Hoglan v. Robinson

Filing 75

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 3/21/2017. (tvt)

ek T ttzsqqt :1 ,t i . .
k.l: 4'd j ::i@' t
f
Ff
A D N Ik,A
T A VIiV
;
FlEb
L

MA2 2 $ 2 1
27
I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT

FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
N
R O AN O K E D I SI N
W O
D O U G LA S A .H O G LA N ,
Pl ntf
ai if,

A.DAW D ROBI
NSON,e aI,
t .
De e
f ndant .
s

JU
BY:

.
Du

,

D 0R L

vi
i
15- 00694
) Ci lA cton N o.7: cv)
)
) M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
)
) By: Ho Ja ks nL. s r
n. c o Kie
)
Se orUnie Stt sDititJudge
ni
td a e src

Pl i ifDougl A.Hogln, Vigi a i t pr ee ng pr K , e a n e d
antf
as
a a r ni nma e oc di
o sld n m nde

c mp an pu s a tt 42U.. 51 8 Pli t f n sf u safô teVigiaDe a t n o
o lit ru n o
SC. 9 3. ani n me o r tf f h r i
f
p rme t f
Co cin (VDOC' a d fn a t: Da dRo is n teVDOC' Ch e o Co rcin
ne to s ç
1
' s ee d n s A. vi bn o ,h
)
S if f re to s
Op rto ; Ea h ,h fr rCharo teVDOC P bl ainsRe e Co te (TRC' ;
e ains C. c o te o me
i fh
u i to
c
viw mmi e t '
t
)
a f me PRC m e r D . Ralfe W al rand Bic
nd or r
mbe s
tif - ke
r khea l Pr s ntybe or m ea e
d. e e l f e
r

Plitf' a dDee a t' a u m'to ,ncu igmoin f rs mma yj d me tb s do
an ifs n fnd n s v do s oins i ldn to s o u r u g n a e n
q lfedi
ua i
mmuniy. Afe r vi wi t r c d, Igr ntDef nda s and de Pl n ifs
t 2 tr e e ng he e or
a
e nt '
ny aitf

mo in frsl r u g n t a r q l di miyt Dee a t i t erid vd a
to s o l
mmayj d me t o wad uai mmt t o fnd ns n h i n i iu l
se
c p cte , ndIds s wi o t rj d c t p ris mo in a t Dee d n si t erofca
a a iis a
imis t u p eu ie he a t ' to s s o fn a t n h i fiil
h
e
c pactes
a ii .
1.

Pli ifpur uesf z cli si t n nded c
antf
s olr am n he mè
ompli â ns Robi on,Eac
ant gai t
ns
ho,

Ral f - ake, n Bicc e d Fis,
ti e W l r a d rl a . rt VDOC Opeai P o e u e(OP' 8 2. i o e b o d
f
h
rt r c d r $ ' 0 1 s v r r a
ng
( )
a vag f dee i ç odii d orale e '
nd ue or m ng G
m fe
t r d' publc tons a ot r ie sa c r ba
ia i
nd he t m s onf a nd.

1Fi ngi a opraet do i s i a cor ewih defndant'r pr s nttonsandFe . R. v. 1 ()
ndi t ppr it o n o n c danc t
e
s e e e ai
d Ci P. 7 d
a 21 C.Ea hoi s tmt f deenda PRC M e rNumbe l.
nd ,
c s ubsi ed or f nt
mbe
r

2PaniffldaE to fraj dcto sq e c 'i whihh rq et tec u tod cd c ranis e
litf ie ' in o du iain e u n e'n c e e u ss h o r t e ie eti su s
mo
i hi pr f r d or r Pli ifdoe nott ciea pr sonof1w asaf
n s eere de . antf s
o t ny ovii
a
ounda i f t moton. Themotoni
ton or he i
i s
de ed.
ni
'

Se ond,OPs8 1and 803. a eunc tt i na,bot f i l a a a id,be us t y
c
02.
2 r
onsiuto l h acaly nd s pple
ca e he
pr bi s xualy e ii commt c tons Thid, 803. unlwf ly al w e t PRC t
ohi t e l xplc t
mia i . r OP
2 a ul lo d he
o
pr lbi Pl i ifspos e son ofSuc s f lGl
oli t antf
ss i
ce s u amourPhot a
ocr phy.Fourh,OP 803. vi ae
t
2 olt s
duepr e sbe aus t e a t lnotc o dia ove phot r phsa publc tonsi t va e
oc s c e hs cua ie f s ppr d
og a
nd
i ai s oo gu
t c tt e a quaeno i Pl ntf ge r ly ale t t i r lton t t f cli s
o ons iut de t tce. ai if ne a l lges ha ,n ea i o he our am ,
Def nda s
e nt :

a) g a t i td d rcl i t e alg d v oain a d o b. a tr ben
. plri pae ie ty n h le e i lto , n /r ) fe ig
c
i or d of t vi a i
nf me
he ol tons t ough lte , r por, c
hr
e tr e t ompl i , g i vanc ,
ant re
e

c u e,o oh r me ns fie t r me y t ij r ,a /r c) ce td a
o nsl r t e a ald o e d he nu y ndo . r ae
polc pr dur pr tc or c t m unde whih unc tt tonal a t
i y, oce e, aci e,
uso
r
c
onsiu i
cs

o c re , o alwe t pesse c o s i i t me t,a d o d. wa
c u rd r lo d he ritn e f ad nsnz n s n /r ) s
gr sy ne i nti s r ii s di t swho pm ii t d i co itng
os l glge n upe v sng ubor na e
cpa e n mm ti

t v o g u a t, a do e) e hii d d lb rt i ifrnc o tct
he
n f l cs n /r . x bt eieae ndfee e r a i
e
a horzai i t vi a i ofrgh soft pl i ifa t eno be or t
ut i ton n he oltons i t
he antf nd hos t f e he
Cour .
t

( Co . 9) P an ifs e ij n tv rle a d ma e a ans De e d n si t er
Am. mpl! . litf e ks n u cie eif nd n g s g i t fn a t n h i
ofi i a i vi ua ca cii sf alf urcai s
fcal nd ndi d l pa te or l o l m .

Th frtcam i t a VDOC Op rtngPr c d e(1 ' 8 2.,t fn e P o e ty i
e is li s h t
eai o e m & ) 0 1 G e d r r p ry' s
OP'
of
'
'

ove br d a vaguef de mi a c r ba a publc ton orot rie t ti S odii d
r oa nd
or e ng s onta nd ny
ia i
he t m ha s t fe
m
orale e ' Not bl none oft pa te fld ac ofOP 80 1, c e nty,Ir l o
tr d.' a y,
he ri s ie
opy
2. and ons que l ey n
t n e dc
he m nde ompli ' des rpton ofi.
ants c i i
t

OP 8 2 1d fn sc nr b n t icud tstt o p ro a p o ry,e ade so h w
0 . ei e o ta a d o n l e t jae r e s n l r pe t r g r ls f o
g
ac r t ti i r bl orha be n m odi dpz a t r d w ihou w rte a ho i t o ' For
quied, ha s nope a e
s e
se
le e t t it n ut r za i n.
'
.

e m pl ,a f l page r m ove f om a publc ton o a publc ton w ih a m i s ng ora c tpag i
xn e u l
e
d r
i ai r
iai
t
si
u
es

2

de m e ç odii orat r ' nd m us bedic de asc r ba t e st i t ha
e d ç fed le ed'a
m
t
s ar d onta nd mls he nma e d
r c ve wrte a hodz ton.
e ei d itn ut
ai 3
/

Pl n ifg ne aly co pl i t t durng hi ove al tm ei t VDOC,sa fhas
aitf e r l m ans ha , i s r l i n he
tf

c s t fom hi l epa s publc tonsm isngpa t ofpa orfl1pa , a
oM caed r
m oos ge , i a i
si
rs
ges t1 ges he dphone
c dsr par wih tpe, ndt s a r t twe edee
or e ied t a a om ne ke s ha r
med c r ba f bei G
onta nd or ng l fe or
modi d
ale e ' Pl ntf be ivest plr eSmodii d orale ed'i t vag ,a he i ups tt tOP
tr dk ai if le
'
he las ç fe
t r ' s oo ue nd s e ha
802. doe no Ca es t s peofc r ba wih r r t modii d oraler d pr ry by
1 s t tddr s he co
onta nd t ega ds o
fe
t e ope t
lnki t m t s ii pe ogialgoa s'lke o he sa e 'c r c i a nces
i ng he o pecfc nol c
l' i t r t t s bre tonal ge i .
B.

The s ond,t r a f t c am si l OP 803. Gl omi Publc tons'
ec
hid, nd ourh l i nvove
2, lnc ng
ia i .'
Pli tf a gue t tOP 803. vi a e duepr s be us t a m a notc ofdia ove
a n if r s ha
2 olt s
oce s ca e he c l ie
s ppr d
'

)

'

Phot a a publc tonsi t vaguet co tmt a uaenotcea t tOP 803.
ogr phs nd
ia i s oo
o nsi e deq t
i nd ha
2
vi a e t Fis Amendme be us a ofpe ua y 1 , 201 i pr bisi t s r c ptof
ol t s he r t
nt ca e, s kbr r 8
5, t ohi t nma e ' e ei
ie sco a ni ç t '
tm
nt i ng ç
nudiy.
'
The OP r ie '
ec t s.

I or rt m ant i s c iy,di cplne and good or ri DOC f iii sa
n de o i an e urt s i i ,
de n
aclte nd

t a ss wih rh b l ain a d te t n o j ci s rd c s x a
o sit t e a ii to n rame t b e t , e u e e u l
t
ve
'

ha a s e , a pr ve a hosie envionmen f r ofe r , sa f a
r s m nt nd e nt
tl
r
t o f nde s t f nd
volmt e s ofe s a e no pe mitd t s nd,r c ve or pos es matra
t e r , f nder r t r te o e
e ei
s s eil
t te
ha mpha i se ii orgr phi d pitonsordes rpto o s xua a t or '
s
'ze xplc t
a c e ci
c i i ns f e l c s
'
c ai nudiy a de
ont ns
t s sned i t so r tngpr e le.
n hi pe ai
oc dtr

TheOP d fn sC udt'a lthes o n (u no c ro n o temaeo fmaeg ntl,
e e i i ' s i j h wig h ma r a to ) f h l r e l e i s
n y
g
a
pubi a ea f m a e br as w ih l s t a f ly o que c rng oft a eol ,orm a e o f m a e
c r , e l e t t e s han u l pa
ove i
he r a
l re l

3OP 80 1as per t t re n books t l ma i s onene pa r a a unlmie ntmbe of
2 lo mis hite
gazne ,
ws pe , nd n i td l r
, weve
clppi ,phot a ,l ldoc nt,a ot rpa rpr t s l ast y al c n beso e pr l
i ngs
ogrphs ega ume s nd he pe oducs o ong he 1 a
tr d opery.

butoc wih l s t n af l opaq c rng oft anus' The OP e m pt S t il tai
t ks t e s ha u l
ue ove i
he
.
'
xe s ç y lusr tve
nudi

o me ia, d ain lo a t rpoo ia c n e t.'
f dc le uc to a, r n h o lg c l o tn g '
j
St f s ul not'lo a i t t r c i apublcai n i i c n betr as bl
a f ho d
al w n nma e o e e ve
i to f t a
te ona y
doc nt d't c an inudiy'ori i vi aesot rc ie i Theot rc e i i l .
ume e ' o ont i t t ' f t olt he rt ra.
he dtra ncude'
ç mpha i sexplctorgr phi a de c i orde c i i ofs xua a t' s i t orpr
ç
e
sze
ii
a c l pitons
s rptons e l c sd; olcis
omot s
e
a tviy i vi ai n off de a orsa el w 5 cont i i t c i orilor tont ti ia e
c i t n ol to
e r l tt a ,
. ans nsnztons rf mai ha mplc t s
prs s c iy6 emphasz st de c i orpr
ion e urt ;
i e he piton
omoton ofvi e , dior r orc i nala tviy
i
ol.
nce s de , rmi c i t

i vi a i off de a orsae lwso t prs ' dicplna y r a i V hasco e t t
n olton e r l t t a r he ion s s i i r egultons ;
nt nt ha
ç oul bede rm e a't a i t sr ha lt ton;hasga -e a e c e ;i wrte i c
G d
c
ti nt l' o n nma e' e bii>i
ng r l t d ont nt s itn n ode
oralngua o he t n Engls orSpa s unl sobt ne fom a a ove ve r ori
a
ge t r ha
ih
nih es ai d r n ppr d ndo ; s
l r rt n e e n i he by f t n i he .
a ge ha l ve nc s
ouree nc s

M aera sr ei d a aprs a ec ke agans t PRC' Dia ovedPublc tons
t il ec ve t ion r hec d i t he
S s ppr
ia i
Lit whi h i a ia et i a e a sa f I t ma e i i ar a on t ls,sa fs ndsa
s, c s val bl o nm t s nd t f . f he t ral s le dy
he it t f e
N otfc ton ofPRC Dia ovalFo t t i aei t adofs ndi t ale dia ove
ii a i
s ppr
nn o he nm t nse
e ng he r ady- s ppr d
tte TheDia o lFor i br t i t oft tte, hea ho o is numbe , heda e
il .
s ppr va
m nf ms he nma e he il t ut r r s ue
rt
t
ofr cept a a c c m a k ne t t a i bl d s ppr lc ie i fom OP 80 2.The
e i , nd he k r xt o he pplca e i a ova rt ra r
3.
Dia ovalFonn f phot r phsi or t i t oft s nde a age r lr as n oft
s ppr
or
og a
nf ms he nma e he e r nd
ne a e o
he

4Ex mplsicu ea ta sx a itr o re ia maeo jc p nerto ; e rto o b dl fud o
a e n ld cu l e u lnec u s;n ni t be t e tain s cein f o i lis r
y
s tnce i t c e ofs la tviyora ous l bondageorvi e a t i t c e ofs xua a tviy or
ubsa s n he ontxt exua c i t
r a;
olnt cs n he ontxt e l ci t
a ous ;anys
r al
exuala ti vi ai off de a orsaelw;a a mani aton ofge tlaorbutoc .TheOP
c n olton e r l tt a nd ny
pul i
niai
t ks
nots howeve ,t tt eexa ess dnotpr cl publc tonsSge alyr ogni asha ng a tsi or
e,
r ha hes mpl houl
e ude
ia i ' ner l ec zed
vi ritc
lt ar val 'or' s rbes
ier y ue' < c i exuala t i t c e ofasor ormor lt c ng unls t des rpto ofs h a t
de
cs n he ontxt
ty
a ea hi
e s he c i in uc cs
i t prma ypur eoft publc ton.
s he i r pos he
ia i '
'
SExa lsi l t a eors xuale oiain ofc l enornudede ci ofc lr n i t c e
mp e ncude he bus
e
xpl tto
hidr
pitons hid e n he ontxt
ofs xuala tviy.
e
ci t
6Exa lsi l es pet l que ma ordie i t tpos as curt tlea;we po o
mp e ncude ca ecmi s; ps r ctons ha e e iy lr t a ns r
i eme sofdesr ton;t c corosve,orilgals t es tc ca deal ofs cu iyorco
mpl nt
tuci oxi, r i
le ubsanc ; e hni l tis e rt
mmuniai
c ton
de ce saf tani manual;o t abiiyt physcal ha m ot r
vi s; t f r i ng
s r he lt o
i ly r hes.
1Agai ,t OP e m pt publcainstge r ly r c ze a havi a tsi orltr r vaue'o des rbes
n he
xe s
i to f ne al e ogni d s ng ritc ie ay l ' r c i
vi e çnt co extofasor o mor lt c ng unls t de crpton ofs h a t i t prma ypur eoft
olnce s he nt
i
t y r a ea hi
e s he s i i
uc cs s he i r
pos
he
publc ton.'
ia i '

4

vi a i s h ast t ' The i t m a a ala diappr d publc ton t r h t
olton, uc
t y.
nudi '
nma e y ppe
s ove
ia i h oug he

Ofe rGre nc Pr dur wihi s ve daysoft m i tnnotfc ton o t de ii
f nde i va e oce e t n e n
he te
i a i f he c son.
I t m aera i notale o t Dia ove Publc i Lit sa fs d f wa d
f he t il s
r ady n he s ppr d
iatons s, t f houl or z
ç s i b1 ma e i l't t t ee me be PRC. PRC me be sr viw m ae il f
û tona e t ra' o he hr - m r
que
8
m r e e
tra s or

c mpla c wi OPs a dt ermao iyv t d tr n swh t rs meh n i a p o e o
o in e t
h , n h i j rt o e ee mie ehe o ti g s p r v d r
dia oved.9 The PRc a adia ovedpublcai sttet t Dia ove Publc to
s ppr
dds s ppr
i ton' il o he s ppr d
i ai ns
Liti a poti ofi co ansdia o d c e .
s f ny ton t nt i s ppr ve ont nt

Pl ntf c
ai if ompli t tt Dia ova For doe no s cl ly i n iyt
a ns ha he s ppr l m
s t pe ika l de tf he

o j cin b ec n e t isl c to , rh w t eie i p o i ie b OP 8 3. Pli tf b l ve
b e to a l o tn ,t o ain o o h tm s r h btd y
0 2. anif ei s
e

t a OP 8 32s udrq iesa f os w t o j cin bemae il ot imaef rt
h t 0 . ho l e u r tf t ho he be to a l tra t he n t o he
i t si pe ton i i woul no bea trevoc bl t e t' ope og c goa s Pl h if
nma e' ns c i f t
d t n t r a e hr a 't nol i al l . aitf
i
.

.

'
:

y
,

.

.

.

e ai t two d de ope m or tu ti sa fi alo d i i pe tt dia ove
xpl ns ha ul vel d e r s n t f f l we o ns c he s ppr d
.

r at ral . 1
n ei s 0

Pl i ifi ups tt tt PRC dia o dt book Suc s f lGl mourPhot phy f r
antf s e ha he
s ppr ve he
ce s u a
ora
o
de c i ç t 'de pieisal ge e
pitng ç y' s t t le d ducai na val Pl i ife anst tt boo
nudi
to l ue. antf xpl i ha he k

l r vd satcmia, c d mi p t t s c e si p o e so a gn u p t g a h gy
i o ie e l c la a e c ah o u c s n r fs in l lmo r hoo rp y b q
p
c v rng. . n r sa dteru e fl a ddgtl e h q e ,ih i , tr , oss gn )
o ei . c me a n h i s , i n iia tc niu s lg tng sl s p e , a d
m
e
wor ng wih m ode sa age i s' Pli ifs yst book ç elbr t st be ut ofw o e
ki
t
l nd nc e .' a ntf a he
ç e a e he a y
c
m n
a i notlwd orde ogaor t wa dst m,'a t thewa st bookt l n nhow t i e
nd s
e
r t y o r he ' nd ha
nt he
o er
o, nt r
a i ,phot r ph m ode s a dn s s i di tes a s r am que ns Pl i ifi f t rups tt t
la
og a
l s m el n s r s nd c e
e . a ntf s urhe
e ha
he di no r c ve Suc e s ulG l m olrPho ogr phy e n t
d t e ei
csf
n z
t a
ve hough t Se lofV i gi a s s a
he a
r ni how n

8Theonl e pton i f quesi bl is sofPrs Legal e s whi a es ntdie tyt t Chifof
y xce i s or
tona e s ue
ion
N w , ch r e r cl o he e
co r tonsope ai .
reci
r tons
9HOweve ,t vo oc Diecora t Chi ofCo r tonsOpe ai mayvet aPRC de so .
r he
r t nd he ef
reci
r tons
o
ciin
1 cur en polc doe no a horzes an i pe i .
0 r t iy s t ut i uch ns cton

e
xpos br s,t Bi ei a ia edes t isde c i i ofs la tviy, R-ae
ed ea t he bl s val bl pie t s rptons exua c i t and r td
m oviswih s xual e i i c e a ebr dc tt i aes Pl ntf c l st tt
e t e ly xplct ontnt r oa as o nm t . ai if oncude ha he

VDOC ç ici n tl , u j ciey a dabta i 'd ne hm p s e so o a ie wi
ç s rmiaey s b e tv l , n r irrl ' e id i o s sin f n tm t
d
y
h
s
exualcont .
ent
111.

Bohp risfldmoinsf rf l o pa t l l r u g n , ndDe e d n sa g e
t a t ie to o ul r ri sl yj d me ta
e
a mma
fn a t r u ,
i e ai ,t tt y a e e il d t qualfe i lniy i t i i vi ua ca cii s A pr ctca
ntr la ha he r ntte o
ii d mm l t n her ndi d l pa te .
a i l
r s f qua i i uniy i t çde iet e ur t ti ubsa ilca msa i t
ea on or lûed mm t s he ç sr o ns e ha ns t nta li ga ns
5
555
g ven n o icas( l bers le p irt ds o e y'1 Pe ro v. lahan, U S 2 3
o r me t f il wil e ov d ro o ic v r . 1 as n Ca l
)
.2,
.

2 ( 0 9 (n e lq oainmak o te ) TheS p e Co r ha ie e tdy . . te s d
31 2 0 ) itma u tto r s mitd .
u r me u t s i p ae l . srs e
r
t i
he mpora eofr s vi i miy que to a t e ri tpos i e sa i ltga i 'l a
tnc
e ol ng mmt t
s ins t he a les sbl t ge n ii tom' d. t

2 2(n e wl u tto mak o te ) Co s q e ty Ia j iaeDe e d n s rq e t o
3 itn q o ain r s mitd . n e u n l, dudc t f n a t' e u s f r
q ai e i miybeo ea j dc t t eo fca c pa iycams
u lf d mmt t f r du iai h fiil a ct li .
i
ng
A.

A pa t i e tt dt s mmayj d me ti t ep e dn s teds l sdmaeil o fl,
ry s nil o u r u g n f h la ig ,h ico e tras n ie
e
a a a sdaviss
nd ny f
t how t tt r i no ge nediput a t a m ae ilf c .Fed. Ci P.
ha he e s
nui s e s o ny t ra a t
R. v.

5 () s eW iln v. ifn 9 2F.d 8 , 23( t Ci. 9 )(e o nzn ap ryi e tte
6 a ; e l ms Gyfi, 5 2 20 8 4 h r 1 91 rc g ii g a t s nild
i
t s mmayj dg n i t rc r a awhoec u dn t e darto a tiro fc t fndi
o u r u me t f he e o d s
l o l o la ain lre f a t o i n
fv ro t en n mo n) ç ae il a t'aeto ef csn c sa yt e tbiht ee n so
a o f h o - va t. ç tra f cs' r h s a t e e sr o sa l he lme t f
M
s
ap ry' c u eo a to .An es n v Lie t Lo b . n .47 U.. 4 , 4 ( 9 6 .A
a t s a s f ci n d ro . b ry b y I c, 7 S 2 2 2 8 1 8 )
ge nediput ofma e i lf te ssi,i viwi t r c d a a1r a ona ei e e es
nui
s e
t ra ac xit f n e ng he e or nd l e s bl nf r nc
dr wn t r fom i alghtm os f vor bl t t non- o ngpa t ar as bl f tfnde
a he e r n i
t a a e o he
m vi
ry, r ona e acr
1 Thecot thadale gr ntd apr e i or rt Defndant bas on t i a s ri ofq lfe
1
l
r
r ady a e
otctve de o e
s ed her s e ton uaiid
i uniy.
mm t

c dr t navedi f t nonoul eur
r ct or he movant J= Themovi pa t hast bur nofs ng. #.
ng ry he de
howi
ç ha i, ntng o t t dititc rt t tt r i a a e eofe de et s
G t s poi i ut o he src ou - ha he e s n bs nc
t
vi nc o uppor t
the

n n vn p y sc s . Ceo e Co . Cart 4 7U. 31 , 2 ( 98 ) l temo a t
o mo ig m ' a e' ltx p v. tet 7 S. 7 3 5 1 6 . f h v n
'
s ts t sbtr n,t n t no m ova m us s tf t s cii f c jt tde onsr t t
a ifes hi lde he he nnt t e orh pe fc a t ha m ta e he

e senc ofage nediput offc frtil J. a 3 24.A c u'ma no rs vediputd
xit e
nui s e a t o ra. . t 22I
L
ot t y t e ol s e
f c s we g t e de e, m a de e mi tonsofc e biiy. Rus el v. ir yneCom . 65
a t, i h he vi nc or ke t r na i
r di lt
s l M c od
,

F.d 1 29 1 9(t Ci.1 9 ) So e e v. u p y 7 7F.d 1 9, 8 (t Ci. 9 6 .I se d
3 2 , 23 4 h r 9 5 ; s b e M r h , 9 2 7 1 2 4 h r 1 8 ) n ta ,
ac ta ce sast et e de e o t non- o ngpa t and r s ve al i e nalc lc s
our c pt
nz he vi nc f he
m vi
ry
e ol s l nt r onfi t
a i e e esi t nonnd nf r nc n he
movi pa t sf vor Cha bonna sdeFr nc v.Sm ih,597F.
ng ry' a . r
ge
a e
t
2d

4 6 41 ( t Ci.1 7 )
0 , 4 4h r 9 9 .
B.

Quaii i miypr t t go r ntofiil fom ci lda ge i aj 1 aci
lted mmt t oecs venme fcas r vi ma s n
983 ton
ç ns f a t rc
ç o ar s hei onduc doesnotvi aeclary e tbls d sa uor orco tt tona rght of
i
t
olt e l sa ihe tt t y
nsiu i l i s

wlih ar a o a epes nwo l h v k o 'Halw v Fi g r l, 5 U. 8 0 8 8( 9 2 ;
l
c e s n bl r o u d a e n wm' ro . t ead 4 7 S. 0 , 1 1 8 )
z
s eJ n sv. c n n, 2 F.d 5 0, 31(t Ci. 0 3 ( e lrngt a t eç uaiidi nt
e o e Bu ha a 3 5 3 2 5 4 h r 2 0 ) d cai h t h ç lfe mmu iy
q
o e ae t e s r t t e o e(u lco ûcas a es b e tdt as i, fiesaeo noiet er
p r ts o n u e ha b fr p bi f il) r u j ce o ut o fc r r n tc h i
c
onduc i unlwf . (ntr lquotsa cttonsomit l.Quaii i l t ç sno
t s a ul' i ena
'
e nd iai
ted)
lfed mmlniy ç
ha

a pl aint s isf rd ca ao yo ij n tv r le. u hCao iaS aeBd. fDe tsr v
p i to o ut o e lrtr r nu cie eif' t r ln tt o n ity .
c
'So
F. C.45 F.d4 6 4 - (t Ci. 0 2 .
T. , 5 3 3 , 4647 4 h r 2 0 )
Fe r lc t m a c i rt que tonst r ol qua ii i miy.Oneque ton
de a ours y onsde wo si o es ve lfed mmt t
si

i l eh r tk ni telg tmo t a r bet t ep rya s ri gt eij r ,hefcsalg d
s t t e, a e n h ih s fvoa l o h a t se t h nu y t a t l e
wh
n
e
s
how t tt ofi e ' conduc vi a e aconsiutona rght' Odom v.Sout Ca olnaDe t
ha he fc r s
t olt d
tt i l i .
'
h r i
p'.

o Cor, 49F.d7 5, 9(t Ci. 0 3 (n en l u tsa d ctto o te ) Th oh r
f r.3 3 6 76 4 h r 2 0 ) itr a q oe n iains mitd . e t e

@

quesi i whehe ,a t tme oft cli e vi a i t rgh wa çce l e tbls d i t
ton s
t r t he i
he am d olton, he i t s tlary sa ihe n he
s c tccon e oft c e. I A ç otl m a add e st s t que to i t or r... ha
pe is
t xt he as ' d. ç lt y r s he e wo si ns n he de
'
c '
t t
wilbe tf iia et f ra ef i ntdiposton ofe h c e. Esa eofAr ton:v. l.of
l s acltt he ai nd sc e s ii
ac as ' tt
'
msr
Vil

Pie t s, ôF.d8 2 8 8( t Ci. 6 .
n hl t 81 3 9 , 9 4h r 201 )
r
Quai i
lfed mmuniys edsa ofii i t algedvi ae rg wa no ce ry
t hil n fcalf he le
oltd iht s t lal
esa ihe a t tme oft i i nt J ,325 F. a 5 527.Cl a l e t bls d me ns
t bls d t he i
he nc de . ones
3d t 26e ry sa ihe
a

ç th u lwf l s o t a to mus beq p rnt e a s sq fo t p rpe tv o a
t q e na une s f he cin t p a e wh n se s d r m he es cie f n
l
o j cieyra o a l o fca c a g dwi k o e g o etbl h dlm ' Lo e v. bn o ,
b e tv l e s n be fiil h r e t n wld e f sa i e a ' p z Ro is n
h
s
9 4F.d48 , 9 (t Ci. 9 0 .ç i i n t osyt ta ofca a to i p oe tdb
1 2 6 48 4 h r 1 9 ) Th s s o t a ha n fiil cin s r tce y
q lfe i
uaii d mmuniy t e st ve y a ton i que to ha pr vi l bee he d t a ul...
t ml s he r ci n si n s e ousy n l mlwf
but
i i t s y t ti t ' g ofpr - xitng1 w t lnl wf ne sm us bea e . Ande s v.
t s o a ha ' hel ht
n
i
e e si a he ' a ul s
t ppar nt'
'
r on

Cr ih o 48 U. 6 5 6 ( 9 7 . A rg tma b ç lal etb ihe 'i aS e rl
eg tn, 3 S. 3 , 40 1 8 )
ih y e l e ry sa ls d'f : nea
c
g

c n tt to a r l aral le tfe i t ed cso a 1w . . p g s Wi o viu ca i t
o siui n l ue le è d' i d n h e iin la . a pll q t b o d lrt ù
y n i
e h
y
t es e ii c n u ti q sin, v nto g t v r a t ni q eto ha ( t p e i u l
h p cfc o d c n ueto e e h u h he ey ci n u sin s noj rv o sy
o
be nhedt a u . Untd S ae v. nir 5 0U. 25 , ( 9 7 (iainso te )
e l mlwf l' ie tts La e , 2 S. 9 271 1 9 ) ctto mitd .
'
Clary esabls d lw f t sc er f st de sonsoft Su e eCour oft Unie
e l t ihe a or hi as e er o cii
he pr m
t he td
St t s t Cour ofAppe l f t Fo t Cic t a t Supr me Cour ofVigila.Edwa ds
a e , he
t
a s or he urh r ui, nd he
e
t
r zi
r

v. t o Go d b r 1 F.d2 , 1( t Ci.1 9 )
Ciy f l s o o, 78 3 31 25 4h r 9 9 .
'
C.

I a e c e r y r t n pr e tons a f de by t Fi s Am e ent butt s rght m us
nm t s l a l e ai ot c i
f or d
he r t
ndm ,
he e i s
t

beba a edwih prs
l nc
t ions'i tt i lne dsofs cliy, s i i a ge r a i sr ton.
nsiutona e
e trt di cplne, nd ne al dm nita i

O' n v EsaeofS b z , 8 U. 3 2, 4 (9 7 .Th ,& prs nr g lto t a a rd e
Lo e . tt
ha a z 4 2 S. 4 3 9 1 8 ) us G io e u ain h t b ig s
a
i aes co tmtona rght i ç ld i i i r as na y r l t t l gii t pe l c
nm t ' nsi i l i s s va i f t s e o bl e aed o e tma e no ogial

8

itrss''Lo lc v. e 47 F.d 1 4 1 9 (t Ci. 0 6 (ii Tu n rv Saly, 2U.
n eet.' vea e Le , 2 3 7 , 9 4h r 2 0 ) ctng r e . fe 48 S.
7 , 4( 9 7 ) W h te arguain i ra o a l r ltdd pe d o
8 8 1 8 ). eh r e lto s e s n by eae e n s n:
() E l t r t r i a ç ld rto a c n e to ' bewe n t p io
1 W hehe hee s l i , ain l o n cin' t e he rs n
va
r gulto oraci a t i e e tas e td by t go r nt orwhehe
e ain
ton nd he nt r s s re
he ve nme ,
t r

t i i tr s i ç or mo ea t rn e t epoiy abtay o irto a' ()
h s nee t s t e t s o e d r h l r irr r rain l; 2
s
c
'
whe he ç t na i m e ns ofe r ii t rg ..r mai ope t prs n
t r s er tve a
al
xe csng he i ht . e n n o io

imae l' . ;()wh ti a tt d srd a c mmo ain wo l h v o
n tsq' . 3 a mp c he e ie c o d to
.
ud a e n
s cliysa f i mae , n t eal c to o p io rs u c s a d ()wheh r
e t t tf, n ts a d h lo ain f rs n e o re ; n 4
r
te
t r e s a çobvi ,e y ale nai ' t t c le d r gulton o
he e xit ny i ous as t r tves' o he ha lnge e a i r

a to whih ma s g e tt a i i ç o ra o a e b t i E ta j a
cin, c
y u g s h t t s ç t e s n bl, u s i e d n
n
ns
e gge a e r pons t prs c
xa r t d es
e o i on once ns
r .

,

1 . t 0(i n Tu n r 4 2U. a 8 - 2 .Th p io rh st eb r e t d s r v t ev ldt
d a 20 ct g r e , 8 S. t 9 9 ) e rs ne a h u d n o ip o e h aii
i
y
ofaprs r ulton pur ua t t Tur ra l i Ove t v. zz ta,539U . 1 1
ion eg a i
s nt o he ne nayss.
ron Ba e t
S. 26, 32

(0 3.
20)
IV .

De e nt a e e il d t qualfe i uniyf t fr tca m a
f nda s r ntte o
i d mm t or he is li boutmodii d orat r
fe
le ed
pr ry ordia l d s xual e i i c
ope t
s lowe e ly-xplct ommuni a i unde OP 8 1.To sae ac us o
c tons
r
02.
tt a e f

a to un e j. 8 , plitf mu tetb iht a heh sb e d prv do rg t g aa te b
cin d r 1 3 a an if s sa ls h t a e n e ie f ihs u rn e d y
9
t Consiu i n a t tt sde i ton r s t d fom cond tco mit by ape s a tng
he
tt to nd ha hi prva i e ule '
r
uc m ted
r on c i

u d rc lro saelw.W etv At s 4 7U. 4 ( 9 8 .A plitf mus afr tv l
n e oo f tt a
s . l , 8 S. 2 1 8 )
dn
an if t fimai ey
aleget tanamed de e ntwa pe s ly i ved i t al ge vi a i ofaf r lrgh .
l ha
f nda
s r onal nvol n he le d olton
ede a i t

S e e:.Tnzo kv. e h 2 5F.d3 , 2 (t Ci. 0 )( oi gt a l blt i acvi
e . . , l c Fre , 7 3 91 40 4 h r 2 01 n tn h t i i y n i l
a i
rg t c s i ç ro a, a e u o e c d f n a tso c n ttto l ilto s).
ih s a e s ç s n l b s d p n a h e e d n ' wn o siuina vo ai n '
pe
Res
ponde ts rori notas fce bassf la lt vi j1
a upe i s
ufiint i or ibiiy a 983. Se e:.M o lv. p' of
es . , nel De t

S c S r s, 3 U. . 5 , 9 ( 9 8 .
o . e v .4 6 S 6 8 6 4 1 7 )
Pl i ifa l st tbr ke he pho sr pa r d w ih Sc c t pe s a sw ih t n
a ntf lege ha o n ad ne e i e t ot h a , ne ker t or

i rlni a publca i wih mi sngpage we e c ic t f o hi a c ta nd t de
nne i ng, nd
i tons t s i
s r onfs a ed r m m s on r ba m r

8 1be us t y we e de m e modil d ora tr d. Pl i ifa s pa sngl a lgest tOP
02. ca e he
r e d
fe
le e
antf l o s i y le ha
802. i unl wf be us i pr biss xual e i i c
1 s a ul ca e t ohi t e ly-xplct omm l c tons
l ai .
ni
Pl ntf doe notesa ih t ta de e ntpe s ly c
ai if s
t bls ha ny f nda
r ona l onûs t t s ie sor
caed he e t m

ba r d Pli ifst pe te s ly- xplctc
r e antf ms cii d exua l e i i ommlni tonst rOP 802. . Furhe
l cai mde
1
t nnor
e,
none oft def nda s a ac e nc oft i ad i sr tver es had ar e i l tng o
he e nt , s ons que e her m nitai ol ,
ol n ocai r
1

.

co ic tng Pl ntf spr pe t t tdi no c
nfs a i
ai if o ry ha d t ompl wih OP 80 1.M or over Pli ifdoesnot
y t
2.
e , antf
de c i whe o whe et pr rywasconfs a e a wha pr e s i a a tnde t
s rbe
n r
r he ope t
i c t d nd
t oc s , f ny, te d he
co i c ton. Ac r ngl De e nt a ee il d t qualfed i
nfs a i
co di y, f nda s r ntte o
ii mmuniy i t i i vi ua
t n he r ndi d l
c pac te c
a ii s once i OP 802.
m ng
1.

Ther m ani t e cli sc e n OP 803. Spe ii a l Robi on alege y vi a e
e i ng hr e am onc r
2. cfc ly,
ns
l dl olt d
I

.

.

.
'

ieFisAme le tb a toigUP8 32t jo iisk,l e piic mmuncto a d
h rt nd n y uh rn . 0 . o rhbt e u l x lct o
ày
iains n
vi a edt Fouree h Am e
olt he
t nt
ndme be us OP 80 2' no i epr so i t va t
nt ca e
3. s tc ovii n s oo gue o
:

l
a

c tm t lga l ade t notc
onsi e e ly qua e ie. Alo, c Ra lfe W al r a Bic
s Ea ho, tif - ke , nd r khea al gedl
d le y
vi aedt Fis Am e
ol t he r t
ndmentby a yi OP 8 2 t pr bi Pl i ifspos es i of
ppl ng
03. o ohi t antf'
s son

Si es f lGl l Phot r phy. lc udet tDe e nt a e e ttedt qua i d i miy
wc s u amotr
og a
oncl ha f nda s r n il o lfe mmt t
be aus t rc
c e hei onductdi no vi ae ac e ry e t bls drghtofwhih ar s bl pe s i
d t ol t l a l sa ihe i
c ea ona e r on n
de e an s postonswoul ha lnown.
f nd t ' ii
d ve c
Pli ifa knowl st tSucc s ulGlm o Phot a wa dial w e f r
antf c
edge ha
es f
n ur
or phv s s lo d o
c ai ng G t ' defne i OP 803. The ke vo d i t tte oft book i t nm our'
ont ni ç
nudiy' as
dn
2.
n r n he il
he
sG
gl
,'

whih com o e e otcpho osofet rnudeors a iy d e s d m ode s Ti a a i c t
c r ts r i
t
ihe
c ntl r s e
l . me nd gan, ours

1 Pl ntf alo i
2 ai if s nvoke t DuePr es Clus oft Fit Ame
s he
oc s a e he fh
ndme butt tclus a ist t
nt
ha a e pple o he

fd rl o e me tn tot sae.Se . ..Due b r v UntdSae , 3 U. l ,1 7( 0 )(Th Du
e ea g v nz n, o t he tts e eg, s n ev . ie tts 5 4 S. 61 6 20 2 $ e e
Pr es Cl eoft Fit Am e e pr bist Unie Stt s a t DuePr es Clus oft Fouree h
oc s aus
he fh
ndm nt ohi t he td a e , s he
oc s a e he
t nt

Ame d n prhbt teSae , m d p iiga ypes no p o et wi u C u p o eso 1w.)
n me t o ii h tts 9o e rvn n ro f r p ry t tç e r c s fa '.
s
ho d
'

ha uphe d c r c i lofi i s polcist tha ba e f 1 font nudiy i publc tons
ve
l ore tona fcal' i e ha ve n'd ' 1 r al t n
u
iai
a rvi a c r tona f c ltes
r i ng t or ec i l a iii .

A s v y of c e lw on t i s ofprs r gultons o s xua l t med
ur e
as a
he s ue
ion e a i
n e ly he
m a e i s pl i y de
t ral anl monsr t s t t not t t ndi a prvae c tze s Fis
ta e ha , wihsa ng
i t ii n' r t
Am e
ndme rg t pos e s wha c n be g ne a l c t gorz d as Sa t
nt i ht o
ss
t a
e r ly a e i e
tdul

pono r p y' p io a d j i a miitao s c n c nsi to al r src
r g a h y rs n n al d n srt r a o t u in ly etit
'
t
p'r a
o nogr phy a sm ia ç e ly e i t'm ii a phot m a . Se
nd i lr t xua l xplci' tngs nd
s
o phs
em

ec,Baln om 3 6 F.d a 9 6 ( p od n a c nsi in la Or g n
.. l mp t 5 3 t 7 u h li g s o tmto a n e o
r
De t e ofCoreci nsr ulton t tpr bied i aesfom r cevi
parm nt
r to eg a i ha ohi t nm t r
e i ng
publc tonst tc ai d i a porr yi a t lo sm ult d s xuala t
i ai
ha ont ne m ges ta ng c ua r i a e e
cs

o s x a c n a t b tta p nn te n d i g s; o e v. atLa eCo n y
r e u l o tc, u h t e itd u e ma e) J n s S l k u t ,
5 3F.d 1 47 1 5 - 6( 0hCi. 0 7 (p liga c nsi to a ac u t
0 3 1 , 1 5 5 1 t r 2 0 ) u hodn s o tt in l o n y
u
j i' b n o ' e u l e pii maeil ta icu e a b n o p t g a h
als a n ç x al x l t tra' h t n ld d a n hoo rp s
s
y
c
'
of e
xpos d ç e t a ge t l' bu di no e e t t e ly e ii
e ç ass nd nias' t d t xtnd o s xual xplct
br
s

p o eo pcu e o coh d wo nme ' Ast fd r lp io f clte ,he
r s r it r s f l te me / n). o e e a rs n a ii s t
i
Fe ea Bura o P io s(%OP' a pisa saue p s e b Co g e si
d r l e u f rs n ç ' p l
)
e tt t a s d y n r s n
1
996 known as t iE i Ame e ,'whi h pr l
he thsgn
l
ndm nt'
c ecudes f r prs
ede al ions

fo diti i or m a ng a ia e t prs r G ny c
r
' m srbutng
ki
va lbl o ioné s :
a
omm e c al
r i ly
publs i or ton orm aera t ti s xual e ii o f tlesnudiy.
ihed nf ma i
t il ha s e ly xplc t r eatr
t '
'

2 U. C.j5 0 b () çn r s ns t t eEn i n Ame d n , h BOP
8 S.
3 C() 6 . i epo e o h sg
l
n me t t e
pr
omul t an i e ntng r gulton t tna r wst s o oft saut
gaed
mpl me i e a i ha r o he c pe he t t e
by de ng ke sa t or t r ,'a i e r t t Ensgn Ame m e a
sni
y t tz y e ms' nd ntp es he
t
i
nd nt s
a yi onl t pi t i lr pr s nttons J r n v.Sos ,654 F. 1 2,
ppl ng y o cora e e e a i . o da
a
3d 01

1 6 1 ( 0h Ci. 1 )(iig2 C. R.j5 07 ) S c r g lto d ln s
01 - 7 1 t r 20 1 ctn 8 F.
4 .2 . u h e uain e e
I t ' a ç pi t i l de c i whe e ge t la or f m a e br as s a e
&
nudiy' s G c or a pi ton
a
r
nia i
e l e t r
e
xpos 'a de sGs xual e ii' a ç pit i de c i o a t lor
ed, nd fne te ly xplct' s ç coral piton f c ua
'
a
s m ul t d s xua a t ' l ng s xuali e co s or ls x,o m as r t o '
i a e e l c s i udi e
nc
nt r ur e, a e r
m ba i m '

28C. R. 5 07 (9. dto al,h rg lto d fne çe t rs'a u e
F. j 4 .2 1 Ad iin ly te e u ai n ei s û au e , s s d
f
'
i t Epsgn Ame m e ,t m e n t tt t ia i n c t ns de ctons
n he
i
nd nt o a ha he t c to on ai
publ
pi i
ofnudiy ors xualy e i tco uc on ar i orr ulrbassorpr o e
t
e l xplci nd t
outne eg a
i
om t s
is l ba e upo s h de c i i t c s ofi vi
t ef s d
n uc pitons n he a e ndi dualone-i is s'
tme s ue y'

a i ld sa e e to f r'p u lc to sc n anign i ilsrtv o
nd ncu e n xc p in o ç j biain o ti n uds l taie f
l
y u
medi l e a i na ,or a t opol c lc e . I ;s Ama e v.Re
ca, duc to l
n hr ogi a ont nt' d. ee
'
tl
no,

1 6 F.3 1 2, 2,3 2 U. Ap D. 1 ( C.Ci.1 9 )( di Gha
5
d 9 20 3 S. p. C. 91 D. r 9 8 fn ng ç t
t
t g in Ame d n)a d r g lto stsy g u n rv. S fe sd ma d
he Ensg
n me t n e u ain aif - r e ) aly' e n
f
f r a onablnes,s o i a quatl o a1f fco s). Thec rntyi
or e s
e s c rng de ey n 1 our a tr'
ure l n
f c BO P t og a St t m e ' gove ni ç ncom i Publca i ' f r he
pr e
t r m a e nt'
pr
r ng G
l
ng
i tons' ' t r
u
dic s s BOP r quieme s notng t t a wa de mus c i r e h
s us e
e r nt , i ha
r n
t onsde ac

p biain o a is - y is b ss b f r i i rj ce ,a p o ie
u lc to n n sueb -sue a i e o e t s ee td nd r vd s
e
xnmpls pfpublcai t t ae ge rly alowed,s h a :()Naina
e
i tons ha r neal l
uc s 1 to l
Ge g a li,e n i i c nan n i a d () ç po t Ilsrtd s ms t
o rplc ve f t o tis udt n 2 G rs lu tae wi ui
y;
s
i s s 'a t i ere ca a ogs ' unl s t y c a n nudiy. BOP Pr r m
s ue ' nd t ng i t l y
' es he ont i
t
og a
Stt m e 5 11 Nov. 9, 2011 a ia e a htp: ww m bop. v/
a e nt 266. ,
, val bl t t /
/
go
polc pr t tsz66 01lpdf
iy/ ogsa/
. .

Prs n Le N e v.St l No. 1 v424,201 U. Dit LEXI 43228,a *1 1 201 W L
io cal ws
ole, 2: 3c
5 S. s .
S
t 3- 5, 5

1 8 9 , t* ( D. . a. , 01 )(o to e o te a atrto si o ii l.
4 71 0 a 5 E. Va M r 31 2 5 f on ts mitd nd leai n n rgna)
I 1
n 989,t Supr me Cou the dt tt D lne ' r a ona e s sa r m us be
he
e
r l ha he r rs e s bl ne s t nda d
t
a id t c r tona of i s r gul to ofpublc tons Thor gh v.
pple o oreci l scal' e ai ns
iai .
nbur
Abbot, U.
t490 S.

4 , 3( 9 9 .I Th r bu t eS p e Co r a fr dfd r l e u ainst a alwe
01 41 1 8 ) n o n txh,h u rme u t fime e ea rg lto h t l d
o
f de a prs r t s c i t publc tons butt Co ta s a l d prs a horte t
e r l ione s o ubs rbe o
i a i , he ur lo lowe ion ut iis o

rj c p bl ain d e dh r 'l os c rt ode, rds i ie d a 4 4.Therguain
ee t u i to s e me a mf t e u i r r o icpl .I . t 0
c
u
y,
n
e lto s
a s pr vi d pr dur pr t to ,i l ngnotcea i pe ntr vi w.
lo o de oce al o eci ns ncudi
i nd nde nde e e

He e Ro ns e t OP 803. t alow sa eprs i t r cevepublc tonsbutye
r , bi on naced
2 o l t t ione s o e i
iai
t
t e ur pu i a i do nothn m s c y,or r ordi cplne Ftrhe mo e Robi on e t d
o ns e blc tons
r e udt de ,
s i i . lt r r ,
ns nace
OP 803. wih t r quie ntt ta i a er ceveno i ofadia o d publc ton a
2 t he e r me ha n nm t e i
tce
s ppr ve
i a i nd
a
ppea t a i pe ntde ii m a r Si ia l Ea
l o n nde nde
cson ke . m l ry, cho,Ra lfe- ake ,a Bicc a
tif W l r nd r lhe d
de e ne t tSucc s f G l m ourPho ogr phy c a ned nud t a f c w li h i noti
t nni d ha
e s ul n
t a
ont i
iy, a t zc s
n

diput ,s scintt be de m e ha mf t s cziy,or r o dici i I woul no be
s e uf e o
e d r ul o e lrt de , r s plne. t
d t

a pae tt a o j ci l r a o a l ofca c z e wi k wld eo e tbih dlw t a
p rn o n b e t y e s n be fiil hag d t no e g f sa ls e a h t
ve
h
s hc
uc onduc woul bea r nty unl wf l
t
d
ppa e l
a u.
Alhough Pli tf pa sngl a lgesDe e an s'ç i r t i fe e e o t ci
t
a n if s i y le
f nd t ' be ae ndif r nc r a t
del
au horzai ' alege co tt tona de i tons hedoesnote t bls t tade e an ha
t i ton'of l d nsiu i l prva i ,
sa ih ha
f nd t d
acua orco tuci knowl
t l
nsr tve
edget tas di t wa e
ha ubor na e s ngage i co uc t tpos d 1a
d n nd t ha
e G

p r a iea du e s n bers ' fc n t uin ln u y S a v. to d,1 F.d7 , 9 ( t
e v sv n nra o a l ik'o o si t a ij r . h w Sr u 3 3 91 7 9 4h
t o
Ci.1 9 )(mp ssa d d .Tot ee e tPlitf s e st i o ep ro a la ii o
r 9 4 e ha i d e )
h xtn an if e k o mp s e s n liblt n
y
De e nt f neglg e, e po a s ror orr s
f nda s or i enc r s nde t upe i , e pondi t gre es hecn
ng o ivand ,
nnots c d
uc ee

hee.Se e2.Part v. yl ,451U. 5 538- ( 981,ovemze . i lva patky
r e. . , rat Ta or
S. 27, 39 1 )
ld t nee nt r
q

Da il v W iln , 7 U. 3 7 3 0 3 ( 9 6 ; o l, 6U. a 6 3n7 Esel v
nes . l ms 4 4 S. 2 , 3 - 1 1 8 ) M nel43 S. t 6 .; tl .
i
e
Gn l, 2 U. 9 1 4 ( 9 6 ; pa l v. y No 7 1 c 0 39 201 U. Dit LEM S
mb e 4 9 S. 7, 0 1 7 ) De oa Ra , . :2 v 01 , 3 S. s.
1 71 2 a * 3 2 3W L 4 51 3 , t* ( . Va J l 2 2 3 ( age tM .. (iig
1 8 , t 2 , 01
4 2 6 a 8 W D. . uy 2, 01 ) S r n, J) ctn
Br o sv Be r ,1 7F. p' 9 , 25( r Ci. 0 6)
o k . a d 6 Ap x 23 9 3d r 2 0 ).
I c uson,De e nt di no ta gr sb i lneswih OP 803. a ofi il a e
n oncl i
f nda s d t r ns es rght i
t
2, nd fca s r
notla ef l gu s i gr y a e ,'e n i De e nt 'de i i c dbede m e a
ibl or ç
bad es es n a r as' ve f f nda s c sons oul
e d s

s c S e eg, a irel v. u r 9 3F.d2 5 2 8(t Ci. 9 2 .Ac o dn l,
u h. e . ..M cailo S mne, 7 2 9 , 9 4 h r 1 9 ) c r igy
De e nt a e e il t qualfe i t t i t ri viua ca iisc e ni OP 8 2.
f nda s r ntted o
ii d mm miy n hei ndi d l pacte onc r ng
03.
VI
.

Pl ntf ha fld am oto t srke a f rpr s r a i Thi m oto c e nst
ai if s ie
i n o ti nd o e e v ton. s i n onc r he
s pe i è eai ori plm e a i o a s x- f rteam e pl n.Fis , ai ifa kst
us nson, r ton, m e ntton f e èfende r t nt a
r t Pl ntf s he

c t't srkea yme to b d fn a t o hm b ig s be tdt ate t n pa .Plitf
o uto ti n n in y e e' n s f i en u j ce o rame t ln anif
d
a gue t tnoke m e pln wa i efe twhe hec
r s ha
at nt a
s n fc
n
omm e dt saci n and t thewoul be
nce hi to
ha
d

p eu ie b c u et eei ag n i ds ut a t tevaiiyo t te t n p a i s d
rj d c d e a s h r s e une ip e s o h ldt f he rame t ln mpo e
afe t sa ton co m e ed.Sec
tr hi c i
m nc
ond,Pli ifas t c ur t or rde e an st pr e vea
antf ks he o t o de f nd t o es r ny
a a 1r co dsa
nd 1 e r boutt ne te t e pl n i e e ed o Aprl1 201 be us Pli if
he w r am nt a mplm nt n
i 4, 6, ca e antf
expe t t fl al ws tt c le et te t e pln asr t la i f flng t saci n.
c s o ie a ui o ha lng he r am nt a
e a iton or ii hi to

Howe r t s pe i ce ton,ori e nttonofate t ntpln i no acli i t s
ve ,he us nson, rai
mplme ai
rame a s t am n ht
a ton. Furhe mor Pl ntf o a gu e sr og z t tr c dsa
ci
t r e, ai ifs wn r m nt ec nie ha e or boutt te t ntpln
he r a me a
a enotpr tonalt t nee oft sc e.M or r t c rt ar ady hed o Oc obe
z
opori
o he ds hi as
eove , he ou had le
l n t r
1 201 t tunr l e i r e a
4, 6, ha
e at d nqui i s boutt s pe i c e ton, i pl m e a i ofa
he us ns on, r a i or m e nt ton

te t n pa wo dl ri ti ltg to ' n ç u dc u eu d ed ly a dprj iet e
rame t ln ul ç alh s i ain'a d i l a s n u ea n eudc h
de
i
wo
rg t o moj d fn a t t t i a to .'Co e u n l, anifi n te tte t r c r s
ih s f t ee d ns o hs cing ' nsq e ty Plitf s o n ild o e o d
j

a
boutt s pe i c e ton,ori e e a i ofate t ntpl i t sa to e pe i ly i
he us nson, r a i
mplm ntton
r a me ml n hi ci n, s c al n
lghtoft pr e tve o de ar ad g a t d t Def nda sbas o t i a s ri n ofq lfe
i
he ot c i r r le y r n e o e nt ed n he r s e to
uaii d
i uniy.Acc di y,t m oton t srkea f pr s r ton i de e
mm t
or ngl he
i o ti nd or e e va i s ni d.
VI .
l

F rt f r g igra o , fnd ns moi nf rs mmayj g n i g a tdi p r,
o he o e on e s ns Dee a t' to o u r ud me t s rne n a t
a dPli tf smoin frs mmayj g n i d ne i p r, st q lte i mi Th
n anif to o u r ud me t s e id n a ta o uai d mmt t e
i
y.
pa t s mo in f rml r u g n a t osca c pa iycamsa ed s se wih u
ri ' to s o mma yj d me t s o f il a ct li r imis d t o t
e
p eu ie a dt ep oe tveo d ri lfe .C. c o i s b tt tdfrd fn a tP M e e
rj d c , n h r tci r e s itd Ea h s u siue o ee d n RC mb r

Nu e 1 a Plitf smoinf ra j dc to sq e ea dmoint srk a dfr
mb r , nd an if to o d u iain e u nc n to o tie n o
pr s r a i a eDENI .Thi m a tri r f re t m e a i W hiet pa te s d
e e v ton r
ED
s te s e e r d o diton.
l he ri s houl
c
omm uni t i good f t a tdiço r t cou twilno e e t n motonsa
cae n
aih bou s ve y, he r l t nt rai
i
boutdicove y
s r

untlt mediton co l .
i he
a i ncudes
ENTER: '
T

U da ofM a c 201
y
r h, 7.

.*
y

(

.
,

''
'

f

.

Se i Unie SttsDititJ e
or td ae src udg