Wright v. Colvin

Filing 17

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/17/2015. (lab)

cLERo OF CE u.s.Dl .
FI
ATRG NDK: sT GOURT
FI
LE ,VA
D

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROA N OK E D I I ON
V SI

JUt 172 1
25
Juc c
BK
DE

cL
' u
cL

TONY ALLEN W RI
GHT,
Ci lA c i N o. 7: 4CV 00548
vi ton
1

Pl ntf,
ai if

M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON
M
CA RO LYN W .COLV I ,A ctng
N
i
C o m i s one of Soc a Se liy,
m si r
i l ct t
r

By:

Hon. l E.
G en Com a
d
Chi fU nie St t s D it i tJ
e
t d a e s rc udge

Dee
f ndant
.

Pl ntf ha fl t sa ton c le ng t fna dec son oft Comm isone o Soc a
ai if s ied hi c i hal ngi he i l ii
he
si r f il
Se t i y de ng pl i ifs c ai sf di a lt i tr nce be i s a s e e a s cl iy
c u t nyi
a ntf l m or s biiy nsla
nett nd uppl m nt l e z t
r

i omebe ft u t Soca Se iyAc,asa nde 42U. C.jj41 i a 423, 42
nc
neis nder he il curt t me d,
S.
6() nd
and

U. C. 1 81# sq-r s e t l.J rs ito o ti c u tsp rua tt 4 U. C. 4 5 g
S. j 3 . e ,e p ci y u idcin f h s o r i u s n o 2 S. j 0 ( )
1
ve
a 4 U. C.j1 c( .Asr l ce byt me andaa agtme s te byt
nd 2 S.
383()3)
ete td he mor
nd r l nt ubmitd he
pa tes t i s s now bef r t co ta e w he he t Com m i s o rsfna dec s o i
r i , he s ue
o e he ur r
t r he
s i ne ' i l i i n s

s
upporedby s t nta e de e orwhehe t r i '
t
ubsa il vi nc ,
t r he e s '
good ca e't ne es ia er mandi t
us ' o c st t e
ng he

ca et t Commisone f f t rconsdeai Se 42U. C.j405()
s o he
s i r or urhe
i rton. e
S.
g.
Thepl ntf,
ai if TonyAle W rg ,wa bo n o Fe u r 11 1
l n iht s r n br a y , 976, nd e nt ly r ac
a ve ual e hed
t tnt gr dei s hool M r W rghtha bee e pl d asahe vyeq pm e tope at ,
he e h a n c . . i
s n m oye
a
ui n
r or
co t c i lbor r m e tc tr a socke i ar t i de rme sor Appa e l hel s
nsnzton a e , a ute , nd t r n e a l pa t nt t e.
r nty, a t
w or d on a s t i d ba i i 2006. O n Apr l22, 1 M r W r g fl a i a i f
ke
us a ne s s n
i
201 , . i ht ied pplc tons or
di a lt i tr nc be ft a s e e a s ctrt i
s biiy ns la e ne is nd uppl m nt l e liy ncom e bene is Ea le a i a i f
ft . ri r pplc tons or

s h be ksha pr n uns e s ul I flnghi m or r c tc am s pli ifaleg t the
uc net
d ove
ucc s f . n ii
s e e en l i , antf l ed ha
be m e di a ed f r a lf m s o s t nta ga nf le pl ym en on M a c 1 2007,d t bac
ca
s bl o l or
f ubs a i l i u m o
t
rh ,
ue o k

pr bl ms;s de ,ne k, kne pr e s fbr myal a; tta l ai sr sdior r
o e
houl r c and e oblm ; i o
gi pos-r lm tc tes s de ;
e r m ebipo a dior r s hi phr ni r sdua sofs ge yf rbr n a es a t ii a
xte
- l r s de ; c zo e a; e i l
ur r o oke nkl ; rhrts nd

btsts n r ed ma ei h sb c ; eeir t gj it i t hpa t ih; n c r n c
l ii; e v a g n i a k d troai ons n he i nd hg a d h o i
r
n
obsr tvepul o r die s Pli ifnow mai ai t theha r m aned d s bl t t
tuci
m na y s m e. antf
nt ns ha
se i
i a ed o he

p e e tme.Ast hi a i to f rd s biiy i tr nc be ft , her o dr veast tM r
r s nt i
o s pplcai n o i a lt nsla e ne is t ec r e l ha .
W rghtm e t i tr s a us r qui e e soft A c t o t fr tqua t rof201 butnot
i
t he ns led t t e r m nt
he t hr ugh he is
re
0,

tee fe .S eg n rly 4 U. C. j41 () n 4 3 a.Co s q e t M r W rg ti e tte
h r atr e e eal, 2 S. j 6 i a d 2 () n e u n l . ih s nild
y,
t dia lt i t a ebeneksonl i heha e t bls d t thebe a dia e f a lf m sof
o s biiy nsl nc
r
t
y f
s sa ihe ha
c me s bl d or l or

s tni ganf e oyme o o beor M ac 31 201
ubsa tal i ul mpl nt n r f e rh , 0.Se g neal 42U. C.jj
e e rly,
S.
423()
a.
M r W rghtsc am swe e de edupon i ta consde a i a r consde a i He
. i ' li
r ni
niil
i r ton nd e
i r ton.

t nr uetda r eve aétno he rnga r viw beor a Admi sr tveLa J .
he eq se nd ec i d
vo ai nd e e f e n
nitai w udge
I a opi on daedM a c 27, 3, heAdmi sr tveLa J
n n ni
t
r h 201 t
nita i
w udgea s f md t tpli ifi not
l o ot ha antf s
dia ed. TheLa J
s bl
w udgenle t tM r W rghts f r fom s ve als ve e i r e s
l d ha . i ufe s r e r e r mpaim nt,
i udi c oni ba k pai pol r hr t w ih pr babl dege r tve di c di e e oft hi ;
ncl ng hr c c
n; ya t opa hy t o e
ne a i
s s as
he ps

di t i hype tnson;a t ton det thy a tviydior r n ey;pe s iy dior r
asolc
re i ten i
ki per c i t s de ' nxi t r onalt s de '
,
,

d p e so ; n n b sa us ; n ac h l e n e c .( 1 2 .Be a eo t i c mbn to o
e r si n c n a i b e a d lo o d pe d n e TR 7 ) c us f h s o iain f
i pai me s t La J
m r nt , he w udge de e m i d t tpl ntf i di a ed f a1 ofhi pa tr l va w or
t r ne ha ai i f s s bl or 1
s s e e nt k

r e . Howe , heLa J
ols
ver t
w udgehel t tM r W rghtr t i s t intf tona ca ciy f a
d ha . i ea ns ufk e hnci l pa t or

lmiedr ngeofs de aywor a tviy.( 1 .TheLa J
i t a
e ntr k ci t TR 74)
w udgea s s dpli ifsr sdua
sese antf e i l
f i
unctonalcapaciy as f l s:
t
olow

2

Afe c r ulc i r to oft e ier or t t r i ned fndst tt
tr a ef onsde ai n he ntr ec d, he mde sg
i ha he
cai a thast r sdua f nc i lc ct t pe f m s de a y wo k a defne
lm n
he e i l u tona apa iy o ror e nt r r s i d

i 20C. R.404.5674)and41 9674 e e t cai ntc n stf attlof
n
F.
1 a
6. a) xc pt he l ma a i or oa
6 hour ,sa a o wak f rat a of2 holr ,a oc sonal ci b,balnce
s t nd nd/ r l o ot l
zs nd ca i ly lm
a ,
soop,kne ,a c ouc butne rc a a no r pe ii f c r s The
t
el nd r h,
ve r wl nd
e ttve oot ontol.
c am a s d a d he g s haz r ,a f e .Duet t cli ntsm e a
l i nt houl voi i ht , a ds nd um s
o he a ma ' nt l

i ar n sh i l tdt 1t 2 se j bi tu to .
mp ime t e s i e o o tp o nsr cins
mi
( 17 .Gi n s h ar i f tona ca ct a a trc i rngMr W rghtsa
TR 4) ve uc esdual unci l pa iy, nd fe onsdei
. i ' ge,
ed a i n, pr o w or e r e ,a wel ast s i o f om a voc tona e r ,t La
uc to and i r k xpe i nce s l e tm ny r
a i l xpe t he w

J
udgef md t tpl i ifr t nss t intc pact t peror s ve als c fc s de a y wor
ot ha antf eai ufk e a iy o f m e r pe ii e nt r
k

r lse it i sg i n ml e i t en to a e o o ( 1 0 8 ) Ac o dn l,he
o e xsi n int t mb r n h ain l c n my. TR 8 - 1 . c r igy t
ng
ka
La J
w udge uli a e y conc ude t tM r W rghti notdi a ed,a t the i note il d t
tm t l
l d ha
. i s
s bl nd ha
s
ntte o

b n t u d rete fd rlp o rm .S ec n rly 2 C. R. j4 4.5 0 g a d41 .2 ( )
e eks n e i r e ea r g n e e eal, 0 F. j 0 1 2 4 ) n 69 0 g .
h
M r W rg a ald t La J e' dec son t t Soc a Se urt Ad i sr ton'
. i ht ppe e he w udg s ii o he i l c iy m nita i s
Appe l Cot l Shorl a trhe fl hi appe , antf s
a s mci.
t fe
y
ied s
alpli if ubmit anumberofne me c l
ted
w di a
r po t doc z e i team e f ne physc ls
e rs tm ntng r t nt or w
i a ympt m s a wel asf hi l ng-t ndi
o , s l or s o sa ng
ps chi t i di o der How e r t Appe l Cot ci e n ualy a ed t La J
y a rc s r .
ve , he
a s m l ve t l dopt he w udge' opi on
s ni

ast fna de i i oft Com misone .Ha ngno e use a 1a lbl admi sr tve
he i l c son he
s i r vi
w xha t d 1 vaia e
nitai
r m e es M r W r g ha a al d t t sc t
e di , . i ht s ppe e o hi our .

W hiepli ifma be dia ed f c ran f m sofe o e , hec ucalf c ua
l antf y
s bl or e ti or
mplym nt t r i a t l
de e mi ton i whe he pl ntf i dia ed f ralf r ofs tnta ganf le oy e .
t r na i s t r ai if s s bl o l o ms ubsa il i u mpl m nt

Se 42U. C.jj423()2)a 1 () Theeaeftrelme sofpr whihmus be
e
S.
d ( nd 382ca . r r oz e nt
oof c
t
c i r i maki s ha a yss The eeeme sa es
onsdeed n
ng uc n nal i. s l nt r ummmi eda f l
z s olows:( )
1
obe tveme c fcsa ci c fndi ;2)t opi onsa concuso ofte tng
jci
dial a t nd lnial i ngs ( he ni nd
l ins r ai

p y iins ( )s be t e i e c o p y ia ma ietto so i ann ns a d s rb d
h sca ; 3 u j ci v d n e f h sc l n fsain f mp i e t, s e cie
ve
3

t oughacli tstsi
hr
aman' e tmony;a ( t cai tse ai voc i hitr r i al
nd 4) he l man' duc ton, atonal so y,esdu
s ls an a Vie v.Fi h,438F. 11 11 60( hCi.1 ) Undewoodv. biof,
kil, d ge. tk
nc
2d 57, 59- 4t r 971;
z
Ri c f
298F. 850,851(t Ci.1 2)
2d
4h r 96 .
Afe ar e oft r c d i t sc e, hec t us c udet tt r i s tnta
tr eviw
he e or n hi as t our m t oncl ha he e s ubsa il

e de et s
vi nc o uppor t Comm iso rsdenilofpli ifsc am f diabiiy i tr nce
t he
s i ne '
a
antf l i or s lt nsla
be ft . W hie pl i ifdetnie y s f r d f om a va i t ofm us ul ke e alpr e s
ne is
l a ntf i t l uf e e r
re y
c os l t obl m ,

es i l i t l rbac dtrng t pe i bef et e r ton ofhi i ur d sauson
pecaly n he owe
k, li he rod or he xpia i
s ns e tt
M a c 31, 0, heco tbei ve t tt Adm i sr tveLa J
r h 201 t
ur le s ha he
nita i
w udger s bl r le o
ea ona y e id n
co ula i r por s f o Dr W iln H .Hum phr e ,J . an e e g y m e c ls i ls ,
ns t tve e t r m . li m
i s r , m r enc
di a pec a i t and

Dr M a vn A.Ga dne ,J . ac i ca ps hol s,i c l ng t tM r W rghtwasno
. ri
r r r, lni l yc ogit n onc udi ha . i
t
dia e prort t tm eoft eco ula i su e i Jmeof2011 Alhough Dr Humphres
s bld i o he i
hes ns t tve t di s n t
. t
.
i
not d citc fndi ofr uc d moton i t ba a hi ,hi r por cea l s
e lrial i ngs ed e
i n he ck nd ps s e t l ry upporsa
t
fndi ofr sdua f to lc ct f a l a ts de a y e ri la tviy.M or over t
i ng e i l unci na apa iy or t e s e ntr xe tona ci t
e , he
c ltnot t ta ltrM lloft l
otr es ha ae t he umbars ner ve e m ode a ef c ta t o t wiho
pi e ald
r t a e rhr pahy t ut

sgnsofsenossorner er i pi e e .
i
t l
v oot m ng m nt
A sf rM r W r gh ' ps hi ti c ton, olow i a e m i ton o J 29,2011
o
. i t s yc a r c ondii f l ng n xa na i n une
,

Dr Gad e da n s da j sme td s r e wi mie a xeya d p e so a tnin d fct
. r n r ig o e du t n io d r t x d n it nd e rs in; te to eii
h
/
hy a tviydi o de 'a pe s iy dior r Dr Ga dne as e s M r W rghtsf tonal
per c i t s r r nd r onalt s de . . r r s s ed . i ' unc i
,
c pac t asf l s
a iy olow :

Thecli nti a et pe f sm pl a r peii t ksa m ant i r ulr
a ma s bl o ronn i e nd e ttve as nd i an eg a
a t nda i t w o kpl c He i a e t pe f m w or a tvii on a c it nt
te nce n he r a e. s bl o r or
k c i tes
ons s e
basi H e i abl t per orm w or actvii w ihoutspeci oraddii
s. s e o f
k i tes t
al
tonal
s vii Hei a et complt anor lwor y orwor ek wihout
uper son. s bl o
ee
ma
kda
kwe
t
i em z i nsr uli f om hi ps hi t i c ton.The cl i a w a ca bl of
nt pto es tng r
s yc a rc ondii
a m nt s pa e
4

a ce i ali t c i gi n byt se mi ra r s
c ptng l nsnztons ve
hi xn ne nd e pondi a o i t y.
ng ppr prael
Thecli nti lkel t ha no mor t . am ode ae wor r l t s il
a ma s i y o ve
e h:1
1
rt
k-e aed oca
i i nti e a tonwih c
mpanne ntr ci
t owor r a wih t ge r publc. i a et
ke s nd t he ne al i He s bl o
de wih t us lsr s or e ount r d i compe ii wo k.
al t he ua te s s nc e e n
ttve r

( 47 .Theps c ogitase s pli ifsGAF a 65.
TR 0)
y hol s s sed antf'
t 1
I s r ,t c tbeleve t tt r i s t nta e de e t s
n ho t he our i s ha he e s ubs a i l vi nc o uppor t
t he

Comm isone ' deenni i t tM r W rg wa no dia ed f ra1f m sofwor i Jmeof
s i rs t naton ha . i ht s t s bl o 1 or
k n t
201 ,whe hewass e by bot Dr Humphresa Dr Gar r The e i no r as t bei ve
1
n
en
h .
i nd . dne . r s e on o le
t tpl ntf ' physc ,me a ,a e i lpr e swe em or s ve e a any tm eon or
ha ai ifs
ial ntl nd motena eblm
r
e e r t
i

b f r M ac 31 2 0 ted yo wh c panifls e j y dis r dsau .I f l wst a t e
e o e rh , 01 ,h a n ih litf a t n o e n u e tt s t ol h t h
o
Co misone ' fnalde son de ngpl i ifscai f dia lt i ur ebe ft m us be
m si rs i
cii
nyi
antf l m or s biiy ns anc ne is t
a fr e
fim d.
Pl ntf sa i ton f s e nt ls trt i m ebe ispr e sdif r nt
ai if pplcai or uppl me a ecliy nco
neft es nt fe e

pr e
obl ms.l s e st t f l ng t c ula i sudi s M r W rghtsps a rccondii
t e m ha , olowi he ons ttve t e , . i ' ychiti
ton
de e i a ed. Begi ng on M a 1 201 pl i ifw a s n on a nlm be ofoc s ons b
t r or t
nni
y 4, 2, a ntf s ee
l r
ca i
y
Ta ar Ba dw i am e alhea t ntr e pr c ii ne . Att tm e ofhe fr te
m a l n,
nt
lh ls a tto r
he i
r i s ncount rw ih
e t

pli if M s Bal ndi nos bipolrdior ,sve ewihps hotcfatr .( 47 .
antf, . dwi ag ed - a s der e r t yc i e tles TR 4)
On J 11 201 M s Bal n not t tpli ifwa s f rng fo s ve e de e son,a
une , 2, . dwi ed ha antf s ufe i r m e r pr s i nd

t thi a ey, - a dior r a de esi weealworeni ( 65 .M r W rg
ha s nxit bipolr s de , nd pr son r l s ng. TR 9) . iht
wa s me tls deprsedwhe s nonJ y27,201 ( 655) Howe ,o Augus 27,
s o wha e s e s
n ee
ul
2. TR
.
ver n
t

'The gl lasesm e off ncini , o GAF,i u e t rpoth ciiin'j d me to tesbe ts
oba s s nt u to ng r
s s d o e r te lnca s u g n f h u j c'
ove a ll veloff nc i ng. GAF s e be we n 61 a 70 r es t onl s m e m id s m pt sors difculy
rl e
n toni A
cor t e
nd epr en s y o
l y om
ome f i t
i s a, upai ,o s
n ocilocc tonal r choolf to ng, ge alyf to ngprtywelwihs em e ngf i eperonal
uncini but ner l uncini e t l, t om
ani ulntr s

rlto his Ameia Psc arcAso ito Dig otca dSaitc l n a o Me tl s res4 (t e .e t
eains p . rc n y hiti s cain, a n si n ttsia Ma u l f na Diod r 7 4h d tx
rv 2 0 )
e. 0 0.
5

2 2, s Bad na anf u dt t litf' s mp o weewo s nn ( 6 ) On
01 M . lwi g i o n ha pan ifs y tms r re ig. TR 51.
Fe u y 25,201 M s B a dw i obs n'd t M r W rghtwass f rng f om pa c a t c
br ar
3, . l n e e hat . i
uf e i r
ni ta ks

sv rl i sp rwe k ( 6 ) Ath t o tea mi srtv h a ig teAd n sr tv
e e a tme e e . TR 68 . te i f h d nitaie e rn ,h miitai e
me
La J d ea r e t hodter c r o e f ra a dto l se s n fo M s Bad n.(
w u g g e d o l h e o d p n o n d iina a s sme t r m . lwi TR
1 98, ) Shorl atrt he rng,M s Badwi s te ame ca ase s ntof
97- 220 .
ty fe he a i
. l n ubmitd
di l ss me
pl n if sme ala lt f wo k-ea e a tvii . Stt d s ci ty, s Ba d n f undt t
aitf
nt biiy or r r lt d c i tes a e uc nc l M . l wi o
ha

Mr W rg t x ein e s ro l tto si hsa ii t fn to i awo kstigz ( 6 2
. ih e p re c s eius i ai n n i b ly o u cin n
mi
t
r e t . TR 6 n
66)
.
The A dm i s r tve La J
nit a i
w udge dec i d t gi g ea w e g t M s Ba dw i sr por s
lne o ve r t i ht o . l n' e t

a as e s e .Cii Soc a Se trt Rulng 06- p, heLa J
nd s s m nt tng i l c liy i
03 t
w udgec r cty not d t t asa
ore l
e ha ,

ntrepr tto r Ms Bad ni no a a e a eme ca s c ( 1 ) Se alo20
ls aciine, . lwi s t n cc ptbl di l oure. TR 78 . e s
C. R.j41 927( TheLa J deemi dt gi Fe t wei t t ps hol c l
F.
6. *.
w udge tr ne o ve aer ght o he yc ogia
r por fom Dr Gadne .( 179) I t sr pe tt c t le st tt La J
e tr
. r r TR
. n hi es c,he our beive ha he w udge'
s
a l i i s wha s pe t i muc a M s Ba d n frts w M r W rghts ve a m o hs
nayss s ome t us c , nas h s . l wi is a
. i e r l nt
a trDr Ga dne ' e
fe . r r s xnmi ton,a i muc asM s Badwi r cognied pli ifsm o e
na i nd nas h
. l n e
z
a ntf
r
s r ous s pt m s a ofm or r e ons t l a e n ,i s e st tM r W r g ha now
ei
ym o
s
e ec nt e . n ny ve t t e m ha
. i ht s

r r d a to lm e alhe t te t e , es tng i i e v i by aps hi tit
equie ddii na nt alh r am nt r uli n ntr enton
yc ars.
A spr vi l not i a
e ousy ed, n ppea i t La J
lng he w udge' de i i t t A ppea s Cot c l M r
s c s on o he
l
m i, .

W rghts itd ne me c le denc ts e st ti M a of201 pl i ifr quie
i ubm te w di a vi e.I e m ha n y
3, antf e r d
hos t lt e t e f r s pt s c it ntw ih s gm oi di r i ult s H e e t l c m e
pia r a m nt o ym om ons s e
t i
d ve tc ii .
ven ualy n

2Si ii nty, s.Balwi i c t t ts co dnot s spl ntf' c tonpro t t tmeofhe tr t
pzfca l M
d n ndiaed ha he ul ases ai ifs ondii ir o he i
r is

c n twi Mr Wrg to Ma 1 , 01 .( 6 )
o tc t . ih n y 4 2 2 TR 65.
h
6

und rt c eofDr Punee Gil a i e nit Bas d o he obs r to , .Gilr f redM ..
e he ar
.
t l, n nt r s. e n r e vai ns Dr l e e r
1
.
W rghtt Dr Da Ha ngtn, ps hi tit Afe hi i tale
i o . n ni o a yc ars. tr s nii xami to o J y 11 201 Dr
nai n n ul , 3, .
Ha ngtn dignos de e so bipol afe tvedior r a pa a d s hi phr ni
ni o a
ed pr s i n, - ar f ci
s de , nd r noi c zo e a.
Ho ve ,heps hi titsm e a sat e m wasnoto ry r m aka e,a hems e s d
we r t
yc ars ' nt l t us xa
ve l e r bl nd
sse

pli ifsGAF a 65. ( 1 ) Se e r17 201 Dr Ha ngt co ee ame c l
antf
s 3 TR 37 .On ptmbe , 3, . ni on mpltd
dia
a s s e ofpl ntf sm e a a lt f w o k-el t d a tvii s D r H a rngt n' fndi a
s es m nt
ai i f
nt l biiy or r r a e c i t e . . r i o s i ngs s

t pl ntf swor r l td ca c t a e sm ia t t eofM s Badwi i t thenot s rous
o ai if
k-e ae pa iy r i l r o hos
. l n,n ha
ed e i
lm ia i ast m os wor r a e c
i ttons o
t k-elt d ompone s
nt .Theps hitita ti e pl i ifspr blm s
yc a rs trbut d antf
o e

t s hi fe tvedior wihpaa a poorj me , ndi s c r is .( 1 .
o c zoafci s der t rnoi,
udg nta mpule ontol sues TR 4)

Dr Harngo o ie t t r W rg ti u a l t wo k ( 1 ) Th d co q e to e hi
. ri tn pn d ha M . ih s n b e o r . TR 6 . e o tr u sin d s
abiiy t as e st ons tofpli ifsdia lt i m uc a heha te t d M r W rg f onl
lt o s s he e
antf
s biiy, nas h s
d rae
. i ht or y

t monhs.( 1 .
wo t TR 6)
TheAppe l Cot ldee m i d t tt ne me c le de edi no wa r nta
a s mci t r ne ha he w di a vi nc d t ra ny
c nge i t A dm i s r tve La J
ha
n he
nit a i
w udge' de i i be a e t r por sr a e t a û a e tm e.'
s c s on, c us he e t el t o l t r i '
l

( 2 .Th Ap e l Comcl ttdt a t en w e i e c é o sn t fe t h d cso a u
TR ) e p as t i sae h t h e v d n e û e o af c t e e iin bo t
d
whehe ( r W rg lwa dia e begimi orbeor M ac 27,201 5t daeoft La
t r M . iht s sbld r ng
f e rh
3,5he t he w

J d e sd cso ( 2 .
u g ' e ii n. TR )
A s um i t tt ne m e ca r po t s it d by M r W r ghtdi e ty t t A ppea s
s ng ha he w di l e r s ubm te
. i
r c l o he
l
Co m c la e be tc r c e i d asne e d e, he c t i ve t tpl i i fhases a ihe
t i r s ha a t rze
w vi enc t our bele s ha a nt f
t bls d

3Aspr vi l not , aGAF s ebet e 61a 70r pr s nt o ymid s o ors medit t i
e ousy ed
cor we n
nd e e e s nl l ympt ms o
fkuly n
s aloc upatonal o s
oci , c i : r choolf toni bu ge r l f nctoni pr tywel,wih s em ea ngf i e e s
unc i ng, t ne aly u i ng et
l t om
ni ul ntm ronal

rlto s p . rc nPsc iti Aso ito , a notca Stt tc l n a o Me tl s r es 7(t e tx
eainhis Amela y harc s cain Dig si nd ai ia Ma u l f na Dio d r 4 4h d.e t
s
rv 2 0 )
e. 0 0.
7

ç
û
good c us 'f r m a ofhi c et t Comm isone f f t rc i r ton o t m e is
a e' or e nd
s as o he
s i r or urhe onsde a i n he rt .

I Bo d r v. c lr 7 7F.d9 4( t Ci.1 8 )t eUntdS ae Co r o Ap asf rt
n r es He ke , 7 2 5 4h r 9 5 ,h ie tts u t f pe l o he
Fourh Cic ts ma i e t sa r t rwhih amoton f r mand ba e on ne
t r ui um rz d he t nda ds mde
c
i or e
sd
w
evi ncemus be c i r .
de
t onsde ed'

A rv e n c u t yr ma aSo il cliyc s t te ( mmiso elo
e iwig o r ma e nd ca Se t t a e o h Co s in r n
r
t bassofne y dic r e de ei f urpr r quiie a em e .Thee de e
he i
wl s ove ed vi nc f o
e e st s r t
vi nc
m us be ' e e ntt t de e m i ton ofdi a lt a t tm e t a i a i w a
t ' l va o he t r na i
r
s biiy t he i he pplc ton s
fr tfl a notm e e y cu ul tve. M ic l v.Schwei r 699 F. 1 188
i s ied nd
r l m a i ' t he l
'
ke ,
2d 85,

( h Ci.1 3) l mus bemaei t t e e t tt (
4t r 98 . t t
tralo he xtntha he Commisone 'l
si rs
dec son ' i tr as na y ha bee dif r nt' d t ne evi nc bee be or
i i ' gh e o bl ve n f e e 'ha he w de e n f e
m

he .Ki v.Caia 599F. 597,599( h Ci.1 ;Si v. ri,631
r ng
lfno,
2d
4t r 979) ms Hars
F.d2 , ( t Ci.1 8 ) Th r mu tb g o c us frt ecama t f i t
2 6 28 4h r 9 0 . ee s e o d a e o h li n ' al o
s me
s tt e denc whe t cai wasbeor t (
ubmi he vi e n he l m
f e he Commisonel 42U. C.j
s i r,
S.
405g) a t cli ntmus prs ntt t rma ngcou t' tlas age r
( , nd he ama
t e e o he e ndi
r ' e t neal
a
s i oft naur ' t ne e de e. K i 599 F. at599.
how ng he t e'of he w vi nc
ng,
2d

777 F. a 955.
2d t
l t i t ntc s t ne m e c le de e w a r c ve by t A ppe s Counc l
n he ns a a e, he w di a vi nc
s e ei d
he
al
i.

Thus t r i no quesi a t t naur oft e de e. M or ver gi n t f ct t tt
, he e s
ton s o he t e he vi nc
eo , ve he a s ha he
ne e de ewasobvi usy ge r e i t c s ofc i ngte t t a t tt r po t
w vi nc
o l ne atd n he oure ontnui r a men , nd ha he e rs
we e f r r t t AppeasCounc l t r c n benoconc r ast a f iur t s
r o wa ded o he
l
i, he e a
e n o ny al e o ubmi t
t he
e de e w hie t c ai w asbe or t Com m i s one . W ihoutq s i Dr H a rngt s
vi nc
l he l m
f e he
si r
t
ue ton, . r i on'
r por sr a e t t s e m e a he t s pt sw hi h w e e c i r by t La J
e t el t o he nm
nt l alh ym om
c
r ons de ed
he w udge i
n
hi opi o
s ni n.

Ast t r m ani eeme i t Bo de st s,t c t ive t tt r i a
o he e i ng l nt n he r r e t he our bele s ha he e s
s e ha cl e que to a t whe he c i r ton ofDr H a r ngt sr por m i r s na y
om w t os
si n s o
t r ons de a i
. r i on' e t ght ea o bl
r ul i a di er adm i s r i di posii i M r.W r ght scase. A spr ousl not t
es t n
ff ent
ni t atve s ton n
i '
evi y ed, he

ps hi titque tonedhi a lt t pr dea as esm e a t pli ifsc ton a atm e
yc ars
si
s biiy o ovi n s s nt s o antf ondii t i
be or t A d i sr tve La J
f e he m ni t a i
w udge i s d hi opi o M or ve , he e i no i ca i a t
s ue s ni n.
eo r t r s ndi ton s o
8

whehe Dr Ha ngt bele st tM r W rghtss mpt a epe m a nt orwhehe t y
t r . ni on i ve ha . i ' y oms r r ne ,
t r he
m ihtbes e s ul addr s e t ough a opraete t e a media i On t ot r
g
ucc s f ly
e s d hr
ppr i t r am nt nd
c ton. he he
ha D r H a ngt sfndi a e e s taly t s m e ast e ofM s Ba dw i w ho s w M r
nd, . ni on' i ngs r s en i l he n
hos
. l n,
a
.

W rghtprort t dae oft Law J
i
i o he t
he
udge' opi o Onc a i t c t t t tt r i not
s ni n.
e gan,he our no es ha he e s
nec s miy a ir c iabl co lc bewe n t r po t ofDr Ga dne ,M s Badwi a Dr
e s l n re onc l e nfit t e he e rs
. r r . l n, nd .
Ha ngtn. l s e st tt r hasbee s m ewo s ni ofpli ifsc to a t tM s
ni o t e m ha he e
n o
r e ng
antf' ondii n, nd ha
.
Badwi a Dr Ha ngtn smpl s M r W rghta a lt rpoi i tm e.I s t gi n t
l n nd . ni o i y aw . i t a e nt n i
n hor, ve he
c r ntsaeoft medialr c d i M r W rghtsc e,ta
ure tt
he
c e or n . i ' as i ppea st tt r a el r ol d
r ha he e r m es ve
f t que to w hi h s d be c m it d t t ad i s r tve f c fnde i t fr t
ac ual s i ns c houl
om te o he m ni t a i a t i r n he i s
i t e. Upo cons de a i oft Bor r f ct s t cour c udest tpl ntf ha
ns mw
n
i r ton he
de s a or , he
t oncl
ha ai i f s

esa ihed I
t bls G
good c us ' f rr m a ofhi ca et t Comm iso rf f rhe and mor
a e' o e nd
s s o he
s i ne or u t r
e
de a ld c i r ton oft ne m e ca e de .
t ie onsde a i
he w di l vi nce
The c tr c ze t tt new s i s o by pl i ifm i a g bl f l i a
our e ogni s ha he
ubm s i ns
a ntf ght r ua y a l n

s e tdif e c t or i m uc a t r porswe e frtpr dedt t Appe l Counc l
om wha fer nt a eg y, nas h s he e t r is ovi o he
as
i,
a we ea t lyr e e d byt Appe l Counci i isde a ofpl i ifsr
nd r c ua l ef r nce
he
as
l n t ni l
antf eques f
t or
r e . The c tnot t tt Unied St t Cour ofA ppe s f t Fou h Ci c tw a
evi w
our es ha he t
a es
t
al or he rt r ui s

pr e e wih asmia pr durls e roi t c eofM e rv. t e, F. 700( h
esntd t i lr oce a c nai n he as
ve Asnl 662 3d
4t
Ci.201 ) l t tcae,heCour ma t f l ngc
r 1 . n ha s t
t de he olowi omme sast t ase s ntt begi n
nt o he s sme o
ve
t e de s
o vi nce ubmit t t Appe sCot i f isc i r ton i deer ni whehe t
ted o he
al
mcl or t onsde a i n t mi ng
t ro
r vi w t opi on ofa A dm i s r tve La J
e e he ni
n
nit a i
w udge'
.
O n consi aton oft r d asa w hol we s m pl cnnnotdet m i whet
der i
he ecor
e,
i y
er ne
her
s t nta e de e s pporst A LJSdeni lofbe t he e The ALJ
ubs a i l vi nc u
t he
'
a
ne ks r .

e
mpha iedt tt r co dbe or i l ke i esrc i plc o t cl ma by
sz ha he e r f e t ac d û titons a ed n he ai nt
r
9

ate tng physcan,' uggesi t tt se de i yga plye ar ei is
r ai
i i 's
tng ha hi vi ntar p a d ol n t
de i i M e ers e
c son. y ubs quenty obt ne t sm isng e de ef o hi teai
l ai d hi s i vi nc r m s r tng
physcan.Tha e denc co r bo a est opi on ofDr W eis as , c t
ii
t vi e r o r t he ni
. s gl s whih he

ALJha rj ce . toh rr c r e i e c c e ie b t eALJc nlcswi t e
d ee td Bu te e o d v d n e rdtd y h
o tit t h
h
ne e de e.TheAppe l Counci m a t ne e de epa toft r c d but
w vi nc
as
l de he w vi nc r he e or
sl miy d ni r viw oft ALJde son.Thus no f c fnde hmsm a any
lmm l e ed e e
he
cii
, ati r
de
fndi a t t te tng physc a sopi on ora tmpt d t r onciet t
i ngs s o he r a i
ii n' ni
te e o ec l ha
evi ncewih t c lc i a s ppori ev de e i t r c d. s sng t
de
t he onfitng nd u
tng i nc n he e or As es i he
pr tvevaueofcompe i e de e i q n es e i ly t r e oft f t
oba i
l
tng vi nc s uit s nta l he ol
he ac
fnde . e c nnotunde tke i i t trti t nce. r o e wemus r m a
i rW n
ra t n he i s nsn
The ef r ,
t e nd
t c e f f t rf tfnd ng.
he as or urhe ac i i
662 F.d a 707.
3 t
Fort r as sa e t cou tfndst tt Co misone ' tna decson de ng
he e ons t t d, he r i ha he m s i r s i l ii
nyi
pl n if sa i a i f di a lt i tr nc bene isi s
ai t f pplc ton or s biiy ns la e
ft s uppored by s t nta e denc
t
ubs a i l vi e.

Ac or ngl t fnalde i i oft Com misone a r ar t sa i a i f be t mus
c di y, he i
c son he
s i r s eg ds hi pplc ton or neks t

beafr d.La v Cee rz e 3 F.d6 (t Ci. 9 6 .Ast t a p rin o t ec s
fime
ws . lb e z , 68 2 40 4 h r 1 6 )
o h t o to f h a e
de lng wih pl i ifsa i to f rs e nt ls ct iyi omebe ft , heco tha f md
ai
t antf pplcai n o uppl me a e l t nc
r
ne is t
ur s ot
G
t
good c us ' f rr m a oft c e t t Co m i sonerf r c i r ton ofne m e c
a e ' o e nd he as o he m s i
o ons de a i
w
di al

e denc Upon r mand,i t Commi so ri una et de det sr
vi e.
e
f he
s i ne s bl o ci hi emai ng cli i
ni am n
pl i t f s f vorbas d on t e s i r co d, he Com m i s one s l c
a n if a
e
he xitng e r t
s i r ha l onduc a s e e a
t uppl m nt l
a i s r tve hea i a whi h bot sdesw ilbe alow e t pr s nta t o le de a
dm nit a i
rng t c
h i
l
l d o e e ddii na vi nce nd

a g me t Ana p o raej d me ta do d re tr dt i d y
r u n . p r p it u g n n r e nee hs a .
The Cl r i diec e t s nd c r ii d copi oft sopi on t a lcot s ofr or
e k s r t d o e e tfe
es hi
ni o l m el ec d.

DATED:Th s l
i 7

d yo J y, 01 .
a f ul 2 5

Chi fUnied St t sD i ti tJ
e
t
a e sr c udge

1
0