Adams v. Horne et al
Filing
16
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/25/2015. (tvt)
cl 'OF I us olmcou*
mnxs FCE
s
A R A 6 kv
T oNK A
FI
LED
I THE I M TED STATES DI
N
J
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
R O A N O I DI SI N
V
W O
DOM I QUE IERM AN ADAM S,
NI
I
J 25 2 1
UN
25
JUL .
I
BY;
C
CASE NO.7:5CV00168
1
Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.
M EM O R AN DU M O PI ON
M
J S.
. HORNE, K ,
c
By: GlnE. nr d
e Co a
Chi fU ni e St e D i t i Judge
e
t d at s s r d
Dee nts.
fnda t)
Do i que He n Adams a Vigi a i t pr e di pr K ,fl t s ci lrgh s
m ni
nna
,
r ni nma e oc e ng o
ied hi vi i t
a t n pls n t 4 U. C.j 1 8 . Ad msalg s t to M a 20 01 ,t d fn a t
ci t ua t o 2 S.
o r
93
n le e ha n y ,2 4 wo e e d n
c r c i lofi r a W al nsRi St t Prs n us d exc s i f r e a i thi by al ng
or e tona fce s t le
dge ae io e
e sve o c gans m
lowi
a a tc dog t ç a a difgur ' hi wihou wn n ng a by s a ng pe rs a on hi
n ta k
o û ul nd si e' m t t r i nd
m
pr yi
ppe pr y
m
wiho c us Thec
t ut a e.
ompli hasbe n s r d on t et ofi e s
a nt
e e ve
hes wo fc r .
Se dceha notbe n a co pls d,howe r on t t ot rde e nt Adn na
r
s
e c m ihe
ve , he wo he f nda s
ms med
i te c mplit ()ç iae P io M a a eme tCo p rto t a o e ae W aln Ri g
n h o an : 1 t v t rs n n glj n r o ain h t p rt s l s d e
pr
e
SaePrs n'a ( )th To o Bi S o eGa VA W a d n sOf e' ( mpl 1 ECF No
tt io ' nd 2 t e wn f g t n p,
t
r e ' fc . Co . ,
'
.
I li c
n ls ompl i ,Adn s a lges va l t tt e e ii s d be hel la e t r
ant
m le
gue y ha hes nttes houl
d i bl mde
j198 be aus t y < nti d apolc o c t offii t a quael tan a s pe vs
3 c e he t ane
mai
iy r usom alng o de t y ri nd u r ie
Hom e i t pr pe us of hi DOC dog t t c tt t c e a t ual pl s e '
n he o r e
s
ha onsiued nll nd mus
nihm nt'
( mpl8.
Co . )
By or r e e e J m e 8 201 t c tdie t d A dn st pr vi s ci nti or a i
de nt r d t , 5, he our r c e
m o o de uo e nf m ton
a o td fnd n s()a d () t alw t ecek t r atmp s r ieo te .l rs o s t t i
b u e e a t 1 n 2 ,o lo h lr o e te t e vc n h m n e p n e o l s
l
or r Ada fl amoton t a nd,dr ngli cai a i t( )a ( ,andnn ng a a
de , ms ied
i o me
oppi ts l ms gans 1 nd 2)
mi s
de e ntt a
f nda t nage ntAnd Tr ilng Co po ai n,' c he a e ae a M TC. He al ge
M
me
a ri
r r to 'whi h
bbr vi ts s
le s
.
t tM TC ha apolc orc t off ii t ade t l ta n a s r s t K- o fc r i
ha
s
iy
usom
alng o qua ey r i nd upe vie he 9 fi e s n
t a o i t us oft rdogs He as a s rs ve ba i :
he ppr pra e e hei
.
lo s e t, r tm
(
MTQ ha t e lg l G u y .. .f r (i) e tbihng elo cng d rcig
d h ea t t
d
o sc sa ls i , rf ri , ie tn ,
s r ii and c r lngpolc e ,c t s pr tc s us ges andpr dur st
upe vsng
ontoli
ii s usom , aci e , a ,
oce e o
beus d by Core to lOfke s' M TC s t tt i G di t and/ a t G i t
e
r c i na f r 'of
o ha her t c s
e
or c s i gh
m
f il be s d t r pr e t o fc a polc 'of M TC t t aci wihi t t
ary
ai o e es nt he fi i l iy'
ha tng t n ha
C u y'M TC h d by v ro a t o o sin a d c mmiso to tre )a d
t t'
d
a
aius cs f miso n o sin G se ld n
f
e c t a ed a amos h r o lwlsn s,a rh ,r p e so a a rp t ie
n ol g gj n t p ee f a e s e s nac y e rs in nd e ei v
r
t
polcy, c t a pr tc of a e sve,a e a as a tve be vi a
i
usom nd aci e
ggr s i
bus nd s uli
ha or nd
pr ed e t r i vi larse whih (n t dae ofHone a t k on
oc ur s owad ndi dua re tes c o he t
r tac
Pli ifwihli DOC dogOme rpr e e t polc pr cie,c t us ge
antf t zs
nj e esntd he iy, a tc usom, a
a pr dur ' ofM TC,a t tHom e' a tc upon Pli tf w ih hi DOC dog
nd oce e'
nd ha
s ta k
an if t s
Om e wasGn f t r nc of...hepr c ie,c t a pr e eofM TC.
n
i urhe g e
i
t
a tc usom nd oc dur
I e ala,M TC pr vi usy had knowldge of K- ha er r pe t dl
ntr i
e o l
e
9 ndl s e a e y
fiigt gveav r l r ijpirt ted po meto terDOC d gt ma l
aln o i eba wnnn ro o h e ly n f h i
o o u
a di fgur a r se ...f le t enf r e esa ihe pr e e t i tr t
nd si e r e t es
al d o o c t bls d oc dur s o nsle he
s ft o id vd a ar se s etb ihgd a e t c l l q o a s se fr
aey f n i iu l rete ; sa ls e q nd abre d u t y tms o
ar ssa d ctto ...fild t ds iln ...Co rcin lo fc r ...who
re t n i ins
a
ale ) o icp ie
re to a fie s
h db e ft t h v fie i gvn av ra wnnnggirt t d po me t
a en omd o a e ald n iig eb l r i ro o he e ly n
o t i DOC d g t ma a d dsi t e ar se s f lgd a r f s l q t
f her
o o ul n ifgl re te ; ale ) nd e u e d o
r
c
ompee l i si a e al gai nsofa e a a s ul ...by ...Cor e tona
tnty nve tg t le to
bus nd s a t
r ci l
Of r . . o e ld u a t o mic nd ta da us o a t o iyb idv d a
t s . c v re q p cs f s o uc n b e f u h rt y n ii u l
ke
c re to a o t r;... e r e qa d c mme ld ... re to lOfies
o rcin l fkes
rwadgd n o nd e l Co rcina fc r
who dipl ye a es i a e a as a tve be vi t r ...a r se ;
s a d ggr sve, bus nd s uli
ha or owa ds
r e t es
rp ae l .. f ild t a e u tl tan a d e uc t c re to a ofc r i te
e e t dy . ale l o d q aey ri n d ae or cin l f e s n h
p o e us o aDOC d g r p ae l figd t a e u tl s p r iet e a to
rp r e f
o ; e e tdy ale ) o d q aey u e vs h cins
ofc r c ina of e s
or e to l lc r .
( o . n ! 2,ECF No.1 )( tr a atrto si o ii l. Ad msas s e t a d a
M t Ame d.
5 i en l leai n n rgna) n lo e ks o d
n
c am t tOfi e Hor neglge l f l t gi ave balwn i bef r de oyi hi dog.
l i ha fc r ne
i nty aied o ve
r
m ng o e pl ng s
The c t i r uie t dim is a a ton or cai fl d by a prs ne agans a
our s eq r d o s s ny c i
l m ie
io r i t
gove m e a e iy o om c ri t c tdee mi t a ton o c am i âi ous m ai i ,
m nt l ntt r
e f he our tr nes he c i r l i s vol , lcous
orf l t sae a cam upon whih r i ma be grnt 28 U. C.j 1 A( ( ) Gll
ais o tt li
c elef y
a ed.
S.
915 ' 1 . t- he
b)
f
t ne t t a c t m us a ce as t u al of t a l ga i
e t ha
our
t c pt
re l
he le tons c a ne i a c pl n i
ont i d n
om ai t s
i p lc b et lg lc ncuso 'o lth e d r rctl o t ee n so ac us o a to ,
na pia l o e a o l ins' r G j ra bae e ias f he lme t f a e f ci n
l
s p o td b mee c n ls r sae n s' As co tv.I b l 1 9 StCt 1 3 1 4 ( 0 9 .
u p re y r o cu o y ttme t. h r f g a, 2
'
. 9 7, 9 9 2 0 )
2
Rahe, o e c cam i tec mplit t Gta t a alg to smu t e ug t r iearg t
t r fr a h li n h o an ,he Gl ct l le ai n s be no h o as ih
g z
t r le a
o ei f bove t s c a i lve,'a t pl di mus co an E nough f t t sa e a
he pe ul tve e l' nd he ea ng
t nt i ç
e
ac s o t t
da m t r le t ti pl usbl on isf ce. BelAt.Co o.v.
i o e if ha s a i e t a ' l l r
'
Twombl 55 U. 5 555,570
v, 0 S. 44,
( 0 7 (iain o te )
2 0 ) ctto mitd .
The cou twil p a t t m o i t n e dim is al cli s ag ns G i t Prs
r l
n he ton o m nd; s s 1 am
ai t t va e ion
pr
M a glq ntCop o ain t to aes W alns Ri e Stt Prs 'a Gt Town ofBi
na eme
rto ha pert
le
dg ae ion' nd lhe
g
S o Ga VA W ad n' Ofie' t o tp eu ie a d I na e n Tr ii Co p rto '
tne p,
r e s fc 'wih u rj d c ; d t g me t anng r o ain'
Ma
(M TC' a ad fnd n ; n a dacam o n gie ea an tOfie Ho . Afe rv e o
G
&
' s ee a t a d d li f e lg nc g is fc r me tr e iw f
)
t compl nta n nded,howe r t c twilsl a iy dim ist c am a ns M TC.
he
ai s me
ve , he our l lmm rl s s he l i gai t
Fis,Ada
rt
ms'ne s isons do no pr vi a add e s f M TC,a nec s r t
w ubm s i
t o de ny
r s or
s es a y o
s r t compl nto tzs de e nt The e o e Adn sha f ie t c
e ve he
ai n li f nda .
rf r , m
s al d o ompl wih t c ts
y t he our'
o de ofJme8,a t clr hasno wa t s r eM TC.
r r t
nd he e k
y o ev
M oe ve,hec u ta e j d ca n tc o t efc t a W alnsRig i o rtdb t e
r o r t o r tk s u iil oie f h a t h t le d e s peae y h
Vigr a De rme to Cor ci n (<
r ii pa t n f re to s :
l
VDOC',a d n tb a y p i ae c mo ain. Eve i
' n o y n rv t o rto
)
nf
A da i e d t na e t VDOC a t ope a orof a polc m a rf ,t prs whe e
ms ntnde o m he
s he r t
, nd i y ke or he ion
r
te d g atc o c re ,t VDOC i no s be tt s tt e j1 3. Se W ilv. ihz n
h o ta k c u rd he
s t u j c o ui md r 98
e l M c ia
De to S aePoie 491U. 5 ,71( 9 9 (i i ta n i e sae n re tte a tn a
p' f tt lc ,
S. 8
1 8 ) tndng h t et r tts o niis cig s
h
n mso t saeaeG e s n 's be tt s it e j1 8 )
r f he tt r d ro s' u jc o ut md r 9 3 .
p
M os i
t mpora ty, Ada s mne l e sa e no f c s i s
tn l
m '
ncm nt t t s
a t n uppo t of hi cli t t
r
s am ha
a y n ' fiu et tan o s p r ie wa at a s tv f co i t c nsi in lij re' te
n o e s al r o ri r u e vs s t u aie a tr n he o tmto a n u is' h
c
de e ntofi r a l edl c
f nda
fce s leg y omm itd a i thi ;hem us pr s nts h f c si t c m pl i
te gans m
t e e uc a t n he o ant
t saea cam ofs r io y la lt underj1 3 agans a
o tt ny li
upe vs r ibiiy
98
i t nyone. Slka v.Pore,737
a n
tr
F. 368 370(t Ci.198 .I c ntas,Adn 'n nde cai a ns M TC a r t bea
2d ,
4h r 4) n o r t ms me d l m gai t
ppeas o
c l ci n of l ga a f m alc usons fom a t r c e ale ng wr f l us of f ce
ole to
e l nd ac
oncl i
r
no he as l gi
ong u e
or
agans s pe t d
i t us c s udng a r t Suc m e e a s ri oft ee e sofs r s y la lt wih
res. h r s e tons he lm nt
upe vior i biiy, t
no s
uppori f t s c t t Adn s ca e cn t s t e t r I ba t sae a a tona e
tng acs pe ik o
m ' s , nno ufk mde q l o tt ny ci bl
cam u d rj1 8 .
li n e 9 3
Fort sa e r as ,t c twilgr ntAda s moton t a e dim is wihou
he tt d e ons he our l a
m ' i o m nd; s s t t
p eu iet camsa ans û iaeP io M a a ll n Co p rto 'çheTo o Bi S o e
rj d c he li g i t l v t rs n n g eme t r o ain't
pr
t wn f g t n
Ga VA W ad n' Ofie' a d sl rl ds s wi o t p eudc Ad ms cams t t
p,
r e s tc ' n l
' ,
'
mma i imis t u rj ie n ' li ha
y
h
G mA ge e And Tr i ng Cor a i 'orM TC f ie t ta n a s r i e Ofi rHo ne.
t a m nt
M
ani
por ton'
al d o r i nd upe v s fce r
The c e wilgo f wa d onl a t Ada 'c am sofe es i f c ag ns t t de e
as l
or r
y so
ms l i
xc sve or e ai t he wo f ndan
t
ofi e sa li cai ofne i nc by Ofi rHor An a oprae or rwilis he e t
fc r nd ls l m
glge e
fce
ne.
ppr it de l sue r wih.
The Clr i die t d t s nd copi oft s me o a lm o ni a ac mpa ng or r t
ek s r ce o e
es hi m r nd l pi on nd co nyi
de o
llt liï
lErtfl
i
EN TER:Iu s JS
d yo J n , 2015.
a fue
ChifUnie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge
4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?