Rountree v. Clarke et al
Filing
64
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 4/28/2017. (tvt)
RlFRK S OFFI U. DI
CE S. SX
plF'.'OKE,
s- i ''
- . .l
3 .
VA
.,r i
, :.
:
APR 28 2 1
27
I TH E U N I ED STA TE S D I RI C OU R T
N
T
ST CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
ROANOKE DI I O N
V SI
'
J F : $t
ULI. . ' .
p
BY:
PIPE R A .R O U N TR EE,
Ca eN o.7: 5CV 00
s
1
220
Pl i if
antf ,
Y.
M EM O R AN DU M O PI O N
NI
HAROLD CLARKE, AL ,
ZI
By:Ho GlnE.Co a
n. e
nr d
ChifUnie Stt sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge
Dee nts.
fnda t)
By o ni n a or r e e ed Fe ua y 1 201 t c t g a ed t de e nt '
pi o nd de nt r
br r 6,
7, he our r nt he f nda s
moi n frsl r j dg n . Sp cfc l t ec u t o ndt tp an if Pie Ro n re h d
to o l
mmay u me t e iial h o r f u ha litf, p r u te , a
y,
no pr e e a ge ne is of ma e i lf ti diput on whih s c d pe s de a f c
t es nt d
nui s ue
t ra ac n s e
c he oul r ua
at
fnde t tdef nda s polc pr bii he fom ptr ha i a mai ai ng a pe s na yoga
i r ha
e nt ' iy ohi tng r r
lc sng nd
nt ni
ro l
ma i he cel vi aed he rgh s t r t Consi to or t Re i ous La Us and
t n r l olt
r i t mde he
tm i n
he lgi
nd e
I ttto aie Pe s n Ac ($ , PA' . Ro n re h sn w mo d f rr c n ie ain a
nsi in lz d ro s t 1 UI '
u
RI
) u te a o
ve o e o sd rto nd
s kst n e he c
ee o m nd r ompli wih a tona f t a a gume s The c tfndsno m e i t
ant t ddii l acs nd r
nt .
our i
rt o
t m o i n and wilno pe mi n e e oft scos d a to
he to
l t r t m ndm nt hi l e ci n.
Be aus Rot r e sgned a da e he moton wihi 28 da fom e r o t
c e
mte i
nd t d r
i
t n
ys r
nty f he
j d me t t e c u twila d e s i u d rRue 5 ()o te Fe e a Ru e o Ci lP o e t e
u g n, h o r l d r s t n e l 9e f h d rl ls f vi r c dl .
r
Un e t snze çe o sd rto o aj d me ta trise ty i a e ta r ia yrme y whc
d r hi l, i c n i eain f u g n fe t nr s n xr o dn r e d ih
r
s dbeus d s rngl ' .I .Co.v. Na ' FieI .Co. 1 F. 396,403 ( h Ci.
houl
e pa i y.
'Pac ns
Am. tl r ns , 48 3d
4t r
1 (ntmalcttonsandquottonmakso ted) TheUnie SttsCo tofAppeasf
998) i e
iai
ai
r mit .
td ae ur
l or
t eF u t Cic i h srpe tdyr c n z d ta aj d me tma b a n e u d rRue 5 ()
h o rh rut a e ae l e og ie h t u g n y e me d d n e l 9e
i onl t e crumsa es ( )t a ommodaea i e ve ngc ngei c r lnglw;( t
n y hre ic tnc : 1 o cc
t n ntr ni ha n ontoli a 2) o
a co f ne e de eno a lbl a til or( t core tacla er of1w o pr ve
c unt or w vi nc t vaia e t ra' 3) o r c e r ror a r e nt
,
CLERK
ma ie t nu tc . S e e:.Ga la ov. la c S a d r LieI s Co, 4 F.d2 0 2 n.
n fs ij sie e , . , cin Rein e tn a d f n . .5 7 3 3 , 41 8
( t Ci.2 0 ) Th r l i mo t c ranl no Gn e d d t gv a u h p ltg n o e
4h r 0 8 . e u e s s e ti y t û tn e o i e n n a py i a t n
i
i
a dto a c n et s y tej g . o s iev. I Du n d Ne t sa d Co.8 6F.d
d iin l ha c o wa h ud e' swht E.. po t e moz n
'Cr
r
,9 2
1 6 ,1 9 W L 1 6 6*1(t Ci.1 9 )
36 90
58
4h r 9 0 .
The c thas ca e ul r vi wed Rot r s ne s iso a fnds t t i doe
our
r f ly e e
mtee' w ubm s i n nd i
ha t s
pr s nta cic sa e war ntng t r quese r if Rountee m e ey r sa e t e de e;
ee
r um t nc
r a i he e t d ele
r
r l e t t s he vi nc
pr des ne f c s a lbl butnotpr vi l pr s nt ,a r a gues he e ie c e. She
ovi
w a t , vaia e
e ousy e e ed' nd e r
r ntr as
d e n tp e e ta y itr e i g c n e o 1w o i e tf a y ce rer ro 1w o ij sie
o s o r sn n n e v n n ha g f a r d n iy n la ro f a r n u tc .
Th r f r, h c u t l d n h rmo int atro a n j g n .Ana p o it o d rwil
e eo e t e o r wil e y e to o l r me d ud me t
e
p r prae r e l
i s he e ih.
s ue r w t
The Clr i die t d t s nd ac oft so de t t pl ntf a t c
ek s rce o e
opy hi r r o he ai if nd o ouns lo r c d
e f e or
f t de e nt .
or he f nda s
ENTER:
Ths 11 d yo lpp.t , 01
i
a f
/ - 2 7.
Chif nie Stt sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?