Verdugo-Munoz v. Zych

Filing 2

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 4/7/2015. (tvt)

eœ RK: *: I v, . c œ h4
:œ : ol
'
A x vlkt, A
T
k V

F
I
k
I TH E U NI
N
TED ST ATE S D I
STR I T C O U RT
C
FO R T H E W ESTERN D I
STR I O F VI G I A
CT
R NI

kq-

:
J M c. VD :
UI
cv

ay:

R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI
JO SE A N TO N I VER D U G O - U N O Z,
O
M
Pett oner,
ii

Ci lA ct on N o.7: cvvi
i
15- 00080

V.

M EM O R AND U M O PI O N
NI

C H R I O PH ER ZY C H ,
ST
R espondent
s.

By:

L

H on.Jac on L . i e
ks
K sr
Se or U ni e St esD i t i tJudge
ni
t d at
src

J e A nt o V e d o- unoz,a f de a i m a e pr ee ng pr K ,f l d a pe ii f a
os
oni r ug M
e r l n t oc di
o
ie
tton or

wrtofha scor purua t 28U. C.j2241 Peii ra g t thi i a c rtoni
i
bea pus s nt o
S.
. ttone r ues ha s nc r eai s
unconsiutonalbe us he i a t ly i e oft s nt nc i
tt i
ca e s cual nnoc nt he e e e mpos d f hi c i i l
e or s rm na
convi ton. Pe ii ri pr e l c i d a a co r tona f iiy w ihi t sdi t i t a t s
ci
ttone s es nty onfne t r ec i l ac lt t n hi s rc , nd hi

matri bef emef rprlmi r rvi purua t Rul 1b)and4oft RulsGoveni
te s or
o ei na y e ew, s nt o es (
he e
r ng
j2254Ca e . Aftrr vi wi Pettoner' s isons, lco l t tPeii rf l t
s s1 e e e ng ii s ubm s i
ncude ha ttone ais o

d mo taea e tte n t r l f aj2 41 a l imist ep tto wi o t eu ie
e nsrt n n i me t o ei vi 2 , nd d s s h eiin t u prj d c .
l
e
h
I Aprl2006, heUnie St t DititCo tf t Diti tofArz s nt nc d
n
i
t
t d aes src ur or he src
i ona e e e
Pe ii rt i e a i,lf i ionmen f pos es i wih i e t diti e500 g n or
ttone o, nt r la ie mprs
t or s son t nt nt o srbut
r ms
m or ofM e ha phe a i Thi lf s nt nc w asbas d on t e sa e convi tons f r f ony
e
t m t m ne. s i e e e e
e
hr e t t
ci
o el

d' ofe e . TheCour ofAppe l f t N i h Cic ta fr
l
ug f ns s
t
a s or he nt r ui fimed t c c i andt
he onviton,
he
Supr e Cour oft U nie St t de e a pe ii f a w rtofce tor r . The U nied St t
em
t he t d a es ni d
tton or
i
ri a i
t
a es

DititCo r f rteDitito Arz n ds se wi p eu iePeiin rsfrt to t
src u t o h src f io a imis d t rj dc t o e ' is moin o
h
t
vac t,s ta i ,orc r c s tncepurua t 28U. C.j2255, t Cour ofAppeasfr
ae e sde ore t ene
s nt o
S.
and he
t
l o
t N i h C icui di m i ed Pettoner' r a ed a
he nt r t s ss
ii
s el t ppeal
.

1 ue1b p r t ac u toa pyteRue frj2 4Cae t aj2 41h bespeiin a dRul 4p r t a
R l () emi o rt p l h ls o 25 ss o 2 a a tt , n e emis
s
o
cour t dim isahabe speiin wheni pl nl a r t tapettone i note ild t r lel
to s s
a tto
t ai y ppeas ha
ii r s
ntte o eit

Pe ii rfl d t i tntpe ii n t ha t sc t c t hi lf s nt e i
ttone ie he nsa
tto o ve hi our va a e s ie e enc mpos d by
e
t Unied St t D i ti tCo tf t Di t i tofA r z
he t
a es sr c ur or he sr c
i ona. Pe ii ra guest ta lf s t nc
ttone r
ha ie en e e
i il lbe us t pr c t s a e c tf l c c i no l r q lf hi t s r t
s lega ca e he edi a e t t - our e ony onvi tons onge ua iy m o e ve he

lf s n e c i lg t t itrai, z c r- e d v Ho d r 5 0U. 5 3( 01 ) Untd
ie e tn e n i h ol n e l Caa hu iRos n o . l e, 6 S. 6 2 0 , ie
a

S ae v. mmo s 6 9F.d23 ( t Ci. 01 ) a M ilrv. ie Sae , 3 F.d 1 ( t
tt s Si n , 4 3 7 4h r 2 1, nd l Untd tt s 7 5 3 41 4h
e
Ci. 3 .
r 201 )
A dititc t ynotene ti aj22 peiin atmptngt i ldaeac ci
src our ma
tran
41 tto te i o nvai t onviton
unls amotonpurua t j2255i dna quaeori fci t t tt lgaiyofgn
es
i
s nt o
s c de t nefe tve o es he e lt a
i
i t s dee i ' 28U. C.j2255/) Swanv. e se 430U. 372,381( 977 .
nmae'l tnton.'
S.
, i Prs ly,
.
S.
1 )

p o e l a i dme t oj2 5 rle, u ha t sau eo lmiain o t el l a an t
r c dz l mpe i n t 2 5 eif s c s he ttt f i tto s r h ' e g i s
r
u
s e svepeii ,doe notrnde j2255rviw tna
ucc si ttons s e r
e e t dequae' çi feci v'I r Vj l
i
t'or tnef tve' n e a,
11 F.d 1 2,11 4n. ( hCi.1 ) TheUnie SttsCo tofAppeasf t Fo t
5 3 19 9 5 4t r 997 .
td ae ur
l or he urh
Cic thasf
rui
oundt tj2255i i de t andi f tvet ts t lgalt ofac cin
ha
s na quae
nefeci o e the e iy
onvito
onl w he a prs rs ts i s a t ee pa ts a r
y
n
i one a i fe hr - r t nda d:

()g tt tmeofc cin stld1w oft scruiort Supr meCour
1 A) he i
onvito ete a
hi ic t he
e
t
etbls dt lgalt oft co ci ( s e ntt t prs rsdie t
sa ihe he e iy he nviton;2) ubs que o he ione ' rc
a a a trtj2255moton,t s t tvelw c nge s ht tt
ppe l nd is
i he ubsani a ha d uc ha he
co
nduc ofwhi t prs rwa c c e i dee
t
ch he ione s onvit d s medno t be c i i l a
to
rm na ; nd

()t prs rc l stsyt gae e ngpr sonsofj2255be aus t
3 he ione amot aif he tke pi ovii
c e he
ne r e i notone ofc tt i
w ul s
ons iutonall w .
a

l r J s 226F. 328,333- (t Ci.2000)
n e one ,
3d
34 4h r
.
Peiine ma notc lngehi c ci vi j2241.Peii rfist e anhow a
tto r y
hale
s onviton a
ttone al o xpli
c nge i s t ntve l w m ade i l ga t pos e sw ih i en t dit i e 500 g a sorm or of
ha
n ubs a i a
t e l o s s t nt t o s rbut
rm
e
M e ha phe a i . Furhe m or ,t z ' Cic tpr ce ntha ...note e d t r a h of
t m
t m ne
t r e d oulh r ui e de
l t
s
xt nde he e c

g U. C.j2255( t t epeii sc le ngonl t i sntnce. Unie Sttsv.
28 S.
$1 o hos ttoner halngi
y her e e ' td ae
'

Po l, 31F.d2 3 2 7n. (t Ci. 0 8 (iigI r J n s 2 6F.da 3 3 3 )
oe 5 3 6 , 6 7 4h r 2 0 ) ctn n e o e , 2 3 t 3 - 4 .
Ac or ngl Peii fist me tt l r J ssa r t s t tj2255i i de t or
c di y, ttoner al o e he n e one tnda d o how ha
s na quae
i fci t t tt lgalt ofhi c ci hi camsc nnotbea ese t rj2241,
nefe tve o es he e iy
s onviton, s li n
ddr sd mde
and
t pe ii n m us be dim i s d.
he tto
t
s se
EN TER . Thi
. s

r d ofAprl 2015.
ay
i,
î
,
,

*

Se i Unied St t D i ti tJ
or t
a es sr c udge