Gupton et al v. Wright et al

Filing 17

ORDER denying 12 Motion to Certify Class. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/22/2015. (slt)

ct s oy ueU. . B 6OtReRK' Fl S DtT. l i
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
R O A N O K E DI SI N
W O
G

MAï 22 2 1
05
J
ULW G7
DUDLEM LERK

STOPHER GUPTON
Cas N o. 15CV 0021
e
7:
4

BK

D

CL

Pl i i f
a ntf ,
V.

O R D ER

B. RI
W GHT, K ,
C

By:Ho GlnE. nrd
n. e Co a
Chi fUnie Stt Diti tJ
e
t d a es src udge

Dee a ts.
fnd nt)
Pl itf,a Vigi a i t m oc edng pr K ,tl t s cvi rght aci n t r 42
an if
r ni nma e
e i
o
sed hi i l i s to mde
.

U. C.j 1 8 . Heha n w s b te at t n f rca sc riiainy sai hi itn int
S.
93
s o u mitd G i o ls e t c to ' tt
mo o
f
' ng s n e to o
vi c t t r lgi rght ofa g oup ofi aesi a c r td wih hi . Upon r viw oft
ndia e he ei ous i s
r
nm t nc r e ae t m
e e
he
r or i i no
ec d, t s w

Aoz
cbcEo wxo oRoEl
um
t tp an i smoin frc riiain o a ca s( No 1 )i DENI
ha litc
to o e t c to f ls ECF . 2 s
f
ED. Th c u tc n o
e o r nn t
c riy a cl s i a a ton,s h a t s o whe e a pr K ltga s e t r pr s nt t
e tf
as n n c i
uc s hi ne,
r
o
ii nt e ks o e e e he

itr sso t ca s Ox n i v. iln ,5 9 F.d 1 0 ,1 7( t Ci.1 75 (1 ) i pan
n ee t f he ls . e dne W l ms 0 2 4 5 40 4h r 9 ) GIt s li
i
(
e or t pe mi t s i ioned ltga who i l sse by c ms lt r e e hi f low
n' o r t hi mprs
ii nt
s mas it d
ot e o epr s nt s e l

imae i aca sa to ' I s c c s s tec u t yalw i dv d l litfse c t b ig
n ts n ls cin. n u h a e ,h o r ma lo n iiua p an if a h o rn
).
hi o lws i o t s m e i s , satng hi i vi l cai ,or m a a nt c ms lt
s wn a u t n he n
'
s ue t i
s ndi dua l ms
y ppoi ot e o
r pr s nta vibl cas o pli if . I Co ms i a i e t a cvi pli tf o y upon a
e ee
a e l s f antfs d. t el s ppo ntd o i l a n if nl
s
howi ofe e i
ng
xc ptonalcr lm sa es ho ve ,and pl i ifha no de onsr t d t pr s nc
ic l t nc , we r
antf s t m ta e he e e e

of s h cr tm sa es he e. Se Unie St t v. $ 000. 865 F. Supp 339, 340uc icl t nc
r
e t d aes
27. 00,
41
f
'

( D. . 1 9 )
S. A V. 9 4 .
W
TheClr i d r c e t s nd a c py oft sor rt t pl i if
e k s ie t d o e
o
hi de o he antf.

ExTER:

T i AJ. dyo Ma, 0 5
hs
a r y 2 1.
ClifUnie Stt sDititJ
le
t d a e src udge