Littek v. Clarke et al

Filing 64

ORDER adopting Report and Recommendations re 52 ; denying 7 Motion for Preliminary Injunction; denying 28 Motion for Preliminary Injunction; Plaintiff's Objections are OVERRULED. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 5/9/2016. (tvt)

CLERK' OF CEt. DlT COURT
: FI JS, B .
,
ATDANVILE,V
L A
FIED
L

MA rC 2 1
Y
26
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TE S D I
STR I CO U R T
CT

FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O A N O K E DI I O N
V SI

TH OM AS ANTH ONY LI
TTEK ,

Pl ntf
ai it
V.

H AR O LD C LAR K E ,e aI,
t .
De e
f udant .
s

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

.

J AC.
ML
s,!wD DLEM ClqM
vyEPUW CLE j&

C i lA cton N o.7: 6- vvi
i
1 c 00072

By:

H on.Jackson L .K i
ser
Se or U nie St e Di t i tJudge
ni
t d at s s r c

ThomasAnt ny Litk,aVigi a i t pr ee ngpr K ,c
ho
te
r ni nma e oc di
o
omm e d a a ton
nce n c i
.

purua t 42U. C.j 1 a ns anumbe ofc rnta f me safoft Vigi a
s nt o
S.
983 gai t
r ure nd or r tf he r ni
De rm e tofCor e tonsa Poc hont sCo r c i lCe e .Pl i ifa lgedt t
pa t n
r ci
nd a a r e tona ntr antf le
ha
de e nt 'f itr st pr dehi de alte menta de t e vi a e t Ei ht
f nda s a lze o ovi m nt r at
nd n ur s ol t d he g h
Am e
ndme oft Unied St t Consiuton.Pl i ifa s fl d m o i nsf apr lm i r
nt he t
aes
tt i
antf lo ie
to or ei na y

ijmcin,owhihIr fre t Untd Sae M a itaeJ d ePa l M . a g n i
nt to t c e erd o ie tts gsrt u g mea S r e tn
a c r a c wi 28U. C. 6 6 b ( )B)
c od n e t
h
S. j 3 ( )1( .
Afe co uci a e de ir hea i J
tr nd tng n vi nta y rng, udgeSa ge is d ar po ta
r nt s ue e r nd
r comm e to on Aprl15,
e
nda in
i 2015, e omm e ng t t1de t m o i nsf apr lm i r
rc
ndi ha
ny he to or ei na y

ij n to .J g Sag n c n l d dt tPli tf f i dt s w t t d fnd nsd n e hm
n u cin ud e r e t o cu e ha anif al o ho ha: ee a t e id i
e
ne s a ym e c lc r ;he i s f rng fom a s rousm e c lne d;hei lkey t s ee o
ce s r
di a a e
s ufe i r
ei
di a e
s i l o ucc d n

l sEi hhAme me tcam; n h i lk l t s fe irp r beij r wih u ap ei nay
z gt
i
nd n li a d e s iey o g fr re a a l nu y to t rlmi r
ij n to .
n u cin
Plitf ha fldo j cinst t erp r a drc mme ai n Plitf ag e t t
anif s i b e to o h e o t n e o nd to . an if r u s ha
e
J d eSa g n mia pl dt elg l tn adsf rap ei n r ijmcins tf rhi W itrv.
u g r e t sp i h e a sa d r o r l ay nt to e o t n n e
e
mi
NAtrlReour sDee eCot lI ,555U. 7,20(
tza s ce fns mci.nc.
S.
2008) a hec z cei st
, nd ha a trze he

tsi ne fo d fn a t' t e s sa mila ig.Afe rviwi Plitf o j cins te
e tmo is r m e e d n s win s e s se dn
tr e e ng an ifs be to ,h
rpo ta r omme ton, ndpetne tpori oft rcor éqnovo,IagrewihJ
e r nd ec
ndai a
ri n tons he e d
e t udge

S r e tsr c mme d to Ac o dn l , litf o j cin aeOVERRULED,h rp r
ag n ' e o n ain. c r ig y P an ips b e to s r
te e o t
a rc
nd e omm e to i ADOPTED i ise ie y,a Pli i smotonsf apr i i r
nda i n s
n t ntr t nd antc
i or elm na y

ij n to a eDENI
nu cin r
ED.
TheCl r s l s nd c e oftlsOr t t pa te .
e k hal e opi s li der o he ri s
I i s O R DER ED .
ts o

ENTER :Thi
s

%

da ofM a 201
y
y, 6.
h
.

P

S i rU nie St t D it i tJ
o
t d a es s r c udge

2