Moser v. Colvin
Filing
20
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 12/7/15. (eot)
CL
ERKS OFFI U.S. Dl COURT
CE
ST.
A R4scc ,A
T o LED V
FI
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COI RT
CT
J
F0R THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROA N O KE DI SI
VI ON
DE2 2? 2 1
25
JULA C
I
BY:
D P
,
CLERK
LR
ALLEN R. OSER,
M
Ci lAci n No. 7: 5CV00062
vi to
1
Pl i if
nntf,
M EM OR ANDUM OPP WON
CA RO LYN W .COLV W , c i
A tng
Co mi sone ofSoc a Sec iy,
m si r
i l urt
By:
Hon.Gl n E.
e Conr
ad
ChifUnie S ae DititJ
e
t d t t s src udge
Def nda .
e nt
Thepl i if Ale R. os r hasfld t saci n c le ng ce ti pr so oft
antf, ln M e ,
ie hi to ha lngi
ra n ovii ns he
fna de son oft Co misone o Soc a Se urt e tbls ng pl i ifse il me t a
i l cii
he m s i r f i l c iy sa ihi
antf ntte nt o
pe i ofdiabiiy a dia lt i tr nc be t t rt Soca Se utt Ac ,asn e d,
rod
s lt nd s biiy nsla e neks mde he il c ' y t
i
m nde
4 U. C. j41 ()a 4 3 Th Co s in rd tr n dta panifb c meds be fr
2 S. j 6 i nd 2 . e mmiso e ee mi e h t litf e n ia ld o
pu pos ofhi a ia i f rbe f on Augus 21 2020, heda eofhi ffi h bit y.I
r es
s pplc ton o neks
t ,
t
t
s itet rhda n
hi a al M r M os rm ant i t thebe me dia e f a1 f m sofs t ntalganfl
s ppe , . e i ans ha
cn
s bld or 1 or
ubsa i i ll
e oy e on M a c 1 2009,a al d i hi a ia i f be st .J di to oft s
mpl m nt
rh ,
s lege n s pplc ton or ne s uds ci n hi
c u tsp l u n t j2 5 g o t eAc, 2U. C.j4 5 g .
o r i t s a t o 0 ( ) f h t4 S. 0 ( )
r
Thi c tsr viw i lm ie t a d t r na i ast whehert r i s t nta
s our' e e s i t d o e e mi ton o
t he e s ubsa i l
e de et s
vi nc o uppor t Com misone ' c l i t tpl ntf fr tbe n edia ed f ral
t he
s i rs onc uson ha ai if is c m
s bl o l
f msofs tntalganf a tviy o Augus 21 201 I s h s tnta e de e e ss t
or
ubsa i i ul c i t n
t , 0. f uc ubsa il vi nc xit, he
tna de ii oft Commisone mus beafr d.La v.Ceç e ze 368F. 640( h
i l cson he
si r t fime
ws
lhr z ,
2d
4t
Ci. 9 6 .Sae b ify s b tn il v d n eh sb e d fn da s hr lva te ie e
r 1 6 ) ttd rel , u sa ta e i e c a e n eie s uc ee n vd nc ,
co i rngt r or a awhol asm i bef
nsde i he ec d s
e,
ght ound ade t t s
qua e o uppor a c l i b a
t oncuson y
r a o bl mi .Rih r s nv. r ls 4 2U. 3 9 4 0( 9 )
e s na e nd c a d o Peae , 0 S. 8 , 0 1 71.
Asr iec e a
e t d bove, r M os rwa bor on Augus 21,1
M . e s n
t
960,a e nm a l c
nd ve ly ompl t
eed
hi hi s hoole
s gh c
ducai n. Pli ifwo ke prm a iy asa c nsnz to lbor ra f e
to
antf r d i rl
o t ci n a e nd or man. He
l twor d on ar gulrba i i 2007. I hi a i to f rape i ofdia lt a dia lt
as
ke
e a ss n
n s pplcai n o
rod
s biiy nd s biiy
i tr nc be f , r M os ra lge t thebe n edia e on M a c 1 2009 duet r sdual
nsla e neks M . e le d ha
c m s bl d
rh ,
o ei s
ofahe r a tc f tgue,de r as sn i ,c tpai s rne sofbr ah, i i hi lf he l
a t ta k, a i
c e ed tm na hes n, ho t s
e t pan n s e t e
a s cae wihap iriju 1w b c panwi r dainit t el we e te te , e kp i
so itd t ro nty, o a k i t a ito n o h o r xr miis n c an,
h
biae a ha pai l ts de pai wih lmie fmc i di bees a de es i Henow
l tr l nd n, ef houl r n t i t d t ton, a t , nd pr son.
m ant nst theha r mai d dia e t t pr e tm e Ther c d r vea st tM r M os r
i ai ha
s e ne s bld o he es nt i .
e or e l ha . e
me tei s r dsausrq ie nso t eAc a al ee a t i s e g n r l 4 U. C. j
t h n u e tt e u rme t f h t t 1 rlv n tme .S e e eal 2 S. j
y
41 ()a d4 3 a .
6 i n 2 ()
M r M os rsa i a in f be ft wasa ovedupo i ta c i r ton. Bas d on
. e ' pplc to or ne is
ppr
n niil onsde a i
e
a i a i oft m e c lvocai na gui lne a s tf rh unde t gove ni admi sr tve
pplc ton he di a
to l dei s s e o t
r he
r ng
nita i
r g a i ,i wasde e mi d t tpli ifbe n edia ed f ralf r ofs t nta gai u
e ultons t
t r ne ha a ntf c m s bl o l o ms ubsa i l nf l
e l m e twh nh r a he t ea eo f1 o Au s 21 2 0.( 1 7 4 ) I s e ig
mp o n e e e c d h g f 1 n gu t , 01 TR 3 - 0 . n e kn
r c i r ton ast t da eofdia lt o e ,pli ifa i as e t t thebec m edia e
e onsde a i
o he t
s biiy ns t a ntf gan s red ha
n
s bl d
o Ma c 1 20 9 wh n h s fee h sh a t ta k.( 1 9 .Ho v r t ei ta d cso
n r h , 0 , e e u frd i e r atc TR 4 ) we e ,h niil e iin
wa a o tdo rc nsd rto ( 8 - 5 .Plitf he r q e tda drc i daX n vo
s d p e n e o i eain. TR 5 9 ) an ift n e u se n e eve
o
he rnga r viw be or a Ad i sr tveLa J
n i nd e e
f e n m nitai
w udge
.
Folowi c
l ng onduc ofa a i sr tvehe rng,t La J e r nde ed he de son on
t n dm nita i
a i he w udg e r
r cii
Augu t30,201 TheLa J
s
3.
w udge f t t tM r M os s f r fom s ver ls ve ei par e s
o md ha . er ufe s r e a e r m im nt,
i l ng de ne a i dicdie e o t lunba s ne;sauspos l ta ea t ode i;a
ncudi
ge r tve s s as f he t r pi t t
t ef nkl rhr ss nd
c r n r a tr d s a e sau p s h a t ta k a dse t.( 1 ) Be a s o t s
o o ay rey ie s , tt s o t e r atc n tn s TR 7 . c u e f he e
i i nt,t La J er e t M r M os ri d s bld f hi pas r lva wor r esi
mpanne s he w udg uld hat . e s ia e or s t ee nt k ol n
t c n t cinid ty ( 2 ) Ho v r teLa J d ed tr n dt t r M o e r ti s
he o snlto n usr . TR 3 . we e,h w u g ee mie ha M . sr ean
s fcintf nc i c pa iyt pe f m a lm iedr ngeofs de a ywor a tviy. TheLa
ufi e u tonal a ct o ror
i t a
e ntr
k ci t
w
J
udgeas e spl i ifsr sdua f nc i c pa iyasf l :
s s antf e i l n tonal a èt
olows
Afe ca e u co i r ton oft e ier c d,Ifnd t t t ough t pe
tr r f l nsde a i
he ntr e or i ha , hr
he dod i
n
q ton,t cai ntha t r sdua f tona ca ct t pe f m ar nge o
uesi he l ma
d he e i l nnci l pa iy o ror
a
f
sd n aywo ka d fn di 20CFR 4 4.5 7 $. p cfc l ,hecama t a
e e tr r s ei e n
0 1 6 4 S e iial t li n c n
y
lf a orc n. 20 pot oc aso ly a 10pomdsfe nty;c sa
it nd/ a y
mds c i nal nd
t
r que l an t nd
and/ wak f 2 hotr i a 8 hotrwor y;a c stf 6 hour i a 8- tr
or l or
ls n n - l
kda nd an i or
s n n hoz
wor y.He c n occ sona l ci b sar a r
kda
a
a i ly lm t is nd nmps c n ne rc i ldder ,
; a ve lmb a s
s a f l , r pe ;c n oc a i lyba a e be s o lnee , r uc a
c f o ds or o s a c sona l lnc , nd, t op,c l c o h, nd
ca l
rw .
( 1 ) Gi ns harsd a f n to a c p ct, n a trc n ie igpanif a e '
TR 8 . ve uc e iu l n cin l a a i a d fe o sd rn litf s g ,
y
e uc ton,a prorwor e de ,a we last si o fom a voc tonale r,t La
d ai nd i
k xpe nce s l e tm ny r
ai
xpe t he w
J
udgea id t m e c voc tonalgui lne s a t c udet tM T M os rbe n e
pple he dial a i
de i s o s o oncl ha . e c m
dia e f a1f msofs t nta ganf a tviy a o li ffit bit y on Aug t21 201
s bl d or 1 or
ubsa i l i ul c i t s f ls ite h rhda
us , 0.
S e20C. R. 4 4.5 9 a Ru e2 .4o Ap n i 2t S b a t o teAd n srtve
e
F. j 0 1 6 , nd l 011 f pe dx o u p r P f h miitai
Regu ai Pa t404. Howe r a t t pe i prort hi t it bit y,gi n ar sdua
l tons r
ve , s o he rod i o s m eh rhda ve e i l
f nc i lc pa t f almie r ngeofs ntr e ri n, nd ba e on t t tmony oft
u tona a ciy or i t d a
ede a y xe to a
s d he esi
he
voc tona e r t La J e a i d Rul 20121 o Appe x 2 s a t c l t tM r
ai l xpe q he w udg pple
e . f
ndi o s o oncude ha .
M o e wa n tds b e o o b f r Au u t2 , 01 .( 2 - 4 .Th s teLa J g
s r s o ia ld n r eo e g s 0 2 0 TR 3 2 ) u ,h w ud e
utm a ey c l d t tpl ntf be a edia e f a1f nnsofs t talgai ul
li t l oncude ha ai if c m
s bl d or 1 o
ubsan i
nf
e ly n o Aug t , 1 , u t a h wa no ds b e p irt t a tme ( 2 ) Th
mp o me t n us 21 20 0 b t h t e s t ia ld ro o h t i . TR 4 . e
TheLa J e' opi on wa a ed a t fnalde i i oft Co mi so rbyt Soc a
w udg s ni
s dopt s he i
c son he m s i ne
he i l
Se urt Admi sr ton' Appe l Cot i.Ha ng e use al a ia e a nita i
c iy
nita i s
a s mc l vi xha t d 1 val bl dmi sr tve
r m e e , r M os rha no a
e di s M . e s w ppeaedt t sco t
l o hi ur.
W hiepl i ifm a be dia ed f rc rai f
l antf y
s bl o e t n onnsofe o e , hec u alf c ta
mpl ym nt t r ci a tz l
de e nai n i whehe pl i ifwa dia e f a1 f msofs t nta g nf le o e t
t nni to s t r antf s s bld or 1 or
ubsa i l ai u mpl ym n .
S e4 U.. j4 3 d () Th r aef t ee n so p o fwhihmu tb c nsd rdi
e 2 SC. 2 ( )2 . ee r ol lme t f r o c s e o i ee n
r
mn igs ha a lss Th s ee n saesl rz da f l ws ( )o j ci eme ia fcs
kn uc n nay i. e e lme t r l
mma ie s ol : 1 be tv dc l a t
o
a dciia fn ig ; 2 t o n o a d c n lso o te t gp y iin ; 3 s be t e
n l c l dn s ( ) he piins n o cu ins f rai h sca s ( ) u jci
n
n
v
evi nc ofphysca m n f tto ofi i nt,a de c i t ough acli a ' t si on
de e
i l niesai ns mpanne s s s rbed hr
am nts e tm y;
a d()t ecama t e u ain, oc to l itr ,e iua s ls a da e Vie v. n h, 8
n 4 h li n' d c to v aina h so y r sd l ki , n g . tk Fic 43
s
l
F.d 1 5 ,1 5 - 0(t Ci. 9 ) Un e wo dv Riio f 2 8F. 8 0 8 (t Ci. 9 2 .
2 1 7 1 9 6 4 h r 1 71 ; d r o . b c f, 9 2d 5 , 51 4h r 1 6 )
Afe ar viw oft r c d i t sc e,hec t sc nsr i t c udet tt
tr e e
he e or n hi as t our i o taned o oncl ha he
Comm iso rsfna de ii n i s
s ine ' i l c so s uppore by s t nta e de e.Thec ta e t tt
td
ubsa il vi nc
our gr es ha he
medialr c dco l i y e t bls st te n a trons tofhi mus ul kee a pr blm s
c e or ncusvel sa ihe ha ve fe
e
s
c os lt l o e ,
i udi ahit yofl f n ea t ode i a plnt rf c ii , e n afe li he r a t k on
ncl ng sor
e t nkl rhr ss nd a a as its and ve tr ls a t tac
M a c 1 2009,M r M os rr t i d s t intphysc lc pa t t pe f m awi r ngeof
rh ,
. e e ane ufk e
i a a ciy o ror
de a
s de a ywor a tviy. Si y sa e t me c lr c d c s t twhiepl i ifc i
e nt r
k ci t
mpl tt d, he di a e or ontnns ha
l antf ontnues
t e renc mus ul kee a pan i li ba k,kne ,a ankls hei f ly c pa e ofe gi
o xpe i e
c os lt l i n ls c
es nd
e , s u l a bl
nga ng
i wor i wlih hei pe m itd t stt oug utt wor y.M o e r t m e ca r or
n
k n lc
s r te o i hr ho he kda
r ove , he di l ec d
co imst tpli i sc r ova c a pr e ssa lze wihi aye ra trhi hea t tac
nfr ha antc a di s ulr obl m t bii d t n
a fe s r a t k,
wih t pl e e ofse sde i d t r le hi a tra bl kag .W hiepl ntf s
t he ac m nt tnt sgne o e ive s re il oc es
l ai if
t si o s esst the e re e sg fc ntphysc lde lt ton be we n M a c 1 2009
e tm ny ugg t ha
xpe inc d i nii a
i a biia i
t e
rh ,
andAugu t20,201 t c ur fndst tt m e ca r or f l s pporst La J
s
0, he o t i ha he di l ec d uly u
t he w udge s
'
4
d t r nai t tM r M os rr gane t ca ciyt pe f m s ntr e ri wihi a f w
e e mi ton ha . e e i d he pa t o ror ede a y xe ton t n e
m o hsf l ng Mshe r a tc a t thedi notbe ome dia ed wihi t m e ni oft
nt olowi
a t ta k, nd ha
d
c
s bl
t n he a ng he
Soc a Se trt A c a a tm eprort Augus 21 201 I f l wst tt fna de ii oft
i l c liy t t ny i
i o
t , 0. t olo ha he i l c son he
Comm isone mus bea lr e Se La v.Ce e e ze s pr .
s i r t f m d. e ws
lbr z , u a
I pa sng, heco ta s not st t i a s sng t dae ofpli tf dia lt o e ,t
n si t
ur lo e ha ,n s es i he t
a n ifs s biiy ns t he
Law J
udgee i ty r le on t fndi a o ni oft sa ea nc physc a , .
xplcil e id
he i ngs nd pi ons wo t t ge y
ii ns Dr
Th ma P lpsa dDr W y t Be ze .( 2 - 3 .Afe rve ngt eme ia r c r , oh
o s hii n . at a ly TR 2 2 ) tr e iwi h d c l e o d b t
l
physc a o ne t tM r M os rr t i d s fce fmci lc pa iy f s de a y e rin a
ii ns pi d ha . e eane uf int t tona a ct or e nt r xe to t
a1r e nttm e prort Augus 21 201 Thus e n as lmi t tt da eofdia lt ons t
l elva i s i o
t , 0.
, ve sl ng ha he t
s biiy e
i pli ifsc s i a bi
n antf a e s m guous t c ur be ivest tt La J ge c
, he o t le ha he w ud onduc e t a opra e
t d he ppr it
a yssco e a e byt Unie St t Co tofAppe sf rt Fourh Cic ti Baie v.
nal i nt mpl t d he t d aes ur
al o he
t r ui n ly
Ch tr 6 F.d75( t Ci. 9 5 .
ae, 8 3
4h r 1 9 )
On a a t t sc ur,pl ntf r st tt Admi sr tveLa J
ppe l o hi o t ai ifa gue ha he
nitai
w udgef l t
aied o
co i a1o li i
nsder l f ls mpai nt i c
nne s n ombi to Howe r t c t le st t r pors
nai n.
ve , he our bei ve hat he e t
fom t sa ea nc physcanspr des
r he t t ge y
ii
ovi uppo tf t La J
r or he w udge' a s s e ast t
s s es m nt o he
f tona i
unc i l mpac ofpl i ifsc
t
antf ombi ton ofphysc i ime s
nai
ial mpar nt .Onc a n,t c t
e gai he our
be ivest tt La J
le ha he w udger as bl r le on s h opi on e de ei c l ng t tM r
e ona y e id
uc
ni vi nc n onc udi ha .
M os rr a nss fcintf to lc pa iyt pe f m s de a y wor aci te .
e eti ufi e unci na a ct o ror e nt r
k tviis
M r M os ralo c e on a
. e s ontnds ppea t tt La J e i ope l dic mt d t
l ha he w udg mpr ry s ol e he
c e biiy ofpli if st si o a t ad i sr tvehe dng.M r M os rt tfed a t
r di lt
a ntf e tm ny t he m nitai
a
. e esii t he
hea i t t be a e o pa n i hi f ta ba k,i wa ne s a y f hi t 1edown d i t
rng ha , c us f i n s oo nd c t s ce s r or m o i
urng he
ciia peidi tme ( 4 ) as n tdt a, fe h sh at ta k, e peinc d
rt l ro n i . TR 0 .He lo oe h t atr i e r a tc he x re e
c
s o t s o b e t , ai u , n d z i e so ad i b ss TR 4 ) Ho v r t me ia
h rne s f rah ftg e a d izn s n al a i.( 5 . we e,he d c l
y
r c d i c t st tM r M os rha goodr s t 9om hi s gialpr ed le . St t d dif r nty,
e or ndi a e ha . e d
e uls
s m c oc tr s a e fe e l
tec u t o sno b le et a t eei a yo j cieb ssf rpanifsc mp an so
h o r d e t eiv h t h r s n b e tv a i o litf o lit f
de lttng s
biia i ympt aol y durng t r l ntpe i I i wel s tl t t i o de f r
om t og
i he eeva
rod. t s l e ted ha , n r r o
s b e tv s mp o t b ds bi g t eemu tb o j ci me c lfn i se tbihi s me
u j ci e y t ms o e ia ln ,h r s e b e t
ve dia i dng sa ls ng o
c ton t tc d r s na y bee cedt pr et s
ondii ha oul ea o bl
xpe t o oduc he ympt saleg Cr i v. t r
om l ed. a g Cha e ,
7 F.d 5 5 5 2 9 ( t Ci.1 9 ) Fo trv He ke , 8 F.d 1 2 ,1 2 ( t Ci. 98 )
6 3 8 , 9 - 3 4h r 9 6 ; se . c lr 7 0 2 1 5 1 9 4h r 1 6 .
Theco t le t tt m e c lr porsc
ur bei ves ha he di a e t ompie i t sc e i t m ont pro t Augu t
ld n hi as n he
hs i r o
s
21 2 1 smpl d n t elc o j cief ig c n itn wihpani salg to o ttl
, 0 0 i y o o rfe t b e tv mdn s o sse t t li tY l ains f oa
e
diabiiy.
s lt
I a fr ng t Comm iso rsfna decson,t c tdoe nots
n fimi he
s i ne ' i l ii he our
s
ugge tt tM r M os r
s ha . e
wa fe ofal pai dic f r,f tgue a de es i pro t hi ffit bit y.I d, he
s re
l n, s om o t a i , nd pr son i r o s iteh rhda ndee t
m e ca r co d c
di l e r onfr st tpl i ifha e re e sg fc ntmus ul kelt li r nt ,
m ha antf s xpe i nc d i nii a
c os e a mpaime s
es i l i t l rba k a lf a e,a t thehass f r d fom ahe r a tc whih
pecaly n he owe c nd e t nkl nd ha
ufe e r
a t ta k c
c us d awi r ng ofa r es pt s Howe r t f c r m anst tnodocorhas
a e
de a e dve s m om .
ve , he a t e i ha
t
s se t tM r M os rwa dia e f s de a yf m sofwo k a tviyprort Augu t21
ugge t d ha . e s s bl d or e ntr or
r ci t i o
s ,
2010. nde d, s tf t a
I e as e orh bove, hec tbei ve t tt La J
t our le s ha he w udger s bl r le o
ea ona y e id n
o ri fo t m e c doc o si c ncudi t tM r M os rr t ne t c pa iy f
pilons r m wo dial t r n o l ng ha . e eai d he a ct or
s d n aywok, e pt h ss b e t s mp o .Onc a an imu tb r c g z dta te
e e tr r d s ie i u j ci y t ms
ve
e g i,t s e e o nie h t h
ia ii t d wo kwi o ta ys b e t d so o t o sn t fis l rn e acama t oal
n b ly o o r t u n u j ci ic mfr d e o o tef e d r li n t tl
t
h
ve
y
dia e Cr g v.Cha e ,s a. 594s bl d. ai
t r upr at
95.I a
t ppea st tt A d ils r tve Law J
r ha he m zi t a i
udge
a e u tl c n ie e plitY ss b e tv s mp o i t ea j d c to o plitY scam f r
d q aey o sd r d an i u j cie y tms n h du iai n f ani li o
6
a e rird s biiy o e da e I f l wst ta1f c t oft Comm isone ' fna decson a e
n a le ia lt ns t t . t olo ha l a e s he
s i r s i l ii r
s
uppore b s t ntale de e.
td y ubsa i vi nc
Asage r r l r s uto ofc lcsi t e d nc i am a trwihi t pr vi e of
ne al ue, e ol i n
onfit n he vi e e s
te t n he o nc
t Com misone e n i t c t i r ol t c nfit dif r nty. Riha ds n v.
he
s i r ve f he our m ght es ve he o lc s fe e l
c r o
Peae , u r; p n em .. n h, 95F.d3 6(t Ci.1 7 ) Fo t r a o ssae ,he
rls s p a Op e h i v Fic 4 2 9 4h r 9 4 . r he e s n ttd t
c t
our fndst Comm iso rsr s utoh oft pe tne c lct i t r c d i t sc s t be
he
s i ne ' e ol i
he ri nt onfi s n he e or n hi a e o
s
uppo td by s tntale de e.Ac r i y, hefna de son oft Comm isone mus be
re
ubsa i vi nc
co d ngl t
l cii
he
si r t
afr d La v. lb e z , u r .Ana p o raej d me ta do d rwil ee tr dt i
f me . ws Cee rz e s p a
p r p it u g n n r e l b nee h s
da
y.
The' e k i diecedt s nd c rii c esoft sM e or ndtm Opi on t a1co ms l
Clr s r t o e e tfed opi
hi m a l
ni o 1 t e
ofr c d.
e or
DATED :Thi
s
D<
d y ofDecember,2014.
a
ChifUnie St t sDit tJ
e
t d a e sdc udge
7
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?