Snodgrass v. Gilbert et al
Filing
23
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/13/2016. (tvt)
flFRK' OFFI U. DI COURT
b
S
CE S. SQ
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L
J 13 2 1
UL
06
I TH E UM TED STATES DI
N
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGI A
NI
ROANOKE DI SI
W ON
KEW N SNODGM SS,JR.
,
JULI C
A
BY;
D
L
L
E
L
CASE NO .7:
16CV00091
Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM O RA N DU M O PI O N
M
CHRI TOPHER GI
S
LBERT, K ,
c
By: GlnE. nr d
e Co a
Chi fUni e St esD i t i tJudge
e
t d at
src
De e a t)
f nd nts.
Ke n Snodgr s ,J . a Vigi a i t pr e ng pr K ,fld t s cvi rght ac i
vi
a s r,
r ni nma e oc edi
o
ie hi i l i s ton
.
t r42U. C.j1 alegngt tt dee tprs ofkil a Re Orin Stt Prs ae
mde
S. 983, l i ha he fndan ion f as t d lo ae ion r
usng a cas ii ai n polc t thasbe n r pe t dl a id i s h a wa as t ke p ii i
i
l sfc to
iy ha
e e a e y pple n uc
y
o e lm n
l ng-e m s r to wiho due pi s . De e n s ha fld a a we , de ng hi
o t r eg egai n t ut
oce s
f nda t ve ie n ns r nyi
s
alegai ns t tt polces ha vi aed M s c tmto lrg s a t y a e due t fl a
l to ha he i i
ve olt
onsi i na i ht, nd he r
o ie
moin f rsl r j g n wiln a fw we ks S d r s h sno fld a mo in f ra
to o l
mmay ud me t tl e
i
e . no ga s a w ie
to o
tmp rr r sr ii o d ra d p ei nay ijmcin Afe rviw o t moin,te c u t
e o a y e tanng r e n r l r nl to . tr e e f he to h o r
mi
concudest ti mus besl ma iy dim is
l
ha t t lm rl s s ed.
S o g a ssmoin f ritro u o y ijmcier le a pae ty c mp anst to cas
n d r s' to o n elc t r nt tv eif p rn l o li ha x il
i ve i li cas i a i r vi pr e ngs ha r e l û ons r d' t r t i e a ns
nvol d n ls l sfc ton e ew oc edi
ve ec nty i pie ' o ealat gai t
c
h m b rj ci a ç o de a e'hs giv n e a u h s ca sfc to he rng a d sau .
i y ee t s E ng v bl' i re a c bo t i lsiiain ai n tt s
ng n
( o .2,ECF No 20) S o g a s as alg s t t a p r f t rtlao y c ns ia y
M t
. . n d rs lo le e ha s a to he eaitr o pr c ,
def nda s have i ed c ran ee e s of t i o
e nt
gnor
e ti lm nt
her wn c a sfc to po i is a ha
l s iia i n lce nd ve
t ei rtl c n eld E s we ky g o p ca s s ( ) tme wi i a ( ) we k p ro ( G l aey a c le hi e ll r u lse 6 i s t n 8 e ei d 2
d be
h
mo t s. (d. S o g a swa t t e c u tt o d rdee d n s ço e sle t th ' a l t
nh l' l ) n d r s n s h o r o r e fn a t l n t ha e s be o
'
t
r
r ceve pr r Due Pr e s wiho RETM I ON a CON SPI CY fom t na e
e i
ope
oc s
t ut
ATI
nd
M
r
he m d
Dee d n s' nde ecs h srg t t fe do o s e ha da c s t c u t.(1 1)
f n a t'a x r ie i ih s o ' e m f pe c n c e s o o rs Jk .
r
.
The co tc l s t t Snodgr s ha no a lge f cs wm a i t e r r i r
ur oncude ha
as s t le d a t
ntng he xtao d na y
r le h s e .Thep rys e i ap ei nayij cinmu tma eace rs wi Gh th i
eif e e ks
at e kng r lmi r nun to s k la ho ng t a e s
t
lkel t s c d on t m e s t the i lkel t s f r ir par bl hn m i t a e e o
i y o uc ee
he dt , ha
s i y o ufe re a e r n he bs nc f
p ei nryr le,t tt eb ln eo e ute t i h sf v r a d t a a ijmci n i i t e
r lmi
eif ha h aa c f q iis i n i a o , n h t n nl to s n h
ps
p bl i tr s ' W itr v Nau a Re .De .Comcl I c,5 5 U. 7 2 ( 0 ) S c
u i ne et' n e . t rl s f t i. n . 5 S. , 0 20 8 . u h
c
itro u o yijmcierle i ç ne ta r i ayrme yta ma o yb a r e u n ace r
n elc t r nt t eif s û x ro d n r e d h t y nl e wad d po la
v
a
s wi t t pli ifi e ild t s h r lef' I a 22. Be us t prma' pur e of
ho ng hat he antf s ntte o uc e i . d. t
'
ca e he i t
y pos
ijmcier le i t p e e v t esa'sq o p ndn ars lto o t meiso t camsa
nt tv eif s o r s r e h tt u e ig e oui n n he rt f he li t
u
is i tel iain isl,n el c tr ijl t r l fta c n e t sa'sq b f r til
sue n h i g to tef itro uo y nl i ei h t ha g s he tt uo eo e ra
t
nc ve e
u
,
t el
i dico a d a a ïlgii ae e f tq o s c le a pi c m e til, w e z v. Edwa ds 635
s s ur ge s n l e tm t for : e tr
l
t
e e al ra .
r ,
F.d28 28 (t Ci. 98 )
2 3, 6 4 h r 1 0 .
Sno a ss f c ua a lga i smpl do notm e tt f m r quied ee e s f t
dgr s ' a t l le tons i y
e he ot e r lm nt or he
e r r na y r le he s ks M os i
xtao di r e if
ee .
t mpora l he pr s nt no f c s s
tnty,
ee s
a t howi t ta oft
ng ha ny
he
a r e a tonsof whih he compl i we e m o i t d i a r pe tby hi pe ng orpror
dve s c i
c
ans r
tva e n ny es c
s ndi
i
lwslt oroc ur e be aus ofa c piac t de i hi ofc tt i lrg s M e ey
a tis
c rd c e
ny ons r y o prve m
onsiutona i ht . r l
c l or al ai ofr t iton a co pia y aeno a tona et rj 1
oncus y leg tons ealai nd ns rc r t ci bl mde 983.Ada v.
ms
Rie 40 F.d 7 ,7 (t Ci.1 9 ) Br wn v.Anz ln ,9 F.S p 3 0 3 6 ( . Va
c,
3 2 4 4h r 9 4 ; o
eo e 38 u p. 4 , 4 W D. .
1 9 ) F rh r r ,imae h ve n c n ttto lrg tt a p io giv nc p o e u e
9 6 . u temo e n ts a o o siuina ih o rs n re a e r c d r .
Ada ,40 F. a 75. The e or ee e sofa gre nc pr ed le t ta sa e prs s t m
ms
3d t
r f e, lm nt
i va e oc tr ha t t ion yse
c
hoos st cr a eca
e o e t nnoti ia e a i a e' c tt i lrght. I Ac or ng y,Snodgr s
mplc t n nm t s onsiutona i s d. c di l
as
doe nots w a lkei
s
ho ny i lhood ofs e sora i i nt ir pa a e ha m he i lkel t s f r
ucc s
ny mm ne , re r bl r
s i y o ufe
i t a e e oft r sedco ti e v nton.
n he bs nc
he eque t
ur nt r e i
The c tas cn
our lo nnotfnd t tt ba a e o t e te o t publc i e es we g i
i ha he l nc f he quiis r he
i nt r t i h n
Snodg a ss f vor s as t wa r nt t co ts i e l ut r i e f r nce i prs n ofi i s
rs' a
o
o r a he ur' nt roc o y nt re e
n io fcal'
dic e i r c a sf ai n de ii .Thecour t fndsno ba i f de i ng t duepr e s
s r tona y l s ik to c sons
t hus i
ss or c di he
oc s
is s of t s c e i t pic m ea f hi n t t Snodgr s s m o i n de a . M or ove ,
sue
hi as n he e e l as o ha
as '
to
m nds
e r
Snodpa s i rmi d t tj 1983 a ho ies cvi a tons f r vi ai of c tmtonaly
s s e nde ha
ut rz i l ci o oltons onsi i l
pr t c e rg s Hi c i d ltga i ove e r m i ad r ee nthe e ot e si prs
o e t d iht . s ontnue ii ton r ve y nor ve s ve
nc mt r n ion
w il s nde vaua e c ttm e a r s c a sow t r ol i of a potntaly
l qua r l bl our i
nd e our es nd l he es uton
ny e i l
me iozo cli st theorot ri t sma bea tmptngt pr s nt
rt i us am ha
he nma e y
te i o e e .
For t saed r s ,t c tc l
he t t ea ons he our oncudest t Snodgr s c nnotm a t ne s a y,
ha
as n
ke he ce s r
f -a t rs
ourf c o howi t tli st ton wa r nt i e l ut y r le a wildeny hi m oto An
ng ha ls iua i
ra s nt roc or ei f nd l
s in.
a opraeor rwili s t sda
ppr it de l s ue hi y.
The Clr i die t d t s nd c pi of t s m e o a
ek s r ce o e
o es M
m r ndum opi on a ac ompa ng
ni nd c
nyi
o de t pli ifa c uns lofr or f t de e nt .
i r o antf nd o e
ec d or he f nda s
ENTER:Th s(
i 5
d yo J l , 01 .
a f uy 2 6
Chi fUried t t Diti tJ
e lt
aes src udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?