Clehm v. BAE Systems Ordinance Systems, Inc. et al

Filing 244

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 01/11/2019. (aab)

CLERK' OFFI U,s.Dl COURT
S
CE
sTL
AT ROANOKE,VA
FI
LED

I TH E U N I D STATE S D ISTRICT CO U RT
N
TE
FO R T H E W ESTE RN D ISTRI O F W R GI I
CT
N A
ROAN O U D I SI N
W O

J 11 2 1
AN
09
JUL .
I C. DL- CLERK
EY,

BY:

>
DEPUR CL-

CART, A.CLE H M
A
Pl ntf,
ai if

Ci lActon N o.7:6- vvi
i
1 c 00012

V.

BAE SYSTEM S O RD N AN CE
SYSTE M S,I C .MISLZ
N ,

By:H on.M i haelY.U t
c
bahsd
l

Chi f nie S a e Diti t udge
e U t d t t s srv J

.

D ef
endant
s.

M E M O RAN D U M O PI I N
N O
1.

Tlsmatri beor t c lt onPli fCal A. e m' (clhm' Mod t
l te s f e he o'f
i
'
nnif ra Clh s < e )
f
on o
Co rc teRe ot p s a tt Rue1 ()2 7)oft Fe ea Rulsof pelt
te t h c d uru n o l 0e()
he d rl e Ap l e
a
Pr dur ECF No.241 Thectumsa esgi ngts t t smodon a ea f l :On
oce e.
.
ic tnc vi ie o hi
r s olows

J ne2 , 01 Clhm f e aM e a d i Oppo i n t Dee da BAE S tmsI c'
u 9 2 7, e l d
l
mor n um n
sdo o f n nt
yse n .
s

(K AM o ftS mmayl g ntECFNo. 6 , tghi 6 e hbis Clhm fe
T
BAEA don o u r ud me ,
)
1 0 atc ng 5 x i t. e l d
l
a ECF N o.160- dicove y doc e spr
s
57, s r
um nt oduc byBAE wih Ba e s a psBAE 1
ed
t ts tm
7811783.
The docl e satac d a e l we e nott c r c doc ent .D utng
lm nt t he ppar nty r
he or e t um s
i

dicover ,BAE i dve tnty pr
s
y
na re l oduce t Clhm dicover doc e swih Ba ess a ps
d o e
s
y um nt t t t m
t tw e e t pedtve ofBat sa pst thgd pr vi l bçe us BAE cor e e t s
ha r e i
es t m
ha
e ousy n ed.
r ct d hi
ys e oduc ng t e doc e swih c r c ed Bat
i hes
um nt t or e t
es
pr
oducton e r wihi t eeda ,r pr
i r or t n hr
.

sa a d a e plnao yc ve lte onM a 25 2 1 . vet ls, u 29 2 7,
t mps n n x a t r o r ett
y , 0 7 Ne rhee s onl ne , 01
Cl hm ûld asECF N o.160- t Tfr ts ' ofdoc e spr çd wih Ba e sam ps
e
e
57 he çts ey'
um nt oduc
t ts t

BAE 1
781- 783.Clhm ç nm st ts i e d t a tch t <s ond s t'ofdoclm ent
1
e
l i ha he nt nde o ta he fec
e'
l
s
.

pp duc d wih Bat ssampsBAE 1781e t
e t
1783.
I
I.

On De e r4 2 7 t c r g a e BAE' Moto f rSu r u me .
c mbe , 01 ,he ou t r ntd
S in o mma yl dg nt

ECFNo. f Folwigt e typfû lud me tonAug s 2 , 01 , e fe a
1 8. l n he nr na j g n
o
u t 8 2 8 Clhm l d
l
N odceofAppea wih t U nied St t sCpur ofAppe l f t Fourh Cic t a al
l t he t
ae
t
a s or he
t t ui, ppe i
ng
.

tega ofs mmayj g n ds si BAE fo t c s. De e r1 , 01 ,
h znt u r ud me t imisng
r m he ae On c mbe 4 2 8
Clhm fl d t m oton pr s nty bef et cour.I t sm odon,Cl hm s e t r plc a
e
le he
i
e e l or he
t n hi
e
e ks o e a e

pa'oft rc t ECFNo 1 0 5 , nd ra a wihExlbt ( lde i he modo )t
l he eo d,
t
. 6 - 7 u e ppel t lii3 i u d n r
nc
n o
c r tt atac e e r de c i il m.
or ec he t hm nt r or s rbed t- Onl nu r 7, 1 ,
.
p
a a y 20 9 BAE fldat q ns t
l
e e po e o
.

Clhm'mo ,
e s éon ECF No. 4 , ttn t tido sn o e tt t mo n t atrt
2 2 saig ha t e ot bjc o he do o le he
r cor butbeivesi woul bei ppr i e t r m ove dopl e sfom t r or t
e d,
le t
d na oprat o e
m nt r
he ec d hat

we epatoft r c r whe t ec u ti n r diss mma yj g n r l .
r r he e o d n h o t ç dee t u r ud me t ui BAE as
ng
lo
m a ac ca obs p don:r gar es ofwhe he Clhm i e
kes m i l er
e dl s
t r e nt nded t i l t doc ent
o ncude he um s
c aned i Exhi t3,ie. t fs ond s t'ofdoc e spr
ont i n
bi . , he dec
e'
um nt oduce w11 Ba essa ps
d :, t t m
.
1
BAE 17811783,t s docl ent we enet rr eve norr viwed by t c twhe i
he e lm s r ihe ec i d
e e
he our
nt

g a e BAE' moto f rs mmayjd me . a ua y7 20 9 Cll f e ar py ECF
r ntd
S i n o u r u g nt Onl n r , 1 , en l d e l,
m l
N o.
243,t BAE' m s
o
S pons i c dng t ti di notoppos ECF N o.1 57 r m ani
e ndia
ha t d
e
67- e i ng
pa tt r or Fo! t r as s tf h he en,t couy wilDE N Y Clhm ' m oéon.
t he ec d.
he e ons e ort r i he
t t
e s
1 .
11

Rue1 ()oft Fe r l lsof
l 0 e he de a Ru e Appelt Pr c d z alwsadititc tt
l e o eue l
a
o
src our o
s e e t r or t twaspr vi l bef e i.Unde t Rtl ,a diti tcot m a
upplm nt he ec d ha
e ousy or t
r he le
stc ut y

mod f o s pplme tt z c r o a a:()ffa yd fe e eaie a t wha a t al
iy r u e n he e o d n ppe l 1 f n ifr nc rs s s o t c t l
i
zy
oc u r d beo eii or()Tfa t n ma eilt et e pa t i o ate fo t r c r b
c re f r t' 2 ï nyhig tra o ih r ry s n itd r m he e o d y
'
i
v r ora c de . I ;ac d Iln lrv.Com r he i Ca e Co .. 790 F.
r or c i nt' d. cor -iae
'
e nsve r
,
supp.114,115

( D. . 9 2 . r c r o a pe l o it ofTheo ii l pe sa d e hiisfldi
E. Va 1 9 ) The e o d n p a c nsss d rg na pa r n x b t le n
t
t diti ycout , he ta c i ofpt ee ngs i a ,a a c r i d c oft doc
he stc
t t t ns rpt
oc di , f ny nd e dfe opy he ket

e tisp e rdbytecekoftedstc c tt. Fe . App. 1 a.
nte rpae
h lr h itit ott' d R. P. 0()
'
I i welstldta Thepu eo Rul 1 ()i no t alw adititc u tt a d
ts l ete h tf
t pos f e 0e s t o l
o
src o r o d
t t t or m a t r t tdi notoc t t r i t c s oft pr eelngsladi t t
o he ec d te s ha d
cu he e n he our e he oc ci e ng o he

jd me u e rve 'J a c r Rutcdv. X Hotl,nc, 0 U. DitLEM S
u g nt nd r e im 'A9 c od el CS
es I .20 7 S. s.
4 5 a * 4( D. . .un 2 , 0 ) I e d t ce rweg ofa t rt i iae t t
49 4, t 1 S. W VaJ e 0 20 7.nd e ,he la iht ,uhoiy ndc ts ha
adsrq c u ts oudpr ryrf et spplme i rc do a pe l t cic vey
itit o r h l opel eus o u e nt he e or n p a wih l o r
s
docl e st we e dnotfl ...orbr
lm nt hat r f ted
oughtt t a t nton oft dit c t a i
o he te i
he sdct our , s t

ç nsd rdt vriusp p r i e lai t mo frs mmayj g n '
o iee he o a çs n vau tng he don o u r ud me t'Roebo h
u
v. e hLa .l .91 F.d 9 0 9 3 4 n. (t Ci.1 9 ) W he lrv. h
W t bs nc, 6 2 7 , 7 -7 , 8 4. t 9 09 ee Anc or
h

Con i ntlI .1 7 U.. s.
tne a,nc, 9 9 S DitLEXI 8 3 ,1 79W L 5 .. 1 7 )Clue1 e
S 48 9
20 5C.9 9 k l 0()
pr desno ba i f a e
ovi
ss ot ugm néng t r or t i l e de ewlih wasne rbef et
he ec d o ncude vi nc lc
ve
ot he

dititc ..l Tho qv. eNo. 4 ofDitLod e7 oft I 'As' of
stc our'; ma Lod
t'
2 61
s.
4 he nt sn
l
Ma hnit AndAeo. okes3 F. up z 7 8 71 ( D. . 0 4 rr pu eof
c i ss
t W r r, 48 S p.d 0 , 0 E. Va 2 0 ) fihe mos
Rul 1 ()i no t alw acititc lt t a d t t r c r on a pe l test tc dnot
e 0e s y o l
o lsrc olt o d o he e o d p a matr ha l
'
i
oc uzt r i t c ureo t p o e dng la n t t j g ntu rr ve '
c he e n he o s f he r c e i s e dig o he ud me nde e im '
'

(ig onte l;Co bi ofRo i Maii I c, 6 F. D. 0 , 0 ( D. . 9 5
ctdon ritd) m nt
bns rt n .1 2 R. 5 2 5 4 E. Va 1 9 )
me
(al gt a ver l K l s tld' 1 A Fe Pr c & Pr c lA1. 3 5 . (t e )
c ln he bo ue f l ete ); 6 d. a . o . lts j 9 64 4 h d.
i
we '
3

rf rl rl Rul 1 ()s tl no beusdt isr i t rc r ie t taeg
g cnai e 0e hoz t e o n etn he e o d tms ha r ot
q i y
d
pr ry a pa tofi- s a m a e i l t wer notpt ent t t diti c tdltng
ope l
r t uch s t ras hat e
es ed o he stct our xi

t l ia n t a 1d t t c l ng d d src- o lt uig.)
he ig do h t e o he hal e ititc lt r l ' .
t
e
' n '
I Am tv. r ' a St t Uri r i ,t cour di not t s r lcoursouti of
n
Vi ni a e zve s he
t d e hat eve a
t
sde

t Fouzh Cic tha hed t tt z aec zan sm a
he
t t ui ve l ha he e z e ti i donsi whih aditi c tm a
n c
jrct out y
s e e t r cot wih m a e i lt tw a notpr vi l be or i. o. 07c
upplm nt he e d t
t ta ha s
e oùsy f e t N 34 v628,2009

W L 1 08 3 a * ( D. . y4, 0 ) TheAmrc ur notd ho ve ,ha t i is
2 20 , t 3 E. Va Ma 20 9 .
o t e , we r t t h s sue
wasaddr s i t Ea t r D ititofVigi ai ac ew he e t pbi f r led on fa
es ed n he s e n stc
r ni n as
r he ndf s ei
<
ven ofpr e nt'outi oft Folrh Cic twlih pe nate fa la ecourst
i
ec de ' sde he z t t ui lc r it d fppe lt
t o
c i m a t snoti udq i t a na et cor fn t i e ssofl tc ' I
on7der ter
ncl d n he ppe t e d i he nt m t ' ie.' d.
us .
'

(uoé Frel n Le l ol& Smmo v. nd lo 1 7F. D. 6 2 9( D. .
q ng e c
ma
itl i ns Me es n, 9 R. 27 , 7 E. Va
2 0 ) I Me des , hec ur notd t f o .g ne a ctumsa e i wlc fde a
0 0 . n n lon t o t e he f ut e r l ic tnc s n l h e r l
f
i
a elt c utsgoud c nsd rma tt be ondt r c r on a pe l samatrofi e e
pp l e o t c l1 o i e te s y
a
.
he e o d p a a
te nh r nt

d st don. I Thef urcr l tnc swe e ()T n a l t c ur r l g s s t o
ic e ' d. o icz a e r : 1 f ppçl e o t ui ua pon e n
'
ms
a
a
n

q s noflw net ragu dbeo kt tilc ur no e prsl rie ona pel'()f n
uedo a ihe r e fr he ra o t t x e sy asd p ai 2 f
' a
a pelt ç lr rviwi p ob bl c us a ot rp o e url atr . . g )c nsde g
p l e ozt e e ng r a e a e nd he z t d a m te s . i o i dn
a
n
f e he ra out
e de e pr e ed i pr ti lpr eelngsbutnotpr rybr
vi nc es nt n e ra oc ci
ope l oughtbe or t tilc tor
.

idu di t a pelt rc r i ()f na lt c ur . . x riigisi rn diçe n
n de n he p l e e o d' 3 f ppe e o t . e ecsn t nhee t srdo
a
' a
i t i tt s ofj dc t c i e e i e eno c nsd z d b t til o r 'a ()f n
n he n e e t us e o onsd r v d nc t o i e e y he ra c u q' nd 4 r
a
a la ecot consde i s s
ppel t ut
i rng ug pont m i d i s soflw a f c nots c ical r ie i
e xe s ue
a nd a y
pe i ly a s d n
t diti cotr.'1 at279-80.
he ssct zt' d.

TheM e lon c utuli a ey hed t t pl ndf sha fct d no i t nc i
nde s ot tm t l l hat he ai f d fie
nsa es n

whihadsrc c ur a Hn un rRue1 e spplme e amc r ara yona pe l 'h
c itit o t c g de l 0() u e ntd o d le d
p a vi
t
doc
umentr e de enote antatt tmeoft cour'rulnp'1i a 280.Thus t
a y vi nc
xt
he i
he
ts i ' t
,he
c ' de e t m oton t s em e t r or obs dng t t pl ndf sT a be h
oul nid he
t
i o uppl pt he ec d, er
hat he ai f f y nef
m
on a
ppea fom t i e dicz
lr
he nhez nt s edon oft Folth Cic t' butt citi c t m us
he z' t uiy'
t
hat lszct out s t

d ci <êoe c e tesopeof( ze 1 ()'I
el t xed h c
ne
Rt q 0e. d.
l
'
To da e t Fourh Cic ihasye t f lw issse cr uisby e r ii is
t , he
' r ui
t
t o olo t it t ic t
xe csng t
f he enydic edon' i t sm a r a num e ousde ii ofcour si t sc r ui a
v r
sz
' n hi nne , nd
r
c sons
t n hi ic t nd

be
yond m iia ea i tpe- iéng Cl
lt t gans t t
m
ehm t fcor e t't r c d.Seee. .Thom a ,348
o f r c ' he e or
g.
s

F.u zda 7 1( D. . 0 4 rgti not p o daefrt sCo tt s plme t
s pp. t 1 E. Va 2 0 ) fj s a pr p t o hi ut o up e nthe
l
r coz he eby addi g t pe p r e nt); es n v. v cCt.
e d r
n he la g e me . Hu lma Cii r Co .8 3F.d 1 7 ,
7
,7 2 11
,

1 7 n. (t Ci.1 8 )rffhea pelt rc dc nsssonyoftos fcsa maeil
1 5 3 8h r 9 9 rl p lae eor o it l h e a t nd tra
pr s ntd f rt ed stc c ur' c nsdea n. He n v. tl o a hcS .81 F.d
e e e o h itit o t o i r do 7 n Na'Ge
s
);
i oc, 9 2

8 4 8 ( t Ci. 9 7 (Th pade ma r l o a a o yo mae il 6lnihe t t
2 , 31 7h t 1 8 ) ( e r s y ey n ppe l nl n t ras t s d o he
<
csdc J g .) I s r,her c r o a a c nno c nti a ydoc me t ore i e c
l t t' e' . n ho t t e o d n ppe l a t o an n
i
ud '
u ns vd n e

t tweeno fe i tetilc t pro t j g ntI ote wo ds< pat ma not
ha t ti d n h ra out it o ud me .n h t r ,f ry y
l
a
fas addi lis norbeat y s e e t r or on a a wih doc e st t
r ie
dona s ues
l edl upplm nt he ec d' ppe l t
um nt ha
alge yi udef oop ofa is i t ac
le dl ncl pr
n s ue n he don,i t e doc e swer notpr ent t
f hos
um nt
e
es ed o
t e ti lcouz.'N e
l ra
a
t'

or N e H ol n sCo .v. r ua Ci Vii I ,N o.4:
t ws
di
Vit l
son nc.
08CV 19
,

20 0WL 1 5 6 7 , t 2( D. . y1 , 01 )(ingS muesv. i r 8 F.d1 4 ,
1
1 6 3 4 a * E. Va Ma 1 2 0 cé a l W l , 71 2 3 6
de
1 5 Ct Ci. 9 9) Th c r f st prval gpr c d ntlihype s sve
3 4 h t 1 8 ). e ou t md he e in e e e lg l ruai .
i

Torie e adititc t ma mocf o s ppe ntter c r ()ffa y
etmt, stc out y ly r u lme h e o d:1 f n
i
i
dfee c aie a t wha a mal o c r dbeo eii or()ffa t n maeiloet r
ifrn e rss s o t c l c ure fr t' . 2 f nyhig tra t ihe
y
?
i
pa t i o te fo t r c z byer ro a cde . Fe R. p. 1 () Net rp ry
ry s mitd t m he e o d ro r ç i nt' d. Ap P. 0 e. ihe a t
'

a ast cipuetec ntnt oft rc r beo et sc ut ons
ppet o ls t h o e s he e o d fr hi o t ummayj g nt
r ud me .
H e e t onl a ia e g oundsf s e ent éon woul beon ison oft pt f r d
nc , he y valbl r
ot upplm a
d
as i
he ofe e

doc nt i Exhi t3 duet fer orac i nt' Se i Thetr fe r oza i 'i
ume s n
bi
o fror
cde . e da
'
e m fror ccdent's
f oa y i e pr t d t pev tt r cot t be s em e e by a m a t rwhih i
f dl nt r e e o tni he e d o
br
uppl nt d
ny te
c s

p o ryapatt rof'UntdSae v. ro 1 8F. 4 2 48 (t Ci. c 1 9 )
r pel r hee . ie tts Bar w, 1 3d 8 , 8 6h rMih. 9 7 .
'
I por a l s e e a i pev ted onl i t Te z ora i ' r s t i t
m t nty, upplm nt don s tnit
y f he fror ccdent' e uled n he
or si i t appel er c d ofm atra t tw a pat oft t lr or H e e,Cl
nison n he
lat e or
e i l ha s t he da ec d. t ehm

s kst s e e t r or on appe * t'doc ent t y conce we ene
ee o upplm nt he ec d
al .
1 um s he
1
de r ver
pr s nt d t t ti lcout.I ot rwor ,Clhm ' f iur t pt f rt f e
e e e o he ta
t n he
ds e s al e o ofe he < cond s t'of
s
e'
docx e si quesi doesnotc dm t a a dona e de r ora i nt'oft s t
lm nt n
ton
ons e n c
bl ft or ccde ' he or

c e ltd u rRul 1 () S e eg, setv. laKa aE sln, 0 F.d 1 5 ,
ontmpa e nde e 0e . e , ..Fa s t Det
io 8 7 2 1 0

1 65(z C1.98 )( ligt a t c ur i no a hoie u rRul 1 e R u me te
1 3 d 1 6 hodn h t he o ts t ut tz d nde e 0() a g nt h
r or on a a wih de i ta c st tw e e noton t t or be c i a t Hm e
ec d
ppe l t posdon t ns dpt ha z
he ec d fye t t he

isfn ld cso wa rnd r d' ac r J ne v.a k o Na'LieI . ,8 9F. p
t a e iin s e ee . c o d o s J c s n tl f ns Co. 1 su p.
);
1 5 1 8 ( . Mih 1 9 ) Th t f r ,two dbei o rt T o r cy ie,
38 , 3 7 W D. ç . 9 3 . e e o e i ul mpr pe o f re t '..
c
'
s e e t r c d on a
upplm nt he e or
ppea w1. docA ent t wer notbe or t scour (n
l t1 lm s hat e
1
f e hi
t?

S
ummayj g me t
t ud e n .
I .
V

Fo tefrgon ra o , e sVo t Corc t Re o d ECFNo. 41 i
r h o e ig e s ns Clhm' don o re the ç r ,
2 ,s
D EN I .The Clr i die ed t s nd a c oft sM e or ndlm Opi on t al
ED
e k s r ct o e
opy hi m a l
ni o l
c
ouns lofr or
e
ec d.

I i s O RD ERE D .
ts o

Enee: o/- // -2 w zî
trd
-

4 /* 4Z'r /. V-'
r *J
ZJ
M i ha lF.
c e

a

UrtdS ts situg
le / e Dit lde
i t tc