Snodgrass v. Gilbert et al

Filing 112

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 12/17/2018. (slt)

CLERK' OFFI U.S. ST COURS
CE
DI .
I
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STR I O F VI G I A
CT
R NI
R O A N O K E DI I O N
V SI

DEC 1? 2 1
23
J A e.
ULI DUD

B: X
Y

,

UTY

zw .
EK
.
R

R
.

K EVI SN O D GR ASS, .
N
JR ,

CA SE N O .7: 6C V 00091
1

Pl i i f
a nt f ,
V.

M EM O R AN D UM O PI I
N ON

CHRI
STOPHER GI
LBERT, & ,
c

By: Gl n E.Conr
e
ad
Se orUnied St e Dit itJudge
ni
t
at s s rc

De e
f ndant .
s

The pli if Ke n Snodgr s J . a Vigi a i t pr ee ng pr K ,fld tls c vi
antf, vi
as , r,
r ni nma e oc di
o
ie li i l

rg t' cin pls a tt 4 U. C.j1 8 ,riig mutpe cams Th c u th s ar a y
ih s a to t u n o 2 S.
r
9 3 asn
lil li . e o r a le d

a j d c tdma yo hi camsrg r i gp io c ndto .Afe r ve o t rc r ,h c u t
du iae n f s li e ad n rs n o i ns tr e iw.f he e o d t e o r
i
c n ld s t t t tr e d fnd ns rmanng b fr te c u t a e e tte t j d me t
o cu e ha he h e ee a t e ii e o e h o r r n ild o u g n .

S o g a sh sas tldamo inf ritro u oy ij n t er le ta tec u t s ds s.
n d rs a lo ie
to o ne lc t l n u ci eif h t h o r mu t imis
v
The c t ss ma iedt pr e alhit r oft sc s i proro ni ,ECF Nos
our ha um rz he oc dur so y hi a e n i pi ons
.

3 a d 8 . Fo r a o sae i t o e o no s t e c u tg a td sl r j d me to a1
3 q 6 r e s ns ttd n h s piin , h o r rn e l
mmay u g n n 1
camse e talg tr tl to f rt panifsl iain ef rs a d a o tdt eRe o ta
li xc p l eI eai in o he litf i g to fo t, n d' e h p r nd
e
a
t
'
p
Re o n ain o tema itaej d er g r igt er s lso ab nc tils eha c nd t d
c mme d to f h g srt u g e adn h e ut f e h ra h d o uce
on t tcai o Aug t23 a 24, 7. I lghtoft i e ve ng c ur ofa al decson i
hé l m n
us
nd 201 n i
he ntr ni o t ppe s ii n

Bo k rv S. De to Co'. 5 F.d 5 3 (t Ci.2 7 ,h we e ,t e c u tv c td t e
o e . C. p' f 1 ,8 5 3 3 4 h r 01 ) o v r h o r a ae h
r

po t n o t e o d r g a tn s mmay j g n f r d fn a t a t S o g a s camst a
ri f h r e r ni g u r ud me t o e e d n s s o n d r s ' li h t
o
de e nt Ga lha ,Gibe t a Stwa tha delye li pr r s t ough t s gr ga i se
f nda s li r l r, nd e r d a d ls og e s hr
he e e ton t p-

down pr r t r t lae a i thi f hi i onna c
og nm o e ai t gans m or s nf
l ompli sa g i va s 4 e r s of
ant nd re nce , n xe cie
hi c tt i na rg t peii Specsc ly,t co tf
s qnsim o l i ht o tton.
i a l he ur ound m ae ildiput off c a t
t ra s es a t s o
whe he t s tlee de e nt ha t e t ned t hol Snodgr s l ng i s r t d
t r he e lr
f nda s d hr a e
o
d
as o er n eg ega e
c
onfne nti he co i
me f
ntnued t fl i o m a c pli t a g i va s a a t whe he i
o ie nf r l om a n s nd re nce , nd s o
t rn

'

.

.

r t la i f hi flng s h gre nc f ms t y m a r comme to o de ii t hi r
e a iton or s i uc iva e or , he
de e
ndai ns r csons o nde

S o g a s p o rs i tese - o p o rm.Th c u t e e s mmayj d me ta t t e e
n d rs ' r g e s n h tp d wn r g a
e o r d nid u r u g n s o h s
cli s a r f red t m a tr t M a sr t J
am
nd e e r he
te o
gitae udge Pa e a M e de Sa g
m l
a
r ent f f t r
or urhe

p o e dng , u s a t o2 U. C. 6 6 b' )B)
r c e i s p ru n t 8 S. j 3 ( )1( .
(
On J y 1 201 J
ul 7, 8, udge Sa ge cond t a a tonalbe h ti o t r m ani
r nt
uced n ddii
nc ral n he e i ng

camsa d S o pus 'moin f ritro uo y ij nci r l fl Th p risa re t a t
li n n d s to o nel c tr nu t ei . e a t g e d h t he
ve e
e
j g c ud as c n i e e i e c tk n d rng t e 2 7 b n h til Th c s i prs nl
ud e o l lo o sd r v d n e a e u i h 01 e c ra. e a e s e e ty
be or . cour on J
f et
he
t
udge Sa ge ' r por a rc mme d t n Cl e rp l ,ECF No 1 0
r nts e t nd e o
n ai t e of)
o h
. 1,
'i
1
$

rc mme igj d me tf rt d fn a t, n S d r s ' be to t eeo ECFNo 1 1
e o i ndn u g n o he ee d n s a d no g a s o j cins h rt ,
. 1.
!

I'ema itaejd ema so l arc mme aint ti c ut Mah wsv. e e,
lh gsrt u g ke ny e o nd to o hs o r. te
f
W br
1

43 rr2120he (po6orhcutproposedwtmkorucomnvdtmtoaoch
2Uï i6,7-117)Tspeoricae findings. <X mendaeritnf
S
. 7 e9 t. ecifiedshrd i nl ra ootions ni o
g h ne
g
e whi
t e po tons of t r r
hos
1
k
'

o j cin i ma e' 28U.. j 6 6b ( ) Alh u h te dsrc c u tma gv ama itae
be tp s d .
'
SC. 3 ()1 . t o g h itit o r y ie
gsrt
j d ejp o o e fn n sa drc mme dainst u hweg t s(h ijmei c mma sa dt e
u g i r p s d idig n e o n to & c ih a t er rt o nd n h
f
s
1
l

I

'h
'

s t ds rto o t j d warn s tea to iya dt er s o sb l yt ma ea i f r d
omd icein f he u ge ra t,
uh rt n h ep n iii o k n r b me
t
l
l

fn ld tr n to r man wihtedsrc j dg .Uri dS ae v. d az 4 7U. 6 7 68 i a ee miain e is t h ititu e le tts Ra d t , 4 S. 6 , 2
t
8 ( 9 0 . Th rf r ,i p ro mig a X no o r ve rltd t a y p ry' o j cin ,t e
3 1 à )2 eeo e n e fr n
v e iw eae o n a t s b e to s h
dsrc j d e mu te e cs t sn n d lg b e a t rt b c n iei g t e a t a t si n ,
itit u g s x rie l o - ee a l uho i y o sd rn h cu l e tmo y
hi
y
a notm e ey by r vi wi t magita e sr por a r c
nd
rl
e e ng he
sr t ' e t nd e omm e tons' W i me v.Cook,
nda i .
' m r

774F. 68,76(t Ci.1 )
2d
4h r 985 .

'

! The doc tr fecst tt c tno ii Snodg a sweli a nc t t J y 2018 he rng s d
ke e l t ha he our tfed
r s l n dva e hat he ul
a i houl

icu ee d n eo t rmann rtl to cam a wela hi moin fritro uo y ijmcierl f S e
n ld vie c n he e iig eai in li s l s s to o nelc tr nt tv ei e
a
e
ECFNo. 4( ie t S o g aso Ma 1 20l)
9 mald o n d rs n y 7, 8 .
2 The c tha omitd i er quoaton maks alertons or cttons hee and elewhe e i t s
our s te nt nal t i
r , t a i , iai
r
s
r n hi
m emor ndum opi o unl sot r s not
a
nin, es he wie ed.

2

To fnd i f vo ofSnodg as ,t co 'mus bepe s ded t theha pr n ea h oft
i n a r
r s he uz
t t
r ua
ha
s ove c
he
ee e sofhi r t i i cli sby a pr ponde a e oft e denc I r W i hi 397 U .
lm nt
s ealaton am
e
r nc
he vi e. n e ns p,
S.

358,371 (970) Prpondea oft e de me ns a f ti mor pr e t n not
1 . e
rnce he vi nce a
ac s e obabl ha
.
Co r t Pi & Pr .ofCa . I v.Co t.La r r Pe i n Tr f S.Ca . 5 U. 602,
nc e e pe
ods
l- nc.
nsr bo e s nso . or
1, 08 S.

6 2( 9 3 .
2 1 9)
To pr vali ar t la i cli unde Seci n 1 3,apl i ifse denc m us pe s
e i n e a iton am
r to 98
antf vi e
t ruade

t e c u tt a ç 1 he e g g d i p oe td Fis Ame d n a tvt ,( )te d fn a tt o
h o r h t & ) n a e n r tce rt n me t ciiy 2 h ee d n o k
(
s me a to ta a ves l afce h s Fis Ame me trg t,a d ()t ee wa a c us l
o
cin h t d rey fe td i rt
nd n ih s n 3 h r s a a

r lto s p b t e hi p oe td a tv t a d te d fn a tsc n u t' Ma t v Du f ,8 8
eain hi ewe n s r tce ciiy n h ee d n ' o d c. ri . fv 5
'
n
F.d 2 9 2 9 ( t Ci.2 7 ,c r.d n e ,1 8 S.Ct 7 8 ( 8 . To r l i te plitY s
3 3 , 4 4h r 01 ) e t e id 3
. 3 201 )
ue n h an i
f vo ,t f tfnde mus fnd i m or lkey t n nott tt def nda t t a lgedl
a r he ac i r
ti t
e i l ha
ha he e nt ook he le y

rtlao y a tln rs o s t t e g ani s e rie o a c n tmto al p oe td rg t'
eaitr c ç e p n e o h plitc ) xecs f o si in l r tce ih .
i
y
'
Ad msv. c , 0F.d7 , 5(t Ci. 9 4 .
a
Rie 4 3 2 7 4h r 1 9 )
'

S o g a so j cst t erpo tsc aa trz to o c rantsi n a d d c me tto
n d rs b e t o h e r' h r ce iain f e ti etmo y n o u n ain
a isf itr t i epr tt e de e a pr ofhi as e t c am sa i tt defnda s I
nd t alle o nt r e he vi nc s oof
s s red l i ga ns he e nt . n

lg to te eo j cins te c u t a s e i l c n uce éqn v rv e o ter p r a
i h f h s b e to , h o r h s p ct l o d td o o e iw f h e o t nd
ka y
t ie ofe de t tSnodgr s hashi i ht d. Fr t sr viw,t co tco l st t
he t ms vi nce ha
as
ghlg e
om hi e e he ur ncude ha
1

t we g oft e de e f ly s pors t ma e i lf t lfndi a t lgalc l i
he i ht he vi nc ul up t he t ra acua i ngs nd he e
onc usons
oft r po t
he e r .

The201 r por r ogniest tSnodgr s e r s d hi Fis Am e e rg sby flng
8 e t ec z ha
a s xe cie s rt
ndm nt i ht
i
nume ousi or a co ai f ms a gre nc . Some oft a i sr tver me f r s
r
nf m l mpl nt or nd iva es
he dm nita i e dy o m
i t r co d i l t na e of o orm or of t def nda s The r ta s fnds t t
n hé e r ncude he m s
ne
e he e nt .
epor lo i
ha
Snodg as a hi wine s pr e e s e e de e t t t de e nt m a c
r s nd s t s es es nt d om vi nc ha he f nda s de omm e t
ns

s
ugge tng a r ltons p be we n hi flng of ( pe wor 'a hi de a d pr es i t
si
ea i hi t e s ii
G r k' nd s l ye ogr s n he
pa
Se egai n St pgr to
e Down Pr n .3 The de e n s t tfed t t t y ha neve t e tne
ogr m
f nda t esii ha he
d
r hr ae d
Snodgr s wih l rs gr t d c i me ,a had ne rr t la e a i thi ,be a e of
a s t onge e egae onfne nt nd
ve e a it d gans m
c us
hi us oft gre nc pr e es The201 r por sa e t t
s e he iva e oc dur .
8 e t tt s ha
t e de e be or t c t doe no pe s de m e t t a of t delys i
he vi nc f e he our
s t rua
ha ny
he a n
Snodgr s ' pr e son t o h t Stpa s s ogr s i hr ug he e Down pr a w e e c us d by a tons
ogr m r a e
ci
t ke by t defnda si a e f tt r t lae a i tSnodg a sf e r ii
a n
he e nt n n for o e ai t ga ns
r s or xe c sng
hi rg t pe ii by flng co pl nt a gre nc .To t co r r 1
s i ht o tton
ii
m ai s nd iva es
he nta y,
co i t be pe s de t twhe Snodgr s e t e e adely, he dea wa
ntnue o
r ua d ha
n
a s ncomt r d
a t
ly s
bas d on hi own a tonsorhi own f l et pr e st ought pr r m .
e
s
ci
s
aiur o ogr s hr
he og a
Re t14,ECF N o.11
por
0.

Fr m X no rviw of t pates e de , t c t lke s c l
o
vo e e
he ri ' vi nce he our i wie oncudes t t
ha
Snodg a s ha no pr n t ca ai n elm e of hi r t iton c am . The c t i not
r s s t ove he us to e nt
s eala i l i
our s

pe s de t t a o t de e nt 'c a sfc to de ii ns a
r ua d ha ny f he f nda s l s i ai n cs o bout Snodgr s sa's we e
a s' t t
u
r
motvaed by a i e i t r t lae agans hi f hi us oft g i va pr ed e . The
i t
n nt nton o e ait
i t m or s e he re nce oc ur s
se down pr r m i i e
t pog n s nt nded t c nge i t 'be vi r a t nki t pr pa e t m f
o ha
nma es ha o nd hi ng o e r he or
s f r e r i o a ge a populton s ti a a s h,i ha s ve a co pone s Some
a e e nty nt
ner l
a i e tng, nd s uc t s e r l m
nt .

c mp n n s ae o j ci e i ldng t r q ie n t rman fe o n w d s i i r
o o e t r be tv , ncu i he e ur me t o e i r e f e icpl y
na
I
i rci
nfa tons a t r uie e t c
nd he eq r m nt o ompl t a sgne pori
ee s i d
tons of t Cha lng Sere
he
le e
is

wo k o k . Anoh ri o tn c mp n n o t e se - o p o r m tn a y prs n s c rt
rb o s
t e mp ra t o o e t f h tp d wn r g n a d n io e u iy
ca st to d cso )i s be tve s h a o fcas we l rtng o t ei maesb h vir
lsi in e ii n s u j ci , uc s fiil' edy ai s f h n t ' e a o
ka
a t i as es me oft l ve ofrs hepos i r l s d fom s gr to
nd her s s nt he e l ik
es f eea e ' e egai n.
r

W inese tsi t S
t s s etfed hat nodgrs ofe r c ve a wa notfed oi poor be ' o
a s tn e ei d, nd s ii l
ha r
vi
r tngs bec us he was nots wi a a opra e l velof r s c . The e 1 r tngs we e
ai , a e
ho ng n ppr it e
e pe t
s ow a i
r
3 The 2017 and 2018 r t pr de det l a
epors ovi
ais boutt sep- zpr a t t cour wilnot
he t dom
ogr m hat he
t l

rg a h r. Moe v r tec u t a ara y d tr n dta ofcas o c so a mia piaino o
e e t ee ro e,h o r h s l d eemie h t fiil' ca in l sp l t f r
e
c o
f l e t com pl w ih s e down pr
alur o
y t t pocedur does not rs t t l of a consiutonalvi a i and
es
ie o he evel
tt i
olton

t s do sn tsaea y vibl cam f r le un rj 1 3.
hu , e o tt n a e li or eif de 98
4

s f e ,pe polc t dely hi pr e s t r l s r src i confne e c tons
ufkl nt r i y, o a s ogr s owa d e s e titve
i m nt ondii ,
r r dl s ofwheherhe ha c
eg es
t
d omplt d r uie cas e orbooks or ha a de d s i i r
e e eq r d l s s
,
d voi d i cplna y
c r s M o e r Snodgr s ha pr s nt no e de e ofr a it y m o i - - a r as
ha ge . r ove ,
as s e e ed
vi nc
etla or
tve -of ny e on
t tt def nda swoul ke p hi i t se down pr n l r m e el bec us he fld
ha he e nt
d e m n he t pogr m onge , r y a e
ie
gre nce a
iva s bout t m or hi s gr ga i cas i a i
he
s e e ton l sfc ton. Ove al t co ltfnds t gr a e
r l, he tr i
he e t r

wei of t mor c e bl e de e t be t t none oft de e nt i e i ly dea d
ght he
e r di e vi nc o
ha
he f nda s nt ntona l lye
Snodgr s'se down pr e sbe a e ofhi i or c
as t pogr s c us
s nf mal ompl i so gre nc s.
ant r iva e
Ba e on t ma e i lf t tndi i t r por a t c r ' own 4 novorviw of
s d he t ra acuali ngs n he e t nd he ou ts
q
e e
.

t r é d asr feced i t so ni t c tco l st tSnodg a sha f l d t pr hi
he e or
el t n hi pi on, he our ncude ha
r s s aie o ove s
r t i i ca ms by a pr ponde a e of t e de e. Ac r ngl t c twil ove ze
ealaton li
e
r nc
he vi nc
co di y, he our l
m l

S o g a s o j cin t t erpo t a o tt rpo ti ise trt ,a e trj g n frte
n d r s' be to s o h e r, d p he e r n t n iey nd n e ud me t o h
de e nt .
f nda s

S o g a s moin f ritro u o y ij n tv r l f ECF No 9 s e sata fra y
n d r s' t o n elc t r nu cie ei ,
o
e
. 2, e k rnse wa
fom W ale Ri Stt Prs n,whe ehe i c r nty c i t a l rs urt lve prs
r
lns dge ae i o
r
s ur e l onfned, o owe ec iy e l ion
f iiy. The t ee de e an s r mai ng be or t cou ta e e pl es ofRe Oni St t
ac lt
hr
f nd t e ni
f e he r r m oye
d
on a e
Prs not W a lns li . l i undiput d t t none of t m ha a ho iy t have hi
ion,
le tdge. t s
s e ha
he
s ut rt o
m
ta f re ele r On t s g ound,t de e nt ha m ove f dim is lofSnodgr s
r ns e r d s whe e.
hi r
he f nda s ve
d or s s a
as '
m oto a t c twilgr ntt i m o i n.An a oprae o de wile e t sda
i n, nd he our l a her to
ppr i t r r l ntr hi y.
The Cl r i dieced t s nd c e o t s me or ndlm opilon a a co nyi
e k s r t o e opi s f hi m a l
ri nd c mpa ng
or rt pl i i fa t couns ofr c d f t de e nt .
de o a ntf nd o
el e or or he f nda s

Ex'
rsR:Thi 1 I da ofDec m be , 201
s -N y
e r
8.
Se orUnie Stt sDititJ e
ni
t d a e src udg