Portis v. Ruan Transportation Management Systems, Inc.

Filing 16

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/26/2015. (lab)

CLERKS OFFI u. . ST. URT
CE % DI O
AT R- OG ,
VA

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON
D ON A LD W .PO RTI
S,

Pl i if
a ntf ,

FIED
L

J 2s 2 1
UN
25
J A C.
UL
BY:

DE

.

RX

CE

Ci lA c i N o.7: 5- - 1
vi ton
1 CV 00l 8

M EM O M NDUM O PI ON
NI
RU AN TM N SPORTATI
ON
M AN A GEM EN T SY STEM S,l C.
N ,

By:H o Gl n E.
n. e
Conr
ad
ChifUnie Stt sDititJ e
e
t d a e src udg

De e nt
f nda .
Pl ntf D o d W . ts pr e di pr K ,fl d t sac i n a i thi f nne e pl r
ai if nal
Por i , oc e ng o
ie hi to ga ns s o r m oye ,

Dee ntRuanTrns ttonM a me tSyse ,l Ct n' , l ngt thewashaase
fnda
a porai
nage n tms nc. Rua ' alegi ha
)
r sd,
di ci i d,a eve ualy t nni t f om hi e pl e tasa r s tofhi r pe t c pl i s
s plne nd nt l e na ed r
s m oym n
e ul
s e a ed om a nt
r r ng s f t vi a i a Rua s Sa e , igi a f ciiy. tscl i st thi t r i ton
ega di a e y ol tons t n' l m V r ni a lt Pori a m ha s e m na i

v oae VignaCo ej4 .- . 1 whc p o bt t ic a g ig o i a ywa d s rmia l j
i lts r i i d 0 1512:, ih r hiis s s h r gn l r n n y ic i n ti
d
ng
a i tan e pl e be a e t e pl
ga ns
m oye c us he m oyee ha fl d a he t o s e y c pl nt .' The m a t r i
s ie
alh r af t om ai . .'
te s

now be or t c ton Rua smoton t d s ist c
f e he our
n'
i o im s he ompli t ori t at r tve, o c
a n , n he le na i t ompel
a bir ton. t f l ngr a ons t c twilg a t m o i a c
r ta i For he olowi e s , he our l r nt hat ton nd ompela bir to of
r tai n
Pori ' c a m s
ts s l i .
Backeround

Pori bega w or ng f Rua asa f l- i e t uc drve on ora
ts
n
ki or n
u ltm r k i r
boutOc obe 1 2007.
t r 6,
A c or ng t t c pl i ,Pori r por e a va i t o uns f w o ki c tons t Rua
c di o he om a nt
ts e t d
z e y f a e r ng ondii o
n
m a ge e t oughou hi e pl en . tsalege t thi s r i o seihe i e hi
na m nt hr
t s m oym t Pori l s ha s upe v s r t r gnor d s
c pl nt o t e t d hi w ih o n hos iiy a r di ul H e a s cl i st tRua m a ge en
om ai s r r a e m t pe
tlt nd i c e.
l o a m ha
n na m t
r prm a
e i nded hi f a num be ofm i of e es s e ofw hi he di notc m i, hi h r s t
m or
r
nor f ns , om
ch
d
om t w c e uled
i hi t r na i on N ovem be 21,
n s e mi ton
r 2012. c r ng t t c pl i ,Rua us d t s r prm a
A co di o he om a nt
n e he e e i nds

t diguiet r lr s f Pori' t nni ton,whi h wa t tRua be ivedhi contnued
o s s he ea ea on or ts s e nai
c
s ha
n le
s
i

s ft c mpansc u dj o a dz isb sn s rlto hps
aey o lit o l e p r ie t u ie s eains i .
A coleci ba g ni agre nt(( 'bewe Rua a t I emai l
l tve r ai ng e me iCBA') t en n nd he nt tona
Br hehoodofTe tr Loca Uni No.1 (hef on' govenst e oyme oft 1f l
ot r
nmses
l on
71 t s
uni '
) r he mpl nt $ ul
a1

tmedrve a mantna e oye e oyedby( nla asi dt t Kr a oun i
i
i r nd i e nce mpl es mpl
Rua nd sgne o he oger cc t n
Roa
noke,Vigi a'i udi Pori.SeeRa Af.Ex. a 1 Doc tNo. 1. CBA pr de
r ni ,'ncl ng ts
y f
B t , ke
4- The
ovi s

t tRua ma dici i ordic r a empl onl tf j tc us '1 a 2.l as pr bis
ha n y s plne shage n
oyee y kor us a e.'d. t t lo ohi t
Rua f om di c i i tng aga ns a e pl e ç n an t r sorc
n r
s r m na i
i t n m oye i y e m
i
ondii nsofe pl e ' f a
to
m oym nt' or ny

S o bie bassofdic i nai unde a ia esa e, e r l orl allws'l a 1 TheCBA
t hi t d i
pr
s rmi ton
r pplc bl tt f de a , oc a .' d. t .
f r he pr dest te pl esc n c le e a ç l d vi a i n' oft t r soft CBA
u t r ovi ha m oye a ha l ng ny t ege ol to ' he e m
al
he

t oug t giva ea abirto pr e estf t i Aril 6oft ta e nt Jaa 3.
hr h he re nc nd r tain oc dur e orh n tce
ha greme .-. t
p
Pori al t t thehasnotfld a g ivanc wih r s tt hi c am s
ts cmis ha
ie
re
e t e pec o s l i .
On M a c 1 201 Pori tl ac
r h 6, 5, ts ied ompli tc lngi hi tr i ton i t sc t On
a n hale ng s e m na i n hi our.
M a 1 201 Rua tl a a e d m otont dimi sor i t at m a i t c
y , 5, n i e n m nde
i o s s , n he le tve, o ompe a bir ton of
l r ta i
Pori' cli s Thi moton hasbe f l bre e a wasar d on Jme23,201 I i now rpe
ts s am . s i
en uly i f d nd
gue
t
5. t s
i
f r vi w .
or e e
Di si
scus on

I ism oton,Rua as e t t tPori i oblgaedt a bir t hi c am sbe or heca
nt
i
n s rs ha
ts s i t o r ta e s l i
f e
n
pur ue t
s hem he e The c ta e s The Supr m e Cour oft U nie St t s a t Fourh Ci c t
r.
our gr e .
e
t he t d a e nd he
t r ui

Cour ofAppea sha bo h he dt ta a ee ntt a bir t e pl e dic i i ton ca ms
t
l ve t l ha n gr me o r ta e m oym nt s rm nai li
co a ne i a cole tve bar i ng a t m e i e or ea e,s l ng asi i e i i.Se 1 Pe
nt i d n
lci
ga ni gr e nt s nf c bl o o
t s xplc t e 4 nn

Plz s
a a LLC v Py t, 5 U.. 4 , 5 ( 0 9 (ç eh l t a ac l ci - ag iig a re n
. et 5 6 S 2 7 2 8 2 0 ) 1 od h t ol t b r ann g e me t
W
e ve
t tc e r y a l m i t ka y r qtiest o m e be st a bir t A DEA cl m s i e or ea e a a
ha l a l nd m s a bl e lr mi n m r o r t a e
ai s nf c bl s

matroffde a 1w.) Ausi v. nsBr kwayGls Conti rI .78F. 875,885( h
te e r l a ' ; tn Owe - oc
'
as
ane nc,
3d
4t
2

Ci. 9 6 (tA) e ly emus flo tegiv nc p o e ur e tbls e b t ec le t e
r 1 9 ) $ n mpo e
(
t o lw h re a e r c d e sa ih d y h o lci
v
ba gani a e me prort flng s ti fde a cour.)
r i ng gre nt i o ii ui n e r l t' .
'
TheCBA a ia et t sc ee es l pr dest tany dipu e rii t rt
pplc bl o hi as xpr sy ovi ha
s t sng mde he

a re n mu t es b e tdt teg iva c a dabtainp o e u e o ti e te en. e Ra
g e me t s b u j ce o h re n e n r irto r c d r s u ln d h r i S e y
Af. B Ar. j1(ttn t tç g iv n ei a alg dvilto o tes cfctr o gh
fEx. t6 saig ha $ re a c s n le e oain f h pe ii ems f t e
a
CBAI' ndt tû nygreva e.. lbes tldbyt pa te a or ngt t tnnsoft sAril
'a ha i
a i nc .wil ete
he ris cc di o he e
hi tce

e l i y' Unde t gre ncepr ed e,a e oye mus fl amitngre nce whiht
xcusvel ). r he iva
oc ur n mpl e t ie
te iva , c he
Uni a Rua atmptt r s ve.Se j.jj3- I t pari camotr ol t is ,t
on nd n te o eol
e .s 4. f he tes r es ve he s ue he
l
g i va i s it t t Pi dm ontGr e nce Com m it e. d. ft Com m it e f l t r c a
r e nce s ubm ted o he e
i va
te I I he
te ais o ea h

mao i d cso o t eis e t nç ih rpa' ma s b t h d a lc dis et abi ain.
j rt e iin n h su ,he s t e ly y u mit e e do ke su o r t to '
y
e
t
r
'
1 . 5 Atabtai n an u rl hr - a t, i ç o en d a dl tdb tep o so so (h
d j . r irto , e ta t id p ry who s s v r e n i e y h r viin f t e
g
mi

CbA a d a pia elw, r s le t d s ue l . 1 . eabi ao ' r s lto i bn igo
n ) p lc bl a ' e ov s he ip t. d j 0 Th r t t rs e ouin s idn n
'
r
t e pl
he m oyee a Rua 1 The CBA e i ty pr vi st ta le pl esç a ve t i r g t
nd
n. d.
xplcil o de ha 1 m oye t i he r i ht o
w

p ru a yj diil ra mi srtv rme ya an t( M Ja t a ymatrs b e tt te
u s e n u ca o d nitaie e d g i s RU s o n te u j c o h
p o e u e e tb ih db t i Aril u tls c pr c d r sa ee h use . 1 j1
r c d r s sa ls e y h s tce n i u h o e u e r x a td' d. 2.
'
I t sc e,Pori a s rst thewa tnni t d be us ofhi r pe t c
n hi as
ts s e t ha
s e na e ca e
s e aed ompli sa t
ant bou

s ey,nvi ai ofVigni Codej40.- . 1. salgai ,i tu wo dc tt ea
aft i olton
ri a
1512: Hi le tons f r e, ul onsiut
vi a i oft br d l
olton he oa t dic i i ton'pr son oft CBA,aswe la t r uie e t t
non- s rm na i ' ovii
he
l s he eq r m nt ha

Rua o l t u p n , icp ie o d shag e ly e f r us c u e'Ra Af. B. t12.
n ny t s e d d s iln , r ic r e mpo e s o j t a s . y fEx. a s
'
Pori ha t r or al edaC oltonoft s ii tr oft (
ts s heef e leg t ai
vi
he pectc ems he CBAI'whi mus beptrue
,' ch t ts d
t ough t g i va e a a bir to pr e esouti i A ri e 6 oft CBA .
hr
he r e nc nd r t a i n oc dur
lned n tcl
he
The co t
ur

e
mphasze t t at
i s ha , lhough t CBA r r sagre ncet be s te ç t n tn ( 0 d o t
he
equie
i va o ubmitd ' hi e 1 ) ays f he
wi
eve g vi rs t t gr e nce ' Ruan ha e i il a ee S o w ai a tm e lm ia i nsw ih
nt i ng i e o he i va ,'
s xplc ty gr d ç
t
ve ny i i t to
t

rs e tt t p e e tto o ( ag iv n ea dabi ainfldb o o b h l o M r P ri. M o .
e p c o he r sn ai n f 1 re a c n r t to ie y r n e af f . o t ' t
r
s'
Dimisa 7(iigRa Af. 7 , c t . . rt e er ao ,hec u tsc n tane t
s s t ctn y f ! ) Do ke No 4 Fo h s e s ns t o r i o sri d o
c
ompe t pa te t ar ta et c am ss tf rh i Pori ' c
l he ris o bir t he l i e o t n ts s ompl i .
ant
TheFourh Cic thasa
t r ui
cknowldge t nson i isde i i wih r pe tt whehe c t
e d e i n t c sons t es c o
t r ours

s o l sa o dimisa a to wh nal su sp e e tdte en aes be t oabtain. e
h ud ty r s s n cin e lis e r sn e h r i r u j c t r i to S e
r
Agca a v. OL Shi M g . ,675F. 355,376n.8( tngt tigj r ma bes me
ro M
p mt Co.
3d
1 noi ha tthee y o
t nson be we n ourdec son i Hoo e s- i c tng t tasa i r quie whe t a bir ton
e i
t e
ii n
t r ndi a i ha t y s e r d
n he r ta i
a e nttove st mate i diput - a Choi qHo el - s nci ni dimis lS n al of
gr eme c r he t r n s e' nd
c t s a to ng s s a whe l

teis e p e e td.. r ab ta l.' ( u tn Ho trs n . Phli ,1 3F.d9 3(t Ci.
h su s r sn e . a e z irb e') q o ig oes l c v. il 7 3 3 4h r
'
ps
1 ;ChoieHotl l 'al v.
999)
c
es ntl nc. BSR Tr ca RefrsJ ,252F. 707,709- 0( hCi.
opi na s-tt nc.
3d
1 4t r

2001) Noohiv.Tol Br .I ,708F. 599, n. ( h Ci. 3) TheFourh Cic tha as
);
l osn nc.
3d
605 2 4t r 201 .
t rui s lo

n tdta ço t sse cr ut aedvd do wheh radsrc c u t a d srto t ds s
o e h t t ll itr ic is r iie n te itit o r h s icein o imis
l r

rt e t a sa a a to s be t oabtain. Ag a a , 7 F.da 3 6n.8 Gi nti
ah r h n ty n cin u j c t r i to ' g ro 6 5 3 t 7 1 . ve h s
r
'
unce t nt t c twilsa t sa on pe ng a bir ton ofPori ' c am s Se Gr nv.
rai y, he our l t y hi di
ndi r ta i
tss l i . e ee

Za hr I .I , F.Supp.3d669,678( . Va. 4)
c y ndus. nc.36
W D. 201 .
C oncl i
us on

Fort r as saed, heco twilgr ntRua sm oton t c
he e ons t t t
ur l a
n'
i o ompela bir ton a t sa
r ta i nd o t y
t s pr e ngsa co di y. ogni i howe r t tPori m a pr f t f e hi cli s
he e oc edi
c r ngl Rec zng,
ve , ha
ts y e er o or go s am
r t rt n pr e wih a bir ton,t c t l die thi t s i e de et theha fl d a
ahe ha oc ed t r ta i he our wil r c m o ubm t vi nc ha
s ie
gre nc pur uan t t pr ed e s tf t i t CBA wihi 90 da oft dat ofen r oft s
iva e s t o he oc ur s e orh n he
t n
ys he e
ty hi
m e or ndtm o ni n and t ac om pa ng or .Abs nta s w i ofgood c us f f l e t
m a l pi o
he c
nyi
der
e
ho ng
a e or aiur o
pr
oceed w ihi t stm efam e,t coultwildi m i t s acton f f l e t pros e based on t
t n hi i r
he
' l s ss hi i or aiur o
ecut
he

dee n ' e rirmoto t dimis Se Fe R.Ci P. ( 'Za hz 36F. 3da 679.
fnda ts a le
in o s s . e d.
v. 41b) c y,
,
supp. t The
4

Clr i d r c e t s nd c rii c esoft sme or ndum opi on a t a ompa ng or r
e k s ie t d o e e tfed opi
hi m a
ni nd he cc
nyi
de
t t pl ntf a a 1c
o he ai i f nd 1 ouns ofr c d.
el e or

ENTER:Th s XG
i

d yofJ n , 01 .
a ue2 5
Chi Unie Stt sDiti J
ef t d a e srct udge

5