Hoglan v. Robinson

Filing 60

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 10/14/2016. (tvt)

CL : OFFI u. . Dl COURT
ERK'
CE s sm
ATDANVILE,
L VA
FIED
L

I THE UNI S
N
TED TATESDI CT COURT
STRI

021 1i 2 1
26

RO N K D SO
A O E WIIN

B:DEPUWDGc K
Yyc UL $R
J a. C.
u

FO R TH E W E STER N DI
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A

D O U G LA S A . O G L AN ,
H
Pl nt f ,
ai i f

A.
DAW D ROBI
NSON,e al,
t .
Dee
f ndant .
s
.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

C i lA ctop N o.7: cv- 694
vi
i
15- 00
.

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI

By: n J l o L. s r
Ho . act n Kie
s
Se o Unie S a e DititJ g
ni r t d t t s src ud e

Pli ifDougl A .
antf
as Hogl n,aVigi ai aepr e di pr K ,fl d a nme
a
r ni nm t oc e ng o
ie n
nded

c an ptrua t 42U. C.j 1 Pli ifna f l saf oft Vigi aDe rme tof
omplit ls nt o
S.
983. antf mes otr t f he r ni pat n

Co rcin (d
re to s I
VDOC' a d fnd ns A. vdRo i o t VDOC' Che o Cor ci n
' s ee a t: Da i bns n,he
)
S if f re to s
Opeain ; eis W eç ,h Charo t VDOC Pu iainsRe iw Co te (
rto s M lsa lh te i f he
blc to
ve mmite 1 ';
TRC'
)
a unnn edG
nd
m TRC M embe Num be 2'a I RC M e be N mnbe 3.
r
r ' nd T
m r
r '
'
Pr s nty be or m e a e Pl i i f sa D e e nt 'va i m otonsafe D e e nt
ee l f e
r a ntf nd f nda s r ous i
t r f nda s

fldamoin f rs mma yj d me t Afe rviwigt rc r , g a tP an ifss c n
ie
to o u r u g n. tr e e n he e o d 1 r n litf e o d
m o i n t a e a De e nt 'm o i f apr e tveor r Alo, de Pl i ifsfrt
to o m nd nd f nda s ton or ot c i de . s 1 ny antf is
m otont n e m o i t eecr cal sl m oton f prs ne c r s
i o m nd, ton o l toni ly e, i or io r or e ponde ,a r que t
nce nd e s

t d n temo inf rs mmayj d me t Ral f - ake a dBicc e daes b ttt df r
o e y h to o u r u g n . ti e W l r n r l a r u siue o
f
h
de e nt PRC M e be Numbe 2 a PRC M e be N lmbe 3, e c i t r i t a PRC
f nda s
m r
r nd
m r z r W l h s em naed, nd

Me e Nu e 1i j ie .Th Clr s alsndawav rt PRC M e e Nu e 1 al
mb r mb r s on d e ek h l e
ie o
mb r mb r , r
d
P an ifs lr s n t temo inf rs mma yj d me t t i t ny o ed y .
litf hal epo d o h to o u r u g n wihn we t- n a s

1.

Ifrte pant a j iaino Plit fst moin t n n a dDee d n s
is x li he dudc to f ani wo to s o me d n fn a t'
f
r ue tt s tt t pa te .Fort f l wi r a ons 1g a tt motonst upda et
eq s o ubsiu e ri s
he olo ng e s , r n he i o
t he
def nda s na e ,de t sr tm otont n e a gr ntt s ond m o i t n e
e nt ' m s ny he s
i o m nd, nd a he ec
ton o m nd.

l t s c m otont a e Pli ifs e t s tt ePRC M e be Nlmbe 1f
n he e ond
i o m nd, a ntf e ks o ubsim
m r l r or
def nda W e c a t tnni t W ec .1 Alhough W elh i t c r ntChai oft PRC, s
e nt l h nd o e nae lh
t
c s he ur e
r he
he
wasnotame be oft PRC whe i dia ove t book Pli ifs
m r he
n t s ppr d he
antf ought Succ s f l
,
e su
Gl motrPhot r
a l
oc aphy,a adde i t t Dia o d Publcai nsLit Ptrua t Fe r l
nd
d t o he s ppr ve
i to
s . ls nt o de a

Rul ofCi lPr edze21 I
e
vi oc tr , TRC M e be Num be 1' ss tt e f rde e n W ec
m r
r 'i ubsim d o f nda t lh.

De e d n s c t e n tsi temoin frsl r j d me t h t naRal f fn a t' oms l o e n h to o l
mmay u g n t a Da
ti e
f
W al ra Te es Bic ad a et t lnna e Comm it m e be s Alo i a or nce
ke nd r a r khe r he wo l m d
tee m r . s n cc da
wih Rul 21 Ra lfe- ake a Bic ad a es tt e f rde e nt PRC M e be
t
e , tif W l r nd r khe r ubsiutd o f nda s
m r

Nt r2 a PRC M e be Nu be 3.
unbe nd
m r m r
B.

To putt de a oft frtm o i t n e i t pr rc e ,1brel des rbet
he nil he is ton o m nd n he ope ontxt i ty c i he
f c am sPl ntf purue i t a e d c
our l i
ai if s s n he m nde ompli a ns Robi on,
ant gai t
ns PRC M e
mberNumbe
r

1 Ral f- ak r a Bicc e d Fis,
, ti eW le, nd rl a . rt VDOC Opeai gP o e u e(OP' 8 2. i o eb o d
f
h
rtn r c d r ç ' 0 1 s v r r a
G )
a va f dee ng ç t r d'orl odis d'publc tonsa ot rie sasco r ba
nd gue or mi ç e e ' i te ' i a i
al
m
nd he t m
nta nd.
Se ond,O P 803. vi a es d pr es be a e t ac u notc ofdi a ove phot r phs a
c
2 ol t ue oc s c us he t al i e
s ppr d
og a
nd

publc tonsi t vag t c tt t ade t no i e.Thid,OPs802. a 803. a e
ia i s oo ue o onsiu e quae tc
r
1 nd
2 r
unc tt i l bo h f ily a a a i be aus t y pr bi s xua l e i i
onsiutona , t aca l nd s ppled, c e he ohi t e ly xplct

' anifdo sn t eks cfcij n tv rle a an tWec i a otca cpa i
Plitf e o s e pe ii nu cie eif g is lh r n f il a ct
l i
y.

co ml ia i . Fo t OP 8 2 alowe t PRC t pr bi Pl i ifspos e son of
m m c tons urh,
03. l d he
o ohi t antf
ssi

S c e su Glmo rPh t g a h Plitf se sijmcier le a ddn g sf ralft
u c sf l n u o o r p y. anif e k nt tv eif n ma e o l ol
r
ca m s
li .

Vi t trtm o i t a e Pl i ifs e t addt cai sa ns Robi on a
a he s s ton o m nd, antf e ks o
wo l m gai t
ns nd
ne ypr e de e nt .Pl i ifwa t t addcli a
wl opos d f nda s antf n s o
a ms bouta a e
n m ndme t OP 803. i
nt o
1n
M ay201 t tpr ve shi r c ptofe- ie phot a vi aprs ss ur m e s ng
6 ha e nt s e ei
ma ld
ogr phs a ion' ec e s agi
s r ce Pli ifalow a t t addcli c r ng ar vii t Pl i ifste t ntpl n
e vi . antf s
ns o
a ms onceni
e son o antf r a me
a
t tpr bishi pos es i ofs xual s
ha ohi t s s son e ly- ugge tveie a ofAprl1 , 201 2 Thene y
si t ms s
i 4
wl
6.
pr e de e nt a ef r gi na sa foft VDOC who r lt t t ne c am sonl a
opos d f nda s r our e o l tf
he
ea e o he w l i
y nd
nott t c a m s i t n e d c m pl i .
o he l i n he m nde o a nt
I t e c s ofm y di c e i 1de t s c m oto t a e N e t roft
n he xer i e
s r ton, ny he e ond
i n o m nd. ihe
he

pr e cli si ve t def nda PRC m e r orSuc es f lGl m o l Phot r p
opos d am nvol s he e nt
mbe s
c s u a tr
og a hy.
Furhe m or ,t pr
t r e he opos d c a m s c e n OP 803. ,whi h i di f r ntt n OPs 802. a
e l i onc r
1
c s f e e ha
1 nd

8 2 chal nge i t a e d co ant M o e r de vi i o t c r umsanc soft
03.
le d n he m nde mpli . r ove , l ng nt he ic t e
he
te t ntpln wilnec s ia e devi i t Pli ifsc i e ,me a he lh di gnos s a ot r
r a me a l e stt l ng n o antf ' rm s nt l at a
e , nd he
cr um sa s alf c or t twoul de a lt sltga i 3 Bec us c i r to o t
ic t nce , l a t s ha
d r i hi ii ton.
a e onsde ai n f he

p o s dcamswo dc u eu ued lya dp eu ieterg t o mo td fn a t t ti
r po e li
ul a s nd ea n rj d c h ih s f s ee d ns o h s

2Pli ifwa s ntnce t ffp oneye r 'i ionme a rhepl dedguit t t cou sof
antf s e e d o it
a s mprs
nt ûe
ea
ly o wo nt

a utrt d ikt ij r,woc u t o a utrt fo ,he c u t o a ga ae sx a b tey o ec t of
d l ae rn o nu e t o ns f d leae o d tre o ns f g rv td e u l atr , n omt
e

t awf lfl ng/ opa
ml ' imi phot phy,a t co sofposes in ofc l por gr phy.Comm o a1h v.
u
nd wo unt
s so
hid no a
nwe t Hocln,No.
a

CR0 0 01 2 CR08 0 41 , 7 0 9 2 CR0 0 1 l( rut . tfo dCny)(v ia evaVignaCic i
80 0,
0 0 7 CR0 0 0 8 , 7 01 0 Cic iCtSafr t . a albl i rii rut
Co r Ca eIfr to h :e o ilc u .tt.au/ l We /ic t sl s e eg, d. Evd.
u t s n omain, o / ws cs .o lssaev .scls bcruijp y e . ..Fe R. i R.
/
. '
201 9( 4. ReKarn Ca a Brahe Co s lLig.5 3F. u p. 61 , 3133& n 1 -5( D. . 0 )
0 2)1 --tia n l e c s n o. t , 3 S p 2d 5 6 n
i
n.4 l E. La 20 89
W il msv Lo c 5 5F. pp 2 6 , 8 -8& n4( Md 2 0 ) Whl a apro p io VDOC saf
la . n , 8 Su . d 79 6 68
i
. D. . 0 8 . ie t ir rsn,
tf

i plm enedateam e pl t t i e ai,pr ve e hi pos e sonoft ngsofas xualnatr Se .e. , ocln
m e t
r t nt an ha ,ntr la e ntd s s s i
hi
e
u e. e a.H a

v. bis n No. 1 c 25 , 01 U. DitLEXI 1 9 5 a * -, 01 WL 4 8 7 4 a *1( . Va S p . 9
Ro n o , 7:3 v 8 2 4 S. s. S 31 7 , t 25 2 4
6 0 0 , t W D. . e t 1 ,
201 )( sr J) Th tpo iinwa rmo e fo hste t n pa atr wa ta fre t Gre Ro k
4 Kie, .. a rvso s e v d rm i rame t ln fe he s rnser d o e n c
Co r to lCe e ,butprs saf hadr ne e i o Aprl1 201
recina ntr
ion t f
e w dtn
i 4, 6.
3Inoet tt compli , ame
t ha he
ant
ndme s a e bisf rPli ifsprorci la tonabouthi teame
nt, nd xhi t o antf' i vi ci
s r t nt
pln c it ofne l 400page . l , 4 U . D it LEXI 131
a onssed
ary
s d.201 S. s.
S 975,a *1n. , 4W L 468
t
1 201
0704,a *1n..
t
1

'

aci t s c m otont a e i d rid. Se eg. Fo a v. vi,371U. 1 18
ton, he e ond i o m nd s e le
es . , m n Da s
S. 78, 2

( 9 2 ; o to r En l Co lvFr, 6 F. u p. 1 26 ( D. 1 7 )
1 6 ) M n g mey vt. a. i3 6 S p 26 , 6 D. C. 9 3 .
I.
I

Alo pr e l pe i a ePl i i smoto t e e to c l fl Pl i ifsmoto f r
s es nty nd ng r antY
i n o l cr nialy ie, antf
in o
prs rc r s
ione ore ponde e De e nt moton f apr e tveor r a Pli tf' r que tt
nc , f nda s' i or ot c i de , nd a n ifs e s o

d n s mmayj d me tu tl er c i e ds o eyfo De e d n s Fo t f lo ng
e y u r u g n ni h e ev s ic v r r m f n a t. r he ol wi
r a o , g a tD e e nt sm o i a de Pl i if s m otons
e s ns I r n f nda ' ton nd ny a ntf '
i .
?

Pl i ifha fl d am o i n as ngt a l hi m ot rt e e to cal fl doc nt o
antf s ie
to ki o low s he o l c r ni ly ie ume s n

hi be l butsilr quiet c ta o he pa test ma lpa rc esofflngst hi a hi
s haf
tl e r hr our nd t r ri o i pe opi
ii o m t s
prs n. Theco tsA d i sr tvePr e esf Fii Si ng,andV e iyi Pl a ngsa
io
ur ' m nitai
oc dur or lng, gni
rf ng e di
nd
Pa r byEl toni M e nsr ds S e e e e i r e a e pa teswilnotbepe mitd t
pe s
ecr c a ea ,ç pr s nt d nca c r t d ri
um
l
r te o
s i doc nt o pladi eecr c ly,' ndPl i ifdoe notpr f e t thi mot ri
ubm t ume s r e ngs l toni a l 'a
antf
s
o f r ha s he s
a itd t pr c i l i tlsc ur t fl do lm e son hi be l.Acc di l t smoton i
dm te o a tce aw n li o t o ie cz nt
s haf
or ngy, hi
i s
de e
ni d.
Pl ntf ex ai i t m oto f rpr s ne c r ponde e t ta V D O C polc pr ve s
ai if pl ns n he
i n o i o r or es
nc ha
i y e nt

i m a e fom c r pondi unls t y ar r l t Pl i ifs yshenee t c r pond wih
n ts r
ores
ng e s he e e aed. antf a
ds o ores
t

flow i t C. ake, ose i yi notrltdt Pli itt de opClr safda t
el nmae Clr who tnsbl s eae o antfl o vel ake' fi vi.
.

Pli ife c sCl r saf vi t e an ho Clz or r dt boo TheFe aeNude,
antf xpe t a ke' sda t o xpli w ake de e he k
m l
Cl kee cedt boo t be e mptf'm t G t 'r sdci ofOP 803. be a ei i a
ar xpe t he k o
xe
l he t
o
nudiy' e t ton
2 c us t s n
ç
G a i l'
educ tona ' book,VD OC saf di notalow Cl r t pos e si due t isde c i of
t f d
l
a ke o s s t
o t pi ton

ç u iy'a dClr beiv sVDOC sa fço kas b e tv a ds rmiao ya p o c i . .
i dt , n ake le e
n
'
tf s o u j cie nd ici n t r p r a h n .
t
dia ovi t publc i n be a et y di a e d wih t a tss i e i f t a t r
s ppr ng he
iato c us he s gr e t he rit ' nt ntons or he rwo k

fom t 1 j a 1980gsil tains. Pl ntf s kspose sonofTheFe l Nudea a
r he 970(s nd
) lusrto ' ai if ee
'
ssi
mae
sn
4

e li ti t sc e a Pl ntf bei ve hei ltgai o be l ofo heri t t rt
x tbi n hi as , nd ai if le s s ii tng n ha f t nma es mde he

ovebr a h docrne.Se eg.Br drc v.Oklhoma 41 U. 601 61 ( 973)
r e dt ti
e. . , oa ik
a
, 3 S. , 2 1 .
Plrui a o r e h cli a i ta OP doe no me t tPli ifta f
zs ng n ve br adt am gans n
s t an ha antf r ns onnsi o
nt
t ltg t f e h i vi li m a ewhoha ale dl had apublc ton di a ove duet
he ii a or or ac ndi dua n t
s l ge y
iai
s ppr d
o
a OP.I t d,aco 'mus deenni whe he a OP i ea he a s tnta n ountof
n
nsea
ut
t t t ne
t rn
i c s ubsa i l m
r
c tmto ly pr t c e co uc't e ua ewhehe t OP i o r oa Vil ofHofm a
onsi i nal o e t d nd t' o val t
t r he
s ve br d. lace
f n

Esae v. lp ie Ho f nEsae . n .4 5U. 4 9 4 4 9 ( 9 2 .F rh r r ,ç 1
tts F isd s fma tt s l c, 5 S. 8 , 9 - 5 1 8 ) u te mo e $a
(
pli ifwho e ge i s
a ntf
nga s n ome c
onduc t ti cea l pr c i d c nno c pl n oft
t ha s l ry os rbe n t om ai
he
va ne soft 1w asa i d t t c
gue s
he a
pple o he onduc ofot r .A c ts dt r f ee mi t
t
he s
our houl he e or xa ne he
c pl i nts c
om a na ' onduc bef r a yz ng o he hypot tc la i a i oft l w . I
t o e nal i t r
he i a pplc tons he a ' d.
'

(o t t o t da de h ssa d d .Th a j d c to o P an ifscamsa u t OPsa d
f onoe mit n mp a i d e ) e du iain f litf li bo t he
e
n
,

'

Suc s f lGl ourPhot r phy doe notde nd on i a e Cl r sa t ptt pos e The
ce s u am
oc a
s
pe
nm t a ke' tem o s s
Fe a e N ude. A cc di l Pl i if s m oton f prs rc r po nc i de e
m l
or ng y, a ntf
i or i one or es nde e s ni d.

De e nt s e apr eci or rfom Pl i ifst r s tofi e ogaore .4
f nda s e k
ot tve de r
antf hid e
ntn- t is

De e d n s ivo ai no q aiidi mi i s p o t f h i moi nfrs mma yj d me t
f n a t'n c to f u lfe mmt t n u p r o t er to o u r u g n
y
s edst m fom dico r rquet untlt tis i r ol d.Quaiid i l t i Ga'
hil he r
s vey e ss i ha sue s es ve
lfe mmlniy s ûl
l
i t t fom s tr t rt n am e ede e et la lt ,'a i i t r f eçe f tvey l ti
mm miy r ui ahe ha
r f ns o i biiy ' nd t s he e or çfeci l os f

ac s i er n o syp r te t g t til' Pe ro v Calh n, 5 U. 2 3, 31(0 9
a e s ro e u l e mitd o o o ra. as n . ta a 5 5 S. 2 2 2 0 )
'
(uoigM ic l v. ryt, 7 U. 5 1 5 ( 9 5) I d e ,h ç rvigf re' e i t e
q tn thel Fo s h 4 2 S. 1 , 26 1 8 ). n e d te i i n o c 'b hnd h
d
docrnei t l iet e ur t ttns tnta camsa i tgove n ntofcal ( lqbe
ti s he & r o ns e ha i ubsa il li gans
des
r me fii s wil

r s le p irt d so e y''I (l r to i o ii l (u tn And ro v Crih o , 8
e ov d ro o ic v r .' d.at ai n n rgna) q o ig es n . ez t n 4 3
e
U. 635,640n. ( 98 Noneoft s cfci er t i orr que t Pl ntf s e i ofa
S.
2 1 7:.
he pe ii ntrogaores e ss ai if e ks s
4Th t r sto itro aoismotyc n it o q eto st whihDee d nsh dara yo jce i
e hid e fnerg tre sl o sss f u sin o c fn a t a le d betd n
t r po est t frta s cond st ofi eroga o is
he es ns o he is nd e
e s nt r t re .

c r ctrne es iai d s ove ybe o er ol ng qua i i l t Cf Cr wf r Elv.
ha a e c st tng i c r f r es vi
lfed mmlniy. . a o d-

Brto 5 3U.. 7 , 9 n 1 ( 9 8 .Ac o d n l, fn a t ' to f rap oe tv ode
itn, 2 S 5 4 5 3 .4 1 9 ) c r i gy Dee d n s mo in o r tcie r r
a i tPl i ifst r s tofi e r t i a r que t i g a ed,a Pl ntf sm oto t
gans antf hid e nt roga ores nd e ss s r nt nd ai if
in o

d n s mma yj d me t sd ne Cf Fe R. v P. 6 d .Alh u hPlitf h sh dmo e
e y u r u g n i e id. . d. Ci . 5 () t o g an if a a r
t a sx yd y t p e r ar s ns t temoin frs mmayj g n , g a t m t n y
h n it a s o rpae epo e o h to o u r ud me t I rn hi we t o ea d to l a t s b t srs ns t t moi rfrs mmayj d me t
n d iina d ys o u mihi epo e o he toi o u r u g n .
1
11.

Fo t f egoi r s ns lgr ntPli ifss c m o i t n e a De e
r he or ng ea o , a
antf e ond ton o m nd nd f ndant'
s
m o i f apr t c i or r de Pl i ifstrtmoton t n e m o i t e e toni a l
ton or o e tve de .l ny antf' i s
i o m nd, ton o l c r c ly
-

tl, to f rp o e c re p n e e a dr q e t od n t emoin frsl r j d me t
se moin o ds n r o r s o d nc , n e u s t e y h to o l
mma y u g n .
Ra lfe W al ra Bic a a es tt t d f de e t PRC M e be Nlmbe 2 a PRC
tif - ke nd r khe d r ubsiu e or f ndan s
m r l r nd
M e rNum be 3, Dee a tW ec i tnniae , n PRC M e r l e 1i j ie .The
mbe'
r
fnd n lh s e n td a d
mbe Nl r s on d
mb
Cl r s l s nd awave t PRC M e rNumbe 1 a Pli ifs lr s ndt t moto
e k hal e
i ro
mbe
r , nd a ntf hal e po o he i n

f rsl r u me t t i t ny o ed y .
o l
mmayj dg n wihn we t- n a s

E
NTER: hs $ dyo Oco e, 0 6
Ti
a f tb r2 1.
/
G
6

z

6

Se
ni U nie St t D it i tJ
t d a es s rc udge