Farley v. VA Dept of Corrections et al

Filing 31

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 3/20/2015. (slt)

tueaK' oflce u , Dlm e- 1
z
s r l t s. : . *
z
-

AT ;ANVI E,
LL VA

'0 j jz
oax
I TH E U NI
N
TED STATES DISTRI T C O UR T
C
FO R TH E W ESTER N DI
STR I T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O AN O K E D I I O N
V SI
D AR R ELL EU G EN E FA RLEY ,
Pl ntf
ai if,

)
)
)
V.
)
)
VA DEPT OF CORRECTI
ONS, ta . )
e l,
Deendant.
f
s
)

2
2

JULI . UD
A
3Y:
DEPUTY E

Ci lA c i N o.7: c 00713
vi ton
14- vM E M O R AND UM O PIN IO N

By:

H on. ton L.Kier
Jacls
s
Se or U ni e St e D it i tJudge
ni
t d at s s r c

Da r lEuge Fa l y,aVigi a im a epr ee ngpr > f l d a c vi rght co pl i
rel
ne re
r ni n t oc di
o q, ie
i l i s m a nt
-

purua t 42U. C.j 1 OnFe ay 6,
s nt o
S.
983.
bnzr 2015,hec tc tonal fldt ù ai ,
t our ondii ly ie he ompl nt

a vie Plitf t a t ec mpan p e e tdmij ie camsa ans mij ie d fn ns a d
d s d anif h t h o li t r sn e son d li g i t son d ee da t, n
r q ie Plitf t fl ane p e d n wi o t son dcamsa d d fn a t t t ud
e urd anif o ie w la i g t u mij ie li n ee d n s ha wo l
h
d tn lb is l wi o trfrnc t ac mplit atc me t, ra n me t ar a ytld.
s a dg y tef t u ee e e o o an, ta h n s o me d ns le d ie '
s
h
'
The c ta s a s Pl i ift ti w o d notr f rt Pl i tf ' pror flng ,t tprortlngs
our l o dvi ed a ntf ha t ul
e e o a n i fs i ii s ha i i i

s dno ber e e d i t f t m i pl a ng,a t tt f rhc i pl di mus
houl t ef r nce n he orhco ng e di nd ha he o t om ng ea ng
t
c or t Rul 8a 10oft Fe r lRul sofCi lPr ed e
onf m o es nd
he de a
e
vi oc ur .

OnFe uar 1 201 t cour rcevedPli ifsfrtmotont ame ( No.28)
br y 8, 5,he t e i
antf is i o nd ECF
,

a do Fe r ay23 t ec u t e ev dP an ifssc n mo int n n ( No 2 ) Th s
n n b u r ,h o r rc ie litf e o d to o me d ECF . 9 . e e
m oto t a e we ewrte be or Pli ifr cevedt co to lflng or r Fi l t
i ns o m nd r itn f e antf e i he ndii na ii
de . naly, he

c u t e ev dPlitf st r mo int a n ( No 3 )wh c wa flds e iial i
o r r c i e an if hid to o me d ECF . 0 , ih s ie p cfc ly n
r s n et tec u tso d ra o t son dcamsa dd f n a t.
epo s o h o r' r e b u mi ie li n e e d n s
j
None oft s m otonst ame cu et de i e c
he e i o
nd r he fcint ompli a t y al i e t
ant s he l ntnd o

p os c t mij i e camsa an t sone d fn a t.F re a l,h camsi t et id
r e ue so n d li g is mij i d ee d n s o x mp e te li n h hr
m oton t nm end span event f om bef ar i ng att pr s t a1 s sofs equent
i o
sr
ore rvi
he i on o 1 ort
ubs

i ea tonswihvai sat i l ngac es t t 1w lbrr co ant a t prvac
ntr ci
t rous tfl ncudi c s o he a i ay, mpli s bouthe i y

ofs
howe sa phoneca l, a r ce ptofm e c lc r 1 d zea e c am sa i tdif r nt
r nd
ls nd e i
ul
di a a e. ç r lt d l i gans fe e

d fn a t beo gi difr n s t . .' Ge r ev S t 5 7F.d6 5 6 7( t Ci. 0 7 .
e e d n s ln n fee t uis . . o g . mi 0 3 0 , 0 7h r 2 0 )
'
h,

No eo Plitf spla i g o moi n stfrhacam ta p o el j isa1d fn a t, n 1
n f an if e d n s r to s e o t li h t r p ry on l ee d ns a d
de lne t c
c i o hoos whi h cl m s m a be tpr e i t s a ton,e f c i y be m i Pl i tf s
e c ai
y s oc ed n hi c i
f e tvel co ng a n if

c e.Se e. ,Go donv.Lee ,574F. 11 11 (t Ci.1 (ec zi t ta
ouns l e. g. r
ke
2d 47, 51 4h r 978) r ogni ng ha

dsrc c u tsn t x ce t a s met er l o a v c t f rapr â pli t g.Plitf
itit o r i o e pe td o su h oe f d o ae o
o q ani
f anif
r c ve notc oft compl i ' de i i ncesand t o runiy t s i apl di t t
e ei d ie he
ants fc e i
he ppo t t o ubm t ea ng ha ,
e n i lbe a l c t u c or d t t lgalr quie nt e c e ofa1 pl i if .
ve f i r ly onsr ed, onf me o he e e r me s xpe t d
l antfs
D e pie t notc a opporuniy,Pl i ifhasf l t do s i vi a i oft c ltspr or
s t he i e nd
t t a ntf
aied o
o, n ol ton he otr ' i

or r Ac or ngl Idenyt m o i t ame a dim ist compl i d t Pl n ifs
de . c di y,
he tons o
nd nd s s he
ant ue o aitf
f iur t c pl wih a cour or r B e a e i i pos i e f rPl i ift c e t pl a ng'
a l e o om y t
t de . c us t s s bl o a ntf o ur he e di s
de i i i and c i t ltga i i a f tr s pa a e a ton,t dim i s lw ilbe w iho
f c enc es
ontnue he ii ton n utle, e r t c i he s s a l
t ut

p eu ie S e ec, mioS a Co p v S a W o k r Lo a Uno 3 2 1 F.d 1 6 ,
rj dc . e . ..Do n ug r r . . ug r r e s c l in 9 , 0 3 0 4
1 67( h Ci.1 .
066- 4t r 993)
ENTER:Th'

i ofM a c 201
day
r h, 5.
%
)
'

# rUnied St t D it i J
n'
t
a es s rct udge

1Addiinal ,t complita mo i t a
to ly he
an nd tons o mendlr l f i t gi Defnda s(fi notc ofwha ...
a gey al o ve e nt dar ie
t

( anifs caml)(r)a dtego n su nwhc ( e rsl. Bel lCo p v Two v, 5 U.. 4 ,
Plitf') li s ae n h ru d po ih t y) etl' lAt. r . . mbl 5 0 S 5 4
h
'

5 (0 7.Du t Panifsfitet cmpy h we e, del t sre hssb sin pzsato2 U. C.
45 2 0 ) e o litf' alr o o l, o vrl ci o cen i u miso s l un t 8 S.
t
ne
r
j 1 5 a d 1 1 A a d4 U. . j 1 9 eu tls c tmePli tf c n c mp ywi t ec u tso d r o fl a
j 91 n 9 5 n 2 SC. 9 7 n l u h i an if a o l t h o r' r e t i
h
e

compl n t tconf mst t Fede a RulsofCi lPr ed e.Pl ntf i adviedt te pr K ltga sm us
ait ha
or o he
rl e
vi oc ur ai if s s ha ven o ii nt
t
'sop- nd-hi be o ei tal m aki lgal...c e i 'a ç
't a t nk f r niily
ng e
ontntons' nd ç
conduc ar as bl i iy i o t 1 a
t e ona e nqur nt he aw nd
.

fcsbeoesg n pe dn s wrte moin , n oh rd c me tll Fe R. v. l a vsl c mmites
at fr inig la ig , itn to s a d te o u ns.' d. Ci P. l d io' o t '
'
y
e
n t ( 9 3 ( tra q oainmakso te )
oe 1 9 ) i en l u tto r mitd .
n