Hubbert v. Washington et al

Filing 76

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 3/22/2017. (slt)

CL SOFFI U.S. SX COUR)
ERK'
CE
Df
ATROANOG ,VA
FI
LED

MA2 22 2 1
27
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STR I T O F V I GI I
C
R N A
R O A N O K E DI I O N
V SI

JuLA ce DL
I DU EY LE K
BK
A'DE
c

Ci lA c i N o. 14 c 005
vi ton
7: - v- 30

H ASSI H UBBERT,
N
Pl ntf ,
ai if

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
G . .W ASHI
K
NGTON,e al,
t .
D ef
endant
s.

By:

H on. i hae F.U r
M c l
bans
ki
U nied St e D i t i tJudge
t
at s s r c

Ha sn Hubbe t aVigi ai t pr e ng pr K ,fl acvi rg sc
si
r, r ni nma e oc edi
o
ied i l i ht ompl i
ant

p ru n t 4 U. C. 1 3 n migc re ta df r rsafo t eVigni De a t n o
u s a t o 2 S. j 98 , a n u rn n o me tf f h r i a p rme t f
Co r cins(û
re to t
VDOC' a dRe Ono SaePrs n(Re Ono ' a d fn a t.Plitf
' n d in tt io ç d in' s e e d n s anif
)
ç
)
c
ompli t thi cas ii ai a i ar e a i a Se urt Le lS i Re Oni be wee
a ns ha s l sfc ton nd nc c r ton t c iy ve n d on t n
Augus 201 a Oc o r201 vi ae t Ei ht a Fo te h Am e
t 3 nd t be
4 ol td he g h nd ure nt
ndme soft Unie
nt
he t d
Stt sConsiuton.Pr vi usy, hec tha gr nt De e nt fr tm o i f s
ae
tt i
e o l t our d a ed f nda s' is ton or umm a y
r

j d me ti p r a t teEihhAme d n cam, e idia t t eFo re nhAme d n
u g n n at s o h g t
n me t li d n e t s o h u te t
n me t
pr dur ld pr es c am ,a r quie a tona brei a e bis De e nt ha
oce a ue oc s l i nd e r d ddii l i fng nd xhi t . f nda s ve

fldas c n mo inf rsl r u g n wihter q se e hiis t wh c Plitf
ie e o d to o l
mmayj d me t t h e ue td x bt, o ih anif
rs
e ponded, a ng t sm at rrpef diposto Afe r viwi t e nde r co d,
m ki hi te i or s ii n. tr e e ng he xpa d e r

i ld n t es ae r c r s t ec u t r nsDee d h s jt n moinf rs mmayj d me t
ncu i g h e ld e o d ,h o r g a t fn a t' t o d tp o u r u g n .
f
1.

Thepr e la hit r o Pl i ifsc i me a Ke n M ot an Core tona Ce t r
oc dtr l so y f antf' onfne nt t e
mt i
rci l ne

(C CC' a Re Oni aedealdi t c tsprorme a um opi o a ii
ç
KM ' nd d on r tie n he our' i mornd
I
pin, nd t s
unne s a y t r pea t ti or a i he e. I t ad,t c r de c i st r v nti i nt of
ce s r o e t ha nf m ton r ns e he ou t s rbe he el va nc de s

pls lf e t d f a i aecl sse a Le lS i Red Oni n a f whi h Pli if
i on ie xpece or n nm t as i d t ve n
o nd or c antf
co

m m e d t s a ton.
nce hi c i 1

Red Oni n' Leve S i aesm a bedesg t d i oneoft ma n c t gore :l t nsve
o s
l nm t
y
i nae n
wo i a e i s n e i

M a a e n (ç ' o S e il na e n (G '. F o temo t olatrsrci s cliy
n g me t çM ' r p ca Ma g me t t ' 2 r m h s t e s e tit e t t
1 )
SM )
ve r
cls ii tons I i aesa ede i t d a 1 - I - ,I - a I a sfcai , M nm t r sgna e s M 0, M 1 M 2, nd M SL6,a SM i m a e
nd
n ts

ar de i t asSM - , SM -1,and SM - 3 SM - i ae m a ber duc t Le l6'
e sgnaed
O
2 nm ts y e ed o ve s
2.
Stuc u e Li ngPhas 1 a t n t Phas 2. Gr dua i fom Phas 2 m a st i t
r t r d vi
e nd he o
e
a ton r
e
ke he nma e
elgi et bea sgne t Le 5 a hous d i a g r lpo a i uni.Pl i ifwa
i bl o
s i d o vel nd
e n ene a pulton t antf s
desgna e a I f a oxi ae yt e m o hsa a SM f a oxi t l elve m ont .
i t d s M or ppr m tl hr e nt nd s
or ppr ma ey e n
hs
W he i aesexhi tpostvebe vi r a s ce s u l c
n nm t
bi ii
ha o s nd uc s f ly ompl t e t bls d goa s
ee sa ihe
l,
t y a er wa de wih mor prviege vi ar ton i t rs c iy c a sfc tons A1 Le l
he r e r d t
e i l s a educ i n hei e urt l s ii a i . 1 ve
S i a e ar gi t oppor uniy t pa tc pa e i t E le Se i s ' a goa - i t d,
nm t s e ven he
t t o ri i t n he t l nge r e ,'
cha
loren e
lLevelS i notas or d s c iy lve bu i as ci pur ebedasinment Re Oni i t onl
s
c e e urt e l t s pe al pos
sg
.
d on s he y
V DOC f ciiyt thous sLe S i a e .
a lt ha
e vel nm t s
2I i ae a et ei ae
M nm ts r hos nm ts:

g lt te p tnilfr e te a do d a l voe c l ( he ma ha e a
W i h oe ta o x me n /r e dy iln e. Tj y y v n
h
q
isiuin l du t n hso yidc t gtecp blyfre te /e dyvoe c
n ttt a aj sme t itr n iai h a a it o xrmed a l iln e
o
n
i
a i tsa for oherofe r . Thi gr mos oRen woul have an e e i
gans tf
t
f nde s
s oup
t
d
xtnsve
c i nalhitr and lfsyl t tha es aed s t text / dl vi e has
rmi
so y
ie t e ha s calt o ha mmedea y olnce
be ome abe vi a c r trsi. Thepo e talf e te o dea y vi e e i
c
ha or l ha ace itc
t n i or xr me r dl olnc s

n t ei n td depi te ofn rs d i isiuina aj sme t e e wh n
o l ae s t h fe de' al nttto l dut n v n e
mi
e
y
pr di mor t n a ye or c
ovi ng
e ha
ar
omplant polt , a coope ai be o a
i , ie nd
r tve havir nd
atmde. Ale i l t ofe r ma pr s nt a r i l dir ptve a
ti
tnptvey, he f nde
y ee
outney s u i nd
t e tni paterofbe vi and att de. Alo i l sofe si arert f
hr ae ng t
ha or
tiu
s ncude fnder nc c aed or
anooro c i t tput t a rs 9om ohe ofe r
t ius rme ha s hem t ik
t r fndes.
SM i tsa et ei ts:
nmae r hos nmae
'

( h ma ds lya i ttto a a j t n hsoyi iaigrpetddsu tv
Wlo y ipa n nsiuin l dusme t itr ndc tn e ae irp ie

beha oratl
vi
owerlvelfciii ,ahit y oftg i wih saforofbnde s a /
e a ltes sor
i htng t t f
l r , ndor

viln dsu t ebhvira lwe lv laiie,ahsoyo f tn wihsafo
oet irpi ea o to r ee fclis itr fkhij t tf r
v
t

ofe r ,a orvi e r ssanc t r asaf i e v in r s tng i ha m t
f nde s nd/ olnt e it e owa ds t f ntr ento e ull n r o
saf ot rofbnde swihoutt i e t i
tf, he t r t
he ntnt o nvokesrousha m ort i e t kil or
ei
r
he ntnt o l,
s rous dam a t t f iiy,and whe e r a onabl i e v i a t lw e
ei
ge o he aclt
r es
e ntr entons t he o r
s ctrt l elhaveno be n s e s u i ei i tng dir i beha or.
e tiy ev
t e ucc s f l n lm na i suptve
vi s
3l aesi 1 - o SM - c eno t parii t i t se down p ogr orc i t e bi
nm t n M 0 r
O hoos t o tcpae n he tpr am
ontnue o xhi t
i ppr it be vir Cons quenty,he do no be i fo t se downpr a nga i t a r evet
na oprae ha o .
e
l t y
t neft r m he tpogrmmi nd nse d ec i he
bascr quie ensa f dedt i aesi VD OC s cilhousngunis
i e rm t for o nm t n
pe a
i
t.

2

i e i - ed s r ga i housng pln f i t st s dy pr s a goa svi s ve
nc ntve bas eg e ton
i a or nma e o m
o-ocil l a e n
wor
kbooks A m ulidicplna y gr ofsa fwho wo k i t housng uni c l t Uni
.
t- s i i r oup t f
r n he
i
t aled he t
M a e e Te tac a r t se c Le lS i t swe kl pe f
nag m nt am r ks nd a e a h ve nma e' e y ronna e f rt ngslke
nc o hi i
pe s na hygi ne r s t a sa ng f c mta a hivabl pr es t r t ne l
ro l
e , e pec, nd t ndi or ot s c e e ogr s owa d he xt ower
s l iy lve . Cot eor a s r t e h i ae' pa tcpai n asi ompl t postvee f r,or
ecz t e l
r
ms l s lo a e ac nm t s rii to
nc
ee, ii fo t
compl e. St f i bot g o s d c muni t t r tngst i aes a kno e postve
et
a f n h r ups houl om
cae he a i o nm t s c wl dge ii
pero nce a m o i t i t sf ri ove e . A n I orSM i aewho doe no
f nna , nd tvae nma e o mpr m nt4
M
nm t
s t
s ts y pr n crt raata tme c n bede e a t t p down't al
a if ogr m ie i
ny i a
nid ç e
s
'o owerc a sfc ton or
l s ii a i
!

r tu
e t med t a hi he c a s tc ton l ve .
o
g r l s ii a i e l

Durngt tmer lva t t sc e m aeLe lS i a e we epe ted n l e ous
i he i ee nt o hi as , l ve nm t s r nnit lm r

peronalpr ry:s s clt ng' ddi t wel'at t us ac e r ape a a es
s
ope t hoe ; o hi ,
be ng; o s oo hbr h; alnda ; n; n ddr s
,
book;a oxi ael f t frtc a ssn ; ea ng ma e i l r a ng gls e 'ar di a a o
ppr m t y ory is- l s t mps r di
t ra ' e di
,
a s s a o; n udi
,
plye 5 ba tre 'c
a r . te i s omb;har us s vi r z ; t h;we ngba , e gl s s pr c i d
ibr h; ha ng a or wa c
ddi
nd' ye as e ' es rbe
,
,
,
m e c liems a r i i ie s6 Le 1S i a e a er sr i d i ha ufsa s c es
di a t ; nd elg ous t m . ve nm t s r e ta ne n ndc f nd ha kl ,
ar srp s r he and a e e core by s ve a ofi r whe
e ti ea c d,
r s td
e r l fce s neve t y la t rc l
r he e ve hei els.
I a SM i aesa e a f de sm ia prviege .Al I i a e ha t f l ng
M nd
nm t r for d i lr i l s 1 M nm t s d he olowi
m i m um prviege ' wo lbr r boo pe we k;r lgi a l lm ae il i t c l
ni
i l s t i a y ks r e ei ous nd ega tra s n he el;
.
commis r e a i a r lgi ust lvii n pr gr msdiplyed o apod wal ar di a
s a y; duc tonal nd ei o ee so o n
s a
n
l; a o; n

4I a to t t Uni M a ge ntTe swee ypr e rtngs t I tt ina Cls ikai
am'
kl ogrss ai , he nsiuto l a st ton
n ddiin o he t na me

Auh rt (I 'ruieyrve alsge ainimae a po i tl e eynn t da s Th 1 rve a d
to i $CA' o tn l e iws l e rg t n ts p rxmaey v r iey y . e CA e iws n
yç )
o
acsonr comme tonsf se i r as orr to ,a a1casiiaton de sonsm a bea al t ough
t
e
ndai or tp nc e es educins nd 1 l sfc i cii
y ppe ed hr
t Ofe rGre nc Pr edt e.
he
nde iva e oc l
r
5TheVDO C c l i aN P4 'a i woul m or c
als t
' nd t
d e omm onl beknown a a m p3 plye .
y
sn
a r
6Acc s t s epes 1pr t i pr bie whe a i emovesfom Leve 5t Leve S. Fo
n n nmat
r
l o
l
e s o om
rona opery s ohi td
r
e
xampl t Le S i ema no lnge pos e saphot al
e, he vel nmat y o r s s
o bum,abel,at hbr h ca e handkechif,tnni
t oot us s ,
r es e s
s s ac c aor s ases boa dgames pl ng c r ,a ac f emug.The eiemswoul besor untlt
hoe , alult , ungl s , r
, ayi a ds nd ofe
s t
d t ed i he
i aewass ntt al e lvelfciiy.
nm t
e o ow r e a lt

a o plye ;i vi i c lco r c i lpr ams t hour ofo sde r cr a i n pe we k'
udi a r ndi dual n- el r t tona ogr ; wo
s ut i 1 e e to r e ,
t t nt - i ephonec l perm ont t e s
wo we y m nut
als
h; hr e howe sperwee ald anon- ont c vii f
r
k; z
c a t st or
one ho pe w e k. I a e i I l ve sl s r s r c i t n I - r c ve g e t rc e or
ur r e 8 nm t s n M e l e s e ti tve ha M O e ei r a e ont nt

feq nc oft prvie lkem o elbr yboo pe wee a mor a ce sa vare y ofi
r ue y he i lges i
r i ar
ks r k nd e c s nd it
n-

c ltlvso p ogn .I - a dI - imae ma h v o , ndnoa l 1 - a S el ee iin r rms M 2 n M SL6 n ts y a ej bs a tby,M 2 nd M 2
i t sma r c i c r to lpr r m mi i g o ofup t 5vei a e .Pe polc I
nma e y e e ve orec ina og n ng n r ups
o
nm t s r iy, M
a SM i t sr c i t s met pe ofm e sa s r edt t g ne al
nd
nma e e e ve he n y s
al s e v o he e r populton, I a
a i but M nd
SM i aese tt i m e l al i t i cel .
nm t a her a s one n her ls
An i a e scas ii ton i r duc f o Le S t Le 6 St cur d Li ng whe
nm t ' l sfcai s e ed r m vel o vel nlt e vi
n
sa fde e mi sa SM - i t hass tsa t iy c
t f t r ne n
2 nma e
aif c orl ompl td t Cha lnge Se isc rc lm
ee he le
re uri ull
a a hi vedt be vi algoa sofSM - Thepur e ofLe 6 Stucur d Li ng i t
nd c e
he ha or
l
2.
pos
vel r t e vi s o
r i r uc i a e i o a s i le r
entod e nm t s nt oc a nvionme a t t s t i r adi s f rpos i eta f rt
nt nd o e t her e ne s o
sbl r nse o
t ge r lpo a i a Le 5. Phas 1i t sa esng ec l a ea l d t e tac l
he ne a pulton t vel
e nma e r i l eled, r lowe o xi el
a e e t pod i vi ly,a eunr sr i d durng s
nd nt r he
ndi dua l r
e tane
i howe sa r cr a i ha i vi ua
r nd e e ton, ve ndi d l

a dg o pte a y e j yo tier ce to t h u spe we k ma lse t a i b o s a
n r u h r p , n o usd e rain wo o r r e , y itn o udo o k , nd
wak asagr up t t di ng hal t ea gr mea s Pha e2 i aesha t s m eprvie
l
o o he ni
l o t oup
l . s nm t
ve he n
i lges
a Phas 1buta ehous d wih a c lm a e
s
e
r
e t el t .
Pl i ifc
antf ompli t tLe lS i a e tc t ntyt ow f c a t g r a s e ri
a ns ha ve nm t s ionsa l hr e es t he ua d nd m a t

a1o e tewal ndt erc ls. .g k c a db n o t ed o al a a nih g a fo d
l v r h l a h i el . ., ik n a g n h o r l d y nd g t; nd l o
j
t i c lswhe t y don' g twha t y wa .... Pl ntf as c
her e l
n he
te
t he
nt ' ai if lo ompl i t t f l wi
'
ans hat he olo ng
1I we t rdoe notal f ousder r ton, r r to oc si t pod.
f ahe
s
low or ti eceai eceain cur n he
BSM i tsa i e atLeve 6 Stu ur d Li ng Phas s1a 2 aege r ly a f dedt s me
nmae nd nmats
l r ct e vi
e nd r ne al for he a
ûm i m um 'prviege a I i ae ,bu SM i aesa egr ntd m o eprviege quike ast y t tp down'
t ni
' i l s s M nm ts t
nm t r a e
r i l s c r he i e
s
'

s czi lv l.Fo e a e S imae h v erirac s t j bsa daep l te moevstt na dmoe
e l t e es r x mpl, M n ts a e al c es o o n r en td r ii i n r
ry
e
ni
ao
pho c l.
ne als

c tons' hi s g e ton we em o e r src i t n co to e re e by i aesi
ondii of s e r ga i
r r e titve ha ndii ns xpe inc d nm t n

g r populton durnghi a oxi ae420da 9sa a Le S:hec d no buy a muc
ene al
ai
i
s ppr m t
y t y t vel
oul t
s
h
fo t c
r m he omm is y;hewasde i d ofpe s na pr ry lke at e son,aJ 4 pe s
s ar
prve
r o l ope t i
elvii
P- r onal

a d op a e, e d h n s s a e s lngj h s a szg p oe tr ; e r e alwe rt o
u i ly r h a p o e , ne k r, o o n , nd l e r tco s he a n d o r ae f
r
good c
onduc tme; sc l doorwa consr td wih mor m ea ;twa no a e y t
t i hi e l
s
tuce t
e tl i s t s as o
c
omm uni t wih ot i t s' no l rha outo - l r c e ton up t tvehotsawe k;
cae t her nma e ,
he onge d - fcel e r a i
oi
tr
e
hi outi r c eai waslmie t af nc i a e wih ba be wie;he c d s
s sde e r ton
i td o e ed n r a t r d r
oul howe onl
r y
tteetme awe k;hea ehi m e l al i hi cel hewa e c td and wo es c iy
lr i s
e
t s a s one n s l;
s s ore
r e urt
r sr nt whie movi i i t prs n;hi c l wa s a c d m o e ofe hewa srp s a c d
e tai s l
ng nsde he io s e l s e r he
r tn;
s ti e r he
mor o tn; sc
e fe hi ommt c tonswe et
mia i
r ç rs ve la e'c t nty;viiai wasnonunde ur il nc ' onsa l st ton
c a t a he c d notpa tcpa ei g oup ed ai lorr lgi usc a s .1
ont c ; nd
oul
ri i t n r
uc tona
e i o l s es 0
I.
I

Dee d nsag et t h yaee t ldt q lfe i miya ds mma yj d me t
fn a t r u ha t e r ni e o uai d mml t n u r u g n .
t
Qu lfe i ni p r t ç o e n n ofcaspefr ngd sr to r f n to s. . t b )
ai d mmu t e mis t v r me t f il ro mi ic einay n ci n . (o e
y
g
s e de fom la lt f cvi dn a si of rast rc
hil d r ibiiy or i l m ge ns a
hei onduc doe no vi a ecea l
t s t olt l ry
e tbls d saut r orconsiutona rght ofwhi h ar as na epe s woul ha 1 0 1'1
sa ihe t t o y
tt i l i s
c e o bl r on
d ve *1w1. 1
'

9Pl ntf algeshes nt425da i s gr gai , a deenda sa ri was41 da .Thedifr ncei
ai if le
pe
ys n e e ton nd f nt ve t
5 ys
fe e s
lkel depe ntont da s nti i tga o ydetnton beor Pl ntf wa ta f re t Re Oni
i y
nde
he ys pe n nvesi t r e i f e ai if s rns er d o d on.
Ne t es,t tn da dif enc i notmaera.
verhel s he e y fer e s
t il
1 Alho Plitf compl nsge r l abou bei srppeds arhe mor ohe a no ha nggr p
0 t ugh anif
ai ne aly
t ng ti
e c d e n nd t vi ou
r i ouss r c asac eque ofhi cl sfc ton,hedoe notc lnget econdii i pe nty. See
elgi e vies
ons nce
s as iiai
s
hale hes
tons nde nde l
.

eg, Lo ev Esaeo S a z , 8 U. 3 2, 484 ( 9 7 ; lv W ofs , 4lU.. 2 , 5 (9 9; e as
..O' n . tt f h ba z 4 2 S. 4 3 - 9 1 8 ) Bel . l h 4 S 5 0 5 9 1 7 )s e lo
S e v SC. p'o Co . 5 9F.d8 4, 6 -2(t Ci. 9 5 (nb nc (ic sigrao a l a dlgimae
we t . . De t f n. 2 2 5 8 0 6 4h r 1 7 ) e a ) dsu sn e s n be n e t t
,
i
pe oo ia i eet t pe ld go prl iu sr ie frimae i s ge ain .Th c u t oe ta rc r
n lgc lntrss o rcu e ru ei o s evcs o n ts n e r g t ) e o rn ts h t e od
g
o
doe notr fe tapolc t tr uie srp s r he mo eofe ofLeve S i t ort tLe S i e ar
s
e lc
iy ha eq r s ti ea c s r tn
l nmaes ha vel nmats e
te t difr nty i t sr ga dt n i e i l rs cu iyclssfcains
r aed fe e l n hi e r ha nmats n owe e rt a ii to .
l Ri sma bet ea l e tbls d's fce t ovecomeadefndantscli ofquaiid i muniy i a
1 ght y ç ry sa ihe ' ufiint o r
cl
e
' am
lfe nz t f
fge r c tt tonalr ear a ientte i t de iina 1w ma a ywih obviusclrt t t s cik
t ne al onsiu i
ul le dy d ii d n he cso l a
y ppl t
o a iy o he pe f

c n u ti q eto , v nto g tev r ato i q e t nh s(oq rvo syb e h l u lwfl.' Untd
o d c n u sin e e h u h h ey cin n u si a n tp e iu l e n ed na ul ' ie
o
l
Sae v La ir 5 0U.. 5 , 71( 9 7 Unen l u tto mak o te ) I eiin llw'frti c s rfr
tts . ne, 2 S 2 9 2 1 9 ) tr a q oain r s mitd . r cso a a 'o hs a e ees
5

Hal w v. iz e ad, 7U. 8 0 81 ( 9 2 ; nr Al n,1 6F.d58 5 3 (t Ci.1 9 )
ro Ft g r l 45 S. 0 , 8 1 8 ) I e l 0 3 2, 9 4h r 9 7
e
( g no fca ma cam q lfe i nt a ln a hsa to saen tce rye tbih dt
çAj fiil y li uaiid mmu iy s o g s i cin r o lal sa ls e o
:
bebe
yondt boundaisofhi dicei r a ho iy. Onc adee ntr s t quaii
he
re
s s rtonay ut rt '
). e fnda aies he lfed
i uniy de e e apl i ifbe st bur n t s
mm t f ns , a ntf ar he de o how t tade e an ' c
ha
f nd ts onduc vi atd t
t ol e he

plitf rg t Br a t Muh, 9 F.d 1 8 ,1 8 (t Ci. 9 3 .
anifs ih . y n v. t 9 4 2 0 2 0 6 4h r 1 9 )

A pat i e tte t s mmayj dg n i t epe dng ,h d s o eya d ds ls r
ry s n ild o u r u me tf h la i s t e ic v r n ico u e
ma e i son fl ,a a a fda t s w t tt r i no ge ne diput ast a ma e i f c .
t ral
ie nd ny fi vis ho ha he e s
nui s e o ny t ral a t

F d R. v. 5 () s eW ila v. iin 9 2F.d 8 0, 2 ( t Ci.1 91 (e o n znga
e . Ci P. 6 a ; e l ms Grf , 5 2 2 8 3 4h r 9 ) rc g ii
i
pa t i e tte t sl r u g n i ter c r a awh l c udn t e darto lre o
ry s nild o l
mma yj d me t f h e o d s oe o l o la aina tir f
fc t fndi fv ro t en n mo a t.t ae il a t'a et o efcsn c sayt etb ih
a t o i n a o f h o - v n ) ç tra f cs' r h s a t e e sr o sa ls
M
t elm e sofapa t sc us ofa ton. Ande s v. be t Lo
he e nt
ry' a e ci
r on Li ry bby.l . 477 U. 242,248
nc,
S.

( 9 6 .A g n ieds u eo mae il a t xit i,nv e n t er c r a da1 e s n bl
1 8 ) e un ip t f tra f c e ss f i iwig h e o d n lr ao a e
i e e esd a t r f o i alghtm os f vor bl t t no m ovi pa t a r as bl f ct
nfr nc r wn he e r m n i
t a a e o he nng ry, e ona e a -

fnde c dr tm aver c f t nonr oul etz
l
dit or he movant J.Themovi pa t ha t bur n of
.J=
ng ry s he de
s
howi - tha i,poi i outt t dit tc t- t tt ei a a e eofe de et
ng ' t s ntng
t
o he sdc our ha her s n bs nc
vi nc o

s p o then n v n pa t sc s . Ceo e Co v Cart 4 7U. 31 , 25( 9 6 .I t
u p r t o mo i g ry' a e' ltx p. . tet 7 S. 7 3 1 8 ) f he
'
movants tsi st sbur n, he t no m ova mus s tf t s c fcf t t tde o tae
a ife hi de t n he nnt t e orh pe ii ac s ha m nsr t

t exitnc ofage nedipueoffc f til L-a 322- A c tma notrs ve
he se e
nui s t a t or ra. ds t 24. our y
u
e ol
diput f c s we g t e de ,orma dee m i tonsofc e biiy. Rus el v. ir
s ed a t, i h he vi nce
ke t r na i
r di lt
s l M c odyne

Cor ,65F. 1 1 ( hCi.1 ;Sos be v. umhv,797F. 1 1 (t Ci.
p.
3d 229, 239 4t r 995) e e M
2d 79, 82 4h r
1 ) I ta ac tac e sa t et e de eoft non- ngparya r s ve a1
986 . nse d, our c pt s nl he vi nc he movi
t nd eol s 1
t de sonsoft Unie St e Supr Cour,Fou t Cic tCou tofAppe l,a Vigi aSupr Cour
o cii
he td ats
eme
t rh r ui r
as nd r ni
eme
t

is e b fr terlv n t .Ed rsv. t o Godboo l 8F.d2 , 51(t Ci.1 9 ) De iin 9o
su d eoe h ee a ti
me wad Ciy f ls r , 7 3 31 2 4h r 9 9. cso s m

UniedSttsDiti Coursar notperi n t ' ea l e tbls d'a yss I
t ae srct
t e
tne t he ' ry sa ihe ' nal i. d.
cl

6

i e na c nfit a i e e esi t non- o ngpa t sf vor Cha bonnace deFr nc v.
ntr l o lcs nd nf r nc n he
m vi
ry' a . r
s
a e

smi 5 7F.d4 6 41 ( t Ci.1 7 ) A p an ifc n o u ears n et amoinf r
t 9 2 0 , 4 4h r 9 9 . litf n n t s epo s o
h,
to o

sl r u g n t a n o c re t c mpan c le e b temoin frs mmay
lmmayj d me t o me d r o rc a o lit halng d y h to o u r
j d me t Cla ig rv. c vt, 5 F.d3 4, 3 (t Ci. 0 9 .
u g n . o nn e M De it5 5 3 2 3 6 4 h r 2 0 )
1
11.

Ther m ani c am be or t c t once swhe he Pl ntf sc i m e i Red
e i ng l i f e he our c
nz
t r ai if' onfne nt n
Oni n a Le lS vi a e pr edu a duepr s gua antedbyt Fouree h Ame e .
o t ve
olt d oc r l
oce s r e
he
t nt
ndm nt
Thecou tfndst ti di notand a dst De e nt qualfed i muniy and s
r i ha t d
war he f nda s
ii m
t
umm a y
r
'

J
udgm e .
nt

TheDuePr es Cl e o t Fo te h Am e
oc s aus f he ure nt
ndme pr bisasa efom de
nt ohi t t t '
r
pdvi
ng
' ny pe s oflf ,lbe t o pr pery wihoutduepr e soflw.'U. Co t a nd. V,
f
a
r on ie i ry, r o t t
oc s
a ' S. ns. me XI

j 1 < saeap o e u a d ep o e sv oain, plitf mus ()ie tf ap oe tdl e t
. : tt r c d r l u r c s i lto a anif t 1 d n iy r tce i ry
To
b
o pr p ryitr s a d( )d mo taed prv to o ta itrs wi o td p o e so
r o e t n ee t n 2 e nsrt e iain f h t n ee t t u ue r c s f
h
'
lw.1 Pret v Clr e 78 F.d2 5 2 8(t Ci. 01 ) ; lb ryitr s ma aiefo
a '2 i o
ak , 0 3 4 , 4 4 h r 2 5 . : i et n ee t y rs rm
A
.

t Consiùton is f by r as ofgura e i plci i t wor çi ry, ori m a a ie fom
he
tt i tel, e on
nt es m i t n he d lbe t ' t y rs r
'
an e
xpeca i n ori e es c e t d by sa elwsorpolces'1 W iki on v. Ausi 5 U .
tto
ntr t r a e
tt a
i i . 3 l ns
tn, 45 S.

20 , 21( 0 5 (iainso te )
9 2 2 0 ) ctto mitd .
1 N ot y, acai t tprs ofi i sh no f l d t ro i pende polci orpr dur
2 abl
l m ha ion tcal ave t olowe hei wn nde
nt i es
oce es

do sn tsaeac n t in lcam.Se UntdSae v Ca ee, 40U. 7 , 5 -5(9 9 ; c i v. t . f
e o tt o si o a li e ie tts . cr s4 S. 41 7 25 1 7 )Rico Cnv o
mt
Fara ,9 7F.d 1 5 ,1 86 (t Ci.1 9 )( ligta i saelw ga t moep o e ua rg t ta te
ifx 0 2 4 9 46 -9 4h r 9 0 hodn h tf tt a rns r r cd rl ihs h n h
Co siuinrq ie , saesfil t a ieb ta 1w i n tafd r l uep o e sise .
n t to e urs a tt' alr o bd y h ta s o e ea d r c s su )
t
te
1 Thea ndedcompl nta esesonl atsat c e td c tt i lpr e t d lbe t i er t'not
3
me
ai ddr s
y st e r ae onsiutona otc e i ry nt es, '
unde t DuePr e sCl s by isown fr ,a t cou tde lne t c t c s h acam f rPli if See
r he
oc s au e t
o ce nd he r ci s o onsru t uc li o antf.

Be eai . mih 1 0F.d5 0 5 2(t Ci. 9 7 Csic teei n c ne to h r , rIgc l c udtee
v rtv S t, 2 3 0 , 0 4h r 1 9 ) t n e h r s o o tnin ee no o ial o l h r
y
be,t tt c i
ha he ontnementt a nitatv s e i e e tes enc i
o dmi sr ie egrgaton xce ds h ent e mpos d i s h a e rmewayast
e n uc n xte
o
gi rs t t pr t to oft DuePr es Cl eby isownf r e,t quesi be o eusi whehe I t '
ve ie o he oecin he
oc s aus
t
o c he ton f r
s t r nmaes
contne nti ad i srtves gr gai i e s anat ca ha ds p ont vi avi or nar prs lf
i me n m nitai e e ton mpos d uch
ypi l r hi
hem s s di y ion ie

ta te pos se al et itrs i a odigi';e as Br c v. rol1 7F.d2 , 43(t Ci.1 9 )
h t h y se sd i ry neet n v i n t' se lo o k Car l, 0 3 41 2 4h r 9 7
b
.)
7

tf eUnied St t Consiuton is fdoe no gi rs t albe t i e e ti a di
l'
-h
t
aes
tt i tel s t ve ie o i ry ntr s n voi ng
ta f rt mor a r e c tonso confne nt' 1 a 221 22;s eAlgoodv.M ori,724
r nse o
e dve s ondii
f
i me . d. t - e l
'
rs

F.d 1 9 ,1 01(t Ci.1 8 )(<s e r g tdc n ie n i n tp rK u c n ttto l'
2 0 8 1 4 h r 9 4 t j ge ae o fn me t s 0 e . n o siu ina.
g
'
(iig S e, 2 F.da 8 0 6 ) Ho v r asaece tdlb ryitr s ma e it f h
ct we t 5 9 2 t 6 - 2 . we e, tt-rae ie t ne e t y xs i t e
n
i t poi st $ ba i f ra i e e tore c a i i sa er gu ai ns' o a d t
nma e nt o ç ss o n ntr s
a
xpe t ton n tt e l to 't voi he
condii nso hi c v ne e t rt s gr a i cls ii a i s he è a Re Oni a alo
to f s o
m nt mde he e eg ton a sfc ton c m t d on nd s
s
howst tt e c tonsi
ha hos ondii mpos ay ca a sgnii a ha ds p i r a i t t or na y
e t pi l nd i fc nt r hi n elton o he di r
i i s ofprs 1f 1 Sa n v. Come , 1 U. 47 48 (9 5 ; it, 8 F.da 2 0.
i on ie.4 ndi
nCdent
r r 5 5 S. 2, 4 1 9 ) Preo 7 0 3 t 5

Onl i t i t s ts sbo h c tonsdoe t DuePr es Clus r r apa tc a
y f he nma e a ife t ondii
s he
oc s a e equie
ri ulr
m e ur ofpr dur lpr t c i bef r ade i to ofalbe t i e e t I
as e
oce a o e ton o e prvai n
i ry nt r s . d.
None hees ,t lgii a y oft VDOC' pur ei de ini t Le Spr r m i
t l s he e tm c
he
S pos n sg ng he vel og n s

l yondque to ....(
s
be
sin
whenqt r ultonsar e esl ai da pr eci prs s urt a
he eg ai
e xpr sy me t ot tng ion ec iy,
pur e ...c nta t a1o he co r to goa s' Thor ch v.Abbot,490 U. 401,
pos
e r l o 1 t r reci ns l .
'
nbur
t
S.
415

( 9 9 (ne n l u tto mak o te ) l 'eSaesfrt biainmu t et e s r t e
1 8 ) itr a q o ain r s mitd , t h tt' is o lg t
f
o s b o nu e h
s e y ofgua dsa prs n pe s r e,t publc,a t prs r t m s l s' W iki on,545
aft
r nd i o r om l he
i nd he ione s he eve .
' l ns
U. a 227.Gr'edifc tesofope ai a dee i ce t rmus no beunde e tm ae by t
S. t
t h fi uli
f
r tng
tnton n e
t t
r si td
he

c u tgj a d< o rcina o fcas. . s ha es bsa ta d srto t d vs r ao a e
o rs,' n t re to l f il . mu t v u tnil icein o e ie e s n bl
' c
s utonst t pr e st y f ce'n m ant i ngprs n s tiy a s ey.Fl e ev. of
ol i o he oblm he a 'i i ani
i o ecu t nd af t
or nc Bd.

Ch s nFre les 5 6U. 31 , 2 ( 01 ) seW of v. c n el 41 U. 5 9 5 6
o e e hod r, 6 S. 8 3 6 2 2 ; e lf M Do n l, 8 S. 3 , 5
( ti, .c n u n ) Be u et Ciyo Ha tn 7 5F.d 1 7 ,1 7 (t Ci. 9 5; r o v. e e 5 4
Lu t J, o c ni g; a d tv. t f mpo , 7 2 2 4 2 8 4h r 1 8 )Go d n Le k , 7
g
F.d 147 1 51(t Ci.1 7 )(e o nzn ta adsrc c u'i n t x ce t asmeter l o a vo aefra
2 1 , 1 4h r 9 8 rc g iig h t itit o l s o e petd o su h oe f d ct o
t
Dr K pli if.
o
antf)

1 Thenor tvebas lne f aprs nera et i
4
mai
ei or io r he s tonsdi atd b aprs rsc cin a
condii
ct e y ione ' onvito nd

sne e. . o siuigteSr n r icd nt o p io lf.'I u av. il a 7 F.d51 5 7(t Ci.
e tnc . c n tttn h odiay n ie s f rsn ie' nc ma St i , 91 3 7, 2 4h r
'
rn
2 5 .Ge rl o uainiteb sl ei ti cs .Se i.c. it, 8 F3 a 2 3(o c r n p io es
01 ) nea p p lto s h a ei n hs ae e d; fPreo 7 0 .d t 5 c n enig rsn r
n
sne e t d ah .
e tnc d o e t)
8

( 9 4 (( h f c t a p io e srti rg t u e teDu Pr c s Clu ei n wa i le
1 7 ) ç Tj e a t h t rs n r ean ihs nd r h e o e s a s n o y mp is
ç
t a t e erg t aen ts b e t orsrcinsi o e b t n t r o ter gmet whc t y
h t h s ih s r o u j c t e tito mp s d y he au e f h e i o ih he
ha eb e lwf lyc mmitd.) s eas Grh m v Como , 0U. 3 6 4 5( 9 9 (No
v e n a ul o te ' ; e lo a a . r r49 S. 8 , 5 1 8 ) < t
'
<

e eyp s o s ve e e i i ma ltrs e l n c say i tepe c o aj g ' c mb r
v r u h r ho , v n f t y ae e m l e e sr n h a e f ud e s ha e s
n
vo ae t Fo rhAme d n . (nen l u tto ma k a ctto o te l.
ilts he u t
n me t'itr a q oain r s nd i in mitd )
'
a
As tmi a cue
sl ng, r ndo,t tVDOC polc c e t albe t i t r tt a dt co to
ha
i y r a es i ry n e es o voi he ndii ns
ofLe S a Re Oni t c tfndst tPli ifsa oxi aeone- a co
vel t d on, he our i ha antf' ppr m t
ye r nfne e t r ,
m ht he e
a t a tnda c tonshee re d,di notco tt ealçaypi a and sgnii nt
nd he te nt ondii
xpe ince d
nsiut t çt c l
i fca
ha ds p' c
r hi ' ompar d t t ço di r i de sofprs lf ' c d e
e o he sr na y nci nt
ion ie'he oul xpec . Se Sa i 51
t e nd n, 5
U. a 484. Them e e lm ia i on prvie s pr ry,a a tviisf a nita i l
S. t
r i ttons
i lge , ope t nd c i te or dmi sr tve y

s g e ae imae Gal)wi ntee pe tdpei tr o tesn e c i s db ac u t f
e rg td n ts t lg t h x ce rmees f h e tn e mpo e y o r o
f
hi
lw. S n i , 5U. a 4 5; e Ga tnv. yo , 4 F. 3 , 43(t Ci. 9 )( odi
a ' a d n 51 S. t 8 se so Ta lr 9 6 2d 40 3 4 h r 1 91 h l ng
'
t c nge i aprs ' çl a i va itonsofdaiy r i ,c nge i c tonsof
hat ha s n
ioners çoc ton, rai
l outne ha s n ondii

c i me (ncudi a nitai s grgai ,a t de a ofprvie - matr
onfne nt i l ng dmi srtve e e ton) nd he nil i lges
tes
whih e r prs rc n a ii t a eco e aedby hi orgi ls nt ncet prs - a e
c ve y ione a ntcpae r nt mpl t
s i na e e
o ion
r
ne s a iy fmc i ofprs m a ge e t tmus bel f t t br d dic e i ofprs
ce s rl t tons
ion na m nt ha
t e t o he oa s r ton
ion

a nitaor t e et m t ma t prs s fl a efcinty' .
dmi srt s o nabl he o nage he ions aey nd fi e l '
)
The dur to a c to ofPl i ifsc
ai n nd ondii ns
antf onfne e a Re Oni do no i i a et
m nt t d on
t mplc t he

c n en d s u s di W ikns nv. tn 5 5U. 2 9 21 ( 0 5 , n l c ma v. tric
o c r s ic se n li o Ausi, 4 S. 0 , 3 2 0 ) a d n u a S iln ,
791F.d 51 51 ( hCi. ) I W iki on,heSuprmeCour f t ti tshada
3 7, 9 4t r 2015 . n l ns t
e
t ound ha nmae
pr e t d lbe t i e e ti a di as i e t a s a e ç uper a 'prs W ihou
ot c e i r y nt r s n voi ng s gnm nt o t t G
s m x' i on. t t
u r ng a poi - - ntc pa on oft co tons b w e n s gr ga i and ge r
nde goi
ntby poi om ds
he ndii
et e e e ton
ne al
9

populto t Supr m eCour ditng s d t s r a c tonsfom nor ls gr ga i
ai n,he
e
t si uihe he upe m x ondii r
ma e e ton
f t eeprm a y r as
or hr
i r e ons.Fis,i aesi t s r x prs n we et prve ofam os a
r t nm t n he upe ma io
r G i d l t ny
de
'
e r nm e a or s ns y s i ul a ofa m os a lhlm a c ac . 1 w iki on, 545 U . a
nvio nt l e or tm i nd
l t l l n ont t, 5 l ns
S. t

21 Se nd, hei t swe ea sgne t t s pe ma prs n f ça i fniepe i oftm e
4. co t nma e r s i d o he u r x io or tn nde t rod i ,

lmiedonl byEhe i t ssntnce' l Thid,i tsohe wieei bl f paol l t
i t
y t j nmae' e e . d. r nmae t r s lgi e or r e os
'

ta eii lt whi i rsne a t.spema pio l a 21 .çAqyo teec ndto
h t lgbi y l mp io d tl u r x rsn. d.t 5 t n f h s o iins
i
e
l
e
g
sa igao mih n t s fkin t c e t al ryitrs,(uqtke t g t r, te
tndn lne g t o be u f e t o r ae i t n ee t b t a n o ehe g h y
be
)
i s lja ay ia a sg fc n h r hpwi ntec ne to a c ne t' I . t2 4
mpo ed n tpc l nd iniia t ads i t h o -cin l o tx . d a 2 .
hi
'
Si ia l i I tma t Fourh Cic tf und apr t c e lbe t i e es i a di a sgnme
m l ry n ncz a, he
t r ui o
o e t d i ry nt r t n voi ng s i
nt
t Sout Ca olna' s r x ba ed o t prs rst nt yea c i m e t r a is
o
h r i s upe ma s n he ione ' we y- r ontne nt he e nd t
iol tng a r srci lvi c tons i l ng ahi hl i r sve srp s a c e r tmehe
s ai nd e ti tve i ng ondii , ncudi
g y ntu i ti e r h ve y i
l f hi ce lf rt t yea s 791F. a 531 3
e t s l o wen y r .
3d t - 2.

Ta n t t r t conc r e pous d i W iki on a I um a f uso t i fnie
ke ogehe , he
e ns s
e n l ns nd nc a oc n he ndei t
nam r ofs r a contne e .l W iki on,prs polci s pr de çno i c ton how
e upe m x
i m nt n l ns
i on i e ovi d t ndi a i

l n Enimae ma beic reae (th s p r x o c a sg e t e e' 5 U. a 21
o g a n t) y n ac rt d a te u e ma j n e sin d h r . 45 S. t 5.
'
Alo,polc r quie i r ue r viw oft co i d a opra e s o a i ae' s c fc
s
i y e r d nfeq nt e e
he ntnue ppr it ne s f n nm t s pe ii
s gr a i sat onc i taly,t ry da a trhi a rval a a
e eg ton t us: e nii l hit ys fe s ri , nd nnualy t r afe .I a 21
l he e tr d. t 7.
Thepolc i I uma r quiedan i tmto lcas ii ai c
i y n nc a e r
nsi i na l sfc ton omm itet e l t t i t s
te o va ua e he nma e'
sa useve y t ry da .791F. a 5 23. Sout Ca olnapolc pr de t tt i t
tt
r hit ys
3d t 22h r i
iy ovi d ha he nma e
c d qua i y f r r c a s fc ton a r l s f o t s nna by a e ng a t m pr m e
oul
lf o e l s ii a i nd e ea e r m he upe x
chi vi n ç ove nt
i

1 Th c ndto sa tesp r xpio icu e tal tal u nc na tip o i td e e t te
5 e o i n t h u ema rs n n ld d t qmos 1h ma o tc s r hbi v n o h
i
g
e
poi t tconves ton i notpemit 9om celt cel t lghtt ugh i ma bedi
nt ha
ra i s
r ted
l o l;he i ,ho t y
mmed,i onf 24hot s
s or
l;
r

En qe ecs i fr1h u p rd y b to l i as li o r o m. l . t 2324 Th Su r meCo t oe ta
a d x rie s o o r e a , u ny n malnd o r o ' d a 2 - . e pe
'
m'n td h t
t lc ofhuma contc wa t mos ditnci oft elvi c to .I at224.
he a k
n
a t s he t si tve hes i ng ondiins d.

1
0

i be vi l ve . I So h Ca olnapolc f t rdei d G ha o lve'asi l ng a
n ha or e l' d. ut r i
'
i y urhe fne t vi r e l' ncudi
be
c e rdicplnmy r co dand t saf ' e l ton oft i e' ove al co pla e. I a 522.
la s i i
e r
he t fs vaua i
he nmat s r l m i nc d. t
H o ve ,t i t i I uma ha ne ri ureda dicplna y izr ton i t nt ye r ,ye
we r he nma e n nc a d ve nc r
s i i r lfaci n we y a s t

sa fke t i t i s r a c to f t nt yea swihouta be vi r ba i f
t f pt he nma e n upe m x ondii ns or we y r t
ny ha o al ss or
doi s 1 a 5 ng o. d. t 21 23.

Undoub e y, velS i t se re em or r srci c tonst n Le l5
t dl Le
nma e xpe i nc
e e ti tve ondii ha ve
i aesi ge r lpo a i butt tf tdoesnotr nde s h cmfne nta y c lo
nm t n ne a pulton, ha ac
e r uc t i me t pia r
sgnii nty ha s Ge r lpo a i i t ca a s e
i fca l r h. ne a pulton nmaes n lo xpec c land srp s a c s
t el
ti e r he ,
tm por r housng i s r ga i unde smia r titons and lm ied a ce st pr ry a
e
ay
i n eg e ton
r i lr esrci ,
i t c s o ope t nd

t publc.SeeSa n,51 U. a 486( sus i smia c tonsf t ryda ) Be r t,
he i
ndi 5 S. t dic sng i lr ondii or hit ys; ve ai

1 0F.da 5 4(n f rsxmo t )
2 3 t 0 s me o i nhs.
Polc pr de Pl ntf wih pe s lpr ryt tno onl c tt e lf sbasc
iy ovi d ai if t r ona ope t ha t y onsiut d ie' i
ne s ii , as a l d books a a opl ye , elgi usie s a m uli e me nst
ce stes but lo lowe
, n udi a r r i o t m , nd
tpl a o

c mmt c t wihtep lc Le e S imae aealwe o s v stto , r u e p re c s
o miae t h ubi. v l n ts r l dj b , iiai n g o p x ein e ,
o
t e sonpr r mm i e ato pr n i a va i c
elvii
og a ng, duc i nal ogr mm ng, nd rous ommi s r plr ha e .
s a y zc s s

Unlke W il on,t r or doe no r fe tt tLe lS i a e a ede i d of
i
l
dns he ec d s t e l c ha ve nm t s r prve
e r e a ors ns y si iand alhu a c ac .1 Pl ntf al ge i i no ase y t
nvionm nt l e or tmul
1 m n ont t 6 ai if le s t s t as o
c m uni t w ih ot r i a e whie i Le S, Pl i iff ist e t bls t t
om
ca e t he nm t s l n vel but a ntf a l o s a i h ha

çc rai i no pe m itd fo c lt c 1.'? Se W iki o , 5 U. 209( tng
çonve ston s t r te r m el o e 1'1 e l ns n 45 S.
noi
conve s ton wa no pe m it d fom celt c l asaf t f t Cou tsc l i n alhlm a
rai
s t r te r
l o el
acor or he
r ' oncuso l l n
1 I dee ,Pl ntf mpl nsoft muc si ic us by ohe i t .
6 n d ai ifco ai
oo
h tmul a ed t r nmaes
' A Re Oni i t desgnat asI - fld alafd ti s
?
d on nmae i ed M O ie ! fiavi n uppor oft co ai . Notbl t
t he mpl nt
a y,he

imaee pli ,$wa sa dn a myc ld o wh nti c n esto (ewe nPlitf a dsaf to plc ,
n t x ansç s tn ig t el o r e hs o v rain b t e anif n tfj o k a e
1
e e to g tewals aema eo p pe a yo c nh a e eyhn a y y' CfWikn o 5 U. a 21
v n h u h h l ) r d f a r s u a e r v rtig n wa . . lisn, 45 S.t 4
l
'
(oigteclsweec ntu tdi s c awa t p e e tc n esto o c n u iainbewe nimae)
n t h el r o sr ce n u h y o rv n o v rain r o un ncto t e n ts.
n
11

c na t sp o iie ) Fu t r r, o iiec mmt c to wi safi e c u a e a
o tc wa r hbtd . rhemo e p stv o miai n t tf s n o rg d s
h
i aeswor t ough t se down pr r m t l
nm t
k hr
he t p
og n o owert i s urt l vel Alounlke
her ec iy e . s
i
W iki on whe et s pe ma i e we eke i i a r e d onceaye ,Le S
l ns
r he u r x nmats r pt nsde nd eviwe
ar vel
i a e ar a f de e r e a si ul t e tm e awe k wih ou doorr c e to a e
nm t s e for d nvionm ntl tm i hr e i s
e t t
e r a in, r
1 nf r ly'r e d e l t ry da ,a a e t or l ' e e d e r ni t da .'
f o ma l ' eviwe ve' hit ys nd r t maly'r viwe ve y ney ysl
i
y
f

Uni I u a Le lSimae a en t oeyd p n e to tes be tv p rp cie o saf
l nc ma , ve n ts r o s ll e e d n n h u j ci e es e tv s f tf
ke
d rn ar ve I ta , ve Simae c n o j cieyd mo srt p o s ca p o r s b
u ig e iw. nse d Le l n ts a b e tv l e n tae r -o il r g e s y
c pl tng t Cha l nge Se i s wor
om e i he
le
re
kbooks 1 A l o unlke t t e y- rr t i tons
9 s
i he w nt yea esr c i
.

e ince i l uma Pli ifs nta d asialy s trpe i oftm ea Le lS xpere d n nc a, antf pe
r tc l hore rod i t ve
a oxi t l f te m ont ,ofwhi h a oxi a eyt eehes ntasa I i t .
ppr ma ey oure n
hs
c ppr m t l hr
pe
n M nma e
Pli ifsva i compl nt a
antf
rous
ai s boutf we n nii si Le 6 do notdes rbea
e r me te n vel
ci n
aypialorsgnii a ha ds p. M a ofPli ifsc
t c
i fc nt r hi
ny
antf ompl nt a ef i ous lkenotha ng
ai s r rvol , i
vi
s a r i t ad ofsae is s ; beng alowe t i t d c
ne ke s nse
t t s ue hoes not i l d mlmie omm is r ptr has ; ng
s a y lc es havi
a c l doorc tu e wihm or m ea ;e r ii i af nce i a e wih ba be wie whih
el
onsr ctd t
e tl xe csng n e d n r a t z d r , c
s mdsno dif r ntt aprs ge r ly; vi hi c
ot
fe e han ion ne al ha ng s omm lni to ç
l cai ns i rs vela '
unde ur il nce'
;
a no pa tcpai i e
nd t rii tng n ducai na pr a s ese:. W olf 418U. a 5 77;Thor
to l ogr m .Se . , f ,
S. t 76nbum h,
490 U. a 413;W ome Prs r ofD. De tofCor.v.D. ,93 F. 91 927,320 U.
S. t
n ione s
C. p'
r
C.
3d 0,
S.

App.D. 247( C. r 1996) Furhe e prs r ha no c tt i rghtt c ac
C. D. Ci.
. t nnor, iones ve onsiutonal i o ont t
viiai o a e c ai o prva y i aprs c l.Se .e. ,Bl k v.Rut ro d, U .
st ton r n xpe tton f i c n
ion e l e c. oc
he f r 468 S.

576,589( 984) Huds n v.Pame,468U. 51 525( 4) Alo,t fc Le lS i t
1 ;
o
l r
S. 7, 198 . s he a t ve nmaes
a eii e i z ' o c plt s ve wor ksa e m i t i be vi si ùet ra
r çnc ntvied't om e e e n kboo nd xa ne her ha or s ihe n
1 çnf
8 s onnal a tf
l
' nd tonnal r fr gene al t t e e a i aehasnotc oft he rnga i i ve
'
' ee s
'
r ly o he xtnt n nm t
ie he a i nd s nvol d
i t r e pr es .
n he eviw oc s
1 Nonehel s c
9
t es , omplto oft ChalengeSe isi bu onef t c i r
ein he
l
re s t
acor onsdeed.

12

ay c l o sg iia t r s p e eg, c mev. l, 3 U.. 4 3 , 0( 0 2 ( tn
tpia n r infc n had hi.Se e ..M Kt
Li 5 6 S 2 , 6 4 2 0 ) noig
e
Cth Co r ha isnltdta rh b lain i algtmaep noo ia i tr s t a mu tb
' l e u t s n t ce h t e a ii to s e ii t e lgc l ne et h t s e
g
t
weghed a i tt e r s ofa i t slbe t ' c l ng lhede a ofdic et prs n
i
ga ns he xe cie n nma e' i ry'and onc udi l
t
ni l
sr e io

p iie e f rr f s lop riiaei arha ii to p o rm ( o sno)a t g t
rv lg s o e u a t a t p t n e blt in r g n d e t mo mt) o
c
a
u c n ttto a c mp lin' s eas i . t5 ( tv ns J, is n ig (û oo c u d
n o siui n l o u so l; e lo d a 4 Se e , .d se tn ) t ne o l
N
pos i y diag eewih t pl alt ssa e ntt tofe i i m aesm i m a i e i t
sbl s r
t he ur iy' tt me ha f rng n t
ni l nc ntves o

pa t i t (narha iiainp o rmjd e n t mo n t c mpelds l-n rmiain
ri pae i e bltto r g a o s o n u t o o le efi ci n to
c
p o i td b t eFit Ame d n . (ne n l u tto mak o te l.
r hbi y h fh
e
n me t' itr a q o ain r s mitd )
'
Pl ntf doesnote tbls t tc i m e a Re Oni madehi i lgi ef rpa ol
ai if
sa ih ha onfne nt t d on
m ne i bl o r e,
whih wa t c s f t i ae i a t s pe max f c lt i W iki o .2 s(
c
s he a e or he nm t n t he u r
a iiy n l ns n 0 oreover,pj j ir
antf
doe no aleg t te m e good c
s t l e ha a d
onduc tm ewa t ke a
ti
s a n way a a c e nceofbeng
s ons que
i
de i t d asLe lS.2
sgna e
ve 1
l s ,t r c ddoesno e t bls t tt c tonsofPli ifsc i me a
n um he e or
t sa ih ha he ondii
antf' onfne nt t
Le lS i Red Oni i
ve n
on mpos a aypi a a sgnii ntha ds p i r lton t t o di r
ed n t c l nd i fca
r hi n ea i o he r na y
2 P1i ifdoesnote t ih t twa eve elgi ef rpa ol f t crme hec
0 antf
sabls ha s r i bl o r e or he i s ommitd. Ata hm enst
te
tc
t o
t c
he ompli s Pl ntf wa cls iid a (i i bl'f rpaol andcom'r c dsfo t Cic tCo tof
ant how ai if s a sfe s tnelgi e' o r e,
t e or r m he r ui ur
RoanokeCiy s w t tPl ntf wa i ar r edafe pladi guit i J y 2009t i e ala,amur
t ho ha ai if s nc ceat tr e ng ly n ul
o,ntr i
der
c
ommit i 2008.Se l ReKarnaCanalBr ac sCons .Lii ,533F.Supp.2d 61 63133 & = .4ted n
en
ti
e he
ol ta.
5, 1 15

( D. . 0 8 (olcigc ssidc t gt te ea c u' ma tk u iil oieo g v mme tlwe sts
E. La 2 0 ) c l t a e n iai ha fd rl o zs y a ej dca n tc f o e na b i ,
e n
n
t
e
i ldn c ut e od ) P r l wa ds o tn e i Vignaln b fr Plitf c mmitdhi ci si 2 0 .
ncu ig o r rc r s. aoe s ic niu d n r ii o g eoe an if o te s rme n 0 8
S eVA.
e
CODEj5 .- 6 . (b ihn p r l f ridvd asc n ce o afln c mmitdatrJn ay 1
311 51 a ol ig aoe o n iiu l o vitd f eo y o t fe a u r ,
s
e
19 )
9 5.

2 Des t Pli ifsr peae a s ri ofbeng ç s d by l so good c
1 pie antf' e td s e ton
i G he
puni
os f
onduc tme,'t r or doe
t i ' he ec d s
notr l ctt tt as i ntt Le lS de emi dt lngt ofhî s t nc l tad,t r or r l c st the
ete ha he sgnme o ve
t r ne he e h
s en e e. nse he ec d ete t ha
di notean good c
d
r
onduc tmeasar ulofbei Le S.l t donotha apr ece lberyi ees i
ti
es t
ng vel nmaes
ve ot td i t ntr t n
e r n as ii r eofgood c
a nig pecfc at
onduc tme andcou t ha hedt tt e fctofacl stcai cha ont
ti ,
rs ve l ha he fe
asii ton nge he
a lt t e n good-i ecr ti t s ultvet c tt eade i i ofapr t cedlbe t i e e t Se e. ,
biiy o ar
tm edi s oo pec ai o onsiut
prvaton
o e t i ry ntr s. e. a.

Gre h lzv Imae o Ne Pe l Cor Co lx 4 2U..1 7( 9 9. le v S ot71F.d1 2 1 39
e n ot .n ts f b. na & r. mpe , 4 S , 1 7 ) Lt n . c t, 3 9 , 9 -4
, k
(t Ci.1 9 )(iigMe c u v Fa o 4 7U.. 5 2 n8(9 6 De a i v J l o 1 F. u p. 431 :
5h r 9 5 ctn a h m . n , 2 S 21 , 29 . 17 :; Blso . omsn, 28 S p 2 5
3 93 ( D. . 0 ) afd 1 F. p' 9 (t Ci. 0 )s eas W of 41 U.. t5 75 (e o nzngte
2 -0 E. Va 20 0, f', 3 Ap x 6 4h r 2 01*e lo l 8 S a 5 -8 r c g ii h
,
s
Co siuind e n tg aa teg o t ce ifrstsa tr b h virwhl i pio ) Co s q e t tec ut
n ttt o s o u rne o d i rdto aifcoy e a o i n rs n. n e u nl h o r
o
me
e
y,
c nnotfndt tPl ntf stmea RedOni i tbl a fc e t lngt o hi conGne nts ast ti ra
a
i ha ai if' i t
on nevia y fe t d he e h f s
me o o rgge
s pa ae,c tt inal pr t ce lbe t i e e ti a di t tcls iiai Se e. ,Sa n,51 U. a 48
e r t onsiuto ly o e td i ry ntr s n voi ng ha a sfc ton. e. a. ndi 5 S. t 7.

13

i de sofprs lf Thec tonsa Le lS a editng s bl fom t i oltng
nci nt
ion ie.
ondii
t ve r si uiha e r he s a i
c tonsa i fnie s i ntfe i W iki on a l um a and Pli iff ist de c i
ondii
nd nde t ne s de ii d n l ns nd nc a,
antf a l o s rbe

t vi a i ofaf de alrghtt twa c e ry- sa ihe be or ordurnghi c i m e a
he olton
e r i ha s l a l e t bls d f e
i s onfne nt t

Le lSi RedOni Se Ed r ,1 F.d a 251(eerngt ce ryetbls d1w as
ve n
on. e wads 78 3 t rfri o lal sa ihe a
fom t Unie St t Supr m eCour,Fourh Cic tCour ofAppe s a Vigi aSupr me
r he t d aes
e
t
t r ui
t
al, nd r ni
e

Co r) Ac o dn l De e d nsaee tte t q ai di nt a ds mmayj d me t
u t. c r igy, f n a t r n ild o u lfe mmu iy n u z u g n .
I .
V

Fo t f egoi r as ,t c ur gr nt De e nt 's o moton f s ma y
r he or ng e ons he o t a s f nda s ec nd
i or um r

j dg n .
u me t

sxvsu:T i J y
hs

dyo vac,0,
a r rh2 1.
.

'

$1
1,
j

Z .
.W

-'' -' . '. .
,'' r'
'! '
r
4
1
,
'

ç

Unied St t D i t 'tJ
t
a es s r udge

14

.

'

.. .::
.-1.
;:1-.
:
X

''

' ''' * '
'

:.

'