Crawley v. Parsons et al

Filing 52

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 11/21/2016. (slt)

CLERK' OFFI U.S.DI .
S
CE
ST COUR'
AT ROA
.
NOKE,
VA
FIED
L

N2V 21 2 1
25
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DISTRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STR I O F W R G I I
CT
N A
R O A NO K E DI I O N
V SI

DAW D CM W LEY,
Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.

J.M I AEL PARSONS,e aI,
CH
t .
D ef
endant .
s

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

J A
BKULI DUD
DE TY

,

C RK
K

Ci lAci No.7:5-vvi ton
1 c 00647

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI

By: Ho . iha l Ur a k
h M c e F. b ns i
Unie St e Dit c Judge
td ats srit

Da d Cr e aVigi ai aepr e ngpr m , ie a cvi rght co ai
vi awl y, r ni nm t oce di
o fld i l i s mpl nt

p rua t o4 U.. j1 3a an tfl d fn a t: . iha l ro s a Asitn Ato n y
u s n t 2 SC. 98 g i s oz ee d n s J M c e Pas n , n ssz t tr e
r
Ge r ofVigi a;He y Pon on,aReg o lAdmi sr t rf t Vigi aDe m e of
ne al
r ni
nr
t
i na
nita o or he r ni pm nt

Co rcin (1
re to s ç
VDOC' ; si Flmig t eW ad no t W aln Rig S aeP io
' Le le e n ,h r e f he le s d e tt rs n
)
(t ARSP';a J M ic l,t Cha anf rW ARSP i ts Pli ifcli t tDee t
I
W
' nd . thel he pli o
)
nmae . antf ams ha fndans
a e la ef notal wi hi t pa tci t i Pa s ve a W ARSP i 201 i vi a i oft
r ibl or
lo ng m o ri pa e n s o r t
n 5, n oltön he
Fis Am e e t t Unie St t sCo tt in.Pr s nty be or t cou'i Pa s ns
rt
ndm nt o he t d a e nsiuto
e e l f e he t t s r o '

mo inf rs mmayj d me t a da trrv e n t er c r ,h c ur g a t t mo in
to o u r u g n , n fe e iwig h e o d te o t rn s he to .

Pli ifc nsde shi s l aç a s,'
a ntf .o i r m e f i hwit'who i apr c ii m e be oft As e y o
Y'
s a tc ng m r he s mbl f
Ya h r lgi a wan e t pa tcpa ei W ARSP' Pa s ve pr r be wee Aprl4 a
hwe e i on, nd
t d o ri i t n
S s o r og nm t n
i nd
11 201 Bot hea hi co e o , . e r peaedl a tmpt dt a hi hn t t
, 5. h
nd s uns l r D Ros , e t y te e o dd s me o he
Pa s
s overpa tc pa i ls be wee D e e be 201 a Aprl201 butCha ai M ic l
ri i ton i t t n c m r 4 nd
i
5,
pl n t he l
i ed t r que t . Cons q nty, a ntf w âsnota l w e t pm i i t i Pa s r
gnor he e s s
e ue l Pl i if
lo d o
c pa e n s ove .
Pl i i fi s ng a t e Pa s be aus Pl i ifbe i vest tPa s nsf ie t i onn
a ntf s ui tom y r ons c e a ntf le
ha r o a l d o nf

t f r rW a de ofW ARSP a hi s r naesa utas tlm e or ri apro ci l
he o me
r n
nd s ubo di t bo
e te nt de n i t vi
aci n a
to boutPl ntf sr i ousdit r nee . Cr wl y v.Ho l v, o.7:4- vai if elgi
e a y ds a e
lowa N
1 c 00084,si
lp

( a 2( . Va J y2 , 01 ) Th p rissg e t s tlme to J l 2 , 01 , n t
) t W D. . ul 9 2 4 . e a t in d he et n n uy 9 2 4 a d he
p.
e
e
c ta ovedt s tlm e t r sby a o de e e e t s m eda Thepa te a e ,i e
our ppr
he e te nt e m
n r r ntr d he n
y.
ri s gr ed ntr
ala, ha Pl i ifwa a ove t r evet VDOC' Comm o Fa eDi ta t tt Ofi e o
i t t antf s ppr d o ec i he
S
n r e nd ha he fc f
t Ator Ge r la e Go pr
he t ney ne a gr ed ç ompty c
t
l omm unia et so de t t W a de a W al ns
c t hi r r o he r n t le
Ri St t Prs n andt e h oft W a de sdesgne . Pa s wa t As it n Ato ne
dge ae i o
o ac
he r n' i es' r ons s he ssa t t r y
'
Ge r las i d t c
ne a sgne o omm uni t t e i t c ins Pl ntf beive t tt r woul ha
cae hos nsnzto . ai if le s ha he e
d ve
bee ltl c ncehewoul ha be n omitd fom Pa s
n ite ha
d ve e
te r
s overi Aprl2015ha Pa s
n i
d r ohs
e f c ua e t t r s oft s tl m e o d r i J y 201
f e t t d he e m
he e te nt r e n ul
4.

Ther c d r a st tPa s e a ld a c py oft s tlm e o de t hi pa algalon
e or eve l ha r ons m ie
o
he e te nt r r o s r e
J y 29,201 a 5: p. .Pa s i tuc e he t f wa d t o dert t W ARSP W a de
ul
4 t 51 m
r ons nsr t d r o or r he r o he
r n
a t a k t W a de t pr pty c m l i a et i t uc i nst hi de i es O n t ne
nd o s he r n o om l om m c t he nsr to o s sgne .
he xt

da a 1 5 a. . t pa a e le a ld a c py oft s tlm e or ra i t c e t W a de
y t 0:3 m , he r l ga m ie
o
he e te nt de s nsnzt d o r n
Gr gor Holowa Ope ai nsM a ge Re c Yo ,a sa f rKi ry D.W iln .
e y l y, r to
na r be ca ung nd t fe mbe l
li ms
La e t ts m eda a 1 08p. . Ope ai nsM a ge Youhg dis mi t t i t ci nst
t r ha n
y t 2: m , r to
na r
s e naed he nsnzto o
W ARSP sa f
tf
II.

A p ryi e t ldt s mmayj dg n i t ep e dn s teds l e maeil o fl,
a t s ni e o u r u me tf h la ig ,h icosd tras n ie
t
a any a fda t s
nd
f vis how t tt r i no ge nediput ast a m a e i f t Fe R.Ci P.
ha he e s
nui s e o ny t ral ac . d.
v.

56() M aei fcsaet ene esayt etbls t ee nt ofapat sc us ofa ton.
a . tral a t r hos c s r o sa ih he lme s
ry' a e ci
Andes n v.Li t Lobby.nc.477U. 242, ( 986 .A ge nediput ofmaei fd
ro
bery
I ,
S. 248 1 )
nui s e
tral a
e s s i,i vi w i t r o d a a lr as bl i e e esdr w n t e r i a lg m os
xi t f n e ng he ec r nd 1 e ona e nf r nc
a her f om n i ht
t

2

f vo a e t t non- ovi pary,ar s na ef tfnd rc dr t n ave ditf rt nona r bl o he
m ng t ea o bl ac-i e oul eur
r c o he

mova .Lnt p.
Pa s ha s
r ons s hown t tt r i a a e ofe de et s
ha he e s n bs nce vi nc o uppor Pl i ifscai
t antf l m

a ans hi S e eg, ltx Co . Cart 4 7U. 31 , 25( 9 6 .Th rc r
g i t m. e . ..Ceoe p v. tet 7 S. 7 3 1 8 ) e e o d
de
monsr t st tPa s nsco i d wih t t r oft s tlm e o dera ha t or r
ta e ha r o
mple t he e ms he e te nt r
nd d he de
c
omm u c t d t W ARSP ofii l. l c r t Pl i ifha no s tf t s i f c sbas d o
nia e o
fc as n ontas, antf s t e orh pecfc a t
e n
pe s na knowl
ro l
edget de onsr t t e se e ofage ne d s eoff tf til Se e. ,
o m tae he xit nc
nui iput
ac or ra . es c.

j.a 3 2 2 Plitf K mqr t u p re s e uain . .sn te ug t d fa as mmay
-s t 2 - 4. an ifs ç ee ms p o td p c lto . i o no h o ee t u r
l
g

j d me tmo in' En sv. tl sno Bu . Ed c Ra i .nc, 3F.d5 , 2 (t Ci.
u g n to . ni Na' As ' f s & u . d o l .5 3 5 6 4 h r
'
1 9 ) Ac o dn l, ro si e t ldt ml r j g n b c u et rc r a awh l
9 5 . c r igy Pa s n s ni e o mmay ud me t e a s he e od s o e
t
c d notlad ar tona tiroff tt fnd i Pli tf f vora agans Prs . See e. ,
oul
e
a i l re
ac o i n a n ifs a
nd i t ons
. c.

W ilnmsv.Grf 952F. 8 8 ( h Ci.1 )
li
ifn,
2d 20, 23 4t r 991.
11
1.

Fort f e ngr a ons t co tgr n sde e ntPa s ns m o i f s
he or goi e s , he ur a t f nda
r o ' ton or umm a y
r

j d me .Th camsa an t ee d nsPo tn, e n , ndM ic el e i p ndn b f r
u g nt e li g is d fn a t n o Flmig a
th l rman e ig eo e
t c ur .
he o t
ENTER :Thi
s

/

dyfoe e21.
aoNvmbr 06
,

.

/ / '2.. ?. G-X*
w
' .
r 7
'
'

Unied St t sDititJ
t
a e src

3

e