Duncan v. Lee et al
Filing
9
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 11/10/2014. (tvt)
ekev a OFFI u, Dl m lr
CE s. sm A l
A DANVILE,
T
L VA
F n
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI
JO NATHAN ROBERT DUNCAN,
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
Q-
œ#
..
;
JULA
I
BY:
.,
.
DL ,
P
..
C i lA c i N o.7: 4- vvi t on
1 c 00546
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
JA C K LEE,e a .
t I,
D e endant .
f
s
By:
H on.Jaclson L .K i
t
ser
Se or U nie St t sD i t i tJudge
ni
t d a e sr c
J t n Robe tDunc n,a Vigi a i t pr e ng or K ,fl acvi rg s
ona ha
r
a
r ni nma e oce di
o
ied i l i ht
Co ai purua t 42U. C.j 1
mpl nt s nt o
S.
983.Pli ifnn asdefnda sJ kLe t
antf mes
e nt ac e,he
Supe i ende oft M i eIi rRe onalJ i C$a1';StvePlza aJ i Ca an;a Cal
rnt nt he ddl tve gi
al J i' e a , al pti nd r
)
Va a ner aJ i Li u ena .Pl ntf al gest tt de e n sc
nde ve , a l e t nt ai if le ha he f nda t omm itd ç rm i l
te d i na
c
neglg nc ' Thi matri bef emef sr ni purua t 28U. C.j 1 5 Afe
ie e.' s te s or
or cee ng, s nt o
S.
91 A. tr
r ve ngPlitf ss b sin , dimist eCo litwi o t eu ief rf ingt saea
e iwi an if u miso s 1 s s h mpan t u prj d c o al o tt
h
i
c a m upon whi h r le m a be g a e
li
c e if y
r nt d.
Pli ifale t tnon- f ndantde i a t J la tc d hi whe hewa boo
antf lges ha
de e
putes t he ai ta ke m
n
s ked
i o t J i a t tJ lsa fs e nty pl c d hi i s r ton wihoutm e ca a tnton,
nt he a l nd ha ai t f ubs que l a e m n eg egai
t
di l te i
pit e t ke o ç ny booki pr ed e . Pli ifa l est Ca an Pl z a Lt
cur s a n, r i
a
ng oc ur s' antf leg he pt i a a nd .
'
Va a nerwor d i t s gr gaton poddtrng t we Pli ifwa i s gr ga i
nde ve
ke n he e e i
li he ek antf s n e e ton.
Pli iff t a lgest tts xua ofi e sha wine s t f t1wa be tup,t e a
antf urher le
ha se l tc r d t s ed he ac
s a
az d, nd
c r i bl Cla l t She if (i)cosedt lne.Nooner poredt i i nta
oveed n ood. e ry,he rfs sc r s he i
e t he ncde nd
hi t f c st ti ha
d he a t ha t ppene '
d.
'
Sec i 1 r quiesas wi ofper o lf ul on t pa tofade e nte t rbas d
ton 983 e r
ho ng
s na a t he r
f nda ihe
e
on t def ntspe s lco
he enda ' r ona nduc ora he ' c
t not rs onduc i e c i oft def nda ' polc e
t n xe uton he e nts ii s
RK
o c so .Fih rv. a hn tnM er . e Tr n iAuh r, 9 F.d 1 3 ,1 4 - 3(t
r u t ms s e W s iao to Ar a a st f o .6 0 2 1 3 1 2 4 4h
Ci.1982 , ogaedp1ot ar t kyCnt ofRi ri v.McLa i 500U. 44
r
) abr t . her omds
.
1
y. vesdç
ughln,
S.
( 991 .Howeve,Plitf doe no de ci a pe s la toromisonbya defnda .
1 )
r anif s t s rbe ny rona c
si
ny e nt
Cons que l Pl n iff l t de crbe a de e n ' unlwf lco uc . Se eg.Fa me v.
e nty, aitf ais o s i ny f nda ts a ' nd t e. . , r r
u
Brn a ,5 1U. 8 5 8 ( 9 4 ; tlev Ga l, 2 U. 9 ,1 4 ( 9 6 .Fu temo e
e n n 1 S. 2 , 38 1 9 ) Esel . mb e 4 9 S. 7 0 1 7 ) rh r r ,
la lt t rj 1 ma notbeprdiae ont t or ofr pondea s ro .See e. ,
ibiiy mde 983 y
e c td he he y es
t upeir . g.
Mo el De ' o So . e v .4 6U. 65 , 6 n. ( 9 ) M o e v r n gie c i n t ss
n lv. pt f c S r s, 3 S. 8 6 3 7 1 78 . ro e , e lg n e s o ba i
f rrle v aj1 8 .S e eg, a me , u r .Ac o dn l 1ds s teCo an wi o t
o eif i 9 3 e , ..F r r s p a c r igy, imis h mplit t u
h
p eudc , t s a tt 28U. C. 1 5 b () f r aln t saeacam u o whc r l f
rj ie p l u n o
r
S. j 91 A() 1, o f iig o tt li p n ih ei
e
m a be g a ed. l
y
r nt
ENTER:Thi
s
> d ofNove be ,201
ay
m r
4.
Se i Unied St t Diti tJ
or t
aes src udge
1lmus dimisa aci orcli tldbyani t i lde emi t tt aci orcam i fi ousorf l
t s s ny ton
am ie
nmae f t r ne ha he ton li s rvol
ais
t saeacam o whc r l fma b ga td.S e28U. C. jl 5e() 1 5 b ()4 U. C. 1 9 ec.
o tt li n ih ei y e rne e
e
S. j 91 ()2 , 91 A()1; 2 S. j 9 7 ()
Thefrtsanda di udescl msba e upon t n i s a y meils l lt l 'i l msofi ngementofa
is t r ncl
ai
sd
ç ndiputbl rte s ega heoy 'ç ai
a
c
ngi
lgalit r twhih cl ry doe note s ' cli whe et Sfct lc e i a ecea l ba ees ' Neizke
e n ees c ea l s
xit'or ams r he da ua ontntons r l ry s l s. t
'
v W iims 4 0U.. 1 , 2 ( 9 9 .Th sc n sa d r itefmiirsa d r framoint ds s u d r
. l a , 9 S 3 9 3 7 1 8 ) e eo d tn ad s h a l tn ad o
l
a
to o imis n e
Fe ea Rul o CiiPoc d r 1 *)6 , c e t gapanifsfcu lalg to sa tu .A c mpan n e s$
d rl e f vl r e u e 2 4)a c pi litf a ta l ain sr e o lit e d (
n
e
a
s o t n pli sae n o tecam s o n t th pe d ri e tte t rl f a ds f e tû ata
h r a d an ttme t f h li h wig ha te la e s nild o ei ' n ut n ç cu l
e
ki m
alegains...or itarghtt r ifabovet s cultvelvel... BelAt.Cor v.
l to
t as i o ele
he pe ai e . ' l l p. Twombl 550U. 5
'
v,
S. 44,
5 5(0 7 (nen l u tt nmakso te ) A panifsb ssfrr l fSe ursmoeta lb l a d
5 2 0 ) itr a q oai r mi d . lit ' ai o ei t q ie r h n a es n
o
t
f
e r
c ncu ins. .' I .Th rfr , panifmu ttl g fcss fiin t saealh ee nso (h )cam.
o lso . . d eeoe a litf s i l e a t u fce to tt lte lme t f te li '
'
ae
'
Basv E.. po d Ne u s& Co, 2 F.d7 , 6 (t Ci. 0 3 .
s . lDu nt e mo r
.3 4 3 61 7 5 4h r 2 0 )
De emi ngwhet raco ai saesaplusbl cl m f r i i ç c e -pe t t k t tr quiest
t r ni
he
mpl nt tt
a i e ai or elef s ( ontxts cik as ha e r he
a
rve n cutoda o isu iilx ein eadcmmo sne'As r t .g l5 6U. 62, 7 -9
eiwig o rt rw n tjdca ejrec n o n esa hcofv Iba, 5 S. 6 6 87
'
(0 9 .Th s ac ut ce nn ac mplmtu d rRuel ( )6 c nie tf pe dn sta aen t nie t a
2 0 ) u , o rsr e ig o a n e l 2 b() a d niy la ig h t r o e tld o n
t
a s pton oftut bec et yconss ofnom or t n lbel a c l i .l A lhough1lbe al c tu a
s um i
r h aus he
it
e ha a s nd oncusons d. t
i r ly onsr t
pro . .o litHan sv Ken r 4 4U.. l , 2 - (9 2 , d n t c a a imaesa v c t,u s o t
K c mpan, ie . re, 0 S 5 9 5 021 1 7 ) l o o a t s n n t' d o ae s a p ne
deveopi saut y a c tt tonalcai snotce l r ie i ac
l ng tt or nd onsiui
lm
lary as d n ompl nt SeeBr kv. rol,1 F. 241
ai .
oc Ca r l 07 3d ,
2 3(t Ci.1 9 )( ti, .c n u ng; a d tv. t o Ha tn 7 5F2d1 7 ,1 78(t Ci.1 8 ) se
4 4h r 9 7 Lutg J, o c ni ) Be u et Ciy f mpo , 7 . 2 4 2 4h r 9 5 ;e
as God nv Leke 5 4F.d11 7 l 51(t Ci. 9 8 (e o nzn ta adsrc c u tsn t x e tdt
lo ro . e , 7 2 4 , 1 4h r 1 7 ) rc g iig h t itit o r i o e p ce o
asum et r eofa
s
he ol
dvocaef apr %. litf
t or o çpanig.
.
2
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?