Marshall v. Amherst County Circuit Court

Filing 7

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 3/28/2016. (tvt)

Download PDF
A#xN lk,A ' kliM FI LE; , I THE INI D s wrlsDlrm c'cot r N J TE l r sr r m' Fo R TH E w E sTEl x m sTm c' oF VI G I A t r R NI R O A N O K E DI I O N V SI MA 23 11 2 CC JL w B . , n p EDW A R D LER O Y M V SH AI, JR . L, , Pl ntf , ai i f cu . . L Ci lA ct on N o.7: cvvi i 16- 00057 M EM O M ND U M O PI O N M A M H ER ST C O UN TY CI CU I R T C O U RT , Dee f ndant . By: H o Jac t on L . i e n. ls K sr Se or U nied St e D i t i tJudge ni t at s s r c Ed r Le oy M a s l,J . aVigi apr ti lde ane pr e ngpr K , ie a wa d r r ha l r, r ni era t i e oce di o fld c an purua t 42U. C.j198 na ngt Amhes Count Cic tCo tast s e omplit s nt o S. 3 mi he rt y rui ur he ol de e nt Pl i i fnot t the i a de e nti o g ng c i lpr e di i t ts a e f nda . a ntf es ha s f nda n n- oi dm na oc e ngs n ha t t co t a he a ksm e t or rt sa e c ur t c nge ve ,a nt: ne and e f c i ' ur , nd s o de he t t o t o ha nue ppoi t w a f e tve ' c t e, t sa aCul i tg ae 'jzy. oms lal e t t l ne r td'l d f yr Fe r lc ursmus no i e f r wih pe ng sa ec i i lpr ee ngsa e de a o t t t ntr e e t ndi t t rm na oc di bs nt e r r na y c r lm sa es whih a enotpr s nthe e. See e. ,Younce v. ri,401U. xtao di r icl t nc , c r ee r . c. r Ha rs S. 3 4 ( 9 1 ; rz d rv W a ly 1 2U. 1 ,1 9 7 ( 8 8 ; yo v. itr 8 U. 7, 4 1 7 ) Hak a e . de , 7 S. 48 6 - 0 1 9 ) Ta lr Tan o , 3 S. 3 6 3 0( 8 3 .A f d rldsrc c u t h u da sanfo c n tt to a c le e t sae 6 , 7 1 7 ) e ea itit o r s o l b ti r m o siuin l halng s o tt j dca p o e dng , e ad e so acam' meis i t fd r l li c ul b p e e tdi u iil r c e i s r g r ls f li s rt,f he e ea cams o d e r sn e n t eo g i saej dca p o e dn Cie Bl eo Ch rotmnc v Gic rs, 8 F.d4 , h n ong tt u iil r c e ig. n ma u f alte l . . lh it 8 7 2 9 5 5 (t Ci. 9 9 .Fu t r r ,heAn ilj ncinAc, 8U. C. 2 3, x r sl 2- 3 4 h r 1 8 ) rhemo e t t-nu to t 2 S. j 28 e p e sy p o bt af d r l o t r m e j ii t ep o e dn sfo whihPlitf s e srle. r hiis e ea c m'fo n onng h r c e ig r m c an if e k eif M o e ve, fdea c u ta kjlidcint ga tma n srle a an tsaeo fcaso r o r a e rl o r lc t s ito o rn nd mu eif g is tt fiil r r saea nce .Glre v.Supei Cour ofM e llnbt Cnt ,411F. 586,587( hCi. tt ge is zly ror t cce ux y. 2d 4t r 1 .u 969) congrs a t fde a c t havec itnl r ogni dt tfdealc t s d e s nd he e r l ours onsse ty ec ze ha e r ours houl p r t tt c u t t tysaec s s a dt a, r c n tt to a is e aie saec u'j d e e misae o rs o r tt ae , n h t whee o siui n l su s rs , tt o l u g s t aef lyc mpee tt h n l t e s b e t o S prmeCo r r v e ' Bo n rv. rui Co r r ul o tn o a de h m u j c t u e u t e iw. n e Cic t u t ' o S . u s 5 6F.d 1 31 1 3 ( t Ci.1 7 )(nba c .Ac o dn l 1fn i i mo e f t Lo i, 2 2 3 , 3 6 8h r 9 5 e n ) c r igy, i d t s r a p o raef rsaec u t t a j d c t P an ifscams a dId s s tec mp an wih u p r p it o tt o rs o du iae litf' li , n imis h o lit t o t p eu ie rj d c . EN TER : / TI Rda o M a c , 201 y f rh 6. P e ni U nie St t sD i t i tJ t d a e sr c udge 2

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?