Kershner v. Wright et al

Filing 59

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/19/2017. (slt)

R ERKS OFFI U. , ST COURCE s DI .
I
AT'
ROANOKE,
vA
FIED
L

AF2 19 2 1
07
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STR I CO U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I T OF VI G I A
C
R NI
R O A N O K E DI I O N
V SI

JULI C. UDL CLE
A
EY
BY:
/
DE
k
CL K
.

T O BY K ER SH N ER ,
Pl ntf ,
ai if

C i lA c i N o.7: 6- vvi t on
1 c 0006
3

V.

M EM O R AN DU M O PI O N
NI

B. W RI T,e al,
A.
GH
t .
D ef
endant .
s

By:

Hon.M i hae F. bansd
c l Ur
l
U ni e St esD i t i tJudge
t d at
src

Toby Ke s r a Vigi ai aepr e ngpr K ,fld acvi rg sc
r hne , r ni nm t oce di
o
ie
i l i ht ompl i
ant

purua tt 42U. C.j1 3.Pl ntf alge t tt rmani dee t,whoaea s itd
s n o
S.
98 ai if le s ha he e i ng fndan s
r s ocae

wiht eRi r rhCo rcin l ne (lNCC' a dteVignaDe rme to Co r cins
t h ve No t re to a Ce tr çt
t
' n h r ii pa t n f re to
)
(S
E
VDOC') fie t pr tc hi fo a atc by a ot rimaelThermani dee nt
', ald o oe t m r m n ta k n he n t.
e i ng fnda s

fldamo inf rs mmayj d me ta dPlitf rs o d d madn t matrrp f r
i
e
to o u r u g n, n anif e p n e , l g he te ie o
diposton. Afe r vi wi t r c d,t c tg a t t r m ani de enda s m o i f
s ii
tr e e ng he e or he our r n s he e i ng f nt ' ton or

sl r u g n .
l
mmayj d me t

Pl ntf w asr t ni t hi ho i uni f om t pr s di ng ha lon M a c 4,201
ai if
e ur ng o s us ng t r he i on ni
l
rh
5,

whe a t ri t ,C. e de ,at c d hi o sdeoft A- l ng.An of ri me ael
n no he nma e Fil r ta ke m ut i
he buidi
ûce m dit y
r pore t fght o de e t m t so fghtng, de oyed ac m i lm iton t m .Bot
e td he i , r r d he o t p i i and pl
he ca s
he
h
i a e soppe fghtng a we er sr i wihouti i t St f ta po d Pl ntf t t
nm t s t d i i nd r e taned t
ncden . a f r ns /e ai if o he
medialde rm e twhe e anlr eno e heha l e a i t hi uppe 1p a t brdgeofhi
c
pa t n
r
zs t d
d ac r tons o s
r i nd he i
s
nos p hi nos w asdi f gu e a bl e ng.2 N o f m ali s i ton oft i i nt
e nd s e
s i r d nd e di
or
nve tga i
he nc de
oc ur ed,a no vi o w a r t i d bec us i w a de m e a m i a t r to
c r
nd
de
s e a ne
a et s e d
nor le ca i n.

1Thec ttr i td t ot rdefndant b aprorm e or m opi on a or r
our em nae he he e
sy
i
m andu
ni nd de .
2Pli ifalgest tde e ntHoron, teisi in ln siao,o kpitrso Plitf ij re ,
antf le ha f nda
t h n tt o a ivet trto cue f anifsnu is
ut
g
butHoro a st t r i nor cor of hos pit r se si
tn ver hat he e s e d ft e c u e xitng.

l t n e d compl nt Pl i ifa lge ge r ly,1 t dt m t tIc d tgo b k
n he m nde
ai , antf le s ne al & ol he ha oul n'
1
ac
t C&D buidi duet t ga m e r Sxt tngandt e t ni m e. Pli ifct shi
o
l ngs
o he ng mbe s e ori
hr a e ng' ' antf ie s
'
ilonnalc
rf
ompl i da e M a c 11,
ant t d r h 2015 i s
, n uppor oft sge r a lga i n.Pl i ifal ge
t hi ne al le to
antf le d
i t ti or lco pl nt G1br
n ha nf ma m ai ,ç ough t ya'l a tnton vi r s f m st tIc dn' go ba
t o ls te i a eque t or ha oul t
ck
t C&D buidi duet t e ori n by t ga .A m on h lt r Ige my nos br ke
o
l ngs
o he xt to
he ngs
t ae , t
e o ,

punc da so dit t c rt sde kbyU oneo t ga me r whower
he nd tmpe no he oncee i wal
f he ng mbe s
e
e ori me. . . . W hy di ' ya'1bei vem e ' Def nda As it ntW a denBoo r
xt tng
?'
3
e nt ssa
r
ke
dn t 1 le
r ponded t t i or a c pl i s yi K-he e w a no w a t ve iy.
es
o he nf m l om a nt a ng, t - r
l
s
y o rf '
'

Def ntHoron s
enda
t poke wih Pli ifafe t fghtt dic st ale e ori
t a ntf tr he i o s us he lged xt ton.
Howe ,Pli ifdi no sa ea s cii name ,c lnumber ,d t ,ori o ma i a
ver antf d t t t ny pe fc
s el
s a es nf r ton boutt
he
alege e ori Furhe r Pl i ifdi notdic sa col e ton be wee i ae Fi l r
l d xt ton. t nno e, antf d
s us ny m c i
t n nm t ede
and t al ge e ori Nonet l s , ai ifbei ve de e an sLt J. .Hae a J s n
he le d xt ton.
he e s Pl ntf le s f nd t . M
l nd a o
Hi nsç houl ha 'known ofars ofa tckbe a ePl i ift d t s t def nda s
ggi t
s d ve'
ik ta
c us antf ol he e wo e nt
be or t a tckt tFil rwa hi ng co r ba s ci aly a i o s d ttoo gt fom
f e he ta ha e de s di
nta nd, pe sc l n mpr vie a t m, r
sa f
t f.

Ho t a r t t be o et fght Pli ifa i eFi de we e bo h hous d i t
ron ve s ha , f r he i , a ntf nd nmat el r r t
e n he
s
nmepod wihoutanyi i nta t tt r i no r o d t a Pl i ifaz Fi l rha a
t
ncde nd ha he e s ec r h t antf ld ede d ny
,
hi t y ofc pl i s i s s o a t r a i be or t i f gh .
s or
om a nt , s ue , r le c tons f e he r i t
1I.

De e d n slldamoi nfrs mmayj d me t ag igta t yaee tt dt
fn a t ie
to o u r u g n , r un h the r nil o
e
qualfe i miy.Quaii i miype t l r me ofiil pef mi dicei r
iid mmt t
lfed mmt t nnis G n nt fcas ror ng s rtona y
gove

f ncins...(obe s ede fom la lt frcvi dn ge i ofrast i co uc doe not
u to
t j hil d r ibiiy o i l ma s ns a her nd t s
3The er e e d f m sa enoti t r co d.
s efr nce or r
n he e r

2

vi a ecla l e t ihed sa u o y orc tt i lrght ofwhih ar as bl pe s wo d
olt e ry sabls
tt t r
onsiutona i s
c e ona e r on ul

ha e1, w1' Halw v. tc r l, 5 U. 8 0 8 8( 98 ) On ead fnd n rie t
v :1 , ' ro Fiz ead 4 7 S. 0 , 1 1 2 . c ee a t as s he
.0 1
1 .
quai d i muniy def ns ,apl i ifbe z t bm de t s
lfe m
t
e e
antf a s he
n o how t ta de e ntsc
ha
f nda ' onduc
t

viltdt ep an ifsrg t v n v Mu h 9 4F.d1 8 1 8 (t Ci. 9 3 .
oae h litf ih .Br a t . t , 9 2 0 2, 0 6 4h r 1 9 )
A pat i e tte t s mmayj dg n it ep e dng ,heds l s dmaeil o fl,
ry s n ild o u r u me t f h la i s t ico e tras n e
a a afi vis s w t tt r i no ge ne di put a t a m at r a f c . Fed. .Ci P.
nd ny fda t ho ha he e s
nui
s e s o ny
eil a t
R v.

56() i aeilf t'ar t ef t ne sa yt e tbls t ee nt ofapat sc us o
a . l tra acs' e hos acs ce sr o sa ih he lme s
M
ry' a e f

a to An es nv Li ryLo by l .4 7U. 2 2, 48( 9 6 .A g n ieds t o
cin. d ro . bet b .nc, 7 S. 4 2 1 8 ) e un ipue f
maei f te ssili viwi t rc da alr a o bl i ee e drwnt r fo i a
tral ac xit t n e ng he e or nd l e s na e nfrnc s a he er m n
lghtm os f vo a et t no m ovi pary,ar s na ef tfnde c dr t n a ve ditf
i
t a r bl o he nng t ea o bl ac-i r oul eur
r c or
t no m ova .I Them o ng pa t hast bur n ofs
he nnt d.
vi
ry
he de
howi - Sha i , n i outt t
ng t t g poitng
t
o he
diti c t t tt t i a a e eofe de e t s ppo t heno ovi pary' c s '
srct our - ha he e s n bs nc
vi nc o u r t
nm ng t s a e.
'

Ceo e Co . Cart, 7 U. 31 , 2 ( 9 6 .I temo a tstsist sb ld n te t e
ltx p v. tet4 7 S. 7 3 5 1 8 ) f h v n aife hi t e ,h n h
r
non- ova m us s tf rh s cfcf t t tde
m nt t e o t pe ii acs ha monsr t t e se eofage nediput of
ta e he xit nc
nui s e
f c f ti .l a 322- A c t a no r ol diputd f t,wegh t e de e,o m a
a t or ral d. t
24. our m y t es ve s e acs i he vi nc r ke

d tr n t nso c e iiiy Rusel . ir d n Co p, 5F.d 1 2 ,1 3 ( t Ci.1 9 )
eemiai f r db l . s l v M co y e r .6 3 2 9 2 9 4h r 9 5 ;
o
t
S s be v. u y 7 7F.d 1 9 1 2 (t Ci. 9 6 .I se d ac u t c e t a tu te
o e e M mh , 9 2 7 , 8 4 h r 1 8 ) n ta , o r a c p s s r e h
e de e oft non- ovi pa t a r s vesa1 i e na c lc s a i e e s i t no
vi nc
he
m ng ry nd e ol
1 nt r l onfi t nd nf r nce n he n-

mo i pat sfv r Chab n a e d Frnc v S t , 9 F.d4 6 41 (t Ci. 9 9 .
vng ry' a o . r o n c s e a e . mih 5 7 2 0 , 4 4 h r 1 7 )
Ho ve,t eeu s p o tds e uain . .sn te o g t d f a as
we r tmqr n u p re p c lto . i o n u h o e e t umma yj d me t
g
r ug n
moton.'Enni v. tlAs ' o Bus & Ed .Ra o.nc,53F. 55,62(t Ci.1 )
i '
s Na ' sn f . uc di I .
3d
4h r 995 .

TheEi h Am e
ght
ndme i
nt mpos adut o prs ofi i l $ pr ec prs r fom
es
y n ion fc as %o ot t ione s r
vi e a t handsofo he prs r .'Fa m e v.Br r n,511U .S 8 5 8 3( 9 4 .To
olnce t he
t r ione s' r r
ema
. 2 , 3 19 )

etb ihaj1 3cam f raf i r t p oe t ni maefo v oe c ,heimaemu ts o
sa ls
98 li o al e o rt c a n t r m iln e t n t s h w:
u
( )t tap io o fca ha at u fce tyc l besaeo mid'a ( ) h tteimae
1 ha rs n fi il d t fiin l upa l tt f n , nd 2 t a h n t
s
'

s sane as ro o sg fc n p y ia o e to a ij r . I . t8 4 ( tr a q oain
u ti d eius r iniia t h sc l r moin ln u y4 d a 3 i en l u tto
n
ma ksomitd) A G ufi e l c pa esaeofmi ' a t taprs ofii t tboh
r
te . s fcinty ul bl tt
s
nd'me ns ha ion fcals
mus t
be a r off t fom whih t i e e eco d bedr wn t tas tnta rs ofs rousha m
wa e ac s r
c he nf r nc ul
a ha ubsa il ik e i
r

e ss a dh mu tas d a t ifrnc . l . t8 7. e L=a 8 0 4 ( tnge d nc
xit, n e s lo rw he n e e e' d a 3 , e p.t 4 - 2 noi vie e
'
s
co e ni ç onsr ctve notc ' ofas tntalrs i ge r l nots t i ntt e t bls a
nc r ng i tu i
c
i e'
ubsa i ik s ne aly
ufk e o sa ih

d lb rt i ifrnc cam) A s wi o n gie ei n ts fkin .Grv o v. e d 1 5
eieae ndfee e li . ho ng f e lg nc s o u t e t a s n P e , 9
F.d6 2 6 5( t Ci.1 9 ) Th s a o fca' f izet alvaeasg iia t kt a he
3 9 , 9 4h r 9 9 . u , n fiils alr o le it infc n ds h t
l
s d ha ,butdi not pe c i doe no de c i a Ei h Ame e cai .Fn r 511
houl ve
d , r eve s t s rbe n ght
ndm nt l m
mne ,
U. a 8
S. t 38. St t d dif r nty,prs of i a sa e notla e i t G w t unde l ng f c s
a e f e e l i on fci l r
i bl f hey G
kne he
ryi a t

b t le e (l ett o n l)ta ters t whihtefcsg vers wa i u sa ta o
u beiv d ab i ms u dy h t h ik o c h a t a ie s ns b tn il r
none se .'I a 844;s eI 535F. a 141(ttngt tiwa i ufi e t s a
xitnt' d. t
e ko,
3d t
sai ha t s ns fcint o how

d fnd n t h udh ve'e o nz das b tnil iko h r .
ee a tt o l a 'r c g ie u sa ta rs f n m)
s
I Da s rv. tn be ', 7 F.d3 (t Ci. 01 ) teFo rh Cic i Co r o
n n e S a s ny 7 2 3 40 4h r 2 4 ,h u t rut u t f
Appe l va a e a diti co tsor rfndi a dipu eofm ae i lf t a de ng qualfe
a s c t d srct ur' de i ng s t
t ra ac s nd nyi
ii d

i ni i afit et prtc c s .Th r c r o s mma yj g n r v ae t a t eimae
mmu t n alr o oe t a e e e o d n u r ud me t e e ld h t h n t,
y
l
Da e , ol a g r Of e Boyd, ha hewa edt got t ou sder r to ca Ofi e
ns r t d ua d, ûc r
t t
nt o o he t i ec eai n ge. fc r
Boyd as i ne g oupsof i a est ea h r r a i ca bas d o i a e c t l l ,t
sg d r
nm t o c ec e ton ge e n nm t s' us ody eve s he

4Pli ifsdifgu ed,b o e n s i a ij r s fkin frti a ay i.Se , ..1ov S rv , 3
antf' si r r k n o e s n nu y uf e t o hs n lss e eg,k . h e e 5 5

F3d2 5 2 (t Ci. 0 )
. 2 , 41 4h r 2 08.
4

l a i oft i e c l i t f ciiy,a da ai ac
oc ton he nmats' els n he a lt nd t n omput rgene a e S c a Housng
e - r t d pe i l
i

Uni (S 'Re ots Of rBo dplc dDa s ri a o tierc e to c g wi tr e
t t HU' p l
G
)
t
ke y a e n e n n u sd e rain a e t h e
h
ot ri aes oneofwhom woul bet a s ia who ha ne rm e Da e bef r . The SH U
he nm t ,
d he s a lnt
d ve t ns r o e

r por di no m e i t tDa e wa a s x ofe rort tt a s ia twasi a ga
e t d t nton ha ns r s e f nde
ha he s al n
n
ng.
N o t e s Ofi e Boyd c d ha dic r t ti or ton i heha l ke i ot r
nehels , fc r
oul ve s ove ed ha nf ma i f
d oo d n he
prs da a s s buthe di not
ion t ba e ,
d .
I t ad o s r sng t r c eai n c ge a r quie byhi posto Ofi e Boyd i f
nse f upe vii he e r to a s s e r d
s ii n, fc r
et

hi pos,a t a s ia ç
s t nd he s al nt s ke Da e t t gr t a r peaed y ki ke a so d hi
knoc d ns r o he o md nd e t l c d nd t mpe s

fc he d, body....ute gng obs e te a c
a e, a and
tri j c niis nd omme edo Da e ' s x- fnde saus
nt n nsrs e ofe r tt

d rn teatc ' 1 . t3 4.Da e s fe e sg iia t nu isa ar s t
u ig h ta k. d a 4
'
nsr u fr d i nfc n ij re s eul.
Dansrs dunde 42U. C.j 1 arui t tOfie Boydwasdelbe ael
e ue
r
S.
983, g ng ha fc r
i rt y
i fe e tt as t nta rs ofhn Ofi e Bo a gue t t diti tc tt thedi no
ndif r n o ubsa i l ik
nn. fc r yd r d o he src our ha
d t

ha eac la esaeof n b c u eç ewa n ta r o a yf css g si t tgh
v up bl tt mid e a s G s o wae f n a t ug e t ha t e
h
ng
a sia jpos dapa tculrtr a t Da e.'I a 347.Thedititc t ldi Da e '
salnt e
ri a h e t o ns r' d. t
src our nze n nsrs
f
avora s tt m a trf ti l prma iy be us Ofi e Bo as i
nd e he te or ra , i rl ca e fc r yd sgned Da e ,aco ced
ns r
nvi t
s x ofe r t t s m er r a i c a t a s lnt whowa alnown vi l ntga
e f nde , o he n ec e ton age s he s aia ,
s c
oe
ng

me r a dt t nsrsij re o c re whe Of e Bo dlf t ea e t u e vsd.Th
mbe, n ha Da e ' n u is c u rd n fc r y e th r a ms p r ie
e
Cour ofAppe l r ve s d, i prma iy t tt her or a ama trof1w f l t s
t
a s e r e notng i rl ha t ec d s
t
te
' a ais o how t t
ha

g fc r Bo dmu t v a prcae t a h sa to la i gDa e a d g ea s ia t tg t e
ofie) y s ha e p e itd h t i c f e v n nsr n t s alnj o eh r
h
i a uns r i ed a e c e t a e es i rs t D a e ' s e y on t tbas s' I a 348.
n n upe v s r a r a ed n xc s ve i k o ns r s af t
ha
i . d. t
'

TheCour ofAppeasrj ce Da e' agume t tçtwa t ous t g fc r Boydt t
t
l ee td ns rs r nt ha t s obvi ' o ofiej
i
ha
5TheSIU Re ti l d i ats na e a i nttc tonnum be sa not a :s r tor or r y'
I
por ncude nm e , m s nd de ii ai
r nd ed ny (epa aj j de s '

whihaeodr dsrbigwh ec imaeso l b kp sprt 9o i teS F rea e asprto
c r res eci n o ah n t h ud e et eaae m n h HU. o x mgl, eaain
or rwoul pr ventt i atswho ha pr o l f
de
d e
wo nm e
d eviusy ought9om pari pai i t s m er c e tonpe i
tci tng n he a e r a l
rod.

5

p a igDa e i ar ce to c g wi Lh a s ia t a dia n t ae t up r ie wo l
lcn nsr n e rain a e t t e saln) n e vig he r a ms e vs d ud
h
ha ldt a atc ' JLa 348ve e o n ta k. I t 49.
'
-.

I c nr s t Da s r Le r v. vn so Comt 5 F.d4 ( t Ci. 0 8 , n
n o tat o n e , ay Liic t n t y, 28 3 38 6h r 2 0 ) a d
Odom v.So hCaolnaDe me ofCore tons 349F.d765( h Ci.
ut r i pm nt
rci ,
3
4t r 2003) aet
, r wo
exa esofc r tona ofi e sexhi tng dei r t i fe e t a s t ta rs ofi ae
mpl
orec i l fc r
bii
lbe a e ndif r nce o ubsan i l ik nm t
vi e e.l Le r t Cour ofAppeasf rt Si h Cic ta fr d t dititco tsde al
olnc n a y, he
t
l o he xt r ui fime he src ur ' ni

o ac re to a ofc rsmoinf rs mmayj d me tb c u eter c r e tbih d
f o r ci n l fie ' to o u r u g n e a s h e o d sa ls e
delber t i f e e .Theofi ert d t deai e t notdic sli pe i c i lc r
i ae ndif r nce
fc ol he t ne o
s us ls nd ng dm na ha ge
f ral ge y r pi ani ye rol g r be us a he i aem i a tc hi f i, he
o le dl a ng ne- a - d il ca e not r nm t ght ta k m or t t
ofi e s e n l t d ot ri aesa utt dea ne sa lge s x ofe e a t ofi r
fc r ubs que ty ol he nm t bo he t i e' le d e f ns , nd he fce
di no hi t pr ec t de ane fom a s tnta rs ofha m . 5 F. a 441 Si lry i
d t ng o ot t he t i e r
ubsa i l ik
r
28 3d t . mia l n
Odom , he Cour ofAppe l f t Fo t Cic tr ve s a di ti tco ts gr n ofs m a y
t
t
a s or he ur h r ui e r ed s r c ur ' a t um z

j d me tt c re to a o fc r o t eq e to o d lb rt id fee c .Th prs n r Od m,
u g n o o rcin l fies n h u sin f ei eae n ifr n e e io e, o
t d c r c i of r ofhi f a ofpm i a i t s a t o fc r s w t pariulr
ol ore tonal sce s
s er
culr nma e , nd he f e s a he tc a
i aest e t n Odo ,a tmptt br k i o Odom ' c l,a goa ot st a t k Odom .
nm t hr a e
m te
o ea nt
s el nd d her o tac
Vmi sa ft d t ofi r t moveOdom t s ey,butt ofi e sal d t pa tc a
ous t f ol he fce s o
o af t
he fc r lowe he riulr
i est at c Odom a s i Odo gotwha hede e v d f bei a s t h.349F. a
nmat o ta k
nd ad
m
t
s r e 0r ng nic
3d t

7 .I b t Le r a dOd m,h otc r s be tv l rc g z dt es b tn il iko s ro s
71 n oh ay n o te f e s u j ciey e o nie h u sa ta rs f eiu
i
ha f cngt i t - antfs ye t t no se t pr e tt prs r f o t kno
nu a i he nma e pl i if , t hey ook
tps o ot c he ione s r m he wn
rsk.
i

I c r s t Le r a O do ,Def nda sa e e il d t q lf e i m uriy a
n ont a t o a v nd
m
e nt r ntte o ua ii d m
lt nd

s mma yj d me tb c us t rc r e e wh nv e di al h mo tfv rb et Plitf
u r u g n e a e he e od, v n e iwe n i t s a o a l o anit
g
l
6

f ist de o taea de e ntsdei r t i if r nce. Ther c d l c a e de eofa
al o m nsr t ny f nda ' lbe a e nd fe e
e or a ks ny vi nc
s pa a i or rora c lc wha s ve bewe n Pli ifa Fi l rbe or t at c
e r ton de
ny onfi t toe r t e antf nd ede f e he ta k.
Alhoug Pl i ifc am si hi i or a co pli fl d a trt fghtt theha o
t h antf l i n s nf m l m a nt ie fe he i ha
d ompli d
ane
ge r lyt uns i d sa fabou Gg ngex ori 'nvol ng uns c fe i t s t r i no
ne a l o pec/e t f
t ta
t ton'i vi
pe iid nma e , he e s
e de : t s
vi nc o ugges t ta nn e de e ntwa dei r t l i fe e t a s t n i rs
t ha ny m d f nda
s lbe a ey ndif r nt o ubsa tal ik
t tFi de ora ot rpm i ulri t pos d a s t nta rs t Pl n ifon o bef r M a c
ha el r ny he
c a nma e e ubsa il ik o aitf
r o e rh

4, 5 Plitf ag si hsrs n et tes mmayj g n moint a d l rt
201 . an if r ue n i epo s o h u r ud me t to h t ei ae
be
i fe e es
ndif r nc houl be i e r d f om t f c t the t ol Lt J. .H a e & J s n Hi nst t
d nf r e r he a t ha
ç d . M
t
l
ao
ggi ha

i t Fil rha at too gt li n i hi l r' ECF 54,a 1 Bute n a sl i ast e
nma e e de d a t m ldde n s ocke .'
t .
ve s lm ng nz
Pl i ifsc e i t thet dco r e i lofi e st tFil rha co r ba t tdoe no
antf ontnton ha
ol r e tona fc r ha e de d nta nd, ha
s t
rs t t lvelofde i r t i fe e et a at c b Fi l r Si pl be ng a r t t
ie o he e
lbe ae ndif r nc o n ta k y ede . m y i wa e ha
Pl i ifha pr de i o m ai a
antf d ovi d nf r ton bouta t ri a edoe no e t ih aEs t inty
no he nm t
s t sabls tufk e l
c pa esa eofm i ' equie t sae a Ei ht Am e e f ipr t pr e tc am .The e i
ul bl t t
nd'r r d o t t n g h
ndm nt a l e o otc l i
r s
no s
uggesi t ta de e ntwa a et tFil rha a i at tPli ifhadt d
ton ha ny f nda
s war ha e de d ny de ha antf
ol
a hortesa uthi t too g o t tFi l ri t nde t hn m Pl i ifbec us ofi.W ihou
ut ii bo
s at un r ha ede n e d o r antf
a e t t t
t se de ofaCs fc e l c pa esa eofmi 'Pl i ifscai s
hi vi nce
çufi i nty ul bl t t
nd, antf l m oundsi ne i nce
'
n glge ,

a d e n t iet t lv l fa EihhAme me tcam.S eI , 3 F.da 2 (ttn
nd o s o rs o he e e o n g t
nd n li e ko 5 5 3 t 41 saig
t ti wa i uf e t s
ha t s ns fcint o how ade e ntG houl ha 'r cog ze as t nta rs o ha m
f nda s
s d ve' e ni d ubsû il ik f r

a rc nii ne i ncei beo t t e hol t saea Eiht Amè
nd e og zng glge s lw he hrs d o tt n g h
ndme cam)
nt li .
A cc r ngl t r m a ni def nda sa e e il d t qua ii d i m uniy and s m a y
o di y, he e i ng e nt r ntte o lf e m
t
um z

j d me t
u g n.

11
1.

Fort f egoi r as ,t c tgr nt t r m ani de e nt moton f
he or ng e ons he our a s he e i ng f nda s' i or

s mmayj d me t
u r u g n.

s r R 'i /0 dyr pi21/
x s :rs
h
aoAr;07
l .
+/

z y
4 .' .
r'

Unied St t Diti tJ g
t
aes src

8

r#
Zu