
S.
983, mi rous tf he r ni pa t nt
r to nd he lns
Ri Stt Prs n (I RSP' a dee nt.Pli ifc anst theha b ni W RSP'
dge ae io S
W
' s fnda s antf ompli ha
)
s ee n
S

s ge ai nh u igfra u s e i e to g'i a dt a h d e n t n o t esme
e r g to o sn o n n p ct d,s n 'tme n h t e o s o e j y h a
i l
prvie sa ot ri t a W RSP, l edl i vi a i oft Fouree h Ame e '
i l ge s he nma es t
aleg y n olton he
t nt
ndm nts

Equa Pr e tonClus Thi matri beo emef sr e ng, zs ntt 28U. C.j1 5A.
l otci a e. s te s fr
or c e ni ptrua o
S. 91

Afe rve n Plitf ss b sin , ds s t eCo lit t o t rj dc frfi n t
tr e iwig an if u miso s 1 imis h mp an wih u p eu ie o al g o
i
sae ac am upon whi h r le m a be g a e
tt li
c e if y
r nt d.
Pli tf aleg t theha r m ane i W RSP' s gr ga i uni at ug a
a n if l es ha
se i d n
S e e ton t lho h n
i tt i lc r ofs m pl a s ul w asdi m i s i J y 201 Cons ue l Pl ntf d
nsiutona ha ge i e s a t
s s ed n ul
3.
eq nty, ai i f oes

n t n o t ep iie e ta aea albet oh rimae a W RS lk atn i ca s sa d
o e j y h rvlg s h t r v ia l o te n ts t
P,i e te dng lse n
voc tona ta ni wachi TV,a havi mor tm ei t s we and f routi r c eai n.
a i l r i ng, t ng
nd
ng
e i n he ho r
o
sde e r to
Prs ofi i l de e r d Pli ifsr que t t bem ove t a dif r thousng uni wih mor
ion fc a s f r e antf e s s o
d o fe en
i
t t
e
prvieg t tlhe i e i bl a i t be r l s ted a m oved ou ofs gr ga i . 1
i l es m i
s lgi e ga n o
ec as ii nd
t e e ton
1m us di m i san a ton orc a m fl by a i a e i ldet nui t tt a ton orc a m
t s s
ci
l i ied
n nm t f
e ne ha he c i
li

i fi l o f ist saeacai onwhihr i ma begantd.See28U. C.jj1 5()2)
s rvoous r al o tt l m
c elef y r e
S.
91 e( ,
'Pl ntf sgreva s whih heatc dt t Complit i c et ti Fe ' l 201 hewasor r d t
ai if i nce , c
ta he o he
an ,ndiat ha n bl ' 4
uay
de e o
r m an i s gr tonuntla he he rng i hel i sx m ont .
e i n e egai
i not r a i s d n i
hs

O :1/

1 5A( ( ) 42U. C.j 1 e() Thefrtsa r i l cli baeduponi n
91 b)1;
S.
997 c.
is tndad ncudes ams s
û
a
i s a y m e ils lga t r 'é am so i rnge e ofa lga i e es whih cla l
ndiput bl rte s e l heo y,'t i f nfi m nt
cl
e l nt r t c e ry

doesnotexit'orcli swhe e t ( a t lco e i a ecla l ba e e s' Net kev.
s ' am
r he i c ua nt ntons r e ry s l s . iz
f
'

W i ims 49 U. 31 , 2 ( 9 9 .Th s c n sa d r i tef miirsa d r f ramo int
l a , 0 S. 9 3 7 1 8 ) e e o d tn ad s h a l tn ad o
l
a
to o
dimisunde Fe a Rul ofCi lPr e e1 b)6 , c ptngapli ifsf t lalgai
s s
r derl e
vi oc dur 2( ( ) ac e i
antf acua le tons
astue A compl ntnee t s t nd pli saeme oft c am s
r .
ai
ds k hor a
a
an t t nt he l i howi t tt plade i
ng ha he e r s

e tte t r l f a d s fiin tta t a alg to s. .oriearg tt r le a o et
n ild o ei ' n u fce td l cu l l ai n . t as i h o eif b v he
e
g
e
s c ai lve.... BelAt. p. Twombl 550U. 544,555(
pe ultve e l ' l lCor v.
'
v,
S.
2007)(ntr quoai
i enal tton
makso te .A pli ipsba i f rle lequiesmor t nl l a c ncusons....'
r mitd)
antf ss or eif i r
r
e ha abes nd o l i
'

l .Theeo e apanifmu tû l g fcss fiin t saea1 h ee n so (h )cam .z
d
rf r , litf s $ l e a t u fce t o tt lt e lme t f te li '
ae
'
BAs v. 1 DupontdeNe s& Co.324F. 761 765( hCi.2003)
s E..
mour
,
3d , 4t r
.
Pl ntf f ist sae ac am t tade e ntvi aeda f de alrg . See e. ,W es v.
ai if al o t t l i ha
f nda olt
e r i ht
. g.
t

At ns 487U. 42,48( 988) Pli ifdoe notha ac tt i lrg t beplc i a
ki ,
S.
1 . antf s
ve onsiutona iht o
a ed n

s e ii s c rt ca sfc to , n c tdilca stc to d no ce t amao d su to i a
p cfc e u iy lsiiain a d uso a lsi ains o t rae j r ir p in n
i
prs ne' e r
io rs nvionmen .Se e. ,Sa nv.Conne,51 U. 47 48 8 (995) Sttsma
t e. g. ndi
r 5 S. 2, 6- 7 1 . ae y
cr a elbe t i e esspr e t d by t DuePr es Clus whe et f e dom fom r sr i
e t i ry ntr t ot c e
he
oc s a e
r he r e
r e tant
i
mpos d daypi a a sgnii a ha ds p o t i ae i r l tont t o di r i de sof
e tt c l nd i fc nt r hi n he nm t n e ai o he r na y nci nt
prs lf ... 1 a 48 Pl i ifscl sfc i a s r ga i doe note e d a s nt nc
ion ie. ' d. t 4. antf ' as iiaton nd eg e ton s
'
xc e e e e

2Deem i ngwhet raco pli saesaplusbl cam f r le i çaco exts cii t k t tr quiest
tr ni
he
m ant tt
a i e li or eif s $ nt -pe fc as ha e r he

rve n c u tod a o i j dca e p re c a dc mmo sn e' Asco t .u a,5 6U.. 6 , 7 -9
e iwig o r t rw n t u iil x ein e n o n e s . h rf v lb l 5 S 6 2 6 87
s
'
( 0 9 .T s ac u tce nn ac mplit d rRul l ( ()c nie tf pedig ta aen te tt dt a
2 0 ) hu , o r sre ig o an un e e 2b)6 a d niy la n s h t r o nil o n
e

as umptonoftut be aus t y c itofnom or t n l sandco l i
s
i
r h c e he onss
e ha abel
ncusons.1 Alho 1lbe al consr ea
d. t ugh i r ly
tu
pro .K c mplitHan sv. re, 0 U.. 9 5 02l(9 2 , d n tata a imaesa v ct, u s o t
o an, ie Ken r4 4 S 51 , 2 - 1 7 )l o o c s n n t' d o ae s a p ne

de opi s a ut y a c tt tonalc ai snotc e l r i e i a c pl i . Se Br k v.Carol,1 F. 241
vel ng t t or nd ons iu i
lm
l ary a s d n om a nt e oc
r l 07 3d ,

2 (t Ci. 9 ) Lut , .c n u n l Be u et Ciyo Ha tn, 7 F.d 1 7 ,1 7 (t Ci. 98 ) se
43 4h r 1 97 ( ti J, o c ni g ; a d tv. t f mpo 7 5 2 2 4 2 8 4h r 1 5, e
g
.
as Godo v. e e 57 F.d 1 4 ,l 5l(t Ci. 97 )(e o nzn ta adsrc c u tsn te p ce t
lo r n Le k , 4 2 1 7 1 4h r 1 8 rc g iig h t itit o r i o x e td o
asum et r eofa
s
he ol
dvocaef apr K plitf
t or o
anig.
.

2

i s h a e r m e w a ast g ve rs t t pr ec i oft D ue Pr es Cl us by is o n
n uc n xt e
y o i i e o he ot ton he
oc s a e t w

f c SeeBe r iv.Smih,1 F. 500,503( hCi.1 ( di t ta nitai
ore.
veat
t 20 3d
4t r 997) hol ng ha dmi srtve
s e ton f sx m o hswih ve mi human wase fooded t l t unbe r bl he t col f
egr ga i or i nt
t r n;
t; l
oie ;
a a e a ; d ood;
di t c ot ng,lne ,a be ng'l pe i i t ce l no out i r c ea i n'no e a i l
ry l hi i ns nd ddi , ong r ods n he l;
s de e r to , duc tona

orrlgi s r ce ;a ls f wa no s aypia a t i easgniia ha ds p) Nor
ei ous evi s nd e s ood s t o t c l s o mpos i fc nt r hi .
doe a i e e i Pl i if s s urt c as ii a i c tt e a ( t pi ala s gnii a '
s n ncr as n a ntf ' ec iy l s t c ton ons iut n t y c nd i fc nt'
a

h r hp.S eM o d v. c et 4 9U. 7 , 8n. (9 6 (ee tn ap io e ' a gl n
ads i e o y Da c t, 2 S. 8 8 9 1 7 ) rj cig rs n rs r t t
me
t tape ng wa r nta de ane ad r ey a f c e hi prs c a stc ton a qualt ai n
ha
ndi
ra nd t i r ve s l f e t d s ion l s ii a i nd
ik to
f i tt i lpr r m sbe aus note r sa e ac i n c nyi a r e c eq
or nsiutona og a
c e
ve y t t to a ng dve s ons uenc s f
e or

p io imae a t maial a tv tsad ep o e srg t.F rhemo e Plitf d e no
rs n n ts u o tc l ci ae u r c s ih) u t r r , anif o s t
y
s fcinty sa eho he wa te t d dif e ty fo C i lry st t ' nma e asar s tof
ufi e l t t w
s r a e fer n l r m d mia l iuaed'i t s
s
e ul

Dee nt'i e i ldici nai Se eg.M ors nv.Gar ht 239F. 648, ( h
fnda s ntntona srmi ton. e. . , rio
rag v,
3d
654 4t
Ci.2001.Pli ifsr la eo t lbe a c l in oft i lry st t 'i not
r
) antf einc n he a l nd oncuso s mial iuaed' s
s
s fci ntt s ts y t tel m e ofa e lpr t c i c a m . Twom bl 550 U . a 555.
uf i e o a i f ha e nt n qua o e ton l i
v,
S. t

Ac r ngl Pl ntf f l t sae ac am u n whi r le maybe gr nt d,a t Co pli
co di y, ai if ais o t t l i po
ch ei f
a e nd he m a nt

i dimis dwihoutprj i .
s s se t
eu c
ENTER :
Thi

da ofOc obe ,201
y
t r
4.

Se i rU nie St t s i ti tJ
o
t d a e sr c udge

3