Muhammad v. Commonwealth Of Virginia et al

Filing 217

ORDER granting 175 Motion for Summary Judgment; adopting 207 Report and Recommendations; adopting 208 Report and Recommendations; denying 210 Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law; denying 213 Motion for Reconsideration; the clerk sha ll SCHEDULE this matter for a trial before a seven-member advisory jury as to Claim 5 and the defendants are PROHIBITED from putting on specific evidence as directed within this order. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 1/27/2017. (tvt)

cl RKS OF I E U.. S COUc '
P ' F C S DIX
AT ROANOKE,
VA
F?
LED

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STR I T C O U RT
C
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STR I T O F W R G I A
C
NI
RO AN O K E DI SI N
W O
A BDU L. A M ZA W A LI M UH AM M A D ,
H

J 2? 2 1
A.
27
J AC 0
ULI
SY:

C

CA SE N O .7: 4CV 00529
1

Pl ntf
ai if,
O RD ER

V.

RANDALL CI ARLES M ATH ENA,
I
By: G l n E.C onr
e
ad
C hi fU nied St e Di t i Judge
e
t
at s s r ct

W K ,
D efendant
s.

I ac or nc wih t ac ompa ng m e a um opi on,i i he e
n c da e t he c
nyi
mor nd
ni t s r by
AD TUD G ED A N D O R DER ED
asf l s
olow :

Afe t co tsétnovor viw oft petne po tonsoft rpor a t r or t
tr he ur'
ee
he ri nt ri
he e t nd he ec d,he
p an ifso j ci n t t erp r a r c mme d to o s l to ( No. 0 )a d
litf be to s o h e o t nd e o n ain n poi in ECF 2 7 n
a
t rpo t ndrc mme ain o Cli 1( No. 0 )a eOVERRULED, n boh
he e r a e o nd to n am ECF
28 r
ad t
r por s a e A D O PTED ;
e t r

Thepanifsp n i gmoi n frj d me ta ama tro lw a t Cli 5 ( No.
li tf e d n to o u g n s te f a s o am ECF
21 )a dhi mo in s e igt p ru aspaaes o ito cam frd ma e ( No
0 n s to e kn o u s e e rt p lain li o n g s ECF .
21 )aeDENI a wih u mei;
3 r
ED s t o t rt
3.

Thed fn a t's p e na moin f rsl r j d me to Cli 1( No.1 5
e e d n s u plme tl to o l
mmay u g n n am ECF
7)
i GR ANTED,a t c e k s lTERM I
s
nd he l r hal
NATE t f l wi de e nt aspa te t
he olo ng f nda s
ris o
t s l w s t M a he Da a K e e
hi a ui: t na, y, nd gl y;

4.

Th cek s alS
e lr h l CHEDULE ti ma trf rtilb f r asve - mb ra v s r j r a
h s te o ra eo e e nme e d io y u y t
t c ts e ri s c
he our' a le t onve e , a t Cl i 5, alegi t t on J nua y 5, 201
nince s o am
l ng ha
a r
3,
def nda s Co e and Bihop f l t i e ve t pr e t t pl ntf fom a he
e nt yl
s
aied o ntr ne o ot c he ai if r
not r
i a e' physc la s uls a
nm t s
i a s a t ; nd

5.

Bas on ûndi a co l i t tpr s of i l ne i nty a l e s i t o of
ed
ngs nd nc us ons ha i on /c a s glge l low d pola i n
ce ti vi o f t r e nt t pli ifs Cl i 5,t de e nt t t tc am a e
ra n de oo age elva o antf
am
he f nda s o ha l i r

s be tt t f lo n sncinsa til ()t e d fnd n sa ePROHI TED fo
u j c o he o lwig a to t ra : a h ee a t r
BI
rm
puti on e de e r ga di t pl ntf s di cplna y c r s o c ci n a ii
tng
vi nc e r ng he ai if s i i r ha ge r onvi to rsng

fom t J r r 5,201 i ient(o t e e s h e de e wo d ot r s be
r he ama y
3, ncd t he xtnt uc vi nc ul he wie
a misbl) ort t a t lcontnt oft vi f a is l,i udi t m itn
d si e, o he cua
e s he deo ootge tef ncl ng he te
d cso rj ci t p an ifsd si ln r a p a;a d ( t c u tS
e iin ee t he litf icpi ay p e l n b) he o r HALL isnzt
ng
nt c
t ej r t t r c r i o t eJ n r 5atrain wa ma e t panifrq e tdt a
h u y ha a e o dng f h a uay lec to s d ,he litf e u se h t

'

i be pr e v but i was s e ue l l tt oug no ful of t pli if a t
t
es r ed,
t
ubs q nty os hr h
a t he antf, nd he

jlo ss o l n ta s met ttelc o c ro o aigo j ciee d n eu d r n st e
t r h ud o su ha h a k f o r b rtn b e tv vie c n emie h
r
pl i ifsver i ofe nt s r
antf
son ve s uroundi t fgh .
ng he i t
The Cl r i diece t s nd c e oft s or r a t ac
e k s r t d o e opi s hi de nd he compa ng m e a l
nyi
mor ndtm
opi on t J
ni o udgeHoppe, o M uhn a a t couns lofr or f rde e nt.
t
mm d, nd o
e
ec d o f nda s

ENTER:Ths $1 d yo Jn ay 2 7.
i
a f a u r, 01

ChifUnie St t sDititJ
e
d a e src udge

2