Adams v. Horne et al

Filing 30

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 2/8/2016. (tvt)

rlFM s OFFI U. DI COuRT
CE B. SQ
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

I TH E UM TED STATES DI
N
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W EST ERN DI
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
ROANOK E DI
VISI
ON

DOM I QUE HERM AN ADAM S,
M

FE2 û2 2 1
25
JULI C
A
BK
D

CASE NO.7:5CV0016
1
8

Pl nt f ,
ai i f

V.

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
M

J. .
S HORNE, K ,
c

By: Gln E. nr d
e Co a
Chi fUnied St e Dit itJudge
e
t
at s s rc

Dee da ts.
f n n t)
Thi cvi rg t a to fld p ru n t 4 U. C.j1 8 c me b f r t c u to a
s i l ih s cin i u s a t o 2 S.
e
9 3 o s e o e he o r n

moin f r sl r j d me tb Dee d n s J Hon a d D.A.Roln ?s p o td b
to o l
mmay u g n y fn a t .S. r e n
l s u p re y
i
a fda t . Pl n if Dom i q Her n Adn s a Vigila i a e pr e ng pr K , has
fi vis
aitf
ni ue
ma
m ,
r ri nm t oce di
o
.

r ponded wih hi s n sa e e , a ng t mate dpe f diposto Afe r viw oft
es
t s wor tt m nt m ki he
tr
or s ii n. tr e e
he
pa tes s isons t c zt c udes t t m aei l f t al diput pr l
ri ' ubm s i , he otr oncl
ha
tla ac u
s es ecude sl a y
lmm r

j g n , ndt ematrwil es t o t l
ud me ta h te l b e f r da.
Ac or ng t Adn ,on M a 20,201 a W al ns Ri St t Pds I a e Coli
c di o
ms
y
4, t le
dge a e
on, nm t
lns
physcal a tc Ada si t r r a i ya d. W lieAda swa on hi handsa knee a
i ly ta ked
m n he ec e ton r
ll
m
s
s
nd
s nd
tyi t 1y down o hi c t De e ntHo nelr ed hi ca ne,Ome t bie Ada st ce
r ng o a
n s hes, f nda
r zg
s ni
n, o t
m wi

wihou frtgi nga ç r lK- wn ni 'a t nt e Adn ont g omd. ( .Res
t t is vi ny t ba 9 r ng,' nd he hrw
ve
ms he r t
P1 p.

Ad msSmt ! 8 9 ECF No. 6. AsAd msly o li c eto t g omd Roln s r y d
a t . ! -,
2)
a a n l h s n he r t , lis p a e
s
G p p rs r y'i h se s no e a d mo t ( - ! 9. As a rs l o Ho nesalg d
I e pe p a ' n i ye , s , n
OC
uh. J s )
#
e ut f r ' l e
e
m ic
s onduc ,Adn s f r dog biewot t hi ba k a hi unde n m a e on bot sde of
t
ms ufe ed
t
mds o s c nd s
r r ra
h i s

hi b d ,a d a rso t hsk e ,eb w,a' b to k ;hs ijlisr q ie me ia c r .
s o y n b a ins o i ne s lo nd u tc s i nt e e urd dc l a e
r
Ada sc e t tHom e a Roli bot us d lnne s a y a e e sve f ce a i thi
m ont nds ha
nd lns h e l ce s r nd xc s i or gans m

CL RK
,

i vi a i oft Ei ht Am e
n olton he g h
ndmen a t tHor wasneg i nti f ii t gveave ba Kt nd ha
ne
lge n alng o i
r l
9 wa ni be or de o nghi dog.
r ng f e pl yi
s
De e nt c e t tt y us onl s h f ceaswasr as bl nec s r i a g
f nda s ontnd ha he ed y uc or
e ona y es a y n ood

f ih e f tt sop t i a e fom fg i a r sor or r De e nt ' e de i t t
at for o t he nm t s r
i htng nd e t e de . f nda s vi nce s ha
Ada sa Coli beg n fghtng i t r c e ton ya d o M a 20,201 ml r f s d t c
m nd lns a i i n he e r a i
r n y
4, d e u e o ompl
y
wih num e o or r t so e n afe ofi r i t con r b00t a gl pos fr d t
t
r us de s o t p, ve tr fce s n he tol
h nd m
t le wo

e s M Sl
r u d o GOC s ay'latt fght r ( . l J HoneAfi . 4, No 2 . Honete
o n s f t pr ' he
mm. . r fd ! ECF . 4) r h n
.

m o d i wih Ome ga ve balo de st t i aest so fg i a whe t y di no ,
ve n t
n, ve r
r r o he nm t o t p i hthg, nd
n he d t
or r Om e t e age whih t dog di Def nda s e de e i t tAdn spt he t
de ed
n o ng , c he
d.
e nt ' vi nc s ha
m
mc d he

d ga ij r dhm, cac dHo n ' n m, n c n iu dr ssiga dr f sn t c mpywih
o nd nu e i srthe r e s r a d o tn e eitn n e u ig o o l t
or r untlafe Roli s aye OC g on hi .
de s i tr lns pr d
as
m
Fi ng ge neis sofm ae ilf c i diput ast Ada s cai ofe s i f c
ndi
nui s ue
tra a t n s e o
m ' l ms xce sve or e
a neg i nc , a as t ke e e e s of de e n s def ns s of qualfe a s r i
nd
lge e nd
o y lm nt
f nda t ' e e
i d nd ove e gn

i nt , h c u t ild n d fnd ns moin f rs mma yj g n . S e ea,Hu s n v
mmu iy t e o r w' e y ee a t ' to o u r ud me t e , .. d o .
l
M c il n,5 3U. 1 5 ( 9 2 Cç l c say a dwa tn ifito o p i .. c n ttts
M li 0 S. , 1 9 ) t mne e s r n n o n lcin f an . o siue
a
he
cu la d t s a p n s me tf r id n b teEihh Ame d n ) Buo o o ev.Ha s 6
r e n mu u l u ih n o bd e y h g t
n me f'; n c r
ni , 5

F.d 3 7 3 9 ( t Ci. 1 9 ) (i dn sl r j g n no p o e whe r s lto o
3 4 , 5 4h r 9 5 fn ig l
mmay ud me t t r p r n eou in f
q aiid i miy q sin a d cam is l b t d pe d u o d tnn nn wh tha p n d ;
u l e mml t ueto n li tef oh e n p n ee i ig a p e e )
f
Co b v Bo d n 40 S. 2 1 4 1 9 ( 9 )( odng t a fr p i f ce c s p e l ig
l y . v e , 0 E.d 8 , 8 1 91 h li h t o rma a i a e r cudn
de e nt ofi e ' s r gn i
f nda
tc r s ove ei mmuniy de e e,pli if mus sa e f c s s
t f ns
antf
t tt a t howi ofi e '
ng fc rs
ac i c tt e gr s ne i nc - t ta e e of s i dii nc ort wa ofe
tons ons im d os glge e he G bs nc
lght lge e, he nt ven s a
c nt

c r 'twa d s ft o o h r) Be a eno o t p rish sd ma d d atilb j r ,t e
ae' o r aey f t es. c us ne f he a t a e n e ra y u y h
e
' Acc di t deenda s evi nc , t tr &OC gas'r fr t ol r sn ca ium ,as known as
or ng o f nt' de e he em I
' ee s o eo e i psc
lo

pe p rs ry ( S mm. . l Afi.( . Thss btn ei Eo tn susdt c nrldsu tv o fn es'
p e pa . M. u J Rolns fd !5) i u sa c s ç meh e e o o to irpie fe d r.
i
s
'

c u t l rf rt matrt t Untd S ae M a itaeJ dg t e 2 U. C. 6 6b ()B)
o r wi e e he te o he ie tt s gsrt u e md r 8 S. j 3 () 1(
l
t c
o onduc a o it cou tpr e di a r nde pr pos fnd ngs of f c ,concuso of
t ppr pra e r oc e ngs nd e r o ed i i
at
l i ns
l w,a r c me
a nd e om nded diposto oft s cai s
s ii n he e l m .
So e ofAda s cli sf r le m us be s ma iy dim is howe r a t val bl
m
m ' am or e if t um rl s s ed,
ve , s ma ia e

i t i j1 8 a to . Prvat cii ns, l Ad ms c n o b i gadrc c i n la to a ans
n h s 9 3 cin2 i e tze i
ke n , n n t rn ie t rmia cin g i t
a t rpe s orpeii a f de a c tt c
no he r on
tton e r l our o ompelt c nalpr e uton ofa he per o
he dmi
os c i
not r s n.

Se Lid R.S.v.Rih r D. 41 U..61 ,61 ( 9 3 (i dn : p i t ctz n lc a
e na
c ad , 0 S 4 9 1 7 ) fn ig 1 rvae iie a ks
a
j d cal c g ia l itrs i tep o e u in o no p o e uin o a t e' I a dto a
u iil o n z b e n eet n h r sc to r n r s c to f noh r). n d iin, n
y
imaema n tus a j 1 8 a to t s e rso ai n o rv k d g o c n uc tmeba e o
n t y o e
9 3 cin o e k e trto f e o e o d o d t i
sd n
alege vi a i ofhi c tt tonalrght durng dicplna y pr e ngs whe e s es on
l d oltons
s onsiu i
i s i
s i i r oce di , r ucc s
s h a cai woul nec s dl i y t i i t ofhi t r o confne e ,a e as wi
uc
lm
d es a y mpl he nvaldiy
s em f
m nt bs nt ho ng
t thi dicplna y c ci nsha bee o rum ed. Se e. ,Edwa dsv.Ba io 5 U .
ha s s i i r onvi to
ve n ve t
e, R.
r
ls k, 20 S.

6 ( 9 7 . Ad ms h s ma e n s c s o n . Fo t e ra o s sae ,Ad ms cams fr
41 1 9 )
a a d o u h h wig r h e s n ttd n ' li o

ij cie rle,s e i t b i g c i na c a g sa an tt e d f n a t a t e pt e hs
nun tv eif e kng o rn rmi l h r e g is h ee d n s nd o x mg i
dicplna y c ci ns a pe te r lt d t t alege e e sve f r e i i nt wilbe
s i i r onvito nd nali s ea e o he l d xc s i o c ncde , l

sl rl d s se wih u p eu ieu e j 1 5 b ()
l
mma i imis d t o t rj dc nd r 91 A()1 .
y
The j1 3 c s wilgof wad o yast Ada 'cai ofe si f r ea i tt
98 a e l or r nl o ms l ms xce sve o c gans he
t de e ntof e sa hi c am ofne i nc by Ofk e Hom e. An a oprae or rwil
wo f nda
fc r nd s l i
glge e
t r
ppr i t de l
is he e t The Clr i diece t s nd co es of t s memor ndlm opi o a
s ue r wih.
ek s r td o e
pi
hi
a l
ni n nd
ac om pa ng or rt pl i i .
c
nyi
de o a ntg

y
b ur
ENTER:Ths Q X da ofFe r ay, 201 .
i
6
Chi U nie S a e D i t i tJ
ef t d t t s s rc udge
2Theco r mus dimisa cli fld by aprs ra i tagove n t e iy orofieri t acin
u t t s s ny am ie
ione gans
r menal ntt
fc f he to

i d v lu , lco s o fist saeacam u o whihrl f yb g a td. 28U.. j1 5 b ()
s t oo s maiiu , r al o tt li p n c ei ma e rne '
gi
e
'
SC. 91 A()1.