Minor v. Walrath, et al

Filing 26

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 2/27/2015. (tvt)

!

OFFI U.. SX M UX
CF S DI

A$ R:,?r <F V
' 7A..7
.?) A
#p ': '

#A2 22 2 1
25
I TH E U N I D STATE S D I
N
TE
STR I C O U RT
CT
FO R TH E W E STERN D ISTR ICT O F V IR G INIA
R O A NO K E D I I O N
V SI

LAM O NT D.M I
NOR,

J A k.' !..-' C %
ULI . ' tw o j
' . ' .'
.
BY'
D

CASE NO .7:
15CV00021

Pl nt f ,
ai i f

V.

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI

J. W ALM TH,c & ,
F.

By: Gln E.Conr
e
ad
Chi f Unied St e D i t i Judge
e
t
at s s r ct

Defnda t)
e nts.
Ln ont D .M i , a V igi a i a e pr e ng pr K , fl t s ci l r gh s ac i
m
nor
r ni nm t oc edi
o
ied hi vi i t ton
.

purua t 42U. C.j1 3.l hi c ant M i alege t talhoug henoiidofki s
s nt o
S.
98 n s ompli , nor l s ha t h
tfe t al
a Red Oni Sut Prs t the ha e mi s i a c ran ho i zni,he wa ta f re t
t
on
e ion ha
d ne e n e t i usng l t
s r ns e r d o

t a t twh r a oh rimaeatc e a dijle hm i Oco e 2 4.By sp r t o d r t
h t mi, ee n te n t ta k d n n t d i n t b r 01
r
e a ae r e,he
c twil s r M i ' c
our l e ve nors ompli on t def nda prs ofi a s who al ge y f ie t
ant
he e nt ion fcil
le dl a ld o
pr t c hi . The c tfnds howeve ,t tM i ' s pa a ecli ag ns Red Oni physc a
oe t m
our i ,
r ha nors e r t am ai t
on
ii n,
B. uli ,mus bes
M lns
t umm a iy dimis
rl s s ed.

Mi o camst a a un a d imaepmc dh m a dt e j mpe o h sb c Snc
n r li h t n n me n t t he i n h n u d n i a k. i e
t at k,Mi hasal dl s frd fom t e epan'i hi l bac (
he tac
nor
lege y ufee r t ver i 'n s ower k. Compl 5,ECF
s
.
No.1) Hes sDr M uli f monear da ges al ngt tt docorG sye t s ndme
.
ue . lns or
t y ma , legi ha he t d
ha t o e
t aba korne v s ils frs msa pani myba k. (d
o c
r e pecait o pas nd i n
c ' L=)
'
The c ti r r d t dim is a c am fl by a prs r who Gs e r dr s fom a
our s equie o s s
l i ied
ione
te ks e es r
gove n e ale iy or of i e ' i t co tde e ne t a ton orc a m i f i ous m a i ous
r m nt ntt
fc r ' f he ur t nni s he c i
l i s rvol , lci ,

o fist saea cam o whih rle ma b g a td. 28 U. C.j 1 5 b ( ) To saea
r al o tt li n c eif y e r ne
S.
91 A( )1 .
tt
cam,t e panifst a ta alg to smus b e o h t rie a rg tt r l fa vet e
li h li tf û cu l le ai n
m
t e n ug o as ih o ei bo h
e

s cultve lve , t onet ti t a i e on is f e, r t rt n me el ç onc i bl ' Bel
pe a i e l' o
'
ha s û usbl
pl
t ac ' ahe ha
'
r y û e va e.
c
' l

At.Cor .v.Twombl 550U. 544,570(
l p
y,
S.
2007)
.
A pr s ofi i ' de i r t i f e e e t a i a e' s rous m e ca ne ds vi a e
i on tc als lbe a e ndif r nc o n nm t s e i
di l e
ol t s

t eEihh Ame d n .Se Esel v. mbe 42 U. 9 ,1 2( 9 6 .Toa twi d l e ae
h gt
n me t e tle Gn l, 9 S. 7 0 1 7 )
c t ei r t
h b
i fe enc a ofk i lmus ha be n pe s ly a r off c si c tng a s t nta rs of
ndif r e, n t a
t ve e r ona l wa e a t ndi ai
ubsa il ik
s r ous ha m ,a t l r c
ei
r c ualy e ogni e t e s e of s h r s and r s
z d he xi t nce
uc i k,
e ponde unr a ona y t i .
d
e s bl o t

Fn me v.Brn a 51 U. 8 5 8 8 (9 4 . Th d l rt i ifrnc sa d r tsn t
r r
e n n, 1 S. 2 , 3 1 9 ) e ei ae ndfee e tn ad t o
be
i

stsidby ... r dia re n c n e ig 1q u sinso me ia j dg n 'Geman v
aife
mee s g e me t o c m n (l e to f dc l u me t'' r i .
Sheai 531F.App' 39 395 ( h Ci.201 ( i Ruselv.Shefr 5 F. 31 31
rn,
x 2,
4t r 3) quotng s l
fe , 28 2d 8, 9
( h Ci.1 :,orme eneglg nc i dignossorte t nt Esel,429U. a 1 1 s
4t r 975
r
ie e n a i rame . tle
S. t 05- 06; ee

as Bo i v Go wi , 51F.d4 4 ( t Ci.1 7 )(g h e s nil eti o eo me ia
lo wrna . d n 5 2 4, 8 4h r 9 7 E Tl e s e ta ts s n f dc l
l
ne esiya notsmpl t twhihma bec i rdmerl de ia e' .
c st nd
i y ha c y onsdee
ey srbl '
)
M i ' br e alega i aga ns D r M uli do not sa e any pl us bl cons iu i
nor s i f l tons i t .
lns
tt
a i e
tt tonal

c am r ga di M i ' m e c lc r M i doesnotal get tDr M uli hasde e hi a l
l i e r ng nors di a a e. nor
le ha . lns
nid m l
te t ntf rhi ba k pan. He me ey saeshi pe s
r a me o s c i
r l t t s r onaldesr t be e l t d by as cils .
ie o
vaua e
pe a it

S h a d s g e me twih t e d co ' me ia j d me t a o tt e a p o rae c u s o
uc
ia re n t h o trs dc l u g n s b u h p r p it o re f
te t tf M i ' condii doesnots ts y t dei r t i fe enc sandar The e or
r a men or nors
ton
a if he lbe a e ndif r e t
d.
r f e,

t c ttndst tM i ' c
he our i
ha nors ompl i a i tDr M uli mus be sl a iy dimi s d wihout
ant ga ns . lns
t lmm rl s s e t

p eudc u d rj1 5 b () a fioo s An a p o it o d rwil n e t i d y
rj ie n e 91 A( )1, s rv lu . p rprae r e le tr hs a .
The Clr i die t d t s nd c es of t s me o andum opi on a ac ompa ng
ek s rce o e
opi
hi m r
ni nd c
nyi
or rt pl i i f
de o a ntf .

ENTER:Thszn V d yo br r , 01
i
a fye uay 2 5.
Chi Unied St t D i ti tJ
ef t
a es sr c udge
2