LordMaster v. Moore et al

Filing 34

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 9/13/2016. (slt)

CLERKS OFFI U.S. ST.
CE
DI COURT
ATG NOKE, A
V
FI
LED

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI I A
CT
RG NI
RO AN O K E DI I O N
V SI

SEP 13 2 1
25
JUL C
W

EM ckEM

BY:
DE

FRA N K I JA E LO R DM A STER .
E
Pl ntf ,
ai if

C i lAc i N o.7: 5- vvi t on
1 c 00476

V.

M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N
N O

M R .M O O RE ,1 etaI,
11,
.
Dee
f ndant .
s

By:

CLE

H on.M i
chaelF.Urbanski
U nie St t sD i t c Judge
t d a e s ri t

r ni nm t oce ng O
Fr e J Lor m a tr 1aV igi a i a e pr edi pr K ,c
anki ae d se ,
omm e d t scvi
nce hi i l
.

a tonpurua t 42U. C.j 1 noeale t n J 5,201 ( No. anddi notpr pa
ci
s nt o
S.
983
rir ha une
5, ECF 2)
d
e y
t flng f e. U nde ce t i cic s a es a pr s rm a br ng a c vi a ton w ihoutf l
he ii e
r r a n r um t nc , ione y i
i l ci
t
uly

prpa ngt flngfe.28U. C.j l 5()2) ( .Ho ve,28U. C.j191 g pr de
e yi he ii e
S.
91 a( , b) we r
S.
5() ovi s:
tnnoe nts laprs rbrngacvi a tonpr e ng( t prpa ntoft flng
l
l
ve hal ione i
i l ci oce di wihout e yme
he i
fe ...i t prs rhas on 3ormo eproroc sons whiei aceae ordeane i any
e l f he ione ,
r i ca i , l nc r rtd
ti d n
f ciiy,br
a lt oughta a ton ora a ... ha w asdi m i s on t gr
n ci
ppe l t t
s s ed
he ounds t ti i f i o ,
ha t s rvol us
m a i i ,orf ist s a e a cl i upon w hi h r i m a be gr nt unl s t pr s r i unde
lc ous
al o tt
am
c elef y
a ed, e s he ione s
r

i n n da g ro s ro p y ia ij r . 2 U. . . 1 5g . Tofl wi i t e'mmie t
mmi e t n e f eius h sc ln u y' 8 SC j 91 ( )2 al t n h t n n
'
h
i

d ng r' xc p in t p io e ' ij r ç s b i n n o o c ri a t etmet ec mplit
a e 'e e to ,he rs n rs n uy k t e mmie t r c u rng t h i h o an
mu
i fld. Cipaglniv.Sani 352F. 328 330( h Ci.2003)( tngAbdulW a
s ie ' a i
'
i,
3d ,
7t r
cii
- doodv.

Nah n 91F.d 1 2 ( t Ci.1 9 ).Al g to o û n yap s ij r ta h sn t e u rd'
ta , 3 0 3 7h r 9 6 ) l ains f k l at nu y h t a o r c re '
e
o
a e i uf i e . 1
r ns fci nt d.
Pl ntf ha a l as t ee non- bea ci la tons ora al di m i s d asf i ous a
ai i f d t e t hr
ha s vi c i
ppe s s s e
r vol , s
m alci orf f lng t s at a cl m bef e he com m enced t sacton. Seeae. ,Lor ast
i ous, or aii o t e ai
or
hi i
g. dm er

v. vi,No.1:5 9( D.Va M a 1 201 ( s se f fii t saeacli ;
Da s
1 cv31 E.
. y 5, 5) dimisd or alng o tt aml
1Lor
dmaserwa f me l known asJ on Robe G ol de .
t
s or ry
as
rt da r

2Seto 1 1 () o nrfre t a tethe srk s' r vso ,sp rofh P io LiiainReo m
cin 9 5g, oe eerd o s h t re tie'p o iin i at te rs n tg to fr
Ac o 1 9 , b L. 1 4 14,1 0Sa.l 2171( 9 6 .Mc a v Uni dS ae, 6 F.d3 , 9 (t Ci.
t f 9 6 Pu . No. 0 - 3 1 tt 3 - 1 8 ) Le n . t tts 5 6 3 91 3 3 4h r
e
20)
0 9.

Lor trv.Epps No.11 351( D. M a 1 201 ( s s e f fii t saea
dmase
,
:4cv1 E. Va. y 9, 5) dimis d or alng o tt
cli ;Lor trv.Suse 1 Stt Prs n, 1:4-v- ( D. M a 11 201
am) dmase
sx 1 ae i- No. 1 c 507 E. Va. y , 5)
o
( s s e f fii t saeacli ;Gol derv.W oods No.7:2c
dimis d or alng o tt aml da
ons
1 v505( . Va. c.2
W D. De 2,

2 2 ( imis dwi o tp eu iea fioo s; e as Coe nv. l fo
01 ) d s se t u rj dc s rv lu ) s e lo lma Tol s n, U.. ,1 5
h
e
S
3
S. .1 1 ( 5)( di at ti 'dimis i c e rga dls t t tmi ofa
Ct 759, 765 201 hol ng i rke' s sal s ountd e r e s o he i ng
s

s b e u n a p a) Mc a , 6 F.d a 3 9( imis l wih u p eu ief rfio o s e s
u s q e t p e l; Le n 5 6 3 t 9 d s sas t o t rj dc o rv l u n s
s dnotbeexe e fom 28U. C.j1 5( ) Furhe e,hecompli doe notaleg
houl
mptd r
S.
91 g). t nuor t
ant s
le

t t an ifi u d ra yi n n tr a o s rou p y ia ij r wi i teme nigo 2
ha Plitf s n e n mmie t h e t f ei s h sc ln u y t n h a n f 8
h
U. C.j 1 5( .I tad,t c ai c enst Vigi aDe rme ofCore tons
S.
91 g) nse he ompl nt onc r he r ni pa t nt
rci '
r ognii ofPl ntf sr i ousf ih.A c di y, he c ' dim i s s t a ton w ihout
ec ton
ai i f elgi
at
cor ngl t oul s s e he c i
t
t

p eu ieb c u ePlitf ddn t ytefl gf ewhe fln tec mplit Se s ..Du r e
rj d c e a s an if i o pa h ii e
n
n iig h o an . e ec, p e
v. l r 28 F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.
Pame , 4 3d 234, 237 1 t r 2002)
.

ENTER:Ths (
i V

dyo Spe e,0 6
a f etmbr2 1.

f f* Y V f.W
w
U nied St t Di t i J
t
a es s rd ud

2

'