Harris v. Large

Filing 13

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/9/2015. (tvt)

Download PDF
CLERK' OF CE U. DII P S FI S, S nUA in F3A7oKEI v . '' . < VA ' !;.i% Z'a'.' . J. ' ' . ) d2? 2! 2 1 05 I TH E I NI N J TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FO R T H E W ESTERN DI STRI T O F V I G I I C R N A ROANOK E DI SI W ON CLY D E ALLEN H AR RI S, BM. .u ' C A SE N O .7: 5C V 005 1 24 Pl i i f a nt f , V. M E M O R AN D UM O PI O N M CR Y STA L LA R G E,FN P, By: Gl n E.C onrad e Chi fU nied St e D i t c Judge e t at s s ri t D ef endant . Cl Ale Ha s a Vigi a i t pr ee ng pr K ,fld t s c vi rght aci yde ln ni , r ni nma e oc di o ie hi i l i s ton pzs a tt 4 U. C.j1 3. I h ss bsq e ty s mitd n n e c mplit Harssae , l u n o 2 S. r 98 n i u e u n l ub te me d d o an , ri tts v r t : fl o to be o rg th n a d t e lf me s tig f r (le il)3 mo t s ebai & el u f d n ih a d n h y e t m: l et o ilgb e n nh wih u d ig a yti . ( t o t on n lng' ECF No 7 a 2) Hn rs wh i c re ty c n ie a t e l ' . ,t . ri, o s u rnl o fn d t h Sout se Vigi a Reg ona J lf c lt i Abi hwe tm r ni i l ai a iiy n ngdon,nn mes as def nda Cr t lLa ge e nt ysa r , FNP. He doe notsa ewha r le hes e i t sa ton. Upo r viw oft r c d,t c t s tt t e if e ks n hi c i n e e he e or he our f t tt a ton mus be sl miy dim is mds ha he c i t lmm l s s ed. The c t i r quie t dimis a a ton or c am fl d by a prs ne a ns a our s e r d o s s ny ci l i ie i o r gai t gove m e ale iy orofi e i t c rtde e mi st a ton o c am i f o ,ma ii , m nt ntt fc r f he ou t r ne he c i r l i s dvol us lc ous o fist saeacam u o wh c rle ma b g a td.28U. C. 1 5 b ( ) To saea r al o tt li p n ih eif y e r ne S. j 91 A( )1. tt cam u d rb 1 3, h p an ifmu talg fcss o n t tapes n a tn t e c lro li n e 98 t e litf s le e a t h wig ha ro cig md r o o f sa e 1 w t rook co uc t tvi a e t pli ifs c tt to lrg s See Cooper v. tt a mde t nd t ha olt d he antf onsiui na i ht . She n,735 F. 1 1 (t Ci.201 . Be a e la lt t rj 1 i pes l t eha 3d 53, 58 4h r 3) c us ibiiy mde 983 s rona, he E antf mus pl a t t e h Go m me - tc a def nda , t ough t ofk i ls own t i if pl t e d ha ac ve ntofi i l e nt hr he t a ' i vi ua a t o , has vi a ed t Cons iuton. See As r tv.I ,556 U. 66 676 ndi d l c i ns ol t he tt i ' ' hc of qbal S. 2, ( 0 9 . Plitf s <fa tzlalg to s mu tbe e ug t r ie a rg tt r le a o e t e 2 0 ) an if t j ct le ain s l a no h o as ih o eif b v h (. ' . ; s c a i ive r t o t ti G a i eon isf ce' r t rt n m e ey Gc ei bl ' Bel pe ultve e l' o ne ha s G usbl ' pl t a ,' a he ha r l oonc va e. ' l At. p. . mbv 5 0U. 5 4, 7 ( 0 ) lCo v Two ls 5 S. 4 5 0 20 7 . Thec u tc n t e Hars n n e c mpan a camig l e j1 3 ta d fn a t o r o snzs ri' me d d o li t s li n md r 98 h t ee d n vi a e hi c nsi i l rg s by f ii t pr de a o it m e c l te t e f hi olt d s o tt ona i ht m alng o ovi ppr pra e di a ' am nt or s r ijle ha d Onyap io o fca' d lb rt id fee c t a imae ss ro me ia n e nt d n . l rs n f ils ei eae n ifrn e o n n t ' eius dc l e d r voae te Ei hh Ame d n . S e Esel v.Ga l,4 9 U..9 ,1 2 ( 9 ) A p io ilts h g t n me t e tle mb e 2 S 7 0 1 76 . rs n o lca i G ei rtl idfe e t'i h o s e çc o o a dse ads Er r s nd f il s d l aey n ifr n' f e r h Gn ws f nd irg r o epo s d be l u ra o a l t qa e e sv zs t imaehe l o s ft ' F r rv. ema 51 U.. 2 , n e s n by o n xc sie ik o n t at r a ey. n me Br z n, 1 S 8 5 h ' 8 7 ( 9 4 . The d l e ae idfe e c sa ad tsno s ts d by ...mee d sg e me t 3 19) ei rt n ifr n e tnd r G t aife b i r ia r e n c n enn lqu sin o me ia j d me t' Ge man v S e rn 5 F. p' 3 2 3 (t o c r ig lj e to s f d c l u g n ,' r i . h a i, 31 Ap x 9 , 95 4 h ' Ci. 3 (uoigRuselv S efr 5 F.d31 , 9( t Ci.1 7 $, rmeene lg n ei r 201 ) q tn s l . h fe, 28 2 8 31 4h r 9 5 o r gi e c n di nossorte t e t Esele,429 U . a 105 1 s e as Bowrna v.Godwh,551F. 44, ag i ram n . t l S. t - 06; e lo i 2d 4 (t Ci.1 7 )(ç hee s nilts i o e o me ia ne e st a d no smpy t a wl c 8 4h r 9 7 GT) s e ta et s n f d c l c si n t i l h t l h ( y i ma bec i r me eydesr bl '.Fu t r e a ofkilsi eni ac oro s i t t y onsdeed r l ia e' rhe mor , n t a' nt tonal t mison ha ) me el de a a i t sa es t nec s r m e c ca e m a sa e a co tt tonalc am i r y l ys n nma e' cc s o es a y dial r y tt nsiu i li f pl ntf s w st tt def ntsc uc r s t d i s t nta ha m t t pa int W e v. ai if ho ha he enda ' ond t e ule n ubsa il r o he te . bb Hn d lh, F. p' 1 9 1 6(t Ci. 0 )(iigohe c ss . miul 281 Ap x 5 , 6 4h r 2 08 ctn t r a e ) a Ha s nme d co pl ntis fdoesnotal ge f c sa uthi pa tculrm e c ne d, ni ' nde m ai tel le a t bo s ri a dial e whe i oc ur e orhow s rous i i ;ho a whe t de e nt M s La ge,lam e ofli n t o r d, e i t s w nd n he f nda , . z e d ls ij r , rho s r s nd dt i; rwh th sh p e e t Ha sbe a eo s meu s cfe nu y o w he epo e o t o a a a p n d o ni c us f o n pe iid aci n M s La ge al ge y t orf ie t t ke. Thepl i ifmus saet f t s to . r le dl ook a ld o a antf t tt he acs uppo tng li ri ls cli i t c antis lla c nno rl on t c torde e ntt c am n he ompli tet nd a t ey he our fnda o omb t oug hi k h s exhi t t gu swhi h f t he be ivest bei poran . AsHa rs nme bis o es c ac s le o m t t r i' nded c ompli f l t ant ais o 2 sa ea f malba i f a à tona e cai unde I l 556 U. a 676,i ma be sl ma iy t t ac ss or ny c i bl l m r qba , S. t t y lm rl ds se l e j1 1 A( )1. imis d md r 9 5 b ( ) M o eo r Ha rs e bisi c t t the ha no c tmtonalcai a ns M s La ge r ve , ri ' xhi t ndia e ha s onsi i l m gai t . r r ga di te t ntf hi m i t M edia r c ds i l d i t e bis i c t t tHn s e r ng r a me or s s. c l e or nc ude n he xhi t ndi ae ha ni , who haspi i hi m i tfom a pro slge y,wasr cevi pr c i i pan media i e n ns n s s ' r i r tr r e i ng es rpton i c ton ve be or hi f li Aprl201 I J y,M s La ge r f r e Hn rs f X -ays ofhi rgh wrs, f e s al n i 5. n ul . r e e r d ri or r s i t it wlih i c t d a a son fa tleand s tts ue s li . 1 M s La gehasal ge y i onned lc ndi a e n vuli r c tr of i s welng r le dl nf . Hn s howe r t the wilnotbe s he e f r slge y untlhe i ta f red t a VDOC ni , ve , ha l c dul d o tr r i s r ns e r o prs f c lt Ha s a r ntbei ft ts ge y s d be s he ed i e a e y i not ng ion a iiy. ni ' ppa e le ha m r houl c dul mm dit l s hi mo e t n a ds g e me t wih M s La g ' me ia j d me t t p sp n i. S h r ha ia re n t . r es d c l u g n o o to e t uc dia e me t bewe n a pain a hi me c pr de r notaci bl t r j 1 s gre ns t e te t nd s dial ovi rae tona e mde 983, pariulry i a c e,s ast sone wih no e de et tde a ofslge y ha c us orwil tc a l n as uch hi ? t vi nc ha l y tr r s a ed, l ca e, n rsa s t n i lhn m. us H r i ny ubsa ta r Fo t er a o ssae ,h c u t imis sHnrssn nd dc mplitwih u p eudc , r h e s n ttd t e o r d s se ri' me e o an t o t rj ie p ls a tt j1 5 b ( ) frfi tet saea cam. TheClr i dr ce t s n c p e o t u n o 91 A( )1, o alr o tt li r t ek s ie td o e d o is f t sm e o a l opi on a ac ompa ng o de t pl i if hi m r ndlm ni nd c nyi r r o antf. ENTER:Tli Q < d yo No e e zs a f v mb r2015. , ClifUnie St t sDit tJ le t d a e sdc udge 1 See,e. ,htp: www. ves / l kong.coe a cl zz8g37- - e-he-r e ent -oran- li i g. t / di e/ whatr t tea sf - aa son- fa mr/(atviie No 5 201 )CW v so fa t r o c r qwhe alga n o tn n atc e t a r c e ls st d v. , 5 uli n rc ues c u g n i me t r e do ta h d o bone pari l det taly aches, Gki a bone fagment w ih i. . . . The t ng r t t se ypes of f a ur ar r ey r ct es e ar l complcat and easl teat unl s . . . t ndon or lga ent damage accom pani t fac r i ed iy r ed es e i m es he r m e. Tr ame t f ra linfa t r si lder s a d ie i biiain a s g r ' e t n s o vuso rc u e ncu e t n c , mmo lz to nd ur e y.) '

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?