Hibbert v. The Virginia Department of Corrections et al

Filing 9

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 4/27/2015. (tvt)

cbERK' AT c:t. Dl rnlm '
s oFFl t sT. t l
:.
M NVILE,
L VA
FI
LED

I THE UNI S
N
TED TATESDI TRI COURT
S CT

FO R TH E W E STER N D ISTR ICT O F V I G IN I
R
A
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI

AN 27 2 j
gj

JU
L. . u
ak

DESM OND G EORGE HI
BBERT,
Pl ntf ,
ai if

M EM ORANPIM om Nm :
;

TH E V IR G I IA DEPA R TM EN T O F
N
CORRECTI
ONS,e al,
t .
D e endant .
f
s

By:

o a

.

Ci lA c i N o.7: 5- v- 25
vi ton
1 c 001

N.

1
.

H on.Jac on L.K i e
H
sr
Se or U nied St e D it i tJudge
ni
t
at s s r c

De mond Ge geHi taVig ni i t pr ee ngpr K ,fld a cvi rg s
s
or
bber, r i a nma e oc di
o
ie
i l i ht

c ai purua t 42U. C.j 1
ompl nt s nt o
S.
983.Pl ntf nn sasdef nt t Vigi aDe rme
ai if me
enda s he r ni pa t nt
of Cor ec i and c r cto lofi e s Li ut na tCol m a Se g ntColi ,a O fi r
r tons
or e i na t c r e e n
e n, r ea
lns nd tce

Ca te.Pl i ifa lgest tOfi rCa te s a d hi wih m a et m è es a iy'afe Pl ntf
sl
antf le ha fce sl pr ye m t c ' c s rl ' tr ai if
ul
r us t c
ef ed o ompl wih Ofi e Casl sor rt r i uih aphone.Pl ntf f t ra lgest t
y t fc r te' de o elnq s
ai if urhe le ha
Sg . o lnsa Lt Col m an putPl i t f i r s r i s f ei ho sdue t hi nonc pla .
t C li nd . e
a n if n e t a nt or ght ur
o s
om i nce

F rt f lo n r a o s t ec mpan i ds se wih u p eu ief rfiigt saea
o he olwi g e s n ,h o lit s imis d t o t rj dc o al o tt
n
cai upon whi r i fm a begr nt d.
lm
ch ele y
a e 1

l

1mus dimisa a ton orcai tl by a i t i 1dee mi t tt a ton o cli i fi ouso
t s s n ci
l m ied n nmae f tr ne ha he ci r am s rvol r

fi t saeacam o whc rl f yb ga td S e28U. C. j1 5e() 1 1 A()1; 2U. C.
al o tt li n ih ei ma e rne . e
s
e
S. j 91 ()2 , 9 5 b ()4 S.
j1 7 () Thefrtsa d r icu e camsb sdu o knidsua ymeieslg lh oy't li o
99 ec .
is tn ad n ld s li ae p n ç n ip tbl rt s e a te r , ç ams f
a
l
'c
i rnge e ofaI li e e twhi cla l doesno exit'orcamswhe et çacua c e insa ece ry
nfi m nt
ega .ntr s
ch e ry
t s ' li
r he ç t l ontnto r la l
f

b s ls. Netk v W iims 4 0U.. 1 , 2 ( 9 9.Th s c n sa adi tefmiirsa d r framoin
aee s' iz e . l a , 9 S 3 9 3 7 1 8 ) e e o d tnd r s h a la tn ad o
'
l
to
t ds s u d rFe ea Rueo CiiP o e ue1 ( () ac pigapanifsfcu lalg to sa tu .A
o imis n e d rl l f vl r c d r 2b)6 , c e tn litf' a ta le ain s re

complitne das r a pl n satme oft cl m s ng t tt pl de i e ttedt r le ' nds f ent
an eds ç ho t nd ai t e nt he ai howi ha he ea r s n il o eif a ufki

l a ta alg to s. .or iearg tor l fa v tes e uaielv l. . Bel lCon. Two l 5 0
ç cu l l ain . t as ih t ti bo e h p c ltv e e. .' lAt. r v. mbv, 5
m
e
e
'
U.. 4 , 5 (0 7 (nen l u tto mak o te ) A plitf sbai frrl fte ursmo et nlb l a d
S 5 4 5 5 2 0 ) itra q oain rs mitd . anif ss o ei t q ie r ha a es n
e r
c n lso s. .' 1 .Th rfr, pan i muti l g fcssfiin t saealh ee nt o (h jcam.
o cu in . . d eeoe a litf s t l e a t u fce t o tt 1te lme s f te li '
'
f
ae
'
Ba sv E.. o n deNe us& Co.3 4F.d7 , 65(t Ci. 0 3
s . l Du o t
mo r
, 2 3 61 7 4h r 2 0 )
Dee mi ng whehe ac
tr ni
t r omplitsae apl i ecl m f r le i < conexts cik t kt tr quies
an t ts ausbl ai or eif s ç t -pe t as ha e r
a

terve n c u toda o is u iile p re c a dc mmo sn e' As rû v lba, 5 U. 6 2 67 - 9
h e iwig o r t rw n tj dca x ein e n o n e s . hco .q l5 6 S. 6 , 87
'
(0 9 .Th s ac u t ce nigac mpan u d r l l b ()c nie tf pe dn sta aen te t ldt a
2 0 ) u , o r sre n o lit n e Rue 2()6 a d niy la ig h t r o nie o n
t
as
s umpton oft t be us t y c itofno mor t lbel a c usons I A lho llbe al co tuea
i
nzh ca e he onss
e han a s nd oncl i . d. t ugh i r ly nsr

pr j compl nt Hai sv. r r 404 U. 519, 21(1 2) 1donotac a ari t sa
o.
ç
ai , ne Kene s
S. 520- 97 ,
t s l nmae' dvocae,s- s e
t ua pont
de opi saut ya c tt i cl m sno cea l r s i aco pl nt SeeBea t v.CivofHa pt
vel ng tt or nd onsiutonal ai
t l ry aied n
m ai .
ude t
t
m on,

7 5F.d 1 7 ,1 7 (t Ci.1 8 ) seas God nv. e e 5 4F.d 1 4 ,l 51(t Ci.178 (e o nii
7 2 2 4 2 8 4h r 9 5 ,e lo r o Le k x 7 2 1 7 l 4h r 9 ) r c g zng
.
t aditi cou ti no e t t as u et r eofa
hat srct r s t xpeced o s m he ol
dvocaef apr .j plitf
t or o . anig.
A

1

x

A prs ra l i e s i f c i vi a i oft Ei ht Am e
ione leg ng xce sve or e n olton he g h
ndmen mus s t t
t t how ha
a de e ntçntit d unnec s ar a wa o pai a s f rng.'W hil vv. be s 475U .
f nda û lc e
i
e s y nd nt n n nd ufe i '
te Al r ,
S.

31 320( 98 .Therf e,hepr ri r i whehe t f cea idwaskn agoodfih
2, 1 6)
eor t ope nquiy s t r he or pple
ç
i
at
e f t o mai ai orr t edic plne orma ii l a s ditc ly f t ver pur e of
for t
nt n esor s i i
lc ousy nd a si al or he y pos
c usngha m . l a 320- .ByPl i ifso a m ison,heC e us d'or r t r i s a
a i
r ' d. t
'
21
antf wn d s i
ç f e ' de s o elnquih
r

phone,a hehasnotal ge a f c st i caet us off cew a a hi ot rt n a
nd
le d ny a t o ndi t he e or
s nyt ng he ha
good f ih e f tt m ant i o r t edicplne. Be i st lngt oftm e Pli ifhasnot
at for o i an r esor s i i
sde he e h i , antf
alege a ot rf c a
l d ny he a t boutbe ng r sr i d whie i a ce a e whi h i a l w f us off c
i e t a ne
l nc r r t d, c s a ' e or e.
ul

Acc r ngl t c
o di y,he ompli pr e l f ist sa ea cam upon whih r le ma beg a e
a nt es nty a l o tt li
c ei f y
r ntd.
E NTER :
Thi

- da ofApr l 2015.
y
i,

/
e
ni U nied St t D i ti J
t
a es srct udge