Goode v. Collins et al

Filing 9

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 5/14/2015. (tvt)

eL .A Fl u.s. oj couRT
ERK' oF cE
sm
T DANVIL ,vA
F LE
I
LED

MAt 1i 2 1
25
DUDL
FNTHU IEETDE RSRCVRU T BY: x C.v cs
IRTE WET SAIS ITO TIOII JU j R C
O H ENT DR TSDC I CGRA
S N T F N
(

ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI

D EZA CH TR E R .G O O D E,
Pl ntf ,
ai if

C i lActon No.7: 5- v- 85
vi
i
1 c 001

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
CO L LI S,e aI,
N
t .
D efendant
s.

By:

H on.Jack o L.Kier
ls n
s
Se or Unied St e D i t i tJudge
ni
t
at s s r c

Dez c r R . oode, Vi gi a i a e pr e ng pr K , i e a c vi rght c pl nt
a ht e G
a r ni nm t oce di
o t l d i l i s om ai

purua t 42U. C.j 1 na nga dee
s nt o
S.
983, mi s fndant Coli , prs u tma ge ,a Lt
s lns a ion ni na r nd .
M ccoy,aprs buidi s r ior Pl i ifal ge t thet d Lt M cco t thi
ion l ng upe v s . antf le s ha
ol .
y ha s
s
ubor na e ha no gi n Pl i ifa s e a t e m e l a t t de pie Pl i if s
di t s d t ve a ntf how r nd hr e a s nd ha , s t a ntf '
r ques s Lt M c
e
t , . coy w oul nott a f rPl n ift a he pa toft pr s
d
r ns e ai t f o not r r he i on.

Pli tf f l t des i a de e ntsdei r t i fe e ora a y ca orsgnii a
a n if ais o crbe
f nda ' lbe a e ndif r nce n t pi l i fc nt
ha ds p i r l ton t t or na y i i n s ofprs lf ,a he hasno co tt i lr g t
r hi n e a i o he di r nc de t
i on i e nd
ns iutona i ht o

behousd i a pa tculrpa tofaprs Se e. ,Sandi v.Col r 51 U. 472( 995)
e n ny ri a r
ion. e, g.
n
me , 5 S.
1 ;

Fame v Brn a 51 U. 8 5( 9 4 ; e c u v. n , 2 U. 2 5( 9 6 .W hl t e
r r . e n n, 1 S. 2 1 9 ) M a h m Fa o 4 7 S. 1 1 7 ) i h
e
Cons iuto pr e t pr s m e sf om c u la unus llvi co to , i a e i notentte
tt i n ot c s i c r r
r e nd
ua i ng ndii ns an nm t s
il d

t r i be aus hehasbe e
o elef c e
en xpos d t unc ora e, esrc i ,ori onve e co tonsof
e o omf tbl r titve nc
ni nt ndii
c i m e . Se H e r on v. i g ni 2007 U . Di t LEX I 70
onfne nt e nde s
V r i a,
S. s .
S 207, * 2007 W L
at 26,

2 81 2 , t* ( . Va Se t 21 2 0 )( n a J) Rahe,C l t ee e t h ts c
7 7 2 a 7 W D. . p . , 0 7 Co rd, .. t r (to h xtn t a u h
g
c tonsa er src i ore n harh, he a epa t t pe t t tc i nalofe r pay
ondii
r e titve ve
s t y r r of he naly ha rmi
f nde s

f t i ofe e a i ts it ' Rhodesv. pma 45 U. 337,3 ( 981.Ac r ngl
or her fns s gans ocey.'
Cha n, 2 S.
47 1 ) codi y,

tec mpli i d s se wih u p eu iefrfiigt saeacam u o whc rle ma b
h o ant s imisd t o t rj dc o aln o tt li p n ih eif y e
gr nt d.l
a e
ENTER :Thi t M d yo Ma , 201
s Q- a f y
5.
5

k Se rUnie St t Diti tJ
ni
t d aes src udge
<

1Imus dimisanacin orc am tldbya i t i Ide emi t tt a ton orcam i fi o or
t s s
to
l i ie
n nmae f t r ne ha he c i
li s rvolus

fi t saeacam o whc rle ma beg a td Se 2 U. C. j1 5e( ,1 5 b () 4 U. C.
al o tt li n ih eif y rne . e 8 S. j 91 ()2) 91 A()1, 2 S.
s
'
j1 9 ec.Th frt tnd r i ld scamsb sdu nt nids ua l meie slg lhe z 'tli o
9 7 () e is sa ad ncu e li a e po ç n ip tby rt s e a t oy'ç ams f
a
l
c
i rngementofalgali er twhih clarydoe note s 'orcai wheet ç a t co en i aecl ry
nfi
e nt es c e l s
xit' l ms r he < cual nt tons r ea l
f

b sls. Netk v W il ms 4 0U. 31 , 2 (9 9 .Th sc n sa d r i tefmia sa d r framoin
aee s' iz e . la , 9 S. 9 3 7 1 8 ) e e o d tn ad s h a l r tn ad o
'
i
i
to
t ds s u d rFe ea Rueo CiiPr e t el b( )a cpigaplitf sfcu l l g t nsa tu .A
o imis n e d r l l f vl ocdl 2()6, c e tn anif ata al ai s r e
r
e o
c pl ntne dsç s ta pli sae entoftecli s i t t plade i e il t r i a s t int
om ai e t hor nd an ttm
a
h am how ng hat he e r s ntted o elef' nd ufk e

çqa ta alg t n . .oriearg tt rl fa o et s eultv lv l. . Bel lCo p v Two y 5 0
t cu l le ai s . t as ih o ei b v he p c aie e e. .' lAt. r . . mbl, 5
l
o
e
'
U. 5 4, 5 (0 )(nen lq tt nmak o te ) A pan ifsb ssfrrle çe ur smoeta lb l a
S. 4 5 5 2 07 itr a uoai rs mi d . litf' ai o eifi q ie r h n a es nd
o
t
r
c n l ins. .' l Th rfr , panif t<l g fcss fce tt saealh ee nso g e cam.
o cuso . . d. eeo e a litfmusI l e at ufiin o tt 1te lme t f t j li '
'
ae
h
'
Basv. l Du n d Ne u s& Co, 2 F.d7 1 7 5(t Ci. 00 )
s E.. po t e mo r
.3 4 3 6 , 6 4h r2 3.
De emi ngwhehe ac
t r ni
t r ompli saesaplusbl cam f r ifi <acontxts ik t s t tr uie t
ant tt
a i e li or ele s (
e -pect a k ha eq r s he

rve n cutoda o isu iilx rec a cmmo sne'Ascot lba, 6U.. 6 , 7 -9
e iwig o rt rw n tjdca egeine nd o n es. hrfv.g l55 S 6 2 6 87
'

(00 ) Th s ac u t ce nngac mpa u e Ruel ()6 c nie tf pedig t t r n t nildt a
2 9 . u , o r sre i o lmt nd r l 2b () a d n i la n s ha ae o e tte o n
y
asum pto oftut bec us t co itofno m o et n lbesa co l ins l Alho h 1lber l consr a
s
in r h a e hey nss
r ha a l nd ncuso . d. t ug i aly
tue

po..o litHan sv. re, 0 U.. 9 5 021(9 2, d no ata a imaesa v ct,uaso t
r K c mpan, ie Ktn r 4 4 S 51 , 2 - 1 7 )1 o t c s n n t' d o ae s p ne
de o ng saut y a c tt i lcli notcla l r ie i ac
velpi t t or nd onsiutona ams
e ry as d n ompli .Se Br k v.Ca l 1 F. 241
ant e oc
nol, 07 3d ,

2 3(t Ci. 9 7 ( ti, .c n urng; a et . t o Ha tn, 7 F.d 1 7 ,1 7 (t Ci. 98 ) se
4 4h r 1 9 ) Lutg J, o c ri l Beud tv Ci f mpo 7 5 2 2 4 2 8 4h r 1 5) e
v
as God nv Leke 5 4F.d1 4 ,1 5 (t Ci. 97 )(e o niigta adsrc c u tsn te petdt
lo ro . e , 7 2 1 7 1 1 4h r 1 8 rc g zn h t itit o r i o x ce o
as um e t r e ofa
s
he ol
dvoca e f a pr K plitf)
t or o
anit.
.