Harris v. Large

Filing 13

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/9/2015. (tvt)

CLERK' OF CE U. DII P
S FI S, S nUA
in F3A7oKEI
v .
'' . <
VA
'
!;.i%
Z'a'.'
. J.
'
'
.
)

d2? 2! 2 1
05
I TH E I NI
N
J TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R T H E W ESTERN DI
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
ROANOK E DI SI
W ON
CLY D E ALLEN H AR RI
S,

BM.

.u

'

C A SE N O .7: 5C V 005
1
24

Pl i i f
a nt f ,
V.

M E M O R AN D UM O PI O N
M

CR Y STA L LA R G E,FN P,

By: Gl n E.C onrad
e
Chi fU nied St e D i t c Judge
e
t
at s s ri t

D ef
endant
.

Cl Ale Ha s a Vigi a i t pr ee ng pr K ,fld t s c vi rght aci
yde ln ni ,
r ni nma e oc di
o
ie hi i l i s ton

pzs a tt 4 U. C.j1 3. I h ss bsq e ty s mitd n n e c mplit Harssae ,
l u n o 2 S.
r
98 n i u e u n l ub te me d d o an , ri tts
v r t : fl o to be o rg th n a d t e lf me s tig f r (le il)3 mo t s
ebai & el u f d n ih a d n h y e t
m: l
et o ilgb e
n
nh
wih u d ig a yti . (
t o t on n lng' ECF No 7 a 2) Hn rs wh i c re ty c n ie a t e
l '
. ,t .
ri, o s u rnl o fn d t h
Sout se Vigi a Reg ona J lf c lt i Abi
hwe tm r ni
i l ai a iiy n
ngdon,nn
mes as def nda Cr t lLa ge
e nt ysa r ,
FNP. He doe notsa ewha r le hes e i t sa ton. Upo r viw oft r c d,t c t
s
tt
t e if e ks n hi c i
n e e
he e or he our
f t tt a ton mus be sl miy dim is
mds ha he c i
t lmm l s s ed.
The c t i r quie t dimis a a ton or c am fl d by a prs ne a ns a
our s e r d o s s ny ci
l i ie
i o r gai t
gove m e ale iy orofi e i t c rtde e mi st a ton o c am i f o ,ma ii ,
m nt ntt
fc r f he ou
t r ne he c i r l i s dvol us lc ous

o fist saeacam u o wh c rle ma b g a td.28U. C. 1 5 b ( ) To saea
r al o tt li p n ih eif y e r ne
S. j 91 A( )1. tt
cam u d rb 1 3, h p an ifmu talg fcss o n t tapes n a tn t e c lro
li n e 98 t e litf s le e a t h wig ha
ro cig md r o o f
sa e 1 w t rook co uc t tvi a e t pli ifs c tt to lrg s See Cooper v.
tt a mde t
nd t ha olt d he antf onsiui na i ht .

She n,735 F. 1 1 (t Ci.201 . Be a e la lt t rj 1 i pes l t
eha
3d 53, 58 4h r 3) c us ibiiy mde 983 s rona, he
E antf mus pl a t t e h Go m me - tc a def nda , t ough t ofk i ls own
t i if
pl
t e d ha ac
ve
ntofi i l e nt hr
he t a '
i vi ua a t o , has vi a ed t Cons iuton. See As r tv.I ,556 U. 66 676
ndi d l c i ns
ol t he
tt i '
'
hc of
qbal
S. 2,

( 0 9 . Plitf s <fa tzlalg to s mu tbe e ug t r ie a rg tt r le a o e t e
2 0 ) an if t j ct le ain s
l a
no h o as ih o eif b v h

(.
'

.
;

s c a i ive r t o t ti G a i eon isf ce' r t rt n m e ey Gc ei bl ' Bel
pe ultve e l' o ne ha s G usbl
'
pl
t a ,' a he ha
r l oonc va e.
' l

At. p. . mbv 5 0U. 5 4, 7 ( 0 )
lCo v Two ls 5 S. 4 5 0 20 7 .
Thec u tc n t e Hars n n e c mpan a camig l e j1 3 ta d fn a t
o r o snzs ri' me d d o li t s li n md r 98 h t ee d n
vi a e hi c nsi i l rg s by f ii t pr de a o it m e c l te t e f hi
olt d s o tt ona i ht
m
alng o ovi ppr pra e di a ' am nt or s
r

ijle ha d Onyap io o fca' d lb rt id fee c t a imae ss ro me ia n e
nt d n . l rs n f ils ei eae n ifrn e o n n t ' eius dc l e d
r
voae te Ei hh Ame d n . S e Esel v.Ga l,4 9 U..9 ,1 2 ( 9 ) A p io
ilts h g t
n me t e tle
mb e 2 S 7 0 1 76 . rs n
o lca i G ei rtl idfe e t'i h o s e çc o o a dse ads Er r s nd
f il s d l aey n ifr n' f e r h Gn ws f nd irg r o epo s
d be
l
u ra o a l t qa e e sv zs t imaehe l o s ft ' F r rv. ema 51 U.. 2 ,
n e s n by o n xc sie ik o n t at r a ey. n me Br z n, 1 S 8 5
h
'

8 7 ( 9 4 . The d l e ae idfe e c sa ad tsno s ts d by ...mee d sg e me t
3 19)
ei rt n ifr n e tnd r G t aife
b
i
r ia r e n
c n enn lqu sin o me ia j d me t' Ge man v S e rn 5 F. p' 3 2 3 (t
o c r ig lj e to s f d c l u g n ,' r i . h a i, 31 Ap x 9 , 95 4 h
'
Ci. 3 (uoigRuselv S efr 5 F.d31 , 9( t Ci.1 7 $, rmeene lg n ei
r 201 ) q tn
s l . h fe, 28 2 8 31 4h r 9 5 o r gi e c n
di nossorte t e t Esele,429 U . a 105 1 s e as Bowrna v.Godwh,551F. 44,
ag i
ram n . t l
S. t - 06; e lo
i
2d

4 (t Ci.1 7 )(ç hee s nilts i o e o me ia ne e st a d no smpy t a wl c
8 4h r 9 7 GT) s e ta et s n f d c l c si n t i l h t l h
(
y
i
ma bec i r me eydesr bl '.Fu t r e a ofkilsi eni ac oro s i t t
y onsdeed r l ia e' rhe mor , n t a' nt tonal t mison ha
)
me el de a a i t sa es t nec s r m e c ca e m a sa e a co tt tonalc am i
r y l ys n nma e' cc s o es a y dial r
y tt
nsiu i
li f
pl ntf s w st tt def ntsc uc r s t d i s t nta ha m t t pa int W e v.
ai if ho ha he enda ' ond t e ule n ubsa il r o he te . bb

Hn d lh, F. p' 1 9 1 6(t Ci. 0 )(iigohe c ss .
miul 281 Ap x 5 , 6 4h r 2 08 ctn t r a e )
a
Ha s nme d co pl ntis fdoesnotal ge f c sa uthi pa tculrm e c ne d,
ni ' nde m ai tel
le a t bo
s ri a
dial e
whe i oc ur e orhow s rous i i ;ho a whe t de e nt M s La ge,lam e ofli
n t o r d,
e i t s w nd
n he f nda , . z e d ls

ij r , rho s r s nd dt i; rwh th sh p e e t Ha sbe a eo s meu s cfe
nu y o w he epo e o t o a a a p n d o ni c us f o n pe iid
aci n M s La ge al ge y t orf ie t t ke. Thepl i ifmus saet f t s
to
. r le dl ook a ld o a
antf
t tt he acs uppo tng li
ri ls

cli i t c antis lla c nno rl on t c torde e ntt c
am n he ompli tet nd a t ey
he our
fnda o omb t oug hi
k h s
exhi t t gu swhi h f t he be ivest bei poran . AsHa rs nme
bis o es
c ac s
le
o m t t
r i' nded c
ompli f l t
ant ais o

2

sa ea f malba i f a à tona e cai unde I l 556 U. a 676,i ma be sl ma iy
t t ac
ss or ny c i bl l m
r qba ,
S. t
t y
lm rl

ds se l e j1 1 A( )1.
imis d md r 9 5 b ( )
M o eo r Ha rs e bisi c t t the ha no c tmtonalcai a ns M s La ge
r ve , ri ' xhi t ndia e ha
s
onsi i
l m gai t . r

r ga di te t ntf hi m i t M edia r c ds i l d i t e bis i c t t tHn s
e r ng r a me or s s.
c l e or nc ude n he xhi t ndi ae ha ni ,
who haspi i hi m i tfom a pro slge y,wasr cevi pr c i i pan media i e n
ns n s s '
r
i r tr r
e i ng es rpton i
c ton ve
be or hi f li Aprl201 I J y,M s La ge r f r e Hn rs f X -ays ofhi rgh wrs,
f e s al n
i
5. n ul
. r e e r d ri or r
s i t it
wlih i c t d a a son fa tleand s tts ue s li . 1 M s La gehasal ge y i onned
lc ndi a e n vuli r c tr
of i s welng
r
le dl nf
.
Hn s howe r t the wilnotbe s he e f r slge y untlhe i ta f red t a VDOC
ni ,
ve , ha
l
c dul d o tr r
i
s r ns e r o

prs f c lt Ha s a r ntbei ft ts ge y s d be s he ed i e a e y i not ng
ion a iiy. ni ' ppa e
le ha m r houl
c dul mm dit l s hi

mo e t n a ds g e me t wih M s La g ' me ia j d me t t p sp n i. S h
r ha
ia re n t
. r es d c l u g n o o to e t uc
dia e me t bewe n a pain a hi me c pr de r notaci bl t r j 1
s gre ns t e
te t nd s dial ovi rae
tona e mde 983,
pariulry i a c e,s ast sone wih no e de et tde a ofslge y ha c us orwil
tc a l n as uch hi
? t
vi nc ha l y tr r s a ed,
l
ca e, n rsa s t n i lhn m.
us H r i ny ubsa ta r

Fo t er a o ssae ,h c u t imis sHnrssn nd dc mplitwih u p eudc ,
r h e s n ttd t e o r d s se ri' me e o an t o t rj ie
p ls a tt j1 5 b ( ) frfi tet saea cam. TheClr i dr ce t s n c p e o
t u n o 91 A( )1, o alr o tt li
r
t
ek s ie td o e d o is f
t sm e o a l opi on a ac ompa ng o de t pl i if
hi m r ndlm ni nd c
nyi r r o antf.

ENTER:Tli Q < d yo No e e
zs
a f v mb r2015.
,

ClifUnie St t sDit tJ
le
t d a e sdc udge

1 See,e. ,htp: www. ves
/
l kong.coe a cl zz8g37- - e-he-r e ent -oran- li
i
g. t /
di e/
whatr t tea
sf - aa son-

fa mr/(atviie No 5 201 )CW v so fa t r o c r qwhe alga n o tn n atc e t a
r c e ls st d v. , 5
uli n rc ues c u g
n i me t r e do ta h d o
bone pari l det
taly aches, Gki a bone fagment w ih i. . . . The t
ng
r
t t
se ypes of f a ur ar r ey
r ct es e ar l
complcat and easl teat unl s . . . t ndon or lga ent damage accom pani t fac r
i ed
iy r ed
es
e
i m
es he r m e.

Tr ame t f ra linfa t r si lder s a d ie i biiain a s g r '
e t n s o vuso rc u e ncu e t n c , mmo lz to nd ur e y.)
'