Muhammad v. Commonwealth Of Virginia et al

Filing 169

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 101 Motion to Dismiss; denying 146 Motion for Sanctions; denying 147 Prisoner Miscellaneous Motion; denying 152 Motion for Preliminary Injunction; adopting in part Report and Recommendations re 157 Report and Recommendations for 157 Report and Recommendations, ; denying 159 Prisoner Miscellaneous Motion; denying 166 Motion for Settlement. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 3/17/2016. (tvt)

CL
ERKS OFFI U. DI COUA
CE S, SQ
/-!f'..7$5,iI
!- 7-rs 2tq I/K
u - ''': ):E r
.
. '
S

(? -'
' '
J

I TH E U N I
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI T C OI R T
C
J
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGG I
CT
A
R O AN O K E D I SI N
W O

ABDUL.
HAM ZA W ALIM UHAM M AD,

MA2 17 2 1
26
JULA (..
I 'l
'J
BY;
EB

cAs No. 1 cv0 2
E
7:k 0s 9

Pl i i f
a nt f ,
O R D ER

V.

COM M ONW EALTH OF W RGI
NW
By: G l n E .Cbnr
e
ad
C hi fU nie St e D i t i tJudge
e
t d at s s r c

c K ,
Dee
f ndant .
s

I a co dmlewiht ac ompa ng me or ndmn o ni oft c tand t r por
n c r c t he c
nyi
m a
pi on he our,
he e t

a drc mme daino t ema ikaej d e i i h rb
n e o n to f h gs t u g ,t s ee y
A DJUD G ED A ND O R D ERED

af l :
s olows

Afe t co tsX novor viw oft pe tne pori oft rpo ta t r or
tr he ur'
ee
he ri nt tons he e r nd he ec d,
plitY s o j cins t t e rpo ta e S TM NED I PART, a d t rpo t a d
an i b e to o h e r r US
N
n he e r n
r c mme d to (
e o n ain ECF No. 1 7 i REJ
5 ) s ECTED I PART, a t t e fndn s a d
N
s o h i ig n
r omm e d diposton r r ng Cl m 5 a i tDe e ntBihop;butast Cl i 5
ec
nde s ii ega di
ai
ga ns f nda
s
o am

a ans oh r d fn a t a d a t à1 o h r cams plitf o j cin a e
g i t t e ee d n s n s o 1 t e li , anifs b e to s r
OVERRULED a t e rpo t a d r c mme d to o te ma itae j d e i
nd h e r n e o n ai n f h
gsrt u g s
A D OPTED ;
2.

P an ifspe dn moin frp ei n r ijmcin ( No.1 2 i DENI wi u
litf n ig t o r l a y nt to ECF
o
mi
5)s
ED t t
ho
p eu ie a d t cek i DI
rj d c , n he lr s RECTED t fl ac p o t smoin a boh ane a d
o ie o y f hi to s t
w n
spaae cvla to t e 4 U. C.j 1 8 a d a mo in frp ei n r ijmcin,
e rt ii cin md r 2 S.
93 n
to o r l ay nt to
mi
a i tG N NA M ED DEFEN D AN TS';
ga ns t
U
'

4.

P an i soh rp ndn moi n ( No . 4 1 7, 5 , nd 1 6 aeDEM ED;
litY t e e i g to s ECF s 1 6, 4 1 9 a 6 ) r
De e d n s moint d s s , ri t atmaie moi nf rsl r j d me t(
f n a t' to o imis o n he le tv , to o '
mmay u g n ECF
No. 01, sGRANTED I PART AND DENI I PM W , sf lo :
1 )i
N
ED N
a olws

a
.

S mma j d me ti GRANTED a t a1camsa ans ald fn a t,
u y ug n s
s o l li g i t l ee d ns
e cp ()te alg to i Cli 1ta Dee d nsDa ,Ke ly a d
x e t 1 h le ain n am h t fn a t y ge n
M a he de i d M thn m a of a pr t c e lbe t i e es m t ut
t na prve
l m d
o e t d i ry nt r t ho

pr c d ld ep o e s a d(i t ealg to i Cli 5t a Dee a t
o e ma u r c s ; n i) h le ain n am h t fnd ns

.
'

Co e a Biho f l t i t r e t sop a he i t s a tc on
yl nd s p aied o n e v ne o t not r nma e' ta k
M uhn m a o J nua y 5,
m d n a r 2013;
b.

De e d n s mo in i DEM ED u e Ru e 1 b)6 a t t p o e l a
fn a t' to s
nd r l 2( () s o he r c dz l
r
due pr es alegai n i Cli 1 agans Def nda s Da Ke ey,a
oc s l to n am
i t e nt y, gl
nd
M ahe ,a t s de e nt a eDI
t na nd he e f nda s r RECTED t s i, t n 30 da
o ubm t wihi
ys

fo e ty o t i o d r a y s p lme tlmo in f rsl r j d me t
rm nr f hs r e, n u pe n a to o l
mmay u g n
a t t scli ;
s o hi am

S l r j d me ti as DENI a t t ealg to i Cli 5 ta
l
mmay u g n s lo
ED s o h l ain n am h t
e
Def nda sCoyl a Biho f ie t i e v net pr e tM uhn mad on
e nt
e nd s p al d o nt r e o ot c
m
J nua y 5,201 a
a r
3) nd
d.

The clr SH AI, tr i t t f l ng i vi l a pa te t t s
ek
L em nae he olowi ndi duas s ri s o hi
lws t Comm onwe 1h of Vigi a Har d W . Clr , A. Da d
a ui:
at
r ni ,
ol
a ke
vi
Robi on, Bra Ket Da dns He e Sc t li hes
ns
in
ih
wl , l n ot tc on, Ge ad K .
rl
W as ngtn,Adi L.Pog M a k E.Engeke,P.Sca be
hi o
na
ue, r
l
r ny,J hn F.
o
W alah, She Shorrdge J fr y C.Arrp,Ge al ne G.Ba r A.J
rt
ni
ti , e f e
ti
r di
ke ,
.
Galha ,Dewa ne A.Tt e ,CM C J c on,S.Fl t he ,Li u e n C.
li r
y
mlr
a ks
e c r e t na t
St nl y,Se ge ntErc Ant
a e
r a
i
hony M ilr Se ge nt Clnt Dee, Se ge nt
le , r a
i on
l r a
J l M es e ,A.J Va ha Liut na St ve B.Fr nkln,Liut na
om
sr
. ug n, e e nt e n
n i
e e nt
J mes Lyal Liut na J tn Kie ,Ge ge Hi e La r W .J r i,
a
l, e e nt usi s r or
nkl , ry
a vs

J l M c n,Sege ntC.Di UniM a ge To M .Raf d,M is
om ouee r a
xon, t na r d
ior s y
L.Count ,Ca ai D.Stl,A.M u phy,B.Ake s D.W ila s La y 1
s pt n
il
r
r,
lim , n' .
M uli , N . H. Cooki Sc t De a D. Ga d r Pa M oc r, Re
lns
e ot, br
r ne , ul
e i na
M uli ,a t me be so t û
lns nd he m r f he & te men t m';
dual r at t ea '
6.

The c e k i DI
l r s RECTED t c nge t syl o t ca e t ç thn a v.
o ha
he t e f he s o i t mm d
M
M ahe ';
t na'and

The a ton i he e i REFERRED t Urie St t s M ag sr t J
c i s r by s
o lt d a e
ita e udge J lC.Ho ,
oe
ppe

p ua tt 28U. C.j 6 6b ()B) f rc nd to a p o daep o e dn s a f rt
ms n o
S.
3 ()1 ( , o o uc f p r p t r c e ig , nd o he

sb sin o a rp r stiq frh fn ij o fc,c n lso s o lw,a d a
u miso f e o t et o t dn s f a t o cu in f a n
n
r c me
e om nded diposto ofpl ntf s i to al ga i r a e t Cl i 5 a a
s ii n
al ifs polal n le ton elt d o am
nd ny

s p e na moin fr sl r j d me t o Cli 1 a d f r a1 n n ip stv
u plme t l to o l
mmay u g n n am ; n o 1 o d s o i e
i
m o i t tma ai e,i l ng pr tildico r m a tr .
tons ha y ts nc udi
era s ve y te s
EN TER : Thi i
s Q

da ofM a c , 2016.
y
rh

Cli fUnied Stt Diti J
le
t
aes srd udge