Toghill v. Clarke

Filing 31

ORDER denying 30 Motion for Preliminary Injunction. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 1/4/2016. (slt)

%a
N
.

CL S OFFI U. D6 COURT
ERK'
CE S. SQ
AT ROANOKE,V
A
F'
LED

I T H E UN I
N
TED STAT ES D I
STR I C O U RT
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I OF W R G I I
CT
N A
ROANOKE DI SI
W ON
A DA M D A RR I TO G H I ,
CK
LL
Pett oner,
ii

J g1 2 1
Ay ) g5
I Li rU'L , -E
p
k
BK
f
-

l

C i lA c i n N o.7: c 0011
vi t o
15- v9

V.

H AROLD W .CLARKE,
R espondent
.

By:

Hon.M ihae F.Ur
c l
bans
ki
Unied St es Di ri Judge
t
at
st ct

Ada Dmn c Tog l,aVigi ai t pr ee ng pr K ,sl d ape ii f am i o
m
ik
hil
r ni nma e oc di
o
e
tton or
tf

ha a c pusptrua tt 28U. C.j2254,a Reponde tfldamoi t dimis
be s or
zs n o
S.
nd s
n ie
ton o s s.

Pr sn l b f r t ec u tsPeiin rsmoi nfraprlmiayijmcinp ru n t Fe rl
e e ty eo e h o r i t o e ' to o ei n r nt to u s a t o dea
t
Rul o Ci l o e u e6 () Peiin ra k tec u too d rh si daerla efo t e
e f viPr c d r 5 a. t o e s s h o r t r e i mme it ee s r m h
t
i ionme or r d by a sae c t
mprs
nt de e
t t our.

Fe r lRul ofCi lPr e e65ma bea idt aj225 ha aspeii onl t t
de a e
vi oc dur
y pple o
4 be tton y o he
extnti i no i nsse wih a sa uor pr so ort Fede a RulsGove ni Se ton
e t s t nco itnt t ny tt t y ovii n he
rl e
r ng c i

2 4 Ca e .R. v r i gj2 5 Ca e 1 two l beic n itn wi j2 5 a dt Rue
25 s s Go en n 2 4 s s 2.I u d n o sse t t 2 4 n he ls
h

Go en n Se to 2 5 Ca e t iv l aeasaec u tsc i na j g n vaRu e6 b
v r i g cin 2 4 s s o n ai t tt o r' rmi lud me t i l 5 y
d
o d rn Pei o e' r laeb f r a j dc to h sh b a p t in.Co r W i trv. tr l
r eig tt n rs ee s eo e du iain i a e s ei o
i
t
mpae ne Nau a
Re . f Co ncl I .5 5U. 7 2 ( 0 8 , t DA' Ofs ev. bone 5 7U. 5 , 6 7
s De . u i.nc, 5 S. , 0 2 0 )wih s tc Os r , 5 S. 2 7 - 7

( 0 )( i , .(o c ni g (W eha eln r c g ie t ep i ilso fd r l m a d
20 9 Alt J) c n u n ) û
o
G
v o g e o nz d h rncp e f e eai n
s
c t a sa whe sa eprs r a tmptt us t f de a c ut t a t k t rfna
omiy t t ke
n tt ione s te
o e he e r l ot' o tac hei i l
s

c ci . (ii c s l;se,ec.28U. C.âj2244, 4,Ha ngo v. c e,562U.
onvitons' ctng a esl e . ,
'
S.
225 . ni tn Rihtr
S.

8 ,1 0( 01 ) O' u l a v Bo rk l 5 6U.. 3 , 4 ( 9 9 ; a v Neh ra d 51 U.
6 0 2 1; S li n . ec e, 2 S 8 8 8 2 1 9 ) Gr y . teln , 8 S.
v
1 1 ( 996) Colma v. mps n,501U. 72 750( 91 .Ac r ngl Peii rs
52, 61 1 ; e n Tho o
S. 2, 19 ) co di y, ttone '

mo inf rap ei n r ij n to i DENI
to o r l ay n u ci n s
mi
ED.

*.
K.
w

To t e e Pe ii ne ' r que tc dbe c tue asam o i f r e e o bal
he xt nt tto rs e s oul
onsr d
ton or elas n i

p n i gt ea j dc to o hi peiin ter q s i d n e b c us P tto e f i t e tbls
e d n h du iain f s t o ,h e ue t s e id e a e eiin r al o sa ih
t
s
bot s tntalc tt i na c am son whih heha ahi pr biiy ofs ce sa
h ubsa i onsiuto l l i
c
s gh oba lt
uc s nd

e e ina cic sa esm a ng à g a ofbalne es a y f aha sr m e t bee f c i .
xc pto l r um t nc
ki . r nt
i c s r or bea e dy o f e tve

Se . ..Untd S ae v. il 27 F. p' 2 0 27 (t Ci. 0 8 (iigLe v J b , 9
e ece ie tts Eley, 6 Ap x 7 , 0 4 h r 2 0 ) ctn e . a e 98
F.d8 9 8 (t Ci. 9 3 (ppyn t sa d r t asaep io e ) a dCalyv. l wa
2 6 , 71 6h r 1 9 ) a lig he tn ad o tt rs n r, n le Cal y,
a
4 6F.d7 , 0 (t Ci.1 7 )(p l igtesa adt ami tr p io e l.
9 2 01 7 2 5h r 9 4 a p yn h tnd r o l ay rs n r)
i
The Clr s l s nd c e o t sOr rt t pa tes
e k ha l e opi s f hi de o he ri .

Ii s ORDERED.
ts o

sxTs T ;
R: us

W

j

da of
y

- - r i- ?
uc
A
vn
.'s
ta .
s.

.

/ /- 4 J /.
+
A
Unie St t sDit tJ
t d a e sdc udge

2

Z,
%
.