Hoglan v. Robinson
Filing
60
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 10/14/2016. (tvt)
CL : OFFI u. . Dl COURT
ERK'
CE s sm
ATDANVILE,
L VA
FIED
L
I THE UNI S
N
TED TATESDI CT COURT
STRI
021 1i 2 1
26
RO N K D SO
A O E WIIN
B:DEPUWDGc K
Yyc UL $R
J a. C.
u
FO R TH E W E STER N DI
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
D O U G LA S A . O G L AN ,
H
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
A.
DAW D ROBI
NSON,e al,
t .
Dee
f ndant .
s
.
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
C i lA ctop N o.7: cv- 694
vi
i
15- 00
.
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
By: n J l o L. s r
Ho . act n Kie
s
Se o Unie S a e DititJ g
ni r t d t t s src ud e
Pli ifDougl A .
antf
as Hogl n,aVigi ai aepr e di pr K ,fl d a nme
a
r ni nm t oc e ng o
ie n
nded
c an ptrua t 42U. C.j 1 Pli ifna f l saf oft Vigi aDe rme tof
omplit ls nt o
S.
983. antf mes otr t f he r ni pat n
Co rcin (d
re to s I
VDOC' a d fnd ns A. vdRo i o t VDOC' Che o Cor ci n
' s ee a t: Da i bns n,he
)
S if f re to s
Opeain ; eis W eç ,h Charo t VDOC Pu iainsRe iw Co te (
rto s M lsa lh te i f he
blc to
ve mmite 1 ';
TRC'
)
a unnn edG
nd
m TRC M embe Num be 2'a I RC M e be N mnbe 3.
r
r ' nd T
m r
r '
'
Pr s nty be or m e a e Pl i i f sa D e e nt 'va i m otonsafe D e e nt
ee l f e
r a ntf nd f nda s r ous i
t r f nda s
fldamoin f rs mma yj d me t Afe rviwigt rc r , g a tP an ifss c n
ie
to o u r u g n. tr e e n he e o d 1 r n litf e o d
m o i n t a e a De e nt 'm o i f apr e tveor r Alo, de Pl i ifsfrt
to o m nd nd f nda s ton or ot c i de . s 1 ny antf is
m otont n e m o i t eecr cal sl m oton f prs ne c r s
i o m nd, ton o l toni ly e, i or io r or e ponde ,a r que t
nce nd e s
t d n temo inf rs mmayj d me t Ral f - ake a dBicc e daes b ttt df r
o e y h to o u r u g n . ti e W l r n r l a r u siue o
f
h
de e nt PRC M e be Numbe 2 a PRC M e be N lmbe 3, e c i t r i t a PRC
f nda s
m r
r nd
m r z r W l h s em naed, nd
Me e Nu e 1i j ie .Th Clr s alsndawav rt PRC M e e Nu e 1 al
mb r mb r s on d e ek h l e
ie o
mb r mb r , r
d
P an ifs lr s n t temo inf rs mma yj d me t t i t ny o ed y .
litf hal epo d o h to o u r u g n wihn we t- n a s
1.
Ifrte pant a j iaino Plit fst moin t n n a dDee d n s
is x li he dudc to f ani wo to s o me d n fn a t'
f
r ue tt s tt t pa te .Fort f l wi r a ons 1g a tt motonst upda et
eq s o ubsiu e ri s
he olo ng e s , r n he i o
t he
def nda s na e ,de t sr tm otont n e a gr ntt s ond m o i t n e
e nt ' m s ny he s
i o m nd, nd a he ec
ton o m nd.
l t s c m otont a e Pli ifs e t s tt ePRC M e be Nlmbe 1f
n he e ond
i o m nd, a ntf e ks o ubsim
m r l r or
def nda W e c a t tnni t W ec .1 Alhough W elh i t c r ntChai oft PRC, s
e nt l h nd o e nae lh
t
c s he ur e
r he
he
wasnotame be oft PRC whe i dia ove t book Pli ifs
m r he
n t s ppr d he
antf ought Succ s f l
,
e su
Gl motrPhot r
a l
oc aphy,a adde i t t Dia o d Publcai nsLit Ptrua t Fe r l
nd
d t o he s ppr ve
i to
s . ls nt o de a
Rul ofCi lPr edze21 I
e
vi oc tr , TRC M e be Num be 1' ss tt e f rde e n W ec
m r
r 'i ubsim d o f nda t lh.
De e d n s c t e n tsi temoin frsl r j d me t h t naRal f fn a t' oms l o e n h to o l
mmay u g n t a Da
ti e
f
W al ra Te es Bic ad a et t lnna e Comm it m e be s Alo i a or nce
ke nd r a r khe r he wo l m d
tee m r . s n cc da
wih Rul 21 Ra lfe- ake a Bic ad a es tt e f rde e nt PRC M e be
t
e , tif W l r nd r khe r ubsiutd o f nda s
m r
Nt r2 a PRC M e be Nu be 3.
unbe nd
m r m r
B.
To putt de a oft frtm o i t n e i t pr rc e ,1brel des rbet
he nil he is ton o m nd n he ope ontxt i ty c i he
f c am sPl ntf purue i t a e d c
our l i
ai if s s n he m nde ompli a ns Robi on,
ant gai t
ns PRC M e
mberNumbe
r
1 Ral f- ak r a Bicc e d Fis,
, ti eW le, nd rl a . rt VDOC Opeai gP o e u e(OP' 8 2. i o eb o d
f
h
rtn r c d r ç ' 0 1 s v r r a
G )
a va f dee ng ç t r d'orl odis d'publc tonsa ot rie sasco r ba
nd gue or mi ç e e ' i te ' i a i
al
m
nd he t m
nta nd.
Se ond,O P 803. vi a es d pr es be a e t ac u notc ofdi a ove phot r phs a
c
2 ol t ue oc s c us he t al i e
s ppr d
og a
nd
publc tonsi t vag t c tt t ade t no i e.Thid,OPs802. a 803. a e
ia i s oo ue o onsiu e quae tc
r
1 nd
2 r
unc tt i l bo h f ily a a a i be aus t y pr bi s xua l e i i
onsiutona , t aca l nd s ppled, c e he ohi t e ly xplct
' anifdo sn t eks cfcij n tv rle a an tWec i a otca cpa i
Plitf e o s e pe ii nu cie eif g is lh r n f il a ct
l i
y.
co ml ia i . Fo t OP 8 2 alowe t PRC t pr bi Pl i ifspos e son of
m m c tons urh,
03. l d he
o ohi t antf
ssi
S c e su Glmo rPh t g a h Plitf se sijmcier le a ddn g sf ralft
u c sf l n u o o r p y. anif e k nt tv eif n ma e o l ol
r
ca m s
li .
Vi t trtm o i t a e Pl i ifs e t addt cai sa ns Robi on a
a he s s ton o m nd, antf e ks o
wo l m gai t
ns nd
ne ypr e de e nt .Pl i ifwa t t addcli a
wl opos d f nda s antf n s o
a ms bouta a e
n m ndme t OP 803. i
nt o
1n
M ay201 t tpr ve shi r c ptofe- ie phot a vi aprs ss ur m e s ng
6 ha e nt s e ei
ma ld
ogr phs a ion' ec e s agi
s r ce Pli ifalow a t t addcli c r ng ar vii t Pl i ifste t ntpl n
e vi . antf s
ns o
a ms onceni
e son o antf r a me
a
t tpr bishi pos es i ofs xual s
ha ohi t s s son e ly- ugge tveie a ofAprl1 , 201 2 Thene y
si t ms s
i 4
wl
6.
pr e de e nt a ef r gi na sa foft VDOC who r lt t t ne c am sonl a
opos d f nda s r our e o l tf
he
ea e o he w l i
y nd
nott t c a m s i t n e d c m pl i .
o he l i n he m nde o a nt
I t e c s ofm y di c e i 1de t s c m oto t a e N e t roft
n he xer i e
s r ton, ny he e ond
i n o m nd. ihe
he
pr e cli si ve t def nda PRC m e r orSuc es f lGl m o l Phot r p
opos d am nvol s he e nt
mbe s
c s u a tr
og a hy.
Furhe m or ,t pr
t r e he opos d c a m s c e n OP 803. ,whi h i di f r ntt n OPs 802. a
e l i onc r
1
c s f e e ha
1 nd
8 2 chal nge i t a e d co ant M o e r de vi i o t c r umsanc soft
03.
le d n he m nde mpli . r ove , l ng nt he ic t e
he
te t ntpln wilnec s ia e devi i t Pli ifsc i e ,me a he lh di gnos s a ot r
r a me a l e stt l ng n o antf ' rm s nt l at a
e , nd he
cr um sa s alf c or t twoul de a lt sltga i 3 Bec us c i r to o t
ic t nce , l a t s ha
d r i hi ii ton.
a e onsde ai n f he
p o s dcamswo dc u eu ued lya dp eu ieterg t o mo td fn a t t ti
r po e li
ul a s nd ea n rj d c h ih s f s ee d ns o h s
2Pli ifwa s ntnce t ffp oneye r 'i ionme a rhepl dedguit t t cou sof
antf s e e d o it
a s mprs
nt ûe
ea
ly o wo nt
a utrt d ikt ij r,woc u t o a utrt fo ,he c u t o a ga ae sx a b tey o ec t of
d l ae rn o nu e t o ns f d leae o d tre o ns f g rv td e u l atr , n omt
e
t awf lfl ng/ opa
ml ' imi phot phy,a t co sofposes in ofc l por gr phy.Comm o a1h v.
u
nd wo unt
s so
hid no a
nwe t Hocln,No.
a
CR0 0 01 2 CR08 0 41 , 7 0 9 2 CR0 0 1 l( rut . tfo dCny)(v ia evaVignaCic i
80 0,
0 0 7 CR0 0 0 8 , 7 01 0 Cic iCtSafr t . a albl i rii rut
Co r Ca eIfr to h :e o ilc u .tt.au/ l We /ic t sl s e eg, d. Evd.
u t s n omain, o / ws cs .o lssaev .scls bcruijp y e . ..Fe R. i R.
/
. '
201 9( 4. ReKarn Ca a Brahe Co s lLig.5 3F. u p. 61 , 3133& n 1 -5( D. . 0 )
0 2)1 --tia n l e c s n o. t , 3 S p 2d 5 6 n
i
n.4 l E. La 20 89
W il msv Lo c 5 5F. pp 2 6 , 8 -8& n4( Md 2 0 ) Whl a apro p io VDOC saf
la . n , 8 Su . d 79 6 68
i
. D. . 0 8 . ie t ir rsn,
tf
i plm enedateam e pl t t i e ai,pr ve e hi pos e sonoft ngsofas xualnatr Se .e. , ocln
m e t
r t nt an ha ,ntr la e ntd s s s i
hi
e
u e. e a.H a
v. bis n No. 1 c 25 , 01 U. DitLEXI 1 9 5 a * -, 01 WL 4 8 7 4 a *1( . Va S p . 9
Ro n o , 7:3 v 8 2 4 S. s. S 31 7 , t 25 2 4
6 0 0 , t W D. . e t 1 ,
201 )( sr J) Th tpo iinwa rmo e fo hste t n pa atr wa ta fre t Gre Ro k
4 Kie, .. a rvso s e v d rm i rame t ln fe he s rnser d o e n c
Co r to lCe e ,butprs saf hadr ne e i o Aprl1 201
recina ntr
ion t f
e w dtn
i 4, 6.
3Inoet tt compli , ame
t ha he
ant
ndme s a e bisf rPli ifsprorci la tonabouthi teame
nt, nd xhi t o antf' i vi ci
s r t nt
pln c it ofne l 400page . l , 4 U . D it LEXI 131
a onssed
ary
s d.201 S. s.
S 975,a *1n. , 4W L 468
t
1 201
0704,a *1n..
t
1
'
aci t s c m otont a e i d rid. Se eg. Fo a v. vi,371U. 1 18
ton, he e ond i o m nd s e le
es . , m n Da s
S. 78, 2
( 9 2 ; o to r En l Co lvFr, 6 F. u p. 1 26 ( D. 1 7 )
1 6 ) M n g mey vt. a. i3 6 S p 26 , 6 D. C. 9 3 .
I.
I
Alo pr e l pe i a ePl i i smoto t e e to c l fl Pl i ifsmoto f r
s es nty nd ng r antY
i n o l cr nialy ie, antf
in o
prs rc r s
ione ore ponde e De e nt moton f apr e tveor r a Pli tf' r que tt
nc , f nda s' i or ot c i de , nd a n ifs e s o
d n s mmayj d me tu tl er c i e ds o eyfo De e d n s Fo t f lo ng
e y u r u g n ni h e ev s ic v r r m f n a t. r he ol wi
r a o , g a tD e e nt sm o i a de Pl i if s m otons
e s ns I r n f nda ' ton nd ny a ntf '
i .
?
Pl i ifha fl d am o i n as ngt a l hi m ot rt e e to cal fl doc nt o
antf s ie
to ki o low s he o l c r ni ly ie ume s n
hi be l butsilr quiet c ta o he pa test ma lpa rc esofflngst hi a hi
s haf
tl e r hr our nd t r ri o i pe opi
ii o m t s
prs n. Theco tsA d i sr tvePr e esf Fii Si ng,andV e iyi Pl a ngsa
io
ur ' m nitai
oc dur or lng, gni
rf ng e di
nd
Pa r byEl toni M e nsr ds S e e e e i r e a e pa teswilnotbepe mitd t
pe s
ecr c a ea ,ç pr s nt d nca c r t d ri
um
l
r te o
s i doc nt o pladi eecr c ly,' ndPl i ifdoe notpr f e t thi mot ri
ubm t ume s r e ngs l toni a l 'a
antf
s
o f r ha s he s
a itd t pr c i l i tlsc ur t fl do lm e son hi be l.Acc di l t smoton i
dm te o a tce aw n li o t o ie cz nt
s haf
or ngy, hi
i s
de e
ni d.
Pl ntf ex ai i t m oto f rpr s ne c r ponde e t ta V D O C polc pr ve s
ai if pl ns n he
i n o i o r or es
nc ha
i y e nt
i m a e fom c r pondi unls t y ar r l t Pl i ifs yshenee t c r pond wih
n ts r
ores
ng e s he e e aed. antf a
ds o ores
t
flow i t C. ake, ose i yi notrltdt Pli itt de opClr safda t
el nmae Clr who tnsbl s eae o antfl o vel ake' fi vi.
.
Pli ife c sCl r saf vi t e an ho Clz or r dt boo TheFe aeNude,
antf xpe t a ke' sda t o xpli w ake de e he k
m l
Cl kee cedt boo t be e mptf'm t G t 'r sdci ofOP 803. be a ei i a
ar xpe t he k o
xe
l he t
o
nudiy' e t ton
2 c us t s n
ç
G a i l'
educ tona ' book,VD OC saf di notalow Cl r t pos e si due t isde c i of
t f d
l
a ke o s s t
o t pi ton
ç u iy'a dClr beiv sVDOC sa fço kas b e tv a ds rmiao ya p o c i . .
i dt , n ake le e
n
'
tf s o u j cie nd ici n t r p r a h n .
t
dia ovi t publc i n be a et y di a e d wih t a tss i e i f t a t r
s ppr ng he
iato c us he s gr e t he rit ' nt ntons or he rwo k
fom t 1 j a 1980gsil tains. Pl ntf s kspose sonofTheFe l Nudea a
r he 970(s nd
) lusrto ' ai if ee
'
ssi
mae
sn
4
e li ti t sc e a Pl ntf bei ve hei ltgai o be l ofo heri t t rt
x tbi n hi as , nd ai if le s s ii tng n ha f t nma es mde he
ovebr a h docrne.Se eg.Br drc v.Oklhoma 41 U. 601 61 ( 973)
r e dt ti
e. . , oa ik
a
, 3 S. , 2 1 .
Plrui a o r e h cli a i ta OP doe no me t tPli ifta f
zs ng n ve br adt am gans n
s t an ha antf r ns onnsi o
nt
t ltg t f e h i vi li m a ewhoha ale dl had apublc ton di a ove duet
he ii a or or ac ndi dua n t
s l ge y
iai
s ppr d
o
a OP.I t d,aco 'mus deenni whe he a OP i ea he a s tnta n ountof
n
nsea
ut
t t t ne
t rn
i c s ubsa i l m
r
c tmto ly pr t c e co uc't e ua ewhehe t OP i o r oa Vil ofHofm a
onsi i nal o e t d nd t' o val t
t r he
s ve br d. lace
f n
Esae v. lp ie Ho f nEsae . n .4 5U. 4 9 4 4 9 ( 9 2 .F rh r r ,ç 1
tts F isd s fma tt s l c, 5 S. 8 , 9 - 5 1 8 ) u te mo e $a
(
pli ifwho e ge i s
a ntf
nga s n ome c
onduc t ti cea l pr c i d c nno c pl n oft
t ha s l ry os rbe n t om ai
he
va ne soft 1w asa i d t t c
gue s
he a
pple o he onduc ofot r .A c ts dt r f ee mi t
t
he s
our houl he e or xa ne he
c pl i nts c
om a na ' onduc bef r a yz ng o he hypot tc la i a i oft l w . I
t o e nal i t r
he i a pplc tons he a ' d.
'
(o t t o t da de h ssa d d .Th a j d c to o P an ifscamsa u t OPsa d
f onoe mit n mp a i d e ) e du iain f litf li bo t he
e
n
,
'
Suc s f lGl ourPhot r phy doe notde nd on i a e Cl r sa t ptt pos e The
ce s u am
oc a
s
pe
nm t a ke' tem o s s
Fe a e N ude. A cc di l Pl i if s m oton f prs rc r po nc i de e
m l
or ng y, a ntf
i or i one or es nde e s ni d.
De e nt s e apr eci or rfom Pl i ifst r s tofi e ogaore .4
f nda s e k
ot tve de r
antf hid e
ntn- t is
De e d n s ivo ai no q aiidi mi i s p o t f h i moi nfrs mma yj d me t
f n a t'n c to f u lfe mmt t n u p r o t er to o u r u g n
y
s edst m fom dico r rquet untlt tis i r ol d.Quaiid i l t i Ga'
hil he r
s vey e ss i ha sue s es ve
lfe mmlniy s ûl
l
i t t fom s tr t rt n am e ede e et la lt ,'a i i t r f eçe f tvey l ti
mm miy r ui ahe ha
r f ns o i biiy ' nd t s he e or çfeci l os f
ac s i er n o syp r te t g t til' Pe ro v Calh n, 5 U. 2 3, 31(0 9
a e s ro e u l e mitd o o o ra. as n . ta a 5 5 S. 2 2 2 0 )
'
(uoigM ic l v. ryt, 7 U. 5 1 5 ( 9 5) I d e ,h ç rvigf re' e i t e
q tn thel Fo s h 4 2 S. 1 , 26 1 8 ). n e d te i i n o c 'b hnd h
d
docrnei t l iet e ur t ttns tnta camsa i tgove n ntofcal ( lqbe
ti s he & r o ns e ha i ubsa il li gans
des
r me fii s wil
r s le p irt d so e y''I (l r to i o ii l (u tn And ro v Crih o , 8
e ov d ro o ic v r .' d.at ai n n rgna) q o ig es n . ez t n 4 3
e
U. 635,640n. ( 98 Noneoft s cfci er t i orr que t Pl ntf s e i ofa
S.
2 1 7:.
he pe ii ntrogaores e ss ai if e ks s
4Th t r sto itro aoismotyc n it o q eto st whihDee d nsh dara yo jce i
e hid e fnerg tre sl o sss f u sin o c fn a t a le d betd n
t r po est t frta s cond st ofi eroga o is
he es ns o he is nd e
e s nt r t re .
c r ctrne es iai d s ove ybe o er ol ng qua i i l t Cf Cr wf r Elv.
ha a e c st tng i c r f r es vi
lfed mmlniy. . a o d-
Brto 5 3U.. 7 , 9 n 1 ( 9 8 .Ac o d n l, fn a t ' to f rap oe tv ode
itn, 2 S 5 4 5 3 .4 1 9 ) c r i gy Dee d n s mo in o r tcie r r
a i tPl i ifst r s tofi e r t i a r que t i g a ed,a Pl ntf sm oto t
gans antf hid e nt roga ores nd e ss s r nt nd ai if
in o
d n s mma yj d me t sd ne Cf Fe R. v P. 6 d .Alh u hPlitf h sh dmo e
e y u r u g n i e id. . d. Ci . 5 () t o g an if a a r
t a sx yd y t p e r ar s ns t temoin frs mmayj g n , g a t m t n y
h n it a s o rpae epo e o h to o u r ud me t I rn hi we t o ea d to l a t s b t srs ns t t moi rfrs mmayj d me t
n d iina d ys o u mihi epo e o he toi o u r u g n .
1
11.
Fo t f egoi r s ns lgr ntPli ifss c m o i t n e a De e
r he or ng ea o , a
antf e ond ton o m nd nd f ndant'
s
m o i f apr t c i or r de Pl i ifstrtmoton t n e m o i t e e toni a l
ton or o e tve de .l ny antf' i s
i o m nd, ton o l c r c ly
-
tl, to f rp o e c re p n e e a dr q e t od n t emoin frsl r j d me t
se moin o ds n r o r s o d nc , n e u s t e y h to o l
mma y u g n .
Ra lfe W al ra Bic a a es tt t d f de e t PRC M e be Nlmbe 2 a PRC
tif - ke nd r khe d r ubsiu e or f ndan s
m r l r nd
M e rNum be 3, Dee a tW ec i tnniae , n PRC M e r l e 1i j ie .The
mbe'
r
fnd n lh s e n td a d
mbe Nl r s on d
mb
Cl r s l s nd awave t PRC M e rNumbe 1 a Pli ifs lr s ndt t moto
e k hal e
i ro
mbe
r , nd a ntf hal e po o he i n
f rsl r u me t t i t ny o ed y .
o l
mmayj dg n wihn we t- n a s
E
NTER: hs $ dyo Oco e, 0 6
Ti
a f tb r2 1.
/
G
6
z
6
Se
ni U nie St t D it i tJ
t d a es s rc udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?