Staton v. Commonwealth Of Virginia et al

Filing 10

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/26/2014. (kab)

e O u o- l : Dl a
eeu
:m

A q A /i,A
T oN v
F#
LED

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R T H E W ESTERN D I
STR I T O F VI G I A
C
R NI
R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI
G O RD O N S.STAT O N ,

D 2 2j
E&
j
I
B JULA
K
D UT
Y

,

CA SE N O .7: 4CV 00622
1

Pl nt f ,
ai i f
V.

M EM O M N DU M O PI O N
NI

C O M M O N W EA LTH O F VI G I A ,
R NI
By: G l E .Conr
en
ad
Chi Uni St esD i ri Judge
ef ted at
st ct

W K ,
D ef
endant
s.

Gor Sc tStt aVigni i t pr e ng pr K ,fld t sco ai a i tt
don ot a on, r i a nma e oce di
o
ie hi mpl nt gans he

Com monwe t of Vigi a,t Va Polc De rm e 'Ditit 9 Pr ton & Pa ol a
alh
r ni t
U. . ie pa t nt' src
oba i
r e, nd
De rmen ofCoreci , l ng t he s dbec
pa t t
r tons alegi hat houl
ompe ae f rbe ng wr uly aae t d
ns td o i
ongf l
se
a deai d f ni days i M a 201 on a def c i pa ol vi a i wa r tt twas lt r
nd t ne or ne
n y
3
e tve r e ol ton ran ha
ae
dim is
s s ed. Upon r vi w of t r or t cour fnds t t t a ton mus be sl ma iy
e e
he ec d, he
t i
ha he c i
t
lm rl

d s se wi o t rj d c .
imis d t u p eu ie
h
The cour m us dim is a a ton or cai fl d by a prs ragans a gove n e al
t t s s ny c i
l m ie
ione
i t
r m nt
e iy orofk e i t cour dee m i t a ton orda m i G rvol ,m ai i or f ist
ntt
t r f he
t t r nes he ci
i s t i ous lcous, al o
f
s a e a cl i on whi h r le m ay be g a e or s ks m one ar r le f om a def nda w ho i
tt
am
c ei f
r
' nt d; ee
t y ei f r
e nt
s

i n fo s c rle ' 2 U. C.j 1 5 b () ( ) To sae a c u e o a to u d r
mmu e r m u h eif' 8 S.
91 A( )1, 2 .
tt a s f ci n n e
j1 3, a pl ntf mus esa ih t t he ha be n de i d of rght g rnte by t
98
ai if t tbls ha
s e prve
i s uaa e d
he
Consiuton or lws of t Unie St t s a t t t s de i ton r s t fom c uc
tt i
a
he
td a e nd ha hi prva i e uled r
ond t

commitdbyape s aci underc o ofsaelw.W es v.At ns 487U. 42,48( 988)
te
ron tng
olr tt a
t ki ,
S.
1 .
l i wel s tl d t t a sa e,s h as t Comm onweat of Vigi a,c
t s l e te ha
tt uc
he
1h
r ni nnno be s d
t
ue

t e j 1 8 W il . ihia De to S aePoie 4 U. 5 , ( 98 )(:Nl i raS ae
md r 9 3. l v M c a n p' f tt l , 91 S. 8 71 1 9 Gl et
c
l he tt
'
norisofki sa tng i t rofki ca ctesae û ro 't rj 1983.3. Thi r l alo
t t al ci n hei t al pa ii r pes ns mde
'
s ue s

CL
ERK

RK

S

a i s t çgo r nt l e ii s t t a e c i r d û r of t St t f El ve h
pple o û ve nme a ntte ha r onsde e n ms
he ae' or e nt

Ame
ndme pur es' J a 70.Bec us t ot renttesSkt s ar pr l consdee
nt pos .' . t
4,
a e he he ii
on ues e opery
i rd

ç r 'oft Co
l ms' he mmonwe t ofVigi a,he c nno bes d t rj 1
a
alh
r ni t y a t ue mde 983. Thus noneoft
,
he
ngl he
t l
iy
e t is S ao s e ae s j c t s i u d r j 1 8 . A ccordi y,t cour w il sum m arl
ni e tt n u s r ube t o ut n e 9 3
t

ds s ti a to wih u p eu ieu d rj1 5 b ( )1
imis h s ci n t o t rj dc n e 91 A( )2 .
The Cl r i die t d t s nd co es of t s m e a um opi on a ac ompa ng
ek s rce o e
pi
hi
mor nd
ni nd c
nyi
or rt pl i if
de o a ntf .

&

ENTER:Thi 2% da ofNovembe , 2014.
s 6 y
r

Chi fUnie St t Diti tJ
e
td aes src udge

1 I a ye e t St on' al g to sd n tidc t ta h h sa ato a l cam u d rj1 3 a an t
n n v n, at s l ain o o n iae h t e a n cin be li n e 98 g is
e
a ofi a f know i y vi ai hi c tt i lrght. Att m os,healege t tofk i sw e ene i nti
ny fcil or
ngl oltng s onsiutona i s
he
t
l s ha t al r glge n
t i pr pa ai a exe uto of t wa rnt Suc ale to of of al ne i nce do not s
her e r ton nd
c in
he ra .
h lgai ns
lci
glge
uppor a
t
c n ttto a cam a rq ie t p o e dt e j1 3.S e eg,Co nvo S ca nov Le s 5 U..8 ,
o siuin l li s e urd o r c e md r 98 e , .. u t f a rme t . wi, 23 S 33
8 9( 9 8 (l h Co siuin d e no g aa ted ec r o tep r o saeot as l bly frne lg nl
4 1 9 ) tTqe nttt o s t u rne u ae n h at f tt f l; i ii o gie ty
t
o
ki a t
i lce h r i ctg rc l be e t tetr sol'o c nsiuin l r tcin ) Mo e v r Sao salg to s
nfitd am s ae oial n ah h h eh d' f o ttto a p oeto s. ro e, ttn' l ain
y
e
do notr fec t ta
e l t ha nyonede i d hi oft pr e a pr e tonst whih he wa co tt i ly e il atr
prve m
he oc dur l otc i o c
s nsiutonal ntted fe
bei chage wih apr bain orpaol vi aton. Raher i a r t tbe us oft due pr s pr vi t
ng r d t
o to
r e ol i
t , t ppeas ha ca e he
oce s o ded o
hi t co tdimis t wa r a f
m, he ur s sed hc rant nd ound hi pr in oblg i t be f fled.
s obato
iaton o ulil

2