Flowers v. Colvin
Filing
17
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/17/16. (eot)
G ERKS OFFI U. DI CC' f'
CE 9. ST . ' ;
' .2
J
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STY CT COURT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON
MI
CHAEL W AYNE FLOW ERS,
JUN 1? 2 1
26
J A
ULI
BK
DEP
, EIF
CL R C
'
L
ERK
Ci lA c i N o. 7: 5CV 00243
vi ton
1
Pl ntf ,
ai i f
M EM O R AN DU M O PI O N
NI
CA R OLY N W .COLV I A c i
N, tng
Commisone ofSoc a Se t iy,
si r
il cu t
By:
Ho Gl n E.
n. e Conr
ad
Chi fUnie Stt Diti tJ
e
t d aes src udge
Dee n.
f nda t
Pl i ifha fl d t sa ton c lngi t fnaldec so oft Comm isone ofSoc a
antf s ie hi c i hale ng he i
ii n he
si r
il
Se uiyde ngpli ifscai f s e e a s c iyi omebe ist r heSo a Se urt
ct' nyi antf l m or upplm nt l e urt nc
t
neft mde t
cil c iy
Ad,a n n e ,4 U. C.j 1 1# s o.J rs ito o t i c u t sp ru n t 4 U. C.j
s me d d 2 S.
38 . e u idcin f hs o r i u s a t o 2 S.
!
1 8 ()3 , ihi o p rtsj2 5 g o teSo il cziyAc, 2U.. j40 () Thi c u t
3 3 c()wh c nc r o ae 0 () fh ca Se l t t4 SC. 5 g . s o r'
r
s
r viw i lmie t a dee mi ton a t whehe t r i s tnta e de e t s ppor t
e e s i td o
t r na i s o
t r he e s ubsa i l vi nc o u
t he
Commi so rsc l i nt t aitf f ie t me tt c tonsf e ilm e esa ihe
s i ne ' oncuso ha pl n if al d o e he ondii or ntte nt t bls dby
a ptr ua t t Ac .I s h s bsa i le de ee ss t fna de son o t Com misone
nd ls nt o he t f uc u t nta vi nc xit ,he i l cii f he
si r
mu tbea tr d.La v Cee rz e 3 F.d 6 0 (t Ci.1 6 ) Sae b fy, u tn il
s
f me
s
ws . lb e z , 68 2 4 4 h r 9 6 . ttd del s bsa ta
e de eha be n de i a s hr e n e de , nsde i t r c d a awhol ,a mi be
vi nc s e fned s uc elva t vi nce co i rng he e or s
e s ght
f unda uaet s
o
deq t o uppor aco l i
t ncusonby ar as na emi Ri ha ds v. r l s 402U . 389,
e o bl nd. c r on Pe a e ,
S.
4 (9 )
01 1 71.
Thepl ntf , i ha lW . ower , a bo n o br at zl 1 , d e nt lyc pl t
ai i f M c e
Fl
s w s r nFe u y , 965 > ve ua l om e ed
hi hi s hoo e a i M.. owe sas c
s gh c l duc ton. r Fl r lo ompl t d s ve a c s i colege W hiepl ntf
e e e r l our es n l .
l ai if
haswor d fom tm et tm e t Adm i sr tveLa J
ke r i o i , he
nitai
w udgede e m i d t tM r Fl r ha no
t r ne ha . owe s s
pas r e ntwor f pur esofco i r ton ofhi cl m f s eme a s urt i ome
t elva
k or pos
nsde a i
s ai or uppl nt l ec iy nc
b n tt. TR3 0 . uy2 2 1 p anif ie a a p iainf r u plme tl e miyic me
e eis ( 0 ) Onl l 7, 01 , litf fld n p lc to o s p e n a s c t n o
be ft .I s e st e dira i ai f s h be ft ha pr n uns e s ul I flnghi
ne is t e m hat a e pplc tons or uc ne s d ove
ucc s f . n ii s
mos r c ntc am , r Fl r al gb t thebe nmedia e f a 1f r of s t nta ganf
t e e l i M . owe s le d ha
c
s bl d or l o ms ubsa il i ul
e oy e on Jme6,2003,duet pa n i li ba ne k,rg hi a l g;hi bl pr s e
mpl m nt t
o i n ls ck, c i ht p nd e gh ood es ur ,
hit y o pa r a ii ;acd r fux;de es i ,a n e y. Pl i ifnow mai ai t the has
sor f nc e tts i e l
pr son' nd nxit
antf
nt ns ha
r m ane dia e t t pr s nttm e.
e i d s bld o he e e i
M r Fl r cli wasde ed upon i ta co i r ton a r onsde a i
. owe s' a m
ni
niil nsde a i nd ec i r ton. He t n
he
rque t a rceve aéqnovohe dnga rviw beo ea Admi srtveLa J .I a
e sed nd e i d
a
nd e e fr n
nitai w udge n n
opi o da e Fe a y4, 4,heLa J ea s dee ne t tM r Fl r i notdia e f
ni n t d bnz r 201 t
w udg lo tnni d ha . owe s s
s bld or
pu pos ofhi a i ai n f rs e nt ls c liy i m ebe ft . TheLa J
r es
s pplc to o uppl me a e trt nco
neis
w udgef
ound t t
ha
pli ifs f r fo s ve a s r i pa r nt ,ncudi s t eus dior ro t bassof
antf ufe s r m e r l eve e m ime s i l ng ubsanc e s de n he i
cuon cac h l b s ; n raiiion a trlis icu i lmba o c r iaga a h so yo
l i lo o a u e pa ce ttsj it rh aga ,n ldng u g , e vc li, nd itr f
hi slge y;a mi ;hy re i n;r fux/ r as bor ri pe s lt dio de ;a de e so
p tr r ne a pe tnso e l he ni ; de lne r onaiy s r r nd pr s i n.
( 3 0 . I tn o t s q e ta d sbi t a ay i etbl h d f rtea j d c to o s c
TR 0 ) n e ns f he e u nil ia l y n lss sa i e o h du iain f u h
i
s
cams s e20C. R.j416.20,heAdmi srtveLaw J f mdt tpli ifs fr fom a
li , e
F.
9 t
nitai
udge ot ha antf ufes r
lse i ime bas onas ve elm iai n i c nta i a s a e wihhi s t nc a e
it d mpar nt ed
e r i t to n once r ton s ocit d t s ubsa e bus
ds r e . ( 3 6 . Ho v r t e La J g r ld ta M r Flwesd e no s fe fo a
io d rl TR 0 ) we e , h w ud e ue h t . o r o s t u fr ' m
r
dia lt wihi t m e ni oft Ac d t t sdiablng m e alco to be a e hewoul
s biiy t n he a ng he t ue o hi s i
nt ndii n, c us
d
nots frfom a i ime ofdia i sve iyi hea ti dfom t us ofal . (
ufe ' n mpar nt sblng e rt f bsane r he e cohol TR
r
3 9 .I s c a teLa J dg f t ta p an ipsac h ls i ac n rb tn f co mae il
0 ) namu h s h w u e omd h t litf lo oim s o tiu ig a tr tra
1I acl mants f sfom als edi paimentunderAppendi 1t Subpar P oft Adm i sr tve
f ai
uf er r
it m r
x o
t
he
nita i
Regul i Par 404,t cl m anti de eddiabl f a1 f m sofw or w ihoutconsde ton off t s
atons t
he ai
s em
s ed or l or
k t
i ra i
ac or
s ha a e e uc to a p i wor e re e Se 2 C. R. 41 92 d .
uc s g , d a in, nd ror k xpe inc . e 0 F. j 6. 0( )
t t de e m i to ofdia lt t La J
o he t r nai n
s biiy, he w udge pr ee d t c i rwhehe pli tf woul
oc de o onsde
t r a n if
d
rman dsbldi heso dusngalohol Se z n.20 C. R.j41 935.Astmi t tMr
e i ia e f tppe i c . e, e .
F.
6.
sz ng ha .
Fl r c s usng a c ,t La J
owe s ea ed i l ohol he w udge f
ound t thi a lte t s t i c
ha s biiis o usan once r ton,
nta i
p ritn e o pa ewo l b o l mo eaey i ie .( 3 9 .Astmigc s ai no ac h l
e sse c , r c u d e n y d rtl mpar d TR 0 ) sz n e s jo f lo o
us ,t La J
e he w udgewe ont a s s M r Fl r 'r sdua f nci na ca ciy a f l w s
nt o s e s . owe s e i l u to l pa t s olo :
W he t efe t oft ca ma ' s t nc us a e f t r out he r a nst
n he f c s he li nts ubsa e e r ac o ed , eti he
r sdua f to lc pact t pe f a r ng oflg wo k a de i d i 20 CFR
e i l unci na a iy o ronn a e i ht r s fne n
41 96749, xc ptt t mus a de tr oha adss ha da r movi
6. 1 e e ha he t voi xposlet z r uc s ngeous ng
mac ne y a c i ng l dde s r pe ,o s afo di Hei f t rlm ie t no
hi r nd lmbi a r , o s r c f l ng. s urhe i t d o
mor t n oc sona e e sve wo k- ac vi a i .Hi me a i ime s
e ha ca i l xc s i
r pl e br tons s nt l mpa r nt ,
a e s tnc us ,lm ihi t wor i vi no i e a tonwiht publc a
bs nt ubsa e e i t m o k nvol ng nt r c i
t he
i , nd
no o et n oc sona i e a tonwih c wo ke s Hec n pero m t kild wo k
r ha ca i l ntr ci
t o- r r . a
f r ms le
r
t ks
as .
( 31 ) Gie s c ar sd lu cin l a a i , nda tr o i eigp an ips g , d c to
TR 0 . v n u h e iua f n to a c p ct a fe c nsd rn litf a e e u ain,
y
a l c o prorwor e re e t La l
nd a k f i
k xpe inc ,he w udger l dt t i pl i ifa t ne f o usngalohol
u e ha ,f antf bsai d r m i c
a ilga d gs hewo dbec pa eofpe f m i s ve als cii lg a s de a ywor r e
nd le l nz ,
ul
a bl
ror ng e r pe fc iht nd e nt r
k ols
e itn i sg t a tn mb ri ten to a e o o
xsig n ini n u e n h ain l c n my. ( 31 ) Ac o dn l, h La J g
k
TR 2 . c r igy t e w ud e
uli e y c l d t tM r Fl r i notdia e and t he i notentted t s e
tmatl onc ude ha . owe s s
s bl d,
hat s
il o uppl ment
al
sc dt n o be eks S e z n.20C. R. j41 .2 4 ) d41 9 5 Th La u g ' o i o
e u yic me n t . e , e , F. j 69 0 g = 6.3 . e wl d e s pnin
wa a ed a t fna de ii oft Co misone by t Soc a Se iy A dm i s r ton'
s dopt s he i l c son
he m s i r
he , i l eurt
nit a i s
A ppe l Counci. Ha nge use ala ia ea nitai r m e e , r Fl r ha a a e
a s ' l vi xha t d l val bl dmi sr tve e dis M . owe s s ppe l d
t t sc t
o hi our.
W hie pli if ma be di a ed f r ce ti f m s of e oy e ,t c ucalf cua
l a ntf y
s bl o ran or
mpl m nt he r i a t l
dee mi toni whehe antf wa dia e f a l or ofs t nta ganfz e oy e .Se
t r na i s t rpli if s s bl d or l f ms ubsa il i t mpl m nt e
l
42U. C.j1 2c() Theeaef t ee nt o pr whihmus bec i r di ma ngs
S. 38 a . r r otr lme s f oof c
t onsde e n ki uch
a a lss Th s ee n saes mma e a f l ws ( )o j ci eme ia fcsa d ci ia
n nay i. e e lme t r u dz d s ol : 1 b e tv d c l a t n lnc l
o
fn ig ;2 teo no a dc n l ins fr aigph sca s ( ) u j ciee ie c o p y ia
i dn s ( )h piins n o cuso o te tn y iin ;3 s be tv vd n e f h se l
ma ietto so i ar ns a d s rb dt r u hacama t tsi n a ()t cama t
n fsain f mp ime t, s e cie h o g li n' e tmo y; nd 4 he li n'
s
s
e u ain vo aina h soy,e iua s i s a da e Vie v. n h, 3 F.d 1 5 , 1 9 6 (t
d c to , c to l itz r sd l kl , n g . tk Fic 4 8 2 1 7 1 5 - 0 4h
l
Ci. 9 ) Und r o v.kbc f, 9 F.d 8 0, 51(t Ci. 9 2 .
r 1 71; e wo d li io f 2 8 2 5 8 4h r 1 6 )
Afe a r viw o t r c d i t s c e,t c ti c ta ne t c l t tt
tr e e f he e or n hi as he our s onsr i d o onc ude ha he
Commi so r sfnal ii i s
s i ne ' i decson s upporedb s tnta e de e.W ihoutq si d i hos
t y ubsa il vi nc
t
ue ton, urngt e
tm e i whih M r Fl we s us s aco t e es ,he doe notpos es s cint me a or
i s n
c
. o r e l hol o xc s
s
s s ux e
nt l
e i lc pact t e agei a m e ni ul kaci t Ho ver t co t le st tt
motona a iy o ng n ny a ngf wor tviy. we ,he ur bei ve ha he
La J
w udgepr ry de em i t ti pl i ifa t i fo s t nc abus ,hewoul pos e s
ope l t r ned ha f antf bsans r m ubsa e
e
d ss
s ce physc la e i lc pact t e
ux int
i a nd motona a iy o ngag i lghtr f r ofsmpl ,t s led wor
e n i e o ms
i e m kil
k
a tviy. Thus t co ta e t tpli ifss t nc a e dio de i a c rbutng f cor
ci t
, he ur gr es ha a ntf ubsa e bus s r r s onti i a t
mae lot d tr n to o d sbit .S e4 U. C. 1 8 ca( )J.S mpysae , ieMr
tda t he ee miain f ia l y e 2 S. j 3 2 ()3 () i l ttd whl .
i
Flwes x ein e mustos eea c mp an sa dd g n rtv a trtc r c s i lp e ons
o r e p re c s cl k ltl o lit n e e eaie rh i p o e s nmut lj it,
l
i
i
t r i no i c to t thi physc li ime spr ve pe f m a e o lght rf m sofwo k
he e s ndia i n ha s
i a mpar nt e nt ror nc f i e or
r
aci t Ha ng r viwed t media r or t c tfndss t n i le de et s
tviy. vi e e
he
c l ec d, he our i
ubsa ta vi nc o uppor t
t he
La J d esd tr n to t tt e o j cie me ia e ie e smpl fist d cl n t
w u g ' ee miain ha h b e tv d c l vd nc i y al o o l t he
me
e se c o a y ph ia c n iin wl c i s s v r a i p e n pef r nc o lg ta d
xitn e f n ysc l o dto z h s o e ee s o rve t ro ma e f ih n
i
s de a y f r sofe ri I d,when a ke t pr vi s
e nt r o m
xe ton. ndee
s d o o de uppor f rpli tY sa i ton f
t o ani
pplcai or
be ft ,o ofM T Fl w e s t e tng ph i i nsa t VA M e ca Ce e e i ty obs r e t t
ne is ne
. o r 'rai
ys c a t he
di l nt r xplcil
e v d ha
p anifso l p o lm i ac ho d p nd n ea t a het a wok. TR 7 ) W h l p an if
litf ny r be s lo l e e e c nd h t l n r '
c
'( 21. ie litf
alo slf r fo c oni panc e tts whih i de m e t beas oc a e wih li a c
s tfe s r m hr c
r a ii, c s e d o
s i t d t zs l ohola e,a
bus s
4
we lm a hit y of pa r tc ps udoc t ,t r i no i c ton t tt s pr e s pr ve
l s
sor
nc eai e
yss he e s
ndia i ha he e oblm
e nt
pe f m a o r ul ra tviy durng t s pe i i whih M r Fl we si a tne . Ge r ly,
ror nce f eg a c i t
i ho e rods n c
' . o r s bsi nt ne al
t c talo fndss t nta e de et s
he our s i
ubsa i l vi nc o uppo tt La J e' dee m i ton t tpli i s
r he w udg s t r na i ha a ntc
s b e tv c mplit ae o to p o o t n t t me ia e ie c i t e c s ,i panifs
u j cie o an s r u f r p ri o he dc l vd n e n h a e f litf
o
s t nc a ei notc i r
ubsa e bus s
onsde ed.
M r Fl we s e otonal obl pr s ntas wha c os rque to Aspr vi usyno e
. o r ' m i pr ems e e
ome t l e
si n.
e o l t d,
t Admi sr tveLaw J
he
nita i
udgede e i dt t antf s f r fom de es i a e y, ndt thi
t = ne ha pl i i ufe s r
pr son/nxit a ha s
i ime ti c e r to i s s ve ea t r rhi dia e dtrngpe i ofc oni a c
mpar n n onc ntai n s o e r s o ende m s bld li
rods hr c l ohol
a e. Howe r t La J
bus
ve , he w udgewe on t fnd t tpli ifsa lt t s t i c
nt o i ha antf biiy o usan once r ton,
nta i
pe sse e orpa i onl ode a eyi ie durngt epe i i whihhei s r TheLa
r itnc ,
ce s ym r t l mpa r d i hos rods n c
s obe .
w
J
udgede e mi t tt sm ode a el ve ofi nne i nots h ast pr ve pe f manc of
t r ned ha hi
r t e l mpai nt s
uc
o e nt ror
e
t smpl t kil d wo k r esf rwhi h t voc to le r c i r M r Fl r t be
he i e, ms le
r ol o
c he a i na xpe t onsde ed . owe s o
ot t s c pa e.Thecour mus c l t tt sfndi i s
he wie a bl
t t oncude ha hi
ng s upporedby s t nta e de e.
t
ubsa il vi nc
The La J
w udge obs r d t t d li t e pe i i whi h he i fe of a c ,pl i ifs
e ve ha , trng hos rods n
c
s re
l ohol antf '
i par nt nco nkai n, r it nce o
m ime i nce to pe sse , rpac e uls9om l om ec oni i e a e s ue 'a
er s t
G
s
hr cpanr l t di s s' nd
t ts h ma f sa i c d r s bl bem ii t i pli tf pe f r lght rwor aci te
ha uc
nie ttons oul ea ona y
tgaed f a n if r o ms i e
k tvii s
o asmpl a t k l dnaue ( 3 9 .Th c u t eive t a tlsd tr nain
f i e nd ms il tr . TR 0 ) e o r b l s h t l eemi to
e
e
i
i c itntwiht e t t sa eag nc yc og s whoas e s hevoc tonal i t a e
s onsse
t her por of he tt e yps hol it
s s edt
a i sgnik nc
o pl ntf snone r i l m pa nne s I
f ni i f
xe tona i i nt . naps hol c a s s m e tcô pl t d onD e e be 1
yc ogi al s e s n m e e
c m r 2,
2011 D r Lo s Pe r tnot m ode a e lm ia i i t r s of pl ntf ' c pac t t m a nt i
, . ui r ot ed
r t i t tons n e m
ai i f s a iy o i a n
a tnton, once tai a pac ( 355)
te i c nrton, nd e. TR
.Hpwe r bas ont e de eofr c dasoft
ve, ed he vi nc e or
he
da eofhi ps hol c r vi w,Dr Per t o ne t tpli ifs dbec i r d ca bl of
t
s yc ogial e e
. ro t pi d ha antf houl
onsde e pa e
5
ii l, o tn , o -te s'lwo k r q i l td s ca i tr ci n' ( 3 6 . Th c u t
t mpe r u ie n n srs f
s
u r e udng i e o il nea to . TR 5 ) e o r
mi
'
bei ve t tt La J
le s ha he w udgem i tr s na y r l on Dr Pe tsa s s m e i ma ng fndi s
gh ea o bl ey
. aot' s e s nt n ki i ng
a t pli tf sr sdua fmci lca ciy.
s o a n if e i l t tona pa t
I s ta trf c o out hevpc tonalmpa tofpl ntf ' c oni a c
n hor, fe a t dng t
ai i c
ai ifs hr c l ohol e t c t
us , he our
fndst tt La J
i ha he w udge' hy t tc que to t t vocai na e r c pt r d a 1ofpli if s
s po he ial si n o he
to l xpe t a u e 1
a ntf
ph i la e i llm ia i r a ona y s ppore by t m e ca r or I f l t tt
ysca nd motona i ttons e s bl u
td he di l ec d. t olows ha he
La J e pr pe l r le on t vocai na e r' i i dee i zi t tM r Fl r i no
w udg o ry e id he
to l xpe ts nput n trnilng ha . owe s s t
dia e f r a 1f ms of s t n i lga nfl e oyme . Thus t co tc l s t t t
s bld o 1 or
ubsa ta i ll mpl
nt
, he ur onc ude ha he
Co mi so r sfnalde son i t sc ei s
m s i ne ' i
cii n hi as s uppore by s tnta e de e.
td
ubsa i l vi nc
On a alt txs c t pl i if a g s t tt La J
ppe o li our, antf r ue ha he w udge i o ry dic t t
mpr pe l s oun ed he
vo to l i sc nc of ode a elm iai nsi s i lfz tozi co e r to p'r itnce a
cai na sgni a e m r t i t to n oc a l i zng, nc ntai n, e sse , nd
nc
pa e.Cii amuliudeofde ii ,ncudi t toft sc ti Se onv. vi 21F.
c
tng
tt
c sons i l ng ha hi our n xt
Col n,
supp.
3d
6 9( . Va 2 4 a dt a o t eUntdSae Co r o Ap e l f rheFo rhCic ii M a co
3 W D. . 01 ) n h t f h ie tt s u t f p as o t u t rutn s i
v. vi 78 F. 63 ( hCi.
Col n, 0 3d 2 4t r 2015)pl nifague t tt La J
, aitf r s ha he w udge' fndi o almiain
s i ng f i tto
t smpl , l l wor doe no ne es a y i y, tkei o a comt mode aelm ia i i
o i e unsdled k s t c s dl mpl or a nt c t ,
r t i ttons n
c e r ton, r it nc orpa e.W liet c lt le t tpli ifha c r c l i e pr t d
onc ntai pe sse e,
c
ll he otr bei ves ha antf s ore ty ntr ee
t hol i i M a ci a Se on,hec t sno le t t her tonaeoft s c esa i
he d ngs n s o nd xt t our doe tbei ve ha t a i l he e as pples
t A .Fl v r c ar I M as o a Se on,t c am a s pr e s wih c e r ton,
o 4r oq e s' l in. n
ci nd xt
he l i nt ' oblm
t onc nta i
pe sse ,a pa we e a s i t d prm a y wih e i lpr e s Asnot d by t La
r it nce nd ce r s oc a e i dl t motona obl m .
e
he w
J ei hei t n ca e M r Fl we s c e r to pr blm sa ea s it di s t n i l e ur
udg nt nsa t s , . o r ' onc ntai n o e r s oca e n ubsa ta m as e
wihhi
t sphysca dic f r .TheLa l
i l s om o t
w udgea co e or hi c r lm sa ei i ngt t antf
c unt df t s icl tnc nfndi ha pli if
i'i ie t lg e a s de a yf msofphysc la tviy.Asalonot d byt La J
slm t d o i ht r nd e nt r or
ia ci t
s
e
he w udge, r
M .
Fl r a t lype f m e wor a tviydurngt epei i whihhewa notd i ngalohol
owe s cual ror d k c i t
i hos zods n c
s
rnki c
t e c s .( 3 9 .I t ec u tsve t i fc sp rsten to t a p an i sc n e tai n
o x e s TR 0 ) n h o r' iw,h s a t u po t h oi n h t litY o c nr to
pr e sdti pe i ofa tne ea eno s s ve east pr vent e a wor a tviy.Fi ly,
oblm u ng rods bsi nc r t o e r
o e
r gulr k c i t' na l
asno e a
t d bove Dr Pe r t s cfc lyde e mi dt tM r Fl we s de i e e i co e r to
, . r o t pe ii a l t r ne ha . o r ' fcincis n nc ntai n,
pe sse e a pa a e nots h a t pr ve pe f m a e ofsm pl ,unscle wor a tviy
r it nc , nd ce r
uc s o e nt ror nc
i e
lild
k ci t
i vi o y one o t se . Si pl sa e t c tbe ivest tt m e c lr cor i t
nvol ng nl
r wo t ps m y t t d, he our le
ha he di a e d n he
i tntc s ,a t a s s ntoft c iialis sby t Admilsr tveLa J
nsa a e nd he s es me
he rtc sue
he
rita i
w udge dif rfom
, fe r
M a c o' ca e. I e l tng M r Fl e s cl i f be ft , t Law J
si s s
n va ua i
. ow r ' a m or ne is he
udge M f r d s e
f e e om
e a ton, a ct d e de , i s
xpl nai
nd ie vi nce n uppor of t fndi t t pli tf ' i ime s i
t
he i ng ha a n ifs mpar nt n
c
once r ton,pe sse ,a pa e do notpr ve pe f r nce of smpl unsdle lg or
nta i
rit nce nd c
e nt ro ma
i e, l ld, i ht
s de ay wor a tviy.Ass tf t a ve t c t le st tt La J
e ntr
k ci t
e orh bo , he our beive ha he w udge' as e s e i
s s s m nt s
s
uppore by s tntale de . A c or ngy, he fna de son oft Comm isone m us be
td
ubsa i vi nce
c di l t i l cii
he
si r t
a fr d.
fime
I a fr ngt Comm isone ' de son,hec t
n fimi he
s i r s cii t our doesnots ges t tM rFl we si fee
ug t ha . o r s '
r
o a l n,dic or,we knes , ndf tgue.I ed, ve wihouteo i r tonoft i c of
f l pai s omf t n s a a i
nde e n t
nsde ai
he mpa t
pli ifs c oni a c
antf ' hr c l ohol a e t m e ca r or co im s t t M r Fl r s f r fom
bus , he di l ec d nfr ha
. owe s ufe s r
sg t a m us ul ke eal o e , c anbee c e oc us i lmia i ofmoton, nd
i nik nt c os lt pr bl ms whihc
xpe t dt a epan,i t ton
i a
l c ofsami Ho ve ,i m us a n beobs r d t tpl i ifsphyscin a t VA hos t
a k t na. we r t t gai
e ve ha antf
i a t he
pial
s ik al not d t tM r Fl r c d wo k de pie s h pr blm s I m us ber ogni d t t
pect ly e ha . owe s oul r s t uc o e . t t ec ze ha
t eia l yt d wo kwih u a ys be tv d so o td e n t ftefe e acama to al
h n bit o o r t o t n u j ci e ic mf r, o s o o is lrnd r li n t tl
i
y
ds be Cri v. ae , 6F.d5 5 5 4- 5( t Ci.1 9 ) Onc a an,ta pe r t tec ur
ia ld. ag Ch tr 7 3 8 , 9 9 4h r 9 6 . e g i i p a s o h o t
t a t Ad nitai La J d ec nsd rda1 ftes be tvefco sra o a l s pp re b
h the mi srt
ve w u g o ie e 1o h u j ci a tr e s n by u o td y
t me ia rc r i a j iaig panifscam frb neis I f lo t ta1fc t o t
he d c l e o d n dudc tn li t li o e ft. t o lws ha l a es f he
f
Co misone '. lde ii a es
m s i rssna c son r uppored b s t nta e de e.
t y ubsa il vi nc z
Asage r r l ,r s uton ofco lc si t e de e i am a trwihi t pr nceof
ne al u e e ol i
nfit n he vi nc s
te t n he ovi
t Comm iso re n i t c tm ihtr ol t co lc sdif r nty. Ii ha ds n v. r es
he
s i ne ve f he our g es ve he nfit fe e l tc r o Pe al ,
s p a Op n i v. n h, 9 F.d3 6(t Ci. 9 4 .Fo t ra o sae ,h c u tid t e
u r ; pe hem Fic 4 5 2 9 4 h r 1 7 ) rhe e s ns tt d t e o r fn s h
Commi sone ' r s uton oft pe tne confit i t r co d i t sc e t be s
s i rs e ol i
he ri nt
lc s n he e r n hi as o
uppore by
td
s tnta e de e.Ac or ngl t fna de son o t Comm isone m us bea fr d.Laws
ubsa il vi nc
c di y,he i l cii f he
s i r t f me
v. lb e z , u r .Ana p o daej d me ta do de wil ee tr dti d y
Cee r z e s p a
p r p t u g n n r r lb ne e h s a .
TheClr i die t d t s nd c rii co esoft so ni t a1c ms lo r c d.
e k s r c e o e e tfed pi
hi pi on o l ot e f e or
DATED :Thi I
s N
da ofJme 201
y t ,
6.
Chi Unie Stt sDititJ
ef t d a e src udge
2I connectonw ih hi r
n
i
t s eques f r vi oft Adm i s r i La Judge' decii , M r Fl s
t or e ew he
nitatve w
s son . ower
s bmitd amuliu e o n w me c lr p t t t S ilSe u iy Admi sr ton' Apge l Co ncl
u te
tt d f e
dia e ors o he oca c rt
nitai s
as u i.
However t c tfndst t er t r at t teat e ofpl ntf ' l t ngphyscalpr e s
, he our i hat hes epors el e o r m nt ai ifs ongsandi
l
oblm ,
a dt the o frn hi n w. na muc a t ne r po t a eme eyc mua i ,h c urfnds c us
n ha t y fe pt ny e I s h s he w e rs r r l u ltve t e o ti no a e
f rrma df c sd rto o t n w e d nc Se Bor e sv. c e , 7F. 95 (t Ci.1 5) nd
o e n or on le aln f he e vie e. e d r He klr77 2d 4 4 h r 98 a
M e rv. tu , 2F. 70 (t Ci. )
ye Asr e 66 3d 0 4 h r 2011.
8
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?