Muhammad v. Commonwealth Of Virginia et al

Filing 216

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 1/27/2017. (tvt)

Download PDF
. 1 . . nI ' OF CEU.. S. FiKS FI S DITCOUW AT ROANOKE' VA FI LED I THE UNI STATESDI TRI COURT N TED S CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STRI O F VI CT RGI A NI R O AN O K E D I SI N W O ABDULHAM ZA W ALIM UHAM M AD, ) ) Pli if antf, ) v. ) ) ) RANDALL CHARI, M ATHENA, ES ) ET AL. , ) ) Dee fndants. t) ) J 27 2 1 A8 27 a uuA . B Y; ,L CASE NO.7: 14CV00529 M EM ORANDUM OPI ON NI ( ptngRe tandRec Ado i por omme i ndaton) By:GlnE.Conrad e ChifUnie St e Dit c Judge e td ats srit Thi prs rcvi rg sacin unde 42 U. C.j198 wa r er t Unie Stts s ione i l iht to r S. 3 s efred o td ae M a itaeJ d eJ e C. p u e 2 U. C.j6 6b ()o t is s J d eHo p ha gsrt u g o l Ho pe nd r 8 S. 3 () 1 n wo sue . u g p e s n w is e o e rp r a d r c mme d to ( No.2 8 fn ig ta t e d fnd n s ae o su d n e o t n e o n ain ECF 0 ) i dn h t h ee a t r e tte t s mma yj d me to Cli 1 (s po' 1) a d a s c nd rp r ( No.2 7 n i d o u r u g n n am ç l ' n l Re t e o e o t ECF 0) fndi t ts iton ofe de er a e t Clin 5 occ e a r c me ng a a oprae ng ha pola i vi nc elt d o ai un'd nd e om ndi n ppr it s n to a til(le o t1'. Thedee d n sh v fld n o j cins Th p o K panif a cin t ra Gk p r 1' û ) fn a t a e ie o be to . e r li tf, Abd - mz W aiMl mma ,h sfld o jcinst Re o t1( No .2 9 a d 21 )a d ulHn a l z ha d a ie be to o p r ECF s 0 n 2 n Re o t1 ( No. 0 . Heha as fld mo in s e igj d me ti h sfv ro Cli 5 P r 1 ECF 21 )1 s lo ie to s e kn u g n n i a o n am a d s e igt pu s ea i e n e ts ol to cam ( No 21 a 21 ) Afe c nd ci g n e kn o ru n nd pe d n p i in li ECF . 0 nd 3 . tr o u tn a a X n v r ve o te r p rs Mu mma s o j cinste eo a hi oh rmoins a o o e iw f h e o t, ha d' be to h r t nd s t e to , nd p rie tpo t n o t e rc r i a c r a c wih j6 6 b ( ) t e c u twilo e ze te e t n ri s f h e o d n c o d n e t 3 ( )1, h o r l v m l h n o o j cins a o terp rs a d d nyM t a d spe dn mo in . be to , d pth e o t, n e l mma ' n ig to s h Th ma itaej g ' rp r u d rj6 6 b ( )B)ma so l ar c mme d to t t i e gsrt ud es e o t n e 3 ( )1( ke n y e o n ain o hs c t M ahe v.W e r 423 U. 261 270- ( 976) Fe R.Ci P.7 The c ti our. t ws be , S. , 71 1 . d. v. 2. our s 1 Alh u hMt a d d e no ttet ss b sin a a o j cint tema itaej d esrp r o to g l mma o s t i hi u miso s n be to o h gsrt u g ' e o t n h l s iton,hec rt tue i a s h;i e s nce M uhammadcontndst hei e ild t aha s rs ncin f polai t ou consr s t s uc n s e , e hat s ntte o r he a to or s itont nt s tonsr c m e polai ha he anci e om ndedi t r por. n he e t . c ag d wih macn a X no deemiain o a y p rin o t ma itae j d es h re t l g i vo tr n to f n o t s f he gsrt u g ' o rc mme d to t wh c as e ii o j cin i ma e 2 U. C. 6 6 b ( )C) e o n ain o ih p cfc b e to s d . 8 S. j 3 ( )1( . Re r 1 Summ a y J m e on Cli 1 po t : r udg nt am Mt mma i a imae a Re Onin Sae Prs n (Re On o '. Mu mma s l ha d s n n t t d o tt io C d in' G ) ha d' c mplit a n n e ( No .1a d 1 ) alg d i Cli 1ta Dee d n sDa Ke ly, o an , s me d d ECF s n 3 , l e n am h t fn a t y, ge e a M ahe vi aed hi pr e za d pr es rght r l t d t a I tt i lCl s ik ai n nd t na ol t s oc dtr l ue oc s i s e a e o n nsiutona a sf to Au h rt (û ' h a ig o M a 21 20 4. P e o sy t ec u t e e ds sa o ti p r t o iy GCA' e rn n y , 1 rviu l, h o r d nid imis l f h s a t I ) o Cli 1 b tg a td t ed fn a t a s c n o p ru t t s e s mmayj g n . ( e f am , u rn e h e e d n s e o d p o tni o e k u r ud me t Se y ECFNo.1 69. 68- ) Re tI r omm e ûndi t tt de e por ec nds ng ha he f ndan s l sfc ton de i i o M a 21, t 'cas ii ai c sons n y 201 a dtrng a s e 4, nd li ubs quentappe l di notde i M uha a ofa pr eced lbe t i e es a, d prve mm d ot t i ry nt r t wih u d e p o e s On e a imae i ca sfe t Le e S (o gtr a mi srtv to t u r c s. c n n t s ls iid o v l ln -e m, d nitaie s grgai ,t obt n arduci i t tca sfc ton t rt prs n' vol ar s gr ton e e ton) o ai e ton n ha lsiiai mde he io s unt y, e egai r duc i se down pr a ,he mus m ee ce t n r quie é s i l ng c e ton t pogr m t t rai e r m nt , nc udi ompl to oft ei n he Cha lnge Se s wo kboo . M uhn mad c le de r ks m omplt d t s s re a wa brefy r cl sfe t e e hi e i s nd s i l e as ii d o Le l 6,t fr t se i ta ii ni f o s r ga e c v ne e t a ge r l populto ve he is tp n r nsto ng r m eg e t d o m nt o ne a ai n s ti I Jme 201 M uhn a i t 'd s ver ldicplna y c r a wa r c a sfe t e tng. n t 3, mm d ncm e e a s i i r ha ges nd s e l s i d o Le lS. By M a 201 c r -r f e g m ont ,M uhn a de a d r duci t Leve ve y 4, ha ge fee or i ht hs mm d m nde e ton o l 6 a n. The I de e m i ton wast de t s r duc i bas d on M uhn ma sf lle t gai CA t r na i o ny hi e ton, e m d' aitr o r do t Cha l ng Se i a t rhi r c a s fc ton t Le lS. M thn m a c ai ed t tt s e e he le e res fe s e l s ii a i o ve l m d lm ha he t pdown polc di notr quie a s ond c pl ton oft Cha l nce Se i a t t hi f iur t iy d e r ec om e i he le res nd ha s a l e o me tt sr quie ntoft vol a y s e down polc c d notbea vai r as t r f e t e hi e r me he unt r tpi y oul ld e on o e us he r duc i fom Le lS. e ton r ve Th p risa r et a t Vigni De a t n o Co r cins(VDOC' p lc rq iig e a t g e h the r i a p rme t f re to û e G ' o iy e u rn ) l r viw ofi t s's gr to sa tse r ni t da c ea e apot nta lbe t i e es i CA e e nma e e egai n t tz ve y ne y ys r t s e i l i ry nt r t n a di ta f rt o r tnton i Le lS a is C e a r e c to ofc i ment' voi ng r nse o, r ee i n, ve nd t t mor dve s ondii ns onfne . ' ( p r 1 a 6 (uoi W i n o v.Ausi, 5 5 U. 20 2 ( 0 :. Th r p r Re o t , t ) q tng l s n ki tn 4 S. 9, 21 20 5 e eot r c me e om nds fndi of f t a c l i ns of 1 w t t M tha mad di not ha a i ngs ac nd oncuso a ha l m d ve c tt to ly pr e t d lbe t i e es i beng r l as t t ge r lpo a i bec us he onsiu i nal ot c e i ry nt r t n i e e ed o he ne a pulton a e di nots w t tt c tons he e re ed i Le lS pr s nt d a y c a sgnii a d ho ha he ondii xpe inc n ve e e e t pi al nd i fc nt . n r ha ds p c r hi ompa e t t ex c e c ndii ofhi prs s nt nce2 Se Sandi v.Conne , r d o he pe t d o tons s ion e e . e 51 U. 4 2 48 - 4 ( 9 5 . I t atmaie t e rp r as fn t tt e p o e u a 5 S. 7 , 3 8 1 9 ) n he le tv , h e o t lo ids ha h r c d rl pr t to M uhn a r eved me c tt i na r quie e s o eci ns mm d ec i t onsiuto l e r m nt. l h so jcins M u a dlr ey rieae agt n sh h sp e iusy rie . Th n i be to , h mma ag l etrts r t t e a r vo l as d e me c tha rvi d,7qnovo,t agu nt a t rco d,a fndsno f t alorlgalbass our s e ewe . . he r me s nd he e r nd i acu e i 3 c di y h hee f rrj cig o a n ig te fn ig a d c n lso s o t e rp r. A c or ngl , t e r o ee tn r me dn h dn s n o cu in f h e o t c u twi o e zet eo j ci n , d p Re r 1 a g a tt d fn a t'sl r j d me t o r l v m l h be to s a o t po t , nd rn he e e d n s l l mmay u g n moton ast Cl i 1 i o am . 2 Ther po tas not t tt efndi a c usonsae c it twihr ce decsonsbyt Hon. e r lo es ha hes i ngs nd oncl i r onssen t e nt ii he Jme P.o e , i dSae Ditit u g i ti dsrc.( pot , t89 (iig, . , p oav VicnaDe t a s J n s Unt tts src J d e n hs itit Re r 1a - ) ct eg.De a l . r ii o' e n o Cor, . 1 CV00 9 201 W L5 5 0 ( . Va S pt28 2 6) f r.No 7:4 6 2, 6 41 9 3 W D. . e . , 01 ). 3I hso j cinb it Mu mma alg sfrtetrtt t t es fr Rtpc lh r s p'i Le e S n i be to re ha d le e o h is i ha h ufes ay ia adhi' n v l me be us he c nnotpa tcpae i p ou r lgi s r i s i vi ai ofhi rghtt fee e cs ofhi r lgius ca e a rii t n p ei ous e vce , n olton s i o r xerie s ei o beif .M uha d ha notmovedt a nd hi pr dur duepr s cam wih t euns n alegains a le s mma s o me s oce al oce s li t hes wor l to , nd tec u t sn j tfcto frs c a a n me t tti lt sa eo teliain.Moe ve, h mma fis h o r Gnd o usiiain o u h n me d n a hs ae tg f h ig to t r o rMu a d al t s t tt i lt t pr ctc gr up worhi whie i Le S i a dif e t n r srci on gr o how ha he nabiiy o a ie o s p l n vel s ny fernt ha e titons oup worhi t t a y durng a ge r popul i i t s t s p ha ppl i neal aton nmae' empor r a sgn e t s e e c meme f a y s i m nt o egrgatd onf nt or ad nitai r as ns. Thus he f l t s a gr mi sr tve e o , ais o how ny ound her on whih t f t tLe S c tonsmee t e c o md ha vel ondii t he aypi lha ds p sa ar unde Sa n s ast gi rs t ac tttonaly pr e e lbery i e es. 51 U. a t ca r hi tnd d r ndi o o ve ie o onsiui l otctd i t ntr t 5 S. t 483 84. - I Re tI :Spola i ofCl m 5Vi o por I i ton ai de l Cl m 5,M tha a al ge t ton J nua y 5,201 De e nt C. s p a JW . n ai l mm d le d ha a r 3, f nda s Biho nd . Coyl f ie t i e v ne whe I a e D e r c Br t he phys c ly a t c e a l d o nt r e n nm t rik a c r i a l ta ked hi a tr t y ha m f e he d be n r las d f r c eai n. M uha a c am e t tBihop a tmpt d t i e v ne butCoyl e ee e or e r to mm d l i d ha s te e o nt r e , e g a d Biho by t m i ta t d hi t ltt beai c i r bbe s p he s nd ol m o e he tng ontnue. Bihop ha de e a s s nid ny it re e e fom Co e. He ha c e d t tBr t he a M uhn a we e sg i a t t n e f r nc r yl s ont nde ha a c r nd mm d r htng nd ha t ofk e s a co di t t i tai ng,wat d t i e ve un i addii na ofi r a ve t he t r , c r ng o her r ni ie o ntr ne tl to l fce s ni d o hep. Ba e on t m a e l diput s be we n t s a oun s t c t de e s l sd he t da s e t e he e cc t , he our ni d umm a y r j d me t u g n. M t a d iiily came t t t re o t as ( c e Hal a M ah na l mma ntal li d ha h e fkil M oue n, l, nd te ) h i e i l de toye s vela e cn r f a oft J nua y 201 i de t hi r li nt ntonaly sr d ur il nc me a oot ge he a r 3 nci nt o nde ls ltga i n e f r s H e s ug t r c r m one a y da a s f om t s i vi ua s a t i pos ii to f o t . o ht o e ove t r m ge r he e ndi d l nd o m e s i ton- s d s nci nso t Cl i 5 de e nt. The c tr f re t e s i to i s s polai ba e a to n he am f nda s our e e r d hes polai n s ue t J o udgeHoppe, whoor e brefng fom t pa tesa c nd t d a e de ir hea i der d i i ' he ri nd o uc e n vi nta y rng. r Re r 1 r fe t t f l ng f c ua fndi r l t t s i ton. Asa r s toft po t 1 e l c s he olowi a t l i ngs e aed o polai e ul he ale c ton wih Br the ,of i sc r d a co c e M uhn mad on a i tt i lc r tr ai t ac r fcal ha ge nd nvit d m n nsiutona ha ge ofsg i As e ry a J nua y a Fe ua y 201 M uha ad as d ofi a st r vi w a htng. a l s a r nd br r 3, mm ke fcil o e e nd pr e ve s v la e c m e a f age oft aler a i wih Br t he . Durng hi a a oft es r ur eil nc a r oot he t c ton t a c r i s ppe l he fg i c r e,t wa de s desg e r vi we s h f age bu f und i i oncl i ast i htng ha g he r n' i ne e e d uc oot , t o t nc usve o M thnm m ad' actons and de ed t appeal I i t di ed t aft t gr e l s i ni he . t s m sput hat er he i vance appeal , uùde ar i pr c ie t r c d ove pa tf t ge a r outne a tc o e or r s oo a boute r ni t da r ga dl s ofi a e ve y ne y ys e r e s nm t r quess f pr e v ton,t J ua y 5,201 f t ge wa r or d o r a l t At t e t or es r ai he an r 3, oo a s ec de ve nd os. he 4 e i n ir h a ig i t sc s , hn dr q e tdta t c u tnsn c t ej r a tilha vde tay e rn n hi a e Mu mma e u se h t he o r i t zt h u y t ra t t i c d i e t tt contnt o t m isngvi o we e a r et t Cl i 5 de e nt . t oul nf r ha he e s f he s i de r dve s o he am f nda s The r por c udes fom t e de t tt misng vi o f t e wa r e ntt e t oncl r he vi nce ha he s i de oo ag s elva o M uha a s Cli 5,a t tofki l ne i nty br a he a dut t pr s r i. Ther por mm d' a m nd ha f as glge l e c d y o e e ve t e t f t r co l ,howe r t t M uhammad has no s pa a e c us of a ton unde f de alo urhe ncudes ve , ha e rt a e ci r e r r sae1w f mo tr da ge agans M coue M ahe ,a Halrlt t s itonoft tt a or nea y ma s i t en, t na nd l eaed o polai he f o a e Th r p r as fnd t a at o g t d fnd n st Cli 5 ( s o a Co l) o tg . e e o t lo i s h t lh u h he ee a t o am Bih p nd y e pe s ly co mit no m ic r ona l m ted s ônduc r lt d t t f iur t r t i t de ie f t e, t e ae o he a l e o e an he sr d oo ag i putton t t e de e nt ofo he ofi i l ne i nts iton i ne es a y t a d unf i m a i o hes f nda s t r fc as' glge pola i s c s r o voi ar p eu iet M u a d. rj dc o h mma Und rRu e 3 ()2 o t Fe rlRue o Ci i Pr c d r ,t c u tma i os e l 7 e( ) f he dea ls f vl o e u e he o r y mp e c ran t e ti ypes of s nci ns ç y upo fndi t t t pa t a t d wih t i t nt t de i a to û onl n i ng ha he ry c e t he n e o prve a he pa t of t i or ai n' us i t ltga i .. ..' The e s c a s nc i f not r ry he nf m to s e n he ii ton ' s pe i l a tons or itni n l s o ito i cu e i osto o Sa p eu to j ta t l s if r to wa n e to a p lain n ld mp iin f G r s mpin h t he o t n o mai n s g u fv r be't t e d fnd ns o ds s a o d fulj d me t L. On te c nr r ,û po n a o a l' o h ee a t, r imis l r ea t u g n . d u s h o tay G n u fn i gp eudc t a ohe p ry fo gù ne to a)l s o t e if r to ,(h c u' ma id n rj ie o n t r a t ' m u i tn in l o s f h n o main t e o l y r q o d rme sze n g e trt a n c sa yt c r t ep eu ie' Ru e3 ()1 . r e a l s o rae h n e e sr o u e h rj d c . l 7 e () r ' Th r p r n tsta Mu mma h sn tb e irpaa l p eu ie b t el s o te e e o t o e h t ha d a o e n re rb y rj d c d y h o s f h vi o f age Evi nc i t r co d i caest tt f agedi noti l a o a cr a e de oot . de e n he e r ndi t ha he oot d nc ude udi nd e t s t ce t i y t t t f a e n s e t de e nt ' c m ra nt ha he oot ge ve how d he f nda s onduc d i M u m m a s t ur ng ha d' at r to wih Br t he . Alhoug t f a m o e lkey s le cai p t a c r t h he oot ge r i l howed M uhn a so c mm d' wn onduc t t s e e e ,he c n pr s n t si ony,i l ng hi o on t s is wihoutt f t e. o om xt nt a e e t e tm nc udi s wn, hi s ue t he oo ag 5 Uli ael t r po tr c tm t y, he e r e omm e t t as a oprae y m e ur d s nc i f r t neglge nds ha , ppr i tl as e a tons o he i nt s i ton oft f a pola i he oot ge, t Cour s ul f bi t Def nda s fo puti o e denc r ltng t t he t ho d or d he e nt r m tng n vi e ea i o he fc of Muha at mmad' dici i c ge a co ci (o t e e s h s s plnmy har s nd nviton t he xtnt uc e ie c wo l oh r s b a misbe o t t e a t a c n e t o t e v d o vd n e u d t e wie e d si l) r o h cu l o tn s f h i e i ef i ldngt e m itn d cso rj cig M u a d' d s iln r a p a . t l, ncu i h te e iin ee tn s h mma s icpi ay p e l I a dto t e Co r s ul i tu ttej r t a a rc r i g o te J n ay 5 n d iin, h u t ho d nsr c h u y h t e od n f h a u r at r a i was made M uhn a r sed t t i be pr s r ed,but i wa le c ton , mm d eque t ha t eev t s s bsq e ty l s tr u h no futo M u a d s a te j r r s o l no u e u nl ot ho g a l f h mma ', nd h u o s h ud t a s me t t t lc o c ro o aig o j cie e ie c t emie su ha he a k f o r b rtn b e tv vd n e md r n s M tha mad' ve so ofe nt s r l m s rin ve s uroundi t Eght ng he . ( p r1 ) Re o t 9. Th d fn a t d n to j c t t e eprpo e sn to s Mu mma as h sma en e ee d n s o o b e t o h s o s d a cin . ha d lo a d o pa t ua ie o j cin t te c re me s o t e f cu lfn i s a d lg lc ncuso ,a ri lrz d b e to o h o rc s f h a ta idng n e a o l ins s c r fe td i te rpo t Gln te a e e o a tmey Gld o j ci n a d stc c u tne d no elce n h e r. 1 ) h bsnc f i l e be to , it t o r e t ( i c onduc a denovo r viw,buti t a mus onl s tsy is l t tt r i no cla e o on t t e e nse d t y a if te f ha he e s e r n'r he f c o t r or i or er t ac e t r omm e ton. Dim ond v. Col al Lie & a e f he ec d n d o c pt he ec nda i ' ' n oni f Ac ie tI s Co, 6F.d 3 0 31 (t Ci. 0 )(n ena q oainmak o te lBa e o cd n n . .41 3 1 , 5 4h r 2 05 itr l u tto r s mitd . s d n t e fndi a c l i ns a fndi no c e re r ,t c twilado t e pori of hos ngs nd oncuso , nd ng l a ror he our l pt hes tons t r po t he e r . As saed,t c tc tu M uha a s s pa a e m oton r a di s la i a a tt he our onsr es mm d' e r t i eg r ng po iton s n o j cin t t erpo q s e i ahas rs l to s n to ,b sd o n wl r ie alg to be to o h e r e kng rhe poi in a cin a e n e y as d le ains a a o tJ h W art ,f r ra ssa twad n a Re Or o ( No 21 . Tl ss b sin, b u o n lah o me sitn r e t d l n. ECF . 3) z u miso i i tte S o i n f r c i a i t r ns a e ' a s pa a e s i ton c a m , sa es t t t il d G t o or e onsder ton o ei t t ' m e r t pola i li t t ha he s iton wa i e i na . Acc di t M uhn a s t wor m o i n,a tr W alah be me pola i s nt nto l or ng o mm d' ms n to fe r t ca wa d n a Ri rNo t Co rcin lCe tr (Rie No t ' h wa alg dy tnniae f r r e t ve rh re to a n e ç v r rh', e s le e l e n td o l ) or rng de t u ton of vi o f t e r l t d t a us of f c a ns a i a e. M uhn m a de i sr c i de oo ag e a e o e or e gai t n nm t m d 6 a s rs t tt ste de e'wara si s e t ha hi svi nc ' r nt mposton ofa ha s r s iton s nc i t n t r por ii r he pola i a ton ha he e t r c me . Howe r M uhn a ofe s no ot r a s i e e de e i s ppor of hi e om nds ve , mm d f r he , dmi sbl vi nc n u t s co l or a s rin t tt s iton a Re Oni wasi e i l M orove ,t c ut i #q ncus y s eto ha he polai t d on ntntona. e r he ot n . . novo r vi w of t r por a t r o d, doe not fnd a f t l or lgal ba i f r t s e e he e t nd he ec r s s ny ac ua e ss o hi c n e to Ac o dngy t c u twilo e zeM u a d' o j ci n a o tt erpo t a o tnin. c r i l , he o r l v m l h mma s b e to , d p h e r, nd i pos t r om m e d s i ton s nc i a t ti lon Cl i 5. m e he ec nde pola i a tons t he r a am M uha a as s e t pur ue a s pa a e cli f da mm d lo e ks o s e r t am or mage agans M a he s i t t na, M c e and W alah,ba e on t algai t tt s dee nt i e i ly de toyed oue n, rt s d he le ton ha he e fnda s ntntonal sr vi o f t ge a Red Oni n i 201 The r po tfndsno lga ba i unde f de a o sat 1 w de oo a t o n 3. e r e l ss r e rl r t e a f a s pa a e s iton cli a i t ofi a s who f ld t pr s r e de or e r t pola i am gans fcil aie o e e ve vi nce. Se e. , e, g. Sle tiv.Ge M oo sCo .271F.d 5 3 5 0 (t Ci.20 )(G ) iet e s l to o i sr v n. t r p , 3 8 , 9 4 h r 01 CW h1 h poi in f ( a e de e m a gi rs t co ti vi nc y ve ie o ur mpos s nci ns ...t a t ofs i ton do nott ms l s ed a to he c s pola i he eve gv rs i cvi c s st s bsa tv camso d fn e .) Ba sv. I Du n d Ne t s& ie ie n i l a e o u tnie li r ee s s' ; s E.. po t e mo t ' r Co. 28 F.Ap x 2 1 20 (t Ci.2 2 (G r ii d e no r c g ie a tr b s d o , p' 0 , 6 4 h r 00 ) t gn a o s t e o nz vi ot ae n s lain o e i e c .)(iain o te ) Ac o dngy t c u tmu td n Mu mma s poito f v d n e' ctto mitd . c r i l, he o r s e y ha d' ' mo in( No 21 )a ftl. to ECF . 3 s uie Fial,M u n d ha mo e f rj g n a amatro lw o Cli 5 ( No n ly h mma s v d o ud me t s te f a n am ECF . 21 ) Be a s mae ilfc lds u e rmana is ef rtil nt scam, we r tec u t 0 . c u e tra a ma ip ts e i t su o ra o hi li ho ve,h o r mus de t sm o i t ny hi ton. . 7 ' C onc us on l i Fo t e sae ra o s te c ur wi o er l M u a d s o j cin , a o t te r h ttd e s n , h o t l v ru e h mma ' be to s d p h l ma itaej d esrp rs g a ts mmayj d me tf rt e d fn a t o Cli 1 a d a t gsrt u g ' e o t, r n u r u g n o h ee d n s n am , n t he ti l of Cl i 5,wil i ra am l mpos t r co m e d s nc i f r s iton of e de e. An e he e m nde a tons o pola i vi nc a oprae or rwilis t i da ppr i t de l s ue l s y. z ENTER:Thi /1 d yo Jn ay 2017. s a f a u r, # Chi f e 8 ie St t Diti tJ td aes src udge

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?