Thornburg v. Bristol, VA City Jail

Filing 12

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/25/2014. (kab)

e m r:OFFS S.
a
CEU. aBr.
ATROANA ,
VA
FlED
l
-

I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I
STR I T C O U RT
C
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O A NO K E DI I O N
V SI

LARRY M I
CHAEL TH ORNBURG ,

N2#

'29
21

J A G.
ULI
. ERK
CL
BY;
'
D
CL
ERK

CASE NO .7: 4CV00605
1

Pl nt f ,
ai i f

W.

M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON
NI

BRI
STOL VA CI JAI
TY
L,

By: G l n E.C onr
e
ad
Chi Uni St es D i ri Judge
ef ted at
st ct

D e e nt
f nda .

La y M i ha Tho bur a Vig ni i t pr e di pr K ,fl t s cvi rght
n.
c el m g,
r i a nma e oc e ng o
ied hi i l i s

a ton plrua t 42 U. C.j 1
ci zs nt o
S.
983. Tho
mbur alge t the si d i wae fom a laky
g le s ha
lppe n tr r
e

tie a te Brso Ci J i (teji' ,fl,a d b o e h sha d He a s rsta b c u ej i
o lt t h it l t al dh al) el n r k i n .
y
:
'
se t h t e a s al
o t il ha k wn f rmo t t a t t i tha be nla n ,hej i wr n f ly c ag dhm
f as d no o nhs h t he ol d e e kig t al o g ul h r e i
k
e
f pa toft cos ofm e ca ca e he r eved f hi hand. He s e r mbur e e f s h
or r
he t
di l r
ec i
or s
e ks ei
s m nt or uc
c t a c pe a i f pa n a s f rng. U pon r vi w oft r or how e r t co t
os s nd om ns ton or i nd uf e i
e e
he ec d,
ve , he ur

fndst tt a ton mus be s
i ha he ci
t umm a iy dim is d asl aly fi ous.
rl s s e
eg l rvol

The c t i r quie t dimis a a ton or cli fld by a prs r agans a
our s e r d o s s ny c i
am ie
ione
i t
gove n ent le iy or ofi e i t c tde e m i s t ac i n or c ai i f i ous m a i i ,
r m a ntt
fc r f he our t r ne he to
l m s rvol , lc ous

o fist saea cam o whc rle ma b g a td. 28U. C.j 1 5 b ( ) To sae a
r al o tt li n ih eif y e rn e
S.
91 A( )1.
tt
c us of a ton unde j1
a e
ci
r 983,a pli if mus esabls t the has be de i d ofrght
antf
t t ih ha
en prve
i s
gua a e by t Consiuton or lw s oft Unie St t s a t tt s d prva i r s t
r nt ed
he
tt i
a
he
td a e nd ha hi e i ton e uled
fom c
r
onduc c
t omm itd by a pe s n a tng unde c o ofsa e lw . W es v.At ns 48 U.
te
r o ci
r ol r t t a
t
ki , 7 S.

42( 988 . Thej i,ast onl dee n Thom btr ha nn di t saci i notaû ro '
1 )
al he y fnda t
tg s me n hi ton, s
û s n'
pe

s be tt s i u d rj 1 8 P e l Re o 2 3F.d8 , 0 0W L 2 5 , t*1( t Ci. a
u j c o ut n e 9 3. rva v. n , 0 3 21 2 0
0 91 a 4h r J n.
2000) (mpubls d) ( i W ilv.Mihia De tof Stt Polc ,491 U. 58,71
t
ihe quotng l
c g n p'
ae ie
S.

1

( 9 9 M c y v. e a e k Co rcin lCe tr 7 8F. p 8 0,8 3 9 ( D. .1 9 )
1 8 :; co Ch sp a e re to a n e, 8 Su p. 9 9 -4 E. Va 9 2
(i igct almmu efo s t ndno ap ro f r r s so j 1 8 )
tndn iyj i i n rm uia
t e s n o pupo e f 9 3 .

Be a s Th r b r c n tp e ali aj 1 8 cam a ans t ej i,h c u t imis s
c u e o n u g n no r v i n
9 3 li g i t h al te o r d s se
h sc mplitwi u prj ie pzs a tt j1 5 b () a lg l fi oo s1 Th Clr i
i o an t t eudc , l u n o 91 A() 1, s e al rv lu . e ek s
ho
r
y
diece t s nd c e oft smemor ndum o ni a ac om pa ng o de t pl i if
r td o e opi s hi
a
pi on nd c
nyi r r o antf.

ENTER:Thi X
s

da ofNove r 201
y
mbe, 4.
ChifUnie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge

' The c talo f t tThor g' c r ntale tonsf i t sae aconsiui ly sg tc ntcli
our s mds ha
nbur s ure lga i al o tt
tt tonal inii a am

aantay nea teji.Posbl ngi n eb otcas i fiijt rparo rpaetetito t tk ohe
g is n o th al si e el c y fiil,n aln o e i r elc h ol ro ae t r
ge
e

s ft pe a to s smpl d e n tgv rs t a c ntmto lcam ato a l t e j 1 3 S e eg, u t
aey r cuin , i y o s o ie ie o ny o si ina ll cin be md r 98 . e , ..Co ny
ofSacament v.Le s 5 U . . 8 3 8 9( 9 8 (1 h Co si to d e n tg aa ted ec r o t p r o
r
o
wi, 23 S 3 , 4 1 9 ) (T) e ntt in o s o u rn e u ae n he at f
g
u
sae ofk i s la lt f neglgen l i lced ha m i cae i ly be t t t e hol 'of c tt i
tt t al; ibiiy or
i ty nfit
r s tgorcal neah he hr s d'
onsiutonal

p oe to )
rtcins.
2