Smith v. Northwestern Regional Adult Detention Center

Filing 7

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 01/05/2015. (kab)

rapnœs oG l ,s. Dl
cEu
sm

.

AT RoM oKE, A
V
FIED
L

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGI A
NI
R O A NO K E DI SI N
W O
D EV O N TA E SM I ,
TH

J q7,25
AN 2 1
JULI C.
A
BK

,G .**
K
.
Z
:
.

CA SE N O .7:
14CV 00705

Pl nt f ,
ai i f

M EM O M N DU M O PI O N
NI

N O R TH W ESTERN R EG I NA L A DU LT
O
D ETENTI N C EN TER ,
O

By: H on.G l n E .Conra
e
d
Chi fU ni e St esD i t i Judge
e
t d at
srd

Dee
f ndant
.

De ae Sm ih,a Vig ni i t pr e ng pr x ,fld t s cvi rght a ton unde
vont
t
r i a nma e oc edi
o
ie hi i l i s c i
r

4 U. C. 1 8 , g is teNo twe tr Re i n l utDee to Ce tr S t alg st t
2 S. j 9 3 a an t h rh sen go a Ad l tn in n e . mih le e ha
whl o t r we emo ighi t a ohe l t h wa atc da ij r db a oh ri mae
i fkes r vn m o n t r l , e s ta ke nd n u e y n te n t .
e
ni
Upo r vi oft r co d,t c tc l s t tt c
n e ew
he e r he our oncude ha he ompli f is t sae a a tona e
ant a l o t t ny c i bl

c am and,t r or ,sl
li
he ef e lmmarl dim is t c e.
iy s s es he as
The c t i r quie t dimis a a ton or cli fld by a prs r agans a
our s e r d o s s ny c i
am ie
ione
i t
gove n t e iy orofke i t c tde e mi st aci n orcai i fi ous m ai i ,
r men al ntt
t r f he our t r ne he to
l m s rvol , lcous

o fis t sae a cam o whih rle ma be g a t d 2 U. C.j 1 5 b ( ) Th
r al o tt li n c eif y
rn e . 8 S.
91 A( )1. e

panifsû a t a alg to smu tbe e ug t rie arg tt rle a o e te s c ltve
litf û cu l le ain s
m
no h o as i h o eif b v h pe u ai
lve,'t onet ti t a i e on isf c 'r t rt n m e e y ç nc i bl .' Be lAt.Cor .v.
e l' o
ha s t usbl
pl
t a e, a he ha
'
r l i eva e' l l
co
p

Twombl 550 U. 5 570 (
y,
S. 44,
2007) To sae ac e ofa ton under51 apl ntf mus
.
tt aus
ci
983, ai if t
e tbls t the ha be n de i ofrght g r nt e by t Consiuton orl wsoft Unie
sa ih ha
s e prved i s ua a e d he
tt i
a
he t d
St t sa t tt sde i ton r s t d fom co
a e nd ha hi prva i e ule r
nduc c mitd by ape s aci t d rcol
t om te
r on tng m e
or

ofsaelw.W etv.At ns 487U. 42( 988)
tt a
s
ki ,
S. 1 .
The onl e iy t t Smih na
y ntt ha
t mes a a de e
s
f ndan i t de e i c nt r is l. The
t s he t nton e e t ef

d tnin c ne , o ve,i no at e s n's be tt s i u e j 1 8 . P e lv. n 2 3
ee to e tr h we r s t ç ro ' u j c o ut nd r 9 3 rva Re o, 0
p

=
q

F. 821 2000 W L 20591 a *1( h Ci.J 1 2000)( i W ilv.M ihi n De tof
3d ,
, t 4t r an. 3,
quotng l
c ga p'

S aeP lc , 1U. 58 71( 9 9 ) Mc vv. e a e k Co rcin lCe tr 7 8 F. p .
tt o ie 49 S. , 1 8 ); co Ch sp a e re t a n e, 8 Su p
o

8 0 8 3 9 ( D. .1 9 )(i dn ct j i i n fo s i a dno apes nf rp r o e o
9 , 9 - 4 E. Va 9 2 fn ig i al mmu e r m ut n t ro o u p s s f
y
j1 8 ) Theeo e t e c t'wils mmai ds s ti a to wi o tp eu ie p rua tt
9 3 . rf r , h out l u rl imis h s cin t u rj dc , u s n o
y
h
j 1 5 b ( ) a lg lyfio o s'Ana p o raeod rwi is et i d y.
91 A( )1 , s e al rv l u .
p r p it r e l su h s a
l
The Clr i die t t s nd co e oft s m e or ndlm opi o a a compa ng
e k s r ced o e
pis
hi m a l
ni n nd c
nyi
or rt pli tf .
de o a n if

ENTER

:Thi S N da ofJ r , 2015.
s
y anuay
Chi Unie St t sDititJ
ef t d a e src udge

* I a eve , Smih' s realegai dono i caet tt ofie whomovedhi fom onel ton
n ny nt
t s pa s l tons
t ndi t ha he fc r
m r
ocai

t a oh rwi i ted tninc ne ha o jciee ie c ta temo eplcd S t a a yrs o sro sh r
o n te t n h ee to e tr d b etv vd n e h th v a e mi t n ik f eiu am
h
h
fo a oh rimae Se Pars e rl Le v Clv ln 3 2 F.d 2 4 3 2 (t Ci.2 0 )(odn ta
rm n te n t. e rih x e. e . e ea d, 7 3 9 , 0 4h r 0 4 h lig h t
gove nm e ofi alvi aes c tt tonalrght ofpr tilde ane onl whe he know s of but dir r a
r nt tci olt onsiui
i s
era t i e y
n
segads

sg iia trs o sro sham t ted oie )(in Fame v Brn a ,51 U..8 ,8 7(9 4:; hte v
infc n ik f eiu r o h e n e ct g r r . e n n 1 S 25 3 1 9 W i v .
i
l
Ales 4 5U.. 2 31 ( 9 6 (odn ta d l rt i i rn er q rss wi ofû r ta o dn r lc
b r, 7 S 31 , 9 1 8 ) h lig h t ei ae ndfee c e uie ho ng E e h n r iay ak
be
mo
o d ecr frtepio e' itrsso s ft )
f u ae o h rs n rs neet r aef'.
2