Morris v. Woodson

Filing 8

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/4/2015. (tvt)

CL
ERKS OFFIE U. DI COUM
C B. BT.
AT ROANOKE,
VA
F: E3
!
-

N2 21 2 5
V 12
I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I
STR I T C O U RT
C
FO R T H E W ESTERN D I
STR I O F W R G I A
CT
NI
ROAN OK E DI SI
VI ON
Lm

Y JA M ES M O R R I
S,

.t1kç, . .. , Rx
ll . .. , .
.. '
h c
BY'

C A SE N O .7: 5CV 00519
1

Pe ii r
ttone ,
M EM OR ANDUM O PI ON
M

JOHN W OODSON W ARDEN

By: H on.G l E.C onr
en
ad
Chi fUni e St e D i t i tJudge
e
t d at s s r c

R es
pondent.

La y J m es M oni , a Vigila i a e pr ee ng pr K , fl a pos- onviton
n' n
s
r ri nm t oc di
o
ied
tc c i
.

pladlg,wli h t Unie Stt DititCour f rt Ea t r Diti tofVigi a c tue a
e
lc he t d aes src
t o he se n src
r ni onsr d s

ap tto frawrto h be sc r u ,pts a tt 28U. C.j2 5 . Th Ea tr Dititt e
ei n o
i
i f a a op s t u n o
r
S.
2 4 e sen src h n
ka f r e t a to t t s co t be a e Pa Cot y Cic t Cour,wher t c le d
nse r d he c i n o hi ur, c us ge mt r ui
t
e he hal nge

c n ito o c re ,i lc td h r . Bae o M o s o j cin t t e c n t cin o h s
o vcin c u r d s o ae ee
s d n ni ' b e to o h o snzto f i
pla iga aj2 4p tto t c u t l sl rl d s s t a to wih u p eu ie
e dn s 25 eiin,he o r wil l
mma i imis he cin t o t rj dc .
y
By o de e er d Ocobe 8,201 t c t g a ed M on's a oppor niy t eec
r r nt e
t r
5, he our r nt
i n
pl t o l t

wh te o no h o j cst t ec ur' c nsr cin o li po tc n ito mo in a a j2 4
eh r r t e b e t o h o ts o tu to f l s-o v cin to s
s
25
p tto S eCa tov. td S ae ,5 U. 3 , 7 ( 0 3 ; v n ak v Vign a 3 5 F.
eiin. e sr Unie tts 40 S. 75 3 7 2 0 ) Rie b r . r ii, 0

Ap x 1 4 1 5 ( t Ci.2 0 ) (e o nii g a piain o Ca to rq ie ns t p o K
p' 4 , 4 4h r 0 8 rc g zn p lc to f sr e u rme t o r
moin o p tto sc nsrld a j2 4 p tto ) I s d ig t e c u ta vs d M o st
to s r ei n o tt s 25 eiins. n o on , h o r d ie
i
e
ni o
c nsd r p riulry 2 U. C.j 2 4 4 ) (et tme lmi f rpeiine t fl a j 2 4
o i e a t al 8 S.
c
2 4 d sti i i t o tto r o ie
ng
25
p tto )a d 28U.. j 2 4 ( )(e urn p tto e t o ti c ri to fo te c u to
ei n n
i
SC. 2 4 b r q iig eiin r o b an e tkain r m h o r f
t
a l i or rt fl as c j225 peiin) Thec tad s dM ori t thi s s i
ppeas n de o ie e ond
4 tto .
our vie
rs ha s ubmison
a rdt beuntmeyfl a aj2254peii a die tdMm t s twihi tnda a
ppeae o
i l ied s
tton nd r ce
o ubmi t n e ys ny

o j cint t c n tu to o h sp e dnga aj2 5 p tto .
b e to o he o sr cin f i la i s 2 4 ei n
i

I r s ns t t eode o Oco r8 M o rst q io al o j cst ha i gh sp tto
n epo e o h r r f tbe , ri me uv c l be t o v n i eiin
y
c n iee a o e fld un e j2 5 . M o sba e h so j ci n o t e n tr o li cam,
o sd rd s n ie d r 2 4
ni s s i be to n h au e f l li
s

whc i t ttetilc u th dno Ru d cin t a c p t Alo dp e 'a d ta t ec i na
ih s ha h ra o r a
j ds ito o c e t he f r la' n h t h rmi l
j d me ti t u v i t e saelw. ( No 6 a 1)Asrle, o ' t g st a i ta o
u g n s h s od md r tt a ECF . , t .
eif M ni l e h t nse d f
sr
a d e sn h scamst e j2 4,h sc u t h ul ç c e tt so j cin a dr ma dti c s
d rsi g i li md r 25 t i o r s o d t c p hi be to n e n h s a e
a
ba kt t eCic i Co r a drq r t m t a d rs t ej ds ito a is e . .' (d a 2)
c o h r ut u t n e uie he o dlqe s h u dcin l su s . . I . t .
'
Ot rt j2254,t c tfndsno sauo y a hoiy t r whih t c i rt
he han
he our i
tttr ut rt mde
c o onsde he

vaiiy o Mo s c nfn me tu d ra sae c u t ud me t Be a s M ors o jcst t e
ldt f ni ' o i e n n e tt o r j g n . c u e ri be t o h
c t ci ofhi pla ng a a j225 peii t c twildimis t acin wihout
onsnzton
s e di s
4 tton, he our l s s he to t

prj ie An a p o raeo d rwi e trt i d y.Mo si a v sdt a ti ds sto la s
eudc . p r p it r e l ne h s a
l
ni s d ie h t h s ipo iin e ve

hm fe t pu s l sj ds ito lc aln e i t e a p o rae sae c ur,t t e e tn t a
i re o rue k u d cina h le g n h p r p it tt o t o h x e t h t
i
sa e1w a l s h a c lnge
t t a lows uc
hale .
The Cl r i die t t s nd c e oft s me or ndlm o ni n a a ompa ng
e k s r ced o e opi s
hi m a l pi o nd cc
nyi
or rt peii r
de o ttone .
EX TER : Thi
s

V & dyo xo e e 2015.
a f vmbr
,

Cli fU nie St t s D ihid J
le
td ae s
udge