LordMaster v. Barksdale et al

Filing 39

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 9/13/2016. (slt)

CL
ERK:A CE U.9. ST O UR'
OFFI
DI .
i
TROANOKE,VA
FI (
LE )

SEP 13 2 1
2s

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT

FOR TH : W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON

FRANKR JAE LORDM ASTER,
Pl i if
a ntf,
V.

E.
BARKSDALE,e al,
t .
D efendant
s.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

J -A c ,
ull puo
BY:

, sRK
-

/

D#--4 E-&c R
u .
(

C i lA c i N o.7: - vvi ton
15 c 00510

M EM O R AN DU M O PI I N
N O
By:

H on.M i
chaelF.Urbanski
Uni e St esD i t i tJudge
t d at
src

o
Fr nki J e Lor a t r1a Vigila i t pr ee ngpr K , comm e edt scvi
n e a
dm se ,
r ri nma e oc di
nc hi i l

a to p ru n t 4 U. C. 1 8 i S p e e 2 5a dddn t r p yt efl gf e Un r
ci n u s a t o 2 S. j 9 3 n e tmb r 01 n i o p e a h ii e . de
n
c ran cic sa s aprs rm a brng a cvi a ton wiho f l pr pa ngt flngf e.
e ti r um t nce , ione y i
i l ci
t ut uly e yi he ii e

2 U. C. 1 1 ()2 , b .Ho v r 28U.. j1 5 g p o ie :snn e e ts al
8 S. j 9 5a () ( ) we e ,
SC. 91 ( ) r vd s ç o v n h la
l
prs ne bdngacvi acinpr e ng( t prpa ntoft flngfe ...ft prs r
io r
i l to oce di wihout e yme
he ii e ) i he ione
ha ,o 3 o m or pr oroc as ons w hie i a c r t orde ai d i a f iiy,br
s p r
e i
c i , l nc r e a ed
t ne n ny ac lt oughta a ton
n ci

o a a ...t twa dim is d on t gr t t ti i fi ous m a ii us orf ist sa ea
r ppe l
ha s s s e
he o mds ha t s rvol , lc o , a l o t t
cli upon whih r le m a begr nt d,t e st prs ne i unde i i ntd
am
c ei f y
a e ml s he io r s
r mm ne ange ofs rous
r ei

p ysc lij r ' 2 U. . . 1 1 ( )2 Toflwihnt eûmmi n d n e'e e to ,h
h ia nu y. 8 SC j 9 5g .
'
al t i h t ne t a g r' xc pi n te
i
p io e ' ij r ç s bei n n o o c ni a t t t c mpliti fld. Cir a ln
rs n rs nu y G t mmie t r c u ng the i he o an s ie ' ap cii
mu
me
'
v. ii 3 2F.d3 , 3 (t Ci. 0 3 (iigAb u- a o dv Nah n 91F.d 1 23(t
San , 5 3 28 3 0 7h r 2 0 ) ctn d lW d o . ta , 3 0 7h

Ci. 9 6 ) Ale ain o G nyapatij r t a h sno rc re 'a ei u fce t 1 .
r 1 9 ). lg to s f ç l s nu y h t a t e u r d' r ns fiin . d
o
Pl i ifha a l as t e non- be c vi a to o a a sdi m i s d asf i ous as
a ntf d t e t hr e
ha as i l c i ns r ppe l s s e
rvol ,

m a ii ,o f rf ii t sae acai b o ehe c
lc ous r o alng o t t l m ef r
omm e e t sa ton. Se ec. Lor
nc d hi c i
e. . , dmase
tr

v.Da s No.1:5c
vi,
1 v319( D. M a 1 2015 ( s s e f fii t saeacaml
E. Va. y 5, ) dimis d or alng o tt li ;

Lo d se v. ps No 1 1 c 3 ( D. . a 1 , 5 ( imis df rf ingt saea
r matr Ep , . :4 v1 51 E. Va M y 9 201 ) ds se o al o tt
i
1Lor se wa f ry known asJ s Robe tGol r
dma tr s onne l
a on
r dade .

2S cin1 5g, Ae rfre t a teçl e srk s' rviin i p r o teP io LiiainReo m
e to 91 ()o n eerd o s h sz e tie'po so ,s at f h rsn tg t
tr
o fr
Ac o 1 9 , u L. .1 4 1 4 1 0Sa.12171( 9 6.Mc a v Uni dSae, 6 F.d3 , 9 (t Ci.
t f 9 6 P b. No 0 -3 , 1 tt 3 - 1 8 ) Le n . t tts 5 6 3 91 3 3 4h r
e
20)
0 9.

cam) Lp d se v S s x 1 SaePrs n No 11 -v 5 7 ( D. . a 1 , 5
li ; r ma tr . use 1 tt io , . :4 c - 0 E. Va M y 1 201 )
( imis dfrfiigt saeacam) God d rv. o d o No. :2 v 0 ( . Va De . 2
d s se o aln o tt li ; l a e W o s n, 7 1 c 5 5 W D. . c 2 ,

20 2 ( s s e wi o t eudc a fi lu ) s eas Coe nv. les n U. s 3
1 ) dimis d t u prj ie s rvoo s; e lo lma To lfo ,
h
S. 1 5
S. .1 5 ,1 6 ( 01 )( odngaEtie' imis lsc u tdr g r ls t tet n o a
Ct 7 9 7 5 2 5 h li ç rk 'ds sa i o n e e ad e s o h i g f
s
mi

s b e u n a p a) M c a , 6 F.da 3 9( imisl wih u p eu ief rfioo s e s
u s q e t p e l; Le n 5 6 3 t 9 ds sas t o t rj dc o 'v lu n s
r
s o l n tb e mp e fo 28U. C. 1 5 g ) Ft t nn r ,h c mp an d e no alg
h ud o e xe td r m
S. j 91 (). l he o e t e o lit o s t le e
r
t tPlitf i u d ra i n n tr a o s ro p y ia ij r wihnt eme nngo 2
ha an if s n e ny mmie t h e t f eius h sc ln u y t i h a i f 8
U. C.j1 5 g .I ta ,h c mplit o en a c s t g iv n e , dc l e o d , n a
S.
91 ( ) nse d t e o an c nc r s c e s o re a c s me ia r c r s a d n
i e pr t r e l s e ;a ahe rng ad a isa e s re . Ac or ngl t c tdimi s t
nt r e e ; yeg a s s nd
a i i nd t cc s o i s
c di y, he our s s es he

a to wih u p eu ieb c u ePlitf ddn t a t efln f ewhe h fldt c mp an .
ci n t o t rj d c e a s anif i o p y h iig e
n e ie he o lit
Se ec.Duprev.Pal
e- . , e
mer
ENTER :Thi
s

l
b

F.d 1 1 ( t Ci.
3 234, 237 11h r 2002)
.

d yo Se tmb r2016.
a f pe e,

5 /* 4 2 /.
Unie Stt Diti udg
td aes src
e

2

'