Portis v. Ruan Transportation Management Systems, Inc.
Filing
16
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/26/2015. (lab)
CLERKS OFFI u. . ST. URT
CE % DI O
AT R- OG ,
VA
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON
D ON A LD W .PO RTI
S,
Pl i if
a ntf ,
FIED
L
J 2s 2 1
UN
25
J A C.
UL
BY:
DE
.
RX
CE
Ci lA c i N o.7: 5- - 1
vi ton
1 CV 00l 8
M EM O M NDUM O PI ON
NI
RU AN TM N SPORTATI
ON
M AN A GEM EN T SY STEM S,l C.
N ,
By:H o Gl n E.
n. e
Conr
ad
ChifUnie Stt sDititJ e
e
t d a e src udg
De e nt
f nda .
Pl ntf D o d W . ts pr e di pr K ,fl d t sac i n a i thi f nne e pl r
ai if nal
Por i , oc e ng o
ie hi to ga ns s o r m oye ,
Dee ntRuanTrns ttonM a me tSyse ,l Ct n' , l ngt thewashaase
fnda
a porai
nage n tms nc. Rua ' alegi ha
)
r sd,
di ci i d,a eve ualy t nni t f om hi e pl e tasa r s tofhi r pe t c pl i s
s plne nd nt l e na ed r
s m oym n
e ul
s e a ed om a nt
r r ng s f t vi a i a Rua s Sa e , igi a f ciiy. tscl i st thi t r i ton
ega di a e y ol tons t n' l m V r ni a lt Pori a m ha s e m na i
v oae VignaCo ej4 .- . 1 whc p o bt t ic a g ig o i a ywa d s rmia l j
i lts r i i d 0 1512:, ih r hiis s s h r gn l r n n y ic i n ti
d
ng
a i tan e pl e be a e t e pl
ga ns
m oye c us he m oyee ha fl d a he t o s e y c pl nt .' The m a t r i
s ie
alh r af t om ai . .'
te s
now be or t c ton Rua smoton t d s ist c
f e he our
n'
i o im s he ompli t ori t at r tve, o c
a n , n he le na i t ompel
a bir ton. t f l ngr a ons t c twilg a t m o i a c
r ta i For he olowi e s , he our l r nt hat ton nd ompela bir to of
r tai n
Pori ' c a m s
ts s l i .
Backeround
Pori bega w or ng f Rua asa f l- i e t uc drve on ora
ts
n
ki or n
u ltm r k i r
boutOc obe 1 2007.
t r 6,
A c or ng t t c pl i ,Pori r por e a va i t o uns f w o ki c tons t Rua
c di o he om a nt
ts e t d
z e y f a e r ng ondii o
n
m a ge e t oughou hi e pl en . tsalege t thi s r i o seihe i e hi
na m nt hr
t s m oym t Pori l s ha s upe v s r t r gnor d s
c pl nt o t e t d hi w ih o n hos iiy a r di ul H e a s cl i st tRua m a ge en
om ai s r r a e m t pe
tlt nd i c e.
l o a m ha
n na m t
r prm a
e i nded hi f a num be ofm i of e es s e ofw hi he di notc m i, hi h r s t
m or
r
nor f ns , om
ch
d
om t w c e uled
i hi t r na i on N ovem be 21,
n s e mi ton
r 2012. c r ng t t c pl i ,Rua us d t s r prm a
A co di o he om a nt
n e he e e i nds
t diguiet r lr s f Pori' t nni ton,whi h wa t tRua be ivedhi contnued
o s s he ea ea on or ts s e nai
c
s ha
n le
s
i
s ft c mpansc u dj o a dz isb sn s rlto hps
aey o lit o l e p r ie t u ie s eains i .
A coleci ba g ni agre nt(( 'bewe Rua a t I emai l
l tve r ai ng e me iCBA') t en n nd he nt tona
Br hehoodofTe tr Loca Uni No.1 (hef on' govenst e oyme oft 1f l
ot r
nmses
l on
71 t s
uni '
) r he mpl nt $ ul
a1
tmedrve a mantna e oye e oyedby( nla asi dt t Kr a oun i
i
i r nd i e nce mpl es mpl
Rua nd sgne o he oger cc t n
Roa
noke,Vigi a'i udi Pori.SeeRa Af.Ex. a 1 Doc tNo. 1. CBA pr de
r ni ,'ncl ng ts
y f
B t , ke
4- The
ovi s
t tRua ma dici i ordic r a empl onl tf j tc us '1 a 2.l as pr bis
ha n y s plne shage n
oyee y kor us a e.'d. t t lo ohi t
Rua f om di c i i tng aga ns a e pl e ç n an t r sorc
n r
s r m na i
i t n m oye i y e m
i
ondii nsofe pl e ' f a
to
m oym nt' or ny
S o bie bassofdic i nai unde a ia esa e, e r l orl allws'l a 1 TheCBA
t hi t d i
pr
s rmi ton
r pplc bl tt f de a , oc a .' d. t .
f r he pr dest te pl esc n c le e a ç l d vi a i n' oft t r soft CBA
u t r ovi ha m oye a ha l ng ny t ege ol to ' he e m
al
he
t oug t giva ea abirto pr e estf t i Aril 6oft ta e nt Jaa 3.
hr h he re nc nd r tain oc dur e orh n tce
ha greme .-. t
p
Pori al t t thehasnotfld a g ivanc wih r s tt hi c am s
ts cmis ha
ie
re
e t e pec o s l i .
On M a c 1 201 Pori tl ac
r h 6, 5, ts ied ompli tc lngi hi tr i ton i t sc t On
a n hale ng s e m na i n hi our.
M a 1 201 Rua tl a a e d m otont dimi sor i t at m a i t c
y , 5, n i e n m nde
i o s s , n he le tve, o ompe a bir ton of
l r ta i
Pori' cli s Thi moton hasbe f l bre e a wasar d on Jme23,201 I i now rpe
ts s am . s i
en uly i f d nd
gue
t
5. t s
i
f r vi w .
or e e
Di si
scus on
I ism oton,Rua as e t t tPori i oblgaedt a bir t hi c am sbe or heca
nt
i
n s rs ha
ts s i t o r ta e s l i
f e
n
pur ue t
s hem he e The c ta e s The Supr m e Cour oft U nie St t s a t Fourh Ci c t
r.
our gr e .
e
t he t d a e nd he
t r ui
Cour ofAppea sha bo h he dt ta a ee ntt a bir t e pl e dic i i ton ca ms
t
l ve t l ha n gr me o r ta e m oym nt s rm nai li
co a ne i a cole tve bar i ng a t m e i e or ea e,s l ng asi i e i i.Se 1 Pe
nt i d n
lci
ga ni gr e nt s nf c bl o o
t s xplc t e 4 nn
Plz s
a a LLC v Py t, 5 U.. 4 , 5 ( 0 9 (ç eh l t a ac l ci - ag iig a re n
. et 5 6 S 2 7 2 8 2 0 ) 1 od h t ol t b r ann g e me t
W
e ve
t tc e r y a l m i t ka y r qtiest o m e be st a bir t A DEA cl m s i e or ea e a a
ha l a l nd m s a bl e lr mi n m r o r t a e
ai s nf c bl s
matroffde a 1w.) Ausi v. nsBr kwayGls Conti rI .78F. 875,885( h
te e r l a ' ; tn Owe - oc
'
as
ane nc,
3d
4t
2
Ci. 9 6 (tA) e ly emus flo tegiv nc p o e ur e tbls e b t ec le t e
r 1 9 ) $ n mpo e
(
t o lw h re a e r c d e sa ih d y h o lci
v
ba gani a e me prort flng s ti fde a cour.)
r i ng gre nt i o ii ui n e r l t' .
'
TheCBA a ia et t sc ee es l pr dest tany dipu e rii t rt
pplc bl o hi as xpr sy ovi ha
s t sng mde he
a re n mu t es b e tdt teg iva c a dabtainp o e u e o ti e te en. e Ra
g e me t s b u j ce o h re n e n r irto r c d r s u ln d h r i S e y
Af. B Ar. j1(ttn t tç g iv n ei a alg dvilto o tes cfctr o gh
fEx. t6 saig ha $ re a c s n le e oain f h pe ii ems f t e
a
CBAI' ndt tû nygreva e.. lbes tldbyt pa te a or ngt t tnnsoft sAril
'a ha i
a i nc .wil ete
he ris cc di o he e
hi tce
e l i y' Unde t gre ncepr ed e,a e oye mus fl amitngre nce whiht
xcusvel ). r he iva
oc ur n mpl e t ie
te iva , c he
Uni a Rua atmptt r s ve.Se j.jj3- I t pari camotr ol t is ,t
on nd n te o eol
e .s 4. f he tes r es ve he s ue he
l
g i va i s it t t Pi dm ontGr e nce Com m it e. d. ft Com m it e f l t r c a
r e nce s ubm ted o he e
i va
te I I he
te ais o ea h
mao i d cso o t eis e t nç ih rpa' ma s b t h d a lc dis et abi ain.
j rt e iin n h su ,he s t e ly y u mit e e do ke su o r t to '
y
e
t
r
'
1 . 5 Atabtai n an u rl hr - a t, i ç o en d a dl tdb tep o so so (h
d j . r irto , e ta t id p ry who s s v r e n i e y h r viin f t e
g
mi
CbA a d a pia elw, r s le t d s ue l . 1 . eabi ao ' r s lto i bn igo
n ) p lc bl a ' e ov s he ip t. d j 0 Th r t t rs e ouin s idn n
'
r
t e pl
he m oyee a Rua 1 The CBA e i ty pr vi st ta le pl esç a ve t i r g t
nd
n. d.
xplcil o de ha 1 m oye t i he r i ht o
w
p ru a yj diil ra mi srtv rme ya an t( M Ja t a ymatrs b e tt te
u s e n u ca o d nitaie e d g i s RU s o n te u j c o h
p o e u e e tb ih db t i Aril u tls c pr c d r sa ee h use . 1 j1
r c d r s sa ls e y h s tce n i u h o e u e r x a td' d. 2.
'
I t sc e,Pori a s rst thewa tnni t d be us ofhi r pe t c
n hi as
ts s e t ha
s e na e ca e
s e aed ompli sa t
ant bou
s ey,nvi ai ofVigni Codej40.- . 1. salgai ,i tu wo dc tt ea
aft i olton
ri a
1512: Hi le tons f r e, ul onsiut
vi a i oft br d l
olton he oa t dic i i ton'pr son oft CBA,aswe la t r uie e t t
non- s rm na i ' ovii
he
l s he eq r m nt ha
Rua o l t u p n , icp ie o d shag e ly e f r us c u e'Ra Af. B. t12.
n ny t s e d d s iln , r ic r e mpo e s o j t a s . y fEx. a s
'
Pori ha t r or al edaC oltonoft s ii tr oft (
ts s heef e leg t ai
vi
he pectc ems he CBAI'whi mus beptrue
,' ch t ts d
t ough t g i va e a a bir to pr e esouti i A ri e 6 oft CBA .
hr
he r e nc nd r t a i n oc dur
lned n tcl
he
The co t
ur
e
mphasze t t at
i s ha , lhough t CBA r r sagre ncet be s te ç t n tn ( 0 d o t
he
equie
i va o ubmitd ' hi e 1 ) ays f he
wi
eve g vi rs t t gr e nce ' Ruan ha e i il a ee S o w ai a tm e lm ia i nsw ih
nt i ng i e o he i va ,'
s xplc ty gr d ç
t
ve ny i i t to
t
rs e tt t p e e tto o ( ag iv n ea dabi ainfldb o o b h l o M r P ri. M o .
e p c o he r sn ai n f 1 re a c n r t to ie y r n e af f . o t ' t
r
s'
Dimisa 7(iigRa Af. 7 , c t . . rt e er ao ,hec u tsc n tane t
s s t ctn y f ! ) Do ke No 4 Fo h s e s ns t o r i o sri d o
c
ompe t pa te t ar ta et c am ss tf rh i Pori ' c
l he ris o bir t he l i e o t n ts s ompl i .
ant
TheFourh Cic thasa
t r ui
cknowldge t nson i isde i i wih r pe tt whehe c t
e d e i n t c sons t es c o
t r ours
s o l sa o dimisa a to wh nal su sp e e tdte en aes be t oabtain. e
h ud ty r s s n cin e lis e r sn e h r i r u j c t r i to S e
r
Agca a v. OL Shi M g . ,675F. 355,376n.8( tngt tigj r ma bes me
ro M
p mt Co.
3d
1 noi ha tthee y o
t nson be we n ourdec son i Hoo e s- i c tng t tasa i r quie whe t a bir ton
e i
t e
ii n
t r ndi a i ha t y s e r d
n he r ta i
a e nttove st mate i diput - a Choi qHo el - s nci ni dimis lS n al of
gr eme c r he t r n s e' nd
c t s a to ng s s a whe l
teis e p e e td.. r ab ta l.' ( u tn Ho trs n . Phli ,1 3F.d9 3(t Ci.
h su s r sn e . a e z irb e') q o ig oes l c v. il 7 3 3 4h r
'
ps
1 ;ChoieHotl l 'al v.
999)
c
es ntl nc. BSR Tr ca RefrsJ ,252F. 707,709- 0( hCi.
opi na s-tt nc.
3d
1 4t r
2001) Noohiv.Tol Br .I ,708F. 599, n. ( h Ci. 3) TheFourh Cic tha as
);
l osn nc.
3d
605 2 4t r 201 .
t rui s lo
n tdta ço t sse cr ut aedvd do wheh radsrc c u t a d srto t ds s
o e h t t ll itr ic is r iie n te itit o r h s icein o imis
l r
rt e t a sa a a to s be t oabtain. Ag a a , 7 F.da 3 6n.8 Gi nti
ah r h n ty n cin u j c t r i to ' g ro 6 5 3 t 7 1 . ve h s
r
'
unce t nt t c twilsa t sa on pe ng a bir ton ofPori ' c am s Se Gr nv.
rai y, he our l t y hi di
ndi r ta i
tss l i . e ee
Za hr I .I , F.Supp.3d669,678( . Va. 4)
c y ndus. nc.36
W D. 201 .
C oncl i
us on
Fort r as saed, heco twilgr ntRua sm oton t c
he e ons t t t
ur l a
n'
i o ompela bir ton a t sa
r ta i nd o t y
t s pr e ngsa co di y. ogni i howe r t tPori m a pr f t f e hi cli s
he e oc edi
c r ngl Rec zng,
ve , ha
ts y e er o or go s am
r t rt n pr e wih a bir ton,t c t l die thi t s i e de et theha fl d a
ahe ha oc ed t r ta i he our wil r c m o ubm t vi nc ha
s ie
gre nc pur uan t t pr ed e s tf t i t CBA wihi 90 da oft dat ofen r oft s
iva e s t o he oc ur s e orh n he
t n
ys he e
ty hi
m e or ndtm o ni n and t ac om pa ng or .Abs nta s w i ofgood c us f f l e t
m a l pi o
he c
nyi
der
e
ho ng
a e or aiur o
pr
oceed w ihi t stm efam e,t coultwildi m i t s acton f f l e t pros e based on t
t n hi i r
he
' l s ss hi i or aiur o
ecut
he
dee n ' e rirmoto t dimis Se Fe R.Ci P. ( 'Za hz 36F. 3da 679.
fnda ts a le
in o s s . e d.
v. 41b) c y,
,
supp. t The
4
Clr i d r c e t s nd c rii c esoft sme or ndum opi on a t a ompa ng or r
e k s ie t d o e e tfed opi
hi m a
ni nd he cc
nyi
de
t t pl ntf a a 1c
o he ai i f nd 1 ouns ofr c d.
el e or
ENTER:Th s XG
i
d yofJ n , 01 .
a ue2 5
Chi Unie Stt sDiti J
ef t d a e srct udge
5
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?