Littek v. Lee et al

Filing 12

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 09/26/2014. (kab)

a ppa oFFl u s Dl c
c:
sm

Ax l y or
T ii A u

Ft v re$
l
zo
u
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O A NO K E D I I O N
V SI
TH OM AS A.LI
TTEK ,
Pl ntf ,
ai if

sEF 26 2 1
26

B: GDDE V
v kULXC
D
&> C

Ci lAc i No.7: 4- vvi ton
1 c 00489
M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON
NI

JACK LEE,e al,
t .
De e
f ndant
s.

By:

H on. ks L.K i er
Jac on
s
Se orUnied St esDit i Judge
ni
t
at
s rct

Thom a A.Li e aVigi a i t pr ee ngpr j fld a moton f rapr i na y
s
t k, r ni nma e oc di
l
o t, ie
i o
elmi r
.

ij n to t o d r al fcast alw hm t u etej i' lw l r r f rt oh u sawe kf r
nu cin o r e j iofiil o lo i o s h als a i a y o ' o r
b
w
e o
t dur ton oft scvi a to Pl i ift nkst tt e a oxi ael t ry mi esofa ce s
he a i
hi i l c i n. antf hi ha h ppr m t y hit nut
c s
he r cevesea h we i i ufk i nt
e i
c
ek s ns t e .

A p ei n r ij n to i a ç xr o dn r a dd a tcrme y' M t fv. rn 5 3
r l ay nu cin s n d ta r iay n rsi e d . ma Gee , 5
mi
e
'
U. 6 4 6 9 9 ( 0 8 .A mo a tmu t sa ls f u ee nsb f r ap ei nayij n to
S. 7 , 8 - 0 2 0 )
v n s e tbih o r lme t eo e rlmi r nu cin
ma is 1 hei lkel t s c dont meis 2)hei lkeyt s frirpaa eham i t
y sue: ) s i y o uc ee
he rt;
s i l o ufe re rbl r n he

a s n eo prlmi ayr l f 3 t eb ln eo e u te tp i h sfvo ; n 4 a ij n to i
b e c f ei n r ei ; ) h aa c f q iis is n i a r a d ) n nu cin s
e
i t p bi itrs.W itr Nau a Re . f Comcl I .5 5U. 7, 0( 0 ) Plitf
n he u lc n ee t ne v. t rl s De . t i,nc, 5 S. 2 2 08 . anif
i notalowe t de
s
l d o monsr t onl a% sbiiy' ofir pa a eham be us t tsa r i
ta e y ç i lt ' re r bl r ca e ha t ndad s
pos

dn o sse t t g e c aa trz to o ij n tv r l f sa e ta r iayr me yt a ma
ç c n itn wih t ) h r ce iain f n u cie ei a n xr o dn r e d h t y
i
h
e
onl be a r d upon a cea s wi t tt pl i ifi e il dt s h r i . 1 a 23.
y
wa de
l r ho ng ha he antf s ntte o uc elef' d. t
'
Pli iff l t esa ih t the i lkel t s ce d on t me isofva i us dipa a e
antf ais o t bls ha
s i y o uc e
he rt
ro , s r t

c ant a t j i' medials r ce ,Chrsi pr r mmi bookpolc gre nc
ompli s bout he als c evi s itan og a ng,
iy, iva e
polc a l w lbr r a ce sa m a e i l ,e pe i ly s nc he ha no ye pa d t r qui ie
i y, nd a i a y c s nd t r a s s c a l i e
s t t i he e st

flngfea r quiedby 28U. C.j1
ii e s e r
S.
915. Pl ntf as fist etbls irpa a ehar
ai if lo al o sa ih re r bl m
be us he i ad isbei a e t vi i t 1 w lbr r e h w e k f a l s t ry m i ut s
ca e s m t ng bl o s t he a i a y ac
e or t ea t hi t n e .

Pl i t f fz t rf l t es a i h how a or rr quii Pl i ift ha i r a e ac es t t
a n i f t he ais o t bls
r
n de e r ng a ntf o ve nc e s d c s o he

lw lbr r a t pos i ee l i ofot ri aesf rhe st publc' i e e twhe t t
a i a y t he sbl xcuson
he nm t ' t r he
u
i s nt r s
n ha
i e es i s ve by de eni t core tona ofi a sa
nt r t s er d
f ng o r c i l fcil boutt a pr it nes ofr toni
he p opra e s a i ng

lmie r our s See e. ,Belv.W olih, U. 520,540n. 548n. ( 979
i td es ce . s g. l
fs 441 S.
23,
29 1 )
(xpli ngt tmanti ngs urt a or ra o rtnga i tt i i ama ea e
e ani ha i ani ec iy nd de nd peai n nsiuton n
nag bl
f hi a econsde a i pe ula l wihi t pr nc a pr e sona e rie of
as on r
i r tons c iry t n he ovi e nd of s i l xpe ts

core tonsofiil)
rci
fcas.
Bas on Pli ifsa l to a t pr e sausoft c s Pl i iff ist
ed
antf legai ns nd he es nt t t
he a e, antf al o
esa ih t tt balnc ofe testpsi hi f vor De e nt ha notye r po
t bls ha he a e quii i n s a . f nda s ve
t es ndedt t
o he

c mpan , n o d rngg e tra c s t telw lb aya ti j ct ewo l b u d l
o lita d r ei rae c e s o h a i rr t h s un tr ud e n uy
l
b de o eon core tonalofi a s Ac r ngl Pli iff ist s tsy t ee e sf a
ur ns m
rci
fcil . co di y, antf al o a if he lm nt or

p ei nayij ncin, n 1d n h sr q et
r lmi r n u to a d e y i e u s.

ExrER: i 4 GeNa o se tmb r 2014.
r Th s
d y f pe e,
Se i Unied St esD i r ctJudge
or t
at
sti